Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think people should be fined if they leave their tents?

136 replies

adhdforme · 31/08/2022 21:55

I have just seen the mess left behind at the Reading festival. An absolute disgrace! The amount of rubbish and tents left behind that organisers are forced to clear up. What makes people think this is ok? I have:

a) Always wondered why people feels it's ok to leave their mess behind like this. They obviously don't care

b) Can't comprehend how people can pay good money for a tent only to chuck it away after

c) Never been to a festival because I know I just couldn't handle the filth and chaos of it all, so I struggle to understand the above two points.

Is there not a way event organisers can encourage attendees to tidy up after themselves? More waste bins? Attendees given a ticket / wrist band that shows they did or didn't arrive with a tent and then fined at the end if they do not leave with what they came with? As I said I've not been to a festival before, so I have no idea how it all works. But I find the aftermath absolutely disgusting 😡

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrasssInPocket · 04/09/2022 12:01

I stayed after a festival to help clear up about ten years ago and ended up with a free brand new £500 8 man tent. People just buy them for the weekend and then abandon them. I've still got the tent, it's great! But I do wish people wouldn't do it. It doesn't take long at all to take the tent down and even just drop it in a charity shop on the way home. Anything but abandoning them to landfill (which is what happens to most of the abandoned tents).

It's not all cheap pop-up tents that are left, though. I know someone who salvaged a brand new, very expensive, state-of-the-art family tent (after checking inside first!).They'd spotted the occupants calmly packing up and leaving on Saturday night. There was no trouble in that particular camp, but it was just as messy on Sunday morning. The tent has clearly been bought and used just once - most of the guylines still neatly bundled by the manufacturer. Carpet too. They looked it up online out of curiosity to find retailing for well over £1k! Some people clearly have more money than sense. 🙄

DdraigGoch · 03/09/2022 22:18

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 01/09/2022 02:23

The price includes employing staff clearing up, it happens at nearly every festival. The cost of clean up is built in to the price. It’s about 300 quid just for entry, car parking is about 40 quid a day and camping is about 500 quid for a 4 man tent. 300 for a two man which is tiny. Going to reading costs about a grand before you’ve even bought a drink or a sandwich.

"I don't need to look after the environment because I'm paying someone else to chuck stuff in landfill so that I don't have to". There shouldn't be waste in the first place, those tents would last years if looked after.

entropynow · 03/09/2022 15:44

JackieDaws · 31/08/2022 22:00

You're right. But you'll find that the entitled people here will come up with excuse after excuse as to why their tent has been left behind.

Amd if your tent does get stolen, report it to security so you don't get fined.

Exactly. "Oh our tent was too fragile". Bollocks. We've a cheap as chips Mountain warehouse 'festival' tent that's well over 10 years old and has been pitched and put away multiple times, including when wet. You just take it out again and dry it off.

RaggedBlousedPhilanthropist · 03/09/2022 15:02

I used to go to the Reading Festival many years ago with DH.

The final time was enough for us.

All night drunk people shouting and screaming clearly off their faces, fighting, falling into our tent as we were trying to sleep. Trying to force their way into our tent convinced it was theirs. The devastation the next morning with an astonishing amount of litter including human waste.

My defining memory of the last one was seeing a shit-filled adult nappy smeared all over a broken tent.

Humanity at its lowest.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 03/09/2022 14:18

I was dismayed seeing reports from Reading and Leeds this year. I've attended myself when much younger and it really wasn't anything like this.
I'm mostly disappointed because I thought the younger generations were much more environmentally aware these days (being taught in school and growing up in the era of climate emergency).
When you think of how much of the debris will end up in landfill, can we really justify holding such events in the future?

slightlyatsea · 03/09/2022 12:21

It would be really easy to police. You have to give a deposit per tent you arrive with, you get the deposit back if you can show the tent when you leave.

adamanti · 03/09/2022 09:19

Im coming over all DM, sorry but I bet some of these dicks are also the ones who glue themselves to motorways and block ambulances. Hmm. What is it exactly about a tents material composition that stops you getting wet...

xmaswiththeinlaws · 03/09/2022 08:36

I believe some festivals were trialling compostable cardboard tents a few years ago that you pay to rent and then get thrown away afterwards. Not sure how successful they were though.

SouthOfFrance · 03/09/2022 08:04

Saying that the clear up is factored into the price of a ticket is absolutely not saying leaving your tent and litter is acceptable. Of course it isn't. But people saying there should be security on the way out making sure everyone leaves with their sleeping bag and tent are not thinking of the logistics of making that happen.

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 03/09/2022 06:36

Care for Calais and other charities do go to the Reading site and pick up undamaged tents and equipment. They then get cleaned and taken to Calais.

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 03/09/2022 06:22

My sister-in-law and I took our kids to Reading and there were literally no waste bins at all. We were standing there with wrappers from fish and chips and just had no idea what to do with them. I just couldn't bring myself to throw them on the floor but we were standing almost knee deep in absolute filth and crap so nobody else had the same problem.

LethalCocktailOfMindBendingDrugs · 03/09/2022 06:17

I live near a popular beach and they do the same there every night in the summer. Unwanted possessions just left, to be washed into the sea or removed by one overworked litter-picker. It makes me have extremely dark thoughts about humanity. We don’t deserve this planet.

RammyEwie · 02/09/2022 23:14

I hate the fact that disposable festival culture has spread into regular camping. At many sites, if there's poor weather people will abandon their tents and scarper. Even when damaged gear is taken to the bins, it's still bulky and expensive for the site owners to deal with.

I've once had a tent destroyed in a storm and the sodden bundle of fractured fibreglass and ripped nylon at least came home with me. It was a brutal night (I was stranded in a mountain shelter so had no chance to protect the tent) and the site couldn't cope with disposing with the quantity of tents that had been destroyed.
At more commercial sites people do think it's acceptable to dump and run. I know one site that uses a tractor to smush the broken gear into the skips it happens that often.

LemonSwan · 02/09/2022 23:00

I agree it’s a problem much worse at reading/ Leeds. Most other festivals now are shit hot on the whole environmental ethos and people take pride in that even when they are fucked.

And it’s not just visible rubbish - try and piss in a ditch in Glastonbury and your getting booed by 100s if not 1000s of people.

I think the problem at R/L is partly demographic, partly organiser. 1000s of 16yos who have never even been to a bar let alone a festival equals a problem.
The set up of the event makes it worse with the one main arena area and then little in the campsites so you don’t have any natural surveillance/through-fare.

The setup of the bars/alcohol all being in the arena and no bringing alcohol / drinks too and from camp causes issues. People take more drugs if they can’t drink or run out. People also leave arena and then don’t have their drinks so raid others tents, or take more drugs or get bored and cause chaos. I much prefer Glastonbury’s openness with no boundary between campsite and arenas. Everything dotted around so you get that natural activity/ surveillance. That you can take your own drink and everyone float around in a chilled way rather than fighting to get into arenas, fighting to get to the bar, to get out again etc. It’s a recipe for pure chaos all round.

Yourcatisnotsorry · 02/09/2022 22:49

People are disgusting. We just got back from the beach. Families leaving bits of broken plastic buckets, dirty socks, glass and food cartons all over the beach ready to be washed in the sea. There were bins available all over. They don’t even have the youth or drunkenness as an excuse.

sjpkgp1 · 02/09/2022 22:37

IWishIHadNotDoneIt · 02/09/2022 18:44

Our local scout group go and help tidy and are allowed to keep the tents

I think there are some good posts on here about that they factor in the cost of the clear up into the ticket (still doesn't make it right) the horrible setting of fires and exploding canisters (my kids have witnessed this and it is scary), and some festivals being more responsible than others (not all festivals or festival goers are bad). I personally wish the notorious ones were safer for the young people involved, they are often only 16 years old and ill-equipped / short of money / get out of their depth quickly - and it seems all "normal rules" are suspended for the pursuit of profit. It is an interesting point about the scout groups though. Most in my District do NOT go to help tidy because the risk is considered too high. There is sometimes drug paraphernalia / needles about and unfortunately the tents are too soiled inside (people taking their last dump rather than walking to the "by now dreadful" loos) or not that waterproof, slashed or broken to be of use. It is great if some groups can get something out of it though. I also salute all of those who work at these festivals in a supportive way, offering water, a quiet cup of tea and a chat, medical needs to the young people, and I hope that the festival organisers contribute heavily to those that do.

Onlyforcake · 02/09/2022 21:57

I've just seen pictures of the post festival field at Shrewsbury. .... its just grass.

I'm fairly sure the logistics aren't very different. So it is entirely possible to clear up after yourself.

user1477391263 · 02/09/2022 21:54

I'm actually perturbed by the number of people who are basically excusing the appalling behavior of festival-goers based on the idea that "the price of cleaning up the mess is priced into the ticket price."

Remember the "broken windows" theory of policing? That if you excuse, laugh off and ignore petty misbehavior, it sends out the wrong signals to everyone? It makes public spaces feel threatening and unwelcoming, which damages social trust. It encourages people to commit more and more petty misdemeanors. And it hints to the worst members of society that there isn't a lot of social pressure to behave properly, encouraging them to try their luck with the really bad behavior. Litter and abandoned tents MATTER.

Festivals like this should be shut down and not held again if we are seeing evidence that people can't behave properly. I get that we've just had two years of COVID misery, but people can and do enjoy themselves without trashing their environments.

kennycat · 02/09/2022 21:35

I think a lot of people have those pop up tents which take a nanosecond to put up but are almost impossible to work out how to fold down unless you are very spacialy aware. At the end of a festival most aren’t very spacialy aware 🥴

Penguinsaregreat · 02/09/2022 20:45

The waste is disgusting.
Its not the money making organisers who will have to live with the dire consequences of global warming and land fill is it. They profit from it so they should somehow be taxed on all the rubbish that is left.

rita12345 · 02/09/2022 20:09

How would they know the owner of an
Abandoned tent?

Tell me your ideas for
Monitoring that

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 02/09/2022 19:57

Whilst littering in general is awful, at a festival it's not like it's just left in a public park to rot - its part of the cost of running a commercial money making festival. Same as a nightclub or any other venue holding an event. You factor in tidying up in the ticket price. And they make a bloody fortune!

The eco aspect of the plastic / waste is the same whoever tidies it away.

Bobbi730 · 02/09/2022 18:54

Reading Festival is absolutely not typical of festivals, I've been to three this summer and they were all left clean and tidy at the end.
I went to Reading once, years ago, it was absolutely horrible but I love festivals.
The tent idea is good but impossible to police. I can't see how it would work.

IWishIHadNotDoneIt · 02/09/2022 18:44

Our local scout group go and help tidy and are allowed to keep the tents

Blueink · 02/09/2022 18:09

YANBU but obviously it’s not that simple