Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about the number of people who think a ‘fixed’ energy tariff means the monthly price will always be the same - regardless of usage

160 replies

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 12:12

I know there are loads of threads about energy costs at the moment but I have noticed there are quite a number of people who think a fixed price tariff operates in the same way as say a monthly Netflix subscription.

With Netflix, you pay the same each month regardless of how much you watch.

With energy it is only the unit price you are fixing - your monthly bill will vary dependent on usage.

The terms ‘fix’ and ‘cap’ are causing a lot of confusion.

OP posts:
StatisticallyChallenged · 01/09/2022 22:46

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 22:20

Sorry, but that’s not helping.

The simple fact is -

You pay for the number of units you use, at either the fixed rate or your suppliers variable rate.

End of.

No need to be rude - it was a possible explanation for people who don't understand the way the cap is expressed.

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:40

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 22:10

It’s entirely your call if you’ve no idea what your usage is.

My point is, if you ramp up your usage, thinking you’re paying top whack anyway, it will bite you on the arse.

You pay for the units you use - at the suppliers variable rate or whatever rate you fix at.

OK. I know that what I pay each month does not mean unlimited usage for that price.
I have a smart meter so my bills are actual, not estimated.
My supplier adjusts my DD accordingly on a regular basis.

I don't need to know my precise usage to know that if I use less electricity it will in turn cost less.

Augend23 · 01/09/2022 22:35

The way I think about gas and electricity is it's like a combination of a subscription fee (your standing charges) and a charge per unit.

An equivalent example might be Tesco's delivery saver - you pay a subscription fee which covers the delivery costs, but then you pay separately on top for each order that you do.

For gas and electricity the subscription fee - i.e. the cost of electricity and gas bring supplied to your house at all is capped.

The unit price (like £0.50 per kilo for potatoes or whatever) is also capped. But if you bought 100 kilos of potatoes, Tesco is going to charge you more than if you only buy 10kg. The same applies to electricity and gas.

Now where it differs is that Tesco don't have a system where they go: hmmm most households spend £300 a month on food so we'll charge you that as a starting point but then at the end of the year we'll add up everything you've spent and sort out the differences then. That's essentially what your energy direct debit does.

So the cap is on the delivery fee (standing charge) and the utilities equivalent of the cost per kg. But if you use more than they expected, when they tot up what you've used you might owe them money.

PeloDramatic · 01/09/2022 22:32

EngTech · 01/09/2022 22:26

I think once the hefty bills start arriving, people will wake up especially when they have less disposable income for treats etc

If they ignore it, they will get into debt very quickly

Be interesting to see the number of subscribers to Sky, Netflix etc go down or stay the same

My £10 for Netflix is a drop in the ocean. Plus it's my entertainment so well worth it!

PeloDramatic · 01/09/2022 22:31

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:05

Yeah I have no idea what my usage is.

I just want to know how much money is coming out of my bank account each month.

I'm not on a fixed rate, my supplier calculates how much my DD will be based on my predicted usage.

I can try..
Ok think of it as petrol, I've made up the prices

The price cap is the cap per litre. So they can't charge any more than £1.50 per litre and they're saying the average amount of petrol used is £3000 per year which is why they're showing it as "price cap £xxxx". But the cap is on how much they can charge per litre, not how much you can use. So if you drive thousands and thousands of miles, you'll use loads above the average

The usage is up to you of course, if you drive more, you'll use more, drive less you'll use less. But because the cost per litre has gone up so much, it'll affect everyone

Some people are fixing their rate at £1.50 per litre rather than paying a variable rate of less, because it's predicted to go up again
So the variable you might pay £1.30 per litre now, but in January the cap could go up to £2 per litre. People are fixing at £1.50 and paying a bit more than variable for long term reassurance

The standing charge is like line rental, how much you pay for your phone whether or not you use it, and that's the same situation with the price cap

JaceLancs · 01/09/2022 22:29

I despair about the lack of knowledge caused by poor education about basic financial matters
to me it’s far more important than learning a second language etc
I have done my best to educate own DC who are now adults but not everyone has family support and suffer as a result

EngTech · 01/09/2022 22:26

I think once the hefty bills start arriving, people will wake up especially when they have less disposable income for treats etc

If they ignore it, they will get into debt very quickly

Be interesting to see the number of subscribers to Sky, Netflix etc go down or stay the same

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 22:20

StatisticallyChallenged · 01/09/2022 22:16

Think of it like bus tickets

The imaginary travel regulator has decided the maximum cost of a local bus journey is £1. They've decided that instead of talking about a single bus journey they'll work out how many trips the average family takes over a year and express it as an annual cost so that people understand how much extra it might cost over the year when the maximum cost changes. They decide that the average family of 2.4 children will use 537 bus journeys a year so they express the cap as £537. But it's not £537, it's £1 per ticket.

If you're a single person who only uses a bus occasionally you'll pay less

If you're a family of 6 who all take the bus to school/work daily you'll spend a lot more.

The energy cap total is just a bit more complicated because it has two types of tickets (the cost per kWh for gas and electricity) plus a daily standing charge for each, so those 4 bits have to be factored in.

Sorry, but that’s not helping.

The simple fact is -

You pay for the number of units you use, at either the fixed rate or your suppliers variable rate.

End of.

OP posts:
StatisticallyChallenged · 01/09/2022 22:18

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:05

Yeah I have no idea what my usage is.

I just want to know how much money is coming out of my bank account each month.

I'm not on a fixed rate, my supplier calculates how much my DD will be based on my predicted usage.

Do you have smart meters? Because if not this might well bite you in the future if they're working on estimates.

If you're on smart meters or giving regular readings then your most recent bill should have your annual usage in kWh on it.

StatisticallyChallenged · 01/09/2022 22:16

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 21:50

I just can't get my head around any of that. I cannot make sense of it.

Think of it like bus tickets

The imaginary travel regulator has decided the maximum cost of a local bus journey is £1. They've decided that instead of talking about a single bus journey they'll work out how many trips the average family takes over a year and express it as an annual cost so that people understand how much extra it might cost over the year when the maximum cost changes. They decide that the average family of 2.4 children will use 537 bus journeys a year so they express the cap as £537. But it's not £537, it's £1 per ticket.

If you're a single person who only uses a bus occasionally you'll pay less

If you're a family of 6 who all take the bus to school/work daily you'll spend a lot more.

The energy cap total is just a bit more complicated because it has two types of tickets (the cost per kWh for gas and electricity) plus a daily standing charge for each, so those 4 bits have to be factored in.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 22:10

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:05

Yeah I have no idea what my usage is.

I just want to know how much money is coming out of my bank account each month.

I'm not on a fixed rate, my supplier calculates how much my DD will be based on my predicted usage.

It’s entirely your call if you’ve no idea what your usage is.

My point is, if you ramp up your usage, thinking you’re paying top whack anyway, it will bite you on the arse.

You pay for the units you use - at the suppliers variable rate or whatever rate you fix at.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 22:08

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:05

Yeah I have no idea what my usage is.

I just want to know how much money is coming out of my bank account each month.

I'm not on a fixed rate, my supplier calculates how much my DD will be based on my predicted usage.

You can just take meter reading and see if it corresponds with what shows as the estimated usage.
Then you take it again in a month and you see what you use monthly approximately (as it changes a bit as does life)

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 22:05

Yeah I have no idea what my usage is.

I just want to know how much money is coming out of my bank account each month.

I'm not on a fixed rate, my supplier calculates how much my DD will be based on my predicted usage.

cakeorwine · 01/09/2022 21:59

You see it on here all the time

People quote their DD payments but don't know their usage

It would be so much easier if the media quoted the new price per KWH and the new standing charge instead of the 'price cap'.

People have their heads in the sand about this.

I have a spreadsheet and have modelled various scenarios of usage. I understand how energy is used in the house and where I can make savings on usage.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 21:58

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 21:50

I just can't get my head around any of that. I cannot make sense of it.

The ‘price cap’ isn’t the most anyone will pay.

It’s the most anyone with ‘average’ usage will pay.

If you use more units - you pay more.

If you use less units - you pay less.

What’s important is understanding how many units you use and multiplying that by the rate you pay per unit.

OP posts:
ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 21:50

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 01/09/2022 21:23

The £3,549 being spouted is based on a 2-3 bedroom home using 12,000 kilowatt hours (kWh) of gas and 2,900 kWh of electricity per annum on a dual fuel tariff.

Each kWh of electricity will be PRICE CAPPED at £0.52p and the standing charge for providing the home with this electricity will be PRICE CAPPED £0.46p per day.

2900 x .52 = £1508 for the electricity
365 x .46 = £167.90 for the standing charge
1508 + 167.90 = £1675.90 per year for Electricity

Each kWh of Gas will be PRICE CAPPED £0.15p and the standing charge for providing the home with gas will be PRICE CAPPED at £0.28p per day.

12000 x .15 = £1800 for the gas
365 x .28 = £102.20 for the standing charge
1800 + 102.20 = £1902.20 per year for gas.

Total 1902.20 + 1675.90 = £3578.10 the duel fuel tariff is assumed to offer the discount to bring that total down to the £3,549.

If you use more energy than the average OFGEM are using of 12000kwh of gas and 2900kwh of electricity per year your bill will be more than the £3,549. The cap is applied to each individual kWh of energy. Not your total bill.

I just can't get my head around any of that. I cannot make sense of it.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 01/09/2022 21:23

The £3,549 being spouted is based on a 2-3 bedroom home using 12,000 kilowatt hours (kWh) of gas and 2,900 kWh of electricity per annum on a dual fuel tariff.

Each kWh of electricity will be PRICE CAPPED at £0.52p and the standing charge for providing the home with this electricity will be PRICE CAPPED £0.46p per day.

2900 x .52 = £1508 for the electricity
365 x .46 = £167.90 for the standing charge
1508 + 167.90 = £1675.90 per year for Electricity

Each kWh of Gas will be PRICE CAPPED £0.15p and the standing charge for providing the home with gas will be PRICE CAPPED at £0.28p per day.

12000 x .15 = £1800 for the gas
365 x .28 = £102.20 for the standing charge
1800 + 102.20 = £1902.20 per year for gas.

Total 1902.20 + 1675.90 = £3578.10 the duel fuel tariff is assumed to offer the discount to bring that total down to the £3,549.

If you use more energy than the average OFGEM are using of 12000kwh of gas and 2900kwh of electricity per year your bill will be more than the £3,549. The cap is applied to each individual kWh of energy. Not your total bill.

Gingerkittykat · 01/09/2022 21:13

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:44

Ahh yes I get what you mean thank you OP.

If you’re in debt because your DD isn’t matching your usage (say your using way more energy then what you’re actually paying for) does your energy provider not contact you to let you know?

Sorry for the dumb questions but I’ve always rented and my rent has included bills. I’ve been in my flat for a year now and this is the first time I’ve actually had to pay for gas and electric and I’m just realising that I don’t know so much

Energy companies vary. I am with Shell for my gas and their DD has always been a really accurate representation of my usage.

I'm with Scottish Power for electricity and they set their DD higher than you would use so you build up a credit with them. I ended up £300 in credit to them and it was a massive fight trying to get that money back. When I was in credit (before the price increases) they also tried to put my DD up a significant amount, in the end, I cancelled my DD and go onto my online account and make a payment every fortnight so I don't get a big bill.

The best thing you can do is take regular readings(monthly is good) and input the numbers on their site which will give you an accurate picture of what you are using instead of estimating it.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 21:09

Washing curtains! 😂

I have never even thought of doing that in nearly 50 years on this planet!

Like I say - you don’t know what you don’t know!

OP posts:
MomwasCasual · 01/09/2022 21:04

MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/09/2022 19:50

i joined that group @Snazzysausage
i was so shocked yesterday that there were so many posts from people who were washing all bedding and curtains before the price rise
or is it me, am i the only one to think that is barmy and unecessary?

I haven't washed my curtains because frankly who could be fagged with that, but I have washed all the winter duvets and bedding/ cushions, got the sleeping bags washed dried and packed away etc. All the stuff I'd normally do a bit later in the year.

Not necessarily to beat the price rises, but more to take advantage of the incredible drying weather we've had.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 20:54

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 01/09/2022 20:26

@Butterflyfluff

Agree totally. It has massively confused me too. The price 'cap' is a fucking bullshit name, because it suggests that the £3,549 or 'price cap' is the MOST you will pay. It's not. It's a cap for the individual units (or something like that!)

I was thinking the price cap is the most anyone will pay, (altogether - that whole year - ) and that is a load of bollocks. The 'price cap' is ONLY for each unit. You could still have a £5000 a year bill, (or you could have LESS than £3,459 of course!)

I was thinking 'well the 'price cap' is a lot, but at least we know where we stand, and it won't be any more than that. What a fucking fool I was. Hmm

As I said, (and you said OP,) the 'PRICE CAP' (price fix,) it is a VERY MISLEADING NAME!!!

Thank you @WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps

And good luck for the shit show we’re all facing 🙏

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 01/09/2022 20:30

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 20:13

@Catell based on your posts you appear to be one of the people who think your bill is going to stay the same, regardless of what you actually use.

Please correct me if I’m wrong but the screenshot you posted doesn’t mean your DD will cover your energy costs until Dec 2023, regardless of usage.

It just means the rate you pay per unit and the standing charges are fixed.

If your usage increases your total bill will go up.

If your usage stays the same, the fixed DD will cover it.

For those people who think ‘ah well, I’m paying a fortune on my fixed rate so I’ll just crank up the heating’ - they are going to get hit with a big bill as it’s not unlimited usage for the fixed DD.

This!!! ^ @Catell and @SpringIntoChaos WAKE UP!!! The price cap/price fix is NOT what you think it is. Don't be embarrassed or ashamed to admit you got it wrong. I am happy to hold up my hands and admit I did!!!

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 01/09/2022 20:26

@Butterflyfluff

Agree totally. It has massively confused me too. The price 'cap' is a fucking bullshit name, because it suggests that the £3,549 or 'price cap' is the MOST you will pay. It's not. It's a cap for the individual units (or something like that!)

I was thinking the price cap is the most anyone will pay, (altogether - that whole year - ) and that is a load of bollocks. The 'price cap' is ONLY for each unit. You could still have a £5000 a year bill, (or you could have LESS than £3,459 of course!)

I was thinking 'well the 'price cap' is a lot, but at least we know where we stand, and it won't be any more than that. What a fucking fool I was. Hmm

As I said, (and you said OP,) the 'PRICE CAP' (price fix,) it is a VERY MISLEADING NAME!!!

StatisticallyChallenged · 01/09/2022 20:21

I had this exact conversation with my lovely MIL earlier - she thought if she fixed she wouldn't have to worry about putting the heating on. She finds this all really confusing and she's a high user so it could make an enormous difference.

Also discovered she has a 40 year old chest freezer...dread to think what that's consuming energy wise

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 20:13

Catell · 01/09/2022 19:57

This Grin

@Catell based on your posts you appear to be one of the people who think your bill is going to stay the same, regardless of what you actually use.

Please correct me if I’m wrong but the screenshot you posted doesn’t mean your DD will cover your energy costs until Dec 2023, regardless of usage.

It just means the rate you pay per unit and the standing charges are fixed.

If your usage increases your total bill will go up.

If your usage stays the same, the fixed DD will cover it.

For those people who think ‘ah well, I’m paying a fortune on my fixed rate so I’ll just crank up the heating’ - they are going to get hit with a big bill as it’s not unlimited usage for the fixed DD.

OP posts: