Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL annoyance

33 replies

nightanddayy · 31/08/2022 22:32

I live with my dd (12) and dh (not her father)
He has a ds 15, we have a 3 bed house so they have a room each, ds only stays 2 weekends a month, sometimes less if he doesn't feel like coming over (no reason other than being a teen)

We have just had a baby, MIL is upset that we will be using her grandsons room for the baby and he should share with my dd, because her room is bigger.

This has really pissed me off. Firstly its none of her business what we do with our family in our house. Secondly the fact that she wants my dd put out even though there will be a room sitting empty 80%of the time!

We have even said that when ds stays he can have his privacy and baby will sleep in our room that weekend. Not ideal but we cant afford a 4 bed so needs must.

Before anyone starts about not thinking this through, i was told I couldn't have a baby so he was a little miracle baby.

I know that i am probably feeling territorial over dd but why the hell should she suffer and ds be happily in his room at his mums and his room here sitting empty! That makes no sense!

I want to tell her to back off, dh doesnt want me to as he idolises her!

AIBU to say something?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MargotChateau · 04/09/2022 16:02

I lived in a split custody arrangement between my mother’s and father’s house with a stepfather in the mix too.

OP and the husband cannot afford to buy a house to accommodate the teenaged son. He is there 4 nights a month, less if he has plans with his mates, this will presumably get less as he gets older.

If the son has a permanent bedroom with one parent, that is enough. Most children I knew who had one primary residence had to share rooms on their night with the other parent. OP isn’t even suggesting that he share, the baby will sleep with the parents and the son will have the room to himself when he stays over on his nights.

Mil needs to keep her beak out unless she wants to stump up for paying upgrading to a house with an extra bedroom that will be empty 99 percent of the time.

I agree with the previous poster, grey rock her and be boring. Just say it’s not up for discussion ad nauseam, and don’t get into a discussion with her about it.

Pamlar · 01/09/2022 12:10

Ignore her.
None of her business.
Discussing it with her will only irritate you more and honestly why even dignify her interference with a comment.
I would however work out exactly how you plan to store the baby's stuff so you can access it when dss is staying. And I would keep baby decorations to a minimum so it doesn't feel embarrassing for dss to sleep there.

SummerInSun · 01/09/2022 11:55

As PP said, you don't need to have it out with her, you just do what you are planning to do anyway. Or course it would be silly to have one room standing empty most of the time while the two children living in the house squash together.

Make sure DSS understands that when he is visiting, the room will be his, not with a baby napping in it or whatever. If MIL raises the issue again, you can try calmly explaining to her that it will be DSS's room when he is there, not actually sharing with the baby. For all you know, she hasn't appreciated that point. But once she understands, just drop it. A polite "we would love to have 4 bedrooms but as we don't, we have to do the best we can, which is to give DSS his own space when he visits and make the most sensible use of the space the rest of the time." Then just don't discuss it anymore.

CoffeeBeansGalore · 01/09/2022 11:48

Start asking her when she's going to sort out the bedrooms in HER house to make it fair for all your children. As they must ALL be treated the same.

Bobbins36 · 01/09/2022 11:43

Ignore her chat about this. Not her business, just crack on and do what you planned to do.

nightanddayy · 01/09/2022 11:30

@KettrickenSmiled her argument is dd sharing or splitting the room will make it the same size as dss's room (which it wont it will be smaller) so she see's that as fair.

OP posts:
SalviaOfficinalis · 01/09/2022 11:11

It’s none of her business. Let her be unhappy about it.

If she actually says anything about it to you, just say “it’s not up for discussion”.

KettrickenSmiled · 01/09/2022 11:03

FWIW I think you are wrong. The decision will displace and upset a 15 year old much more than a baby. But you don’t care about his feelings do you? Only your baby matters.

What a pile of frothing nonsense.
The 15 year old isn't being displaced @UWhatNow.
On the 4 nights a month he spend with them, he will have his own room to himself as usual.

The alternative is to displace the 12 year old girl, every night of the month, by making her share the only bedroom she has. Or did you not think that bit through?

KettrickenSmiled · 01/09/2022 10:57

I want to tell her to back off, dh doesnt want me to as he idolises her!

Oh dear.
How long have you been suffering from the delusion that you need your DH's permission to open your mouth?
Does he often police your speech, or is this a one-off?

If you want to speak up, just do it. But calmly (don't let her know she's 'got to you') "MiL, it works for us as a family, so that's what we're going to be doing."
That's such a bland & polite statement it's almost Grey Rock -
www.betterup.com/blog/grey-rocking
however, she may give you some push back if she's unused to being stood up to - which I imagine she is if her own son's too wet to challenge her.

In which case you'll probably get an Extinction Burst from her - which you can ride out with more Grey Rock & the Broken Record technique.
www.parentingforbrain.com/extinction-burst/
www.revolutionlearning.co.uk/article/the-broken-record-technique/

NewYorkLassie · 01/09/2022 10:56

So you’re just going to stick a cot and all the baby‘a stuff into DSS’s room and leave the rest the same? Must be a pretty big third bedroom for that to work.

I don’t understand why wouldn’t use the bigger room for the shared space (DSS and baby) and move DD to the smaller room. It would still be her own space not to be shared.

vivainsomnia · 01/09/2022 10:44

Speak with your sds. Would he be upset or not. Discuss decoration. What is important to him? Space for himself when there, places to put his stuff? Walls a particular colour?

Talk it through, agree compromises look at storage, decoration ideas etc...

Holly60 · 01/09/2022 10:16

You are right on a practical level op.

I can see that your MIL is coming at it from an emotional level. It does seem a bit sad that having a new baby brother now means that there is no physical space put aside for your DSS at his dad's house.

I should imagine MIL feels that your DD has an advocate in you, and she is advocating for DSS.

However as I said, practicality dictates that you do what you've outlined but perhaps DH could have a chat with his eldest and explain that he is always welcome and room will always be made for him.

The truth is though, that there won't be room for him really, from now on he will be a guest.

Patchworkpatty · 01/09/2022 07:44

I find the comments on these threads so hypocritical... 'the first wives club' will forever bleat about how terrible it is that the DSC are not treated in the EXACT same way as resident children. (One batshit post even referred to the room size - why is that even a thing when 99% of DSC simply need a space for a screen whilst lounging on their beds ! - but I digress)

It's the determination that 'they must be treated equally' that gets me.. demonstrated in this post by the 'grandmother looking out for her grandson'.. but I note that the same GM doesn't seem to be giving her STEP grand daughter a second thought. Because if she was - she would see that it's barking mad to expect her to share with a baby when there is a room standing empty 80% of the time. It's just not practical when rooms are at a premium.

Dibbydoos · 01/09/2022 01:31

Do what you want. She doesn't live with you so her opinion is just that. Ergo it's irrelevant.

I personally think you're making a good shout. Few of us can afford to leave rooms vacant and your DD will def have interrupted sleep if the baby is in with her.

Thankgoditsbedtyme · 01/09/2022 01:09

UWhatNow · 01/09/2022 00:28

I don’t agree that it’s ‘none of her business’. She’s their grandmother, not a stranger off the street, of course she’ll have a view on how they’re treated. As she should. So again typical MN MIL hating.

If you’re so resolute about the room arrangement then there isn’t much she can do. You don’t need to fall out with her and get some frothed up. Get your DH to pass on the message.

FWIW I think you are wrong. The decision will displace and upset a 15 year old much more than a baby. But you don’t care about his feelings do you? Only your baby matters.

At least the grandmother cares about the teenager.

What about the daughter who lives there full time, the op hasn’t mentioned being worried about upsetting the babies feelings. She’s said why should her daughter have to share when the room is stood empty most of the time.
Both the newborn and the 15 year old are the same sex so therefore it’s more practical that they would share going forward.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/09/2022 01:08

There's a whiff of sexism about it, that a girl is to by put with the baby. I do wonder what you'll do in a few years but that's the future.

perfectstorm · 01/09/2022 01:00

UWhatNow · 01/09/2022 00:28

I don’t agree that it’s ‘none of her business’. She’s their grandmother, not a stranger off the street, of course she’ll have a view on how they’re treated. As she should. So again typical MN MIL hating.

If you’re so resolute about the room arrangement then there isn’t much she can do. You don’t need to fall out with her and get some frothed up. Get your DH to pass on the message.

FWIW I think you are wrong. The decision will displace and upset a 15 year old much more than a baby. But you don’t care about his feelings do you? Only your baby matters.

At least the grandmother cares about the teenager.

They aren't worrying about the baby feeling displaced. They are worrying about the 12 year old, who lives in the house full time, having to share full time with a newborn - when her 15 year old stepbrother has another room all to himself at his mum's house, another at his nan's, and yet another at the OP's house - where he stays for a maximum of 4 nights a month and usually less - and yet said nan feels that he should not have to share there either and that the OP's daughter, who has no other space but that bedroom, must instead.

How is that remotely right or fair? It clearly isn't. You'd need to be so heavily invested in always siding with a MIL that you didn't give a damn about the children to think otherwise, frankly.

OP, I'd have the baby in with you when your stepson visits, so he still has a space he can retreat to, and otherwise I agree: baby in that room, so your daughter has privacy in her one and only dedicated space. It makes no sense at all for a room to sit empty 27 nights out of 31, while your soon-to-be-teenage daughter shares with a baby 365 days a year.

Your DSS is going to be 18 and in all likelihood off to college in a couple of years, so by the time your baby really can't sleep in your room even just two weekends a month or less, your DSS will have left home pretty well, anyway.

UWhatNow · 01/09/2022 00:28

I don’t agree that it’s ‘none of her business’. She’s their grandmother, not a stranger off the street, of course she’ll have a view on how they’re treated. As she should. So again typical MN MIL hating.

If you’re so resolute about the room arrangement then there isn’t much she can do. You don’t need to fall out with her and get some frothed up. Get your DH to pass on the message.

FWIW I think you are wrong. The decision will displace and upset a 15 year old much more than a baby. But you don’t care about his feelings do you? Only your baby matters.

At least the grandmother cares about the teenager.

lickenchugget · 01/09/2022 00:25

Freddiefox · 31/08/2022 22:35

She’s just looking out for her grandchildren, won’t the baby be a newborn for a while and in with you for a few months.
it hard in blended families. But no need to have it out with her, just do what you think is right.

She’s only looking out for one of them though? This is the thing with blended families, everyone else feels like they need to stick up for the poor, poor, DSC. While the new DC must be happy with much less as their parents are together so that’s that.

BashfulClam · 01/09/2022 00:24

‘This is what we have decided’ repeat like a parrot to every comment from her.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/09/2022 00:16

I don't understand why you would even be having a conversation about this with her. It's none of her business. Let your husband deal with her.

NoseyNellie · 01/09/2022 00:10

I don’t think you need to ‘have a word’ with her - just ignore her. She can have all the opinions she wants but who has the time or energy to argue with someone who’s opinion doesn’t count 😀

if it comes up again, change the subject, offer her a cup of tea, start singing “la la la” with your fingers in your ears - she’ll get the message eventually

nightanddayy · 31/08/2022 22:58

MarianneVos · 31/08/2022 22:55

I'm sure DS would much rather just have one room that was his permanently rather than 3 he splits his time between so YABU that he's somehow getting a better deal because of this! It's very disruptive to be moving between households so I would have a bit more empathy for him.

Well i'm sure given the chance my dd would like to have 2 bedrooms one here and one at her fathers if he was a decent human being but he's not.

So that point is irrelevant.

It's black and white, dss will still have his room to himself when he is over, when he's not it's his brothers room.

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 31/08/2022 22:58

What happens in your house does not involve your mil. Hopefully both you and your Dh have told her to keep her neb out?

nightanddayy · 31/08/2022 22:55

MarianneVos · 31/08/2022 22:53

I would want DS to feel like his dad's house was his home just as much as his mum's house, regardless of the time split.

Are both bedrooms the same size? Can you have a divider in the bigger one if not to split it in two? Or do something permanently to change two rooms into three small rooms? Or any space to do loft conversion/extension?

No nothing is changing at all regarding the rooms that's not even up for debate. That is the point i want to tell her. Even if dd's room was 10 times bigger (its obviously not) we have chosen to give her that room and it's not changing!

OP posts: