Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My energy bill will still quadruple even if I put a jumper on?

361 replies

verdantverdure · 01/09/2022 10:53

AIBU to think that even if I participate in this weird new “wear warm clothes in wintertime” trend, shut doors, buy draught excluders, buy Oodies, buy thermal curtains, and buy a £300 air fryer my energy bill will still quadruple.

Especially as most people wete already doing all or some of that.

Nothing short of turning the heating off is going to make much difference is it?

(Although of course I'm trying.)

After all, the money saving expert himself, Martin Lewis, says this isn’t something individuals can fix on their own , and it would be pretty arrogant to think I know better than him.

The "Put a jumper on" advice doesn't help British businesses at all does it?

What do you think?

My energy bill will still quadruple even if I put a jumper on?
My energy bill will still quadruple even if I put a jumper on?
My energy bill will still quadruple even if I put a jumper on?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Eeksteek · 02/09/2022 20:24

I started being a real energy nerd at the wrong time, so I don’t have accurate figures for a whole year. These are my best guesses. (Apologies for length. I wanted to show my working. TLDR: Even with cutting use to the bone, I need to earn £3000 more this year than last year to pay my fuel bill)

My DD should have been £80 pcm (they insisted on £99, but I clawed £300 back in credit over the year, so I was right!) November 2020-2021

Last winter I implemented EVERY single no or low cost energy saving hack I possibly could. Oven only on twice a week and stuffed to the gills, microwaved or quick hob food the rest of the week. Fridge and freezer turned down (up?), garage freezer defrosted and off, smart plugs to turn things off at night where possible (I only have so many smart plugs). No tumble dryer, DW and washer on eco cycles only, absolute minimum and only when full. Washed bedding once a fortnight, clothes only when really dirty (easily three days for me. Two for the kiddo). Showers twice a week if not seeing anyone, max three times if I needed to be polite. Smart radiator valves where possible, rads totally off in some rooms, heating at 18°C for an hour morning and night, 17°C the rest of the time. Completely off if we are out or at night. Solar nightlights and bedside light for me. I go to bed when the kid does and watch TV on my ipad or read by a kindle or solar light. The camper has a solar panel, so I charge kindle/iPad/solar lights in that. Added chimney blockers, and taped up the cat flap and dryer vent. Added draught excluding tape to external doors and loft hatch. I stopped using convenient appliances like the boiling water tap or food mixer and just did without. I don’t see what more I can do and stay in the 21st century.

I was cold and uncomfortable, even in April and May. I couldn’t afford to go out, and couldn’t afford to keep my home comfortable. It was grim. It did make a difference - about £15 a month. I estimate without the March rise, I’d need to pay £65 a month to be just-about-bearably uncomfortable, but miserable by anyone measure. That was in spring though. Obviously usage is less over the summer anyway, so I’m not totally sure of my figures going into winter.

Now I’m slightly better off. I could just about afford the extra £15 quid a month. Only it isn’t £15. Even with every possible cutback, my energy bill is likely to be about £250 a month (I’ve been offered a fix for £360. It’s including the 20% uplift the energy company insist on, even though they were wrong AND excluding my usage decreases, so I reckon £250 is in the ballpark). And I’ve already cut ALL waste, all nice-to-have’s and some normal usage.

So, I’ve put my metaphorical jumpers on, and I’ve still got to find an additional £170 a month. That’s more than twice my food budget. I can’t just divert it from savings, I’m on the bones of my arse and have no savings.

The point I think OP was making (and I think Mr MSE is also making) is that you can’t thrift your way out of this. Even with borderline-unbearable sacrifices, energy bills are STILL going to increase beyond many people’s capacity to pay them. Even with lowered usage, £170 isn’t a small amount to find for an average earner with average expenses. It’s the equivalent of a basic rate taxpayer’s salary decrease of £3000 a year.

The poverty line has effectively just gone up by £3000 a year. And that’s just energy, not including petrol, travel, food or other necessities which will also rise as a result. Wages have not risen by £3000 a year. Everyone who had £3000 to spare last year will not have anything spare this year. Anyone who had less than that, or has higher energy costs than me or can’t and or isn’t prepared to make the sacrifices I have made (and no one should have to) will have less money coming in than going out.

Who said putting jumpers on is bailing out the boat with a teaspoon? You’re absolutely right. Jumpers, energy saving kettles (FFS Boris! Do you ever learn when to STFU? You have no clue and it’s not your call. Stay out of it) and turning down the thermostat is nibbling at a problem that is going to bite back hard.

(I’ll be ok. I’ve got myself a second winter job. With a bit of luck, I’ll have a bit spare for food increases and Christmas as well. But not everyone is in a position to earn £3000 a year more, are they? And what will they do?)

PeachyPeachTrees · 02/09/2022 20:23

It's a bit like the guy who said "the rise in petrol prices hasn't affected me as I still top up with £20 at the petrol station"

BooneyBeautiful · 02/09/2022 19:55

ImEasyLikeSundayMorning · 01/09/2022 11:08

YANBU.

And am I being really thick here - if someone is on a fixed tariff then it surely doesn't matter if you try and keep the heating off, and wear 6 jumpers?

If you are on a fixed tariff, you still have to pay more each month if you use more than your provider predicted. Or vice versa, if you use less, you can ask for your monthly amount to be reduced or ask for a refund.

Dahliasandtea · 02/09/2022 19:53

People giving put on a jumper advice shows how little those people grasp the actual problem. It’s very reminiscent of Edwina Curry telling pensioners to wear a woolly hat

DaughterofZion · 02/09/2022 19:46

luxxlisbon · 01/09/2022 11:14

Since when is wearing a jumper in the winter a new trend? 😂

😅😅😅

Sporty2022 · 02/09/2022 19:22

Apart from cutting back where we can, there’s not much else we can do. The bottom line is the government need to intervene more, otherwise people will die or lose their livelihoods.
Simple as that.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 02/09/2022 19:08

Yes, energy has gone up, hundredth thread on this as if we didn’t know.

JS87 · 02/09/2022 13:12

SlowingDownAndDown · 02/09/2022 08:11

https://www.bestheating.com/info/is-it-cheaper-to-keep-your-central-heating-on-low-all-the-time/

It may be true if you have very good insulation, but probably isn’t for most of us.

we have tended to keep ours on 18.5 all day as wfh and DH gets miserable when cold. I’ve noticed that the radiators never get very warm except first thing in the morning when heating house from cold. Conversely if you have it on twice a day and off all daytime the radiators get hot to touch twice a day instead of once. We don’t have a smart meter yet but this winter I think I will take a reading each day and compare methods (of course the temperature and weather needs to be the same on those days).

TeacupDrama · 02/09/2022 13:09

somethings do not save money, ie boiling a kettle and putting it in a flask it takes twice as much energy to boil 600ml for 2 mugs as it does 300ml for 1 mug
switching wifi off at router can lower your signal and speed as generally it automatically reduces speed to even out the drops ( caused by switching off) a router uses so little it is not worth switching off, however some other things are.
during winter boiler should be on a frost stat setting at 5-8C so it comes on to stop pipes freezing which will cost you a great deal more than the amount of heat to stop freezing pipes.
clothes are generally not dirty or smelly after one wear, the only things we wash after one wear are pants, socks, thin tights, white school shirts, anything that actually has a mark on that won't sponge off, dishclothes for cleaning surfaces floors etc ( they are saved together with towels and eco face make up removal pads for once a week hot wash ) skirts and jackets that barely touch body don't need washing often, tops, shirts leggings joggers after 2-3 wears, hoodies and jumpers regular trousers when necessary

maddening · 02/09/2022 12:48

Or debit if you use more also

maddening · 02/09/2022 12:47

BrownTableMat · 01/09/2022 11:10

Not this misunderstanding again. A fixed rate fixes the UNIT PRICE, not the monthly cost. It is not an ‘all you can eat’ tariff. You will still pay for exactly the amount of energy you use. I am a bit terrified at the number of people who seem to think that ‘the cap’ or a ‘fixed rate’ means you can’t be charged above a certain amount monthly.

However your estimated bill is based on your previous usage, so if you use as before your estimate based on your new kwph rate is likely to balance out over the year. You could end up in credit if you reduce your usage compared to the amount estimated as.

Getoff · 02/09/2022 12:39

etulosba · 01/09/2022 20:29

remember a billion is 1,000,000,000 (one thousand million)

It was 1,000,000,000,000 (one million million) when I was at school.

Granted, that was a while ago.

I've just googled to check, and I reckon 1974 is the year when the UK converted from the million-million definition to the thousand-million one. Apparently Harold Wilson announced then that government statistics would use the thousand million definition.

I suspect it would be some time after that before school textbooks were updated though.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/09/2022 11:51

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 11:47

Unless i spill something on myself or sweat excessively I wear most of my dresses happily 3x before wash.
Tops happily 2x.
And so on.
You don't want to know how many times do I use towels😁

I'm the same. No doubt someone will be along to tell us how disgusting we are!

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 11:47

Unless i spill something on myself or sweat excessively I wear most of my dresses happily 3x before wash.
Tops happily 2x.
And so on.
You don't want to know how many times do I use towels😁

BMW6 · 02/09/2022 11:45

Well I've just calculated that in 2021 my average monthly cost for g & e was £87.50.

I used the tumble dryer at least twice a week apart from Summer, and heating was on 7am to 11pm every day (both retired) from October to Apri / May.

There's quite a lot we can do to reduce our use so our bills don't quadruple. We pay by variable dd for actual useage. Just got our bill for last month Gas £15 and Electric £53 (plus pence).
Used the Electric oven as usual so can cut down that cost.

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 11:23

If it don't smell and it looks clean it doesn't go in the wash

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 10:33

Dadaya · 02/09/2022 08:46

I wfh so I use heating during the day. 8am - 8pm the thermostat is set to 18, and it turns itself on and off as necessary to maintain that temp. 8pm -8am it’s turned off completely. I didn’t think 18 was that high, I often feel cold and still wear a jumper.

Surely washing less means re-wearing dirty clothes?! We wear clean clothes everyday for school and work, I don’t see how we can reduce that. Obviously we re-wear pyjamas and casual clothes around the house, but we can’t go out in dirty clothes.

If you wfh are your clothes really getting dirty after only one day? In winter? Tops or trousers too? I go out to work and tops are fine for two or three days in winter, jumpers and jeans much longer.

JS87 · 02/09/2022 10:32

Dadaya · 02/09/2022 08:46

I wfh so I use heating during the day. 8am - 8pm the thermostat is set to 18, and it turns itself on and off as necessary to maintain that temp. 8pm -8am it’s turned off completely. I didn’t think 18 was that high, I often feel cold and still wear a jumper.

Surely washing less means re-wearing dirty clothes?! We wear clean clothes everyday for school and work, I don’t see how we can reduce that. Obviously we re-wear pyjamas and casual clothes around the house, but we can’t go out in dirty clothes.

Doesn’t that depend on your definition of dirty clothes? Jeans are basically self cleaning and only need washing when smelly. For everything else (except underwear) we only wash if they smell
or have food on them. For me and DH that is after about three wears but for DS it’s generally everyday. He doesn’t change uniform everyday though as packed lunch doesn’t create much mess and he changes when he gets home. Just because you have worn something it doesn’t mean it’s dirty.

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 10:30

Measurements are the only way to know what really works

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 10:29

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 09:37

Well our gas usage is also below average so it's not simple !

It will depend on what you heat the rooms to when you have the heating on

if it's comfortable just before your heating goes on you will be "over heating" to a higher temperature when the heating is on - steady state is usually more efficient

It's more the drop in usage that that convinced me, for our household that is. Was at over 8000kwh for gas a couple of years ago (at 17 degrees but for longer hours), currently the yearly estimate is 5100kwh.

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 09:37

Well our gas usage is also below average so it's not simple !

It will depend on what you heat the rooms to when you have the heating on

if it's comfortable just before your heating goes on you will be "over heating" to a higher temperature when the heating is on - steady state is usually more efficient

FloorWipes · 02/09/2022 09:27

Whether you clothes get dirty after 1 wear sort of depends on the clothes. For travel in winter where washing is limited I’ve used e.g. tweed dress which can be reworn loads before there’s an issue and I can just change tights/undergarments which are small to wash. Not that we can all go out and change our wardrobes! But for a more normal example, you don’t wash jeans after 1 wear.

Dadaya · 02/09/2022 08:46

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 06:09

I don't know your circumstances obviously, but if you mean heating is on for 12 hours a day then that is a lot. Unless you mean off for 12 hours a day and 8 at night or similar? Ours will be on for three hours a day.

I've reduced washing machine usage by washing things less often, bought smaller towels, full loads and only at 30. I keep water in the fridge to avoid losing as much heat in air when I open it.

I wfh so I use heating during the day. 8am - 8pm the thermostat is set to 18, and it turns itself on and off as necessary to maintain that temp. 8pm -8am it’s turned off completely. I didn’t think 18 was that high, I often feel cold and still wear a jumper.

Surely washing less means re-wearing dirty clothes?! We wear clean clothes everyday for school and work, I don’t see how we can reduce that. Obviously we re-wear pyjamas and casual clothes around the house, but we can’t go out in dirty clothes.

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 08:25

SlowingDownAndDown · 02/09/2022 08:11

https://www.bestheating.com/info/is-it-cheaper-to-keep-your-central-heating-on-low-all-the-time/

It may be true if you have very good insulation, but probably isn’t for most of us.

I used to have mine on for two hours in the morning and five and a half in the evening, down to three total and only dropped by one degree and my usage has come down a lot. I have a window open in the day so couldn't leave the heating on anyway.

SlowingDownAndDown · 02/09/2022 08:11

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 07:54

I thought Martin Lewis or someone else had shown that wasn't true? Otherwise, I don't know why my gas usage is so much lower than the average with two people (average 2.4).

https://www.bestheating.com/info/is-it-cheaper-to-keep-your-central-heating-on-low-all-the-time/

It may be true if you have very good insulation, but probably isn’t for most of us.