Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that DM is moving 7 hours away

259 replies

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 20:20

So DM and Step Dad currently live around 1 hour away and visit often (approx 1-2 times per month) for sometimes an afternoon, or a day, occasional overnights.
They have just announced that they are moving 7 hours away. It’s a dream of theirs and I REALLY don’t begrudge them. The place looks amazing and it really is a wonderful place to be, but I am SO gutted that they won’t be around to see the kids more often and just to see them myself. They are not young, 70s, and have not thought about how they might need help in years to come.
we have 2 young DC (4&5) who are going to miss out on so much time
with their grandparents. AIBU to be absolutely gutted by this announcement

OP posts:
LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 01/09/2022 12:07

I'd be upset too. My parents relocated almost 5 hours away 6 years ago. Shortly after that my dad was diagnosed with cancer and died 4 years ago. My mum is alone and I'm dreading her getting older and infirm :(

DreamToNightmare · 01/09/2022 12:04

YANBU.

My FIL has my husband and my husbands brother as his children.

My DH’s brother has always lived away from the home town (he’s in the forces) and so FIL hasn’t really seen his grandchildren grow up on that side.

Me and DH live a 10 minute walk away from FIL and he is a very active part of my children’s lives and they adore him. They are 8 and 4 years old.

Lady month FIL announced he’s moving to the other end of the country to be near his other so he can spend time with those children and get to know them as he’s missed out on their childhood. Those three children are 16, 15 and 14.

Me and DH are quite upset as I imagibr at those ages they aren’t going to want to hang around with their 72 year old grandad, whereas our 4 and 8 year old children are incredibly sad they won’t see their grandad anymore.

All that will happen is that he will miss out on seeing his younger grandchildren growing up and being part of their lives in the same way that says he missed out on with his other grandchildren.

I obviously know we have no say on where he lives but it does sting a bit that he’s just dropped our children in favour of his other grandchildren who are probably even too old to care whether he’s around or not. It’s just hard seeing my children so sad that he’s leaving.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 01/09/2022 11:59

i think everyone of any age benefits from organising their life in a sensible way. So if a person needs help from another person, they will need to facilitate that help and living nearby may be part of it

That is true, but the OP's parents don't need any help at the moment. They might never need any help. Lots of people manage old age without support from their families. And not everyone has a protracted period of frailty. MN has a very skewed view of old age. As an HCP, I have plenty of patients in their 80s and 90s who are living independently without family close by.

I've been a carer to both my parents, so I don't underestimate the difficulties, but the OP is not in that situation at the moment.

At 70ish, her parents might be lucky and have a couple of decades of good quality life ahead of them. They should pursue their dreams but, if they do need help from the OP in the future, they should expect to move closer to her again.

SenecaFallsRedux · 01/09/2022 11:55

What is the solution - without being ‘ageist’?

I don't have a solution, and I wasn't speaking to your type of situation. I think your parents are probably being unreasonable about not being willing to move. When my mother needed more help, she agreed to move to our town and to a retirement community that had elder support that was very near my house. I realize that I was lucky in that.

I hope that I will be just as reasonable when the time comes that I need help, but right now being close to retirement and recognizing that DH and I have a limited number of active, independent years left, we want to spend them in the place that we have dreamed of living for a long time, but haven't been able to move to because of work. If and when we need more help from our children, we will likely move closer to them.

EmmaH2022 · 01/09/2022 11:37

Seneca "There is quite a bit of ageism on this thread: expectations that older people should defer to what is convenient for their adult children"

i think everyone of any age benefits from organising their life in a sensible way. So if a person needs help from another person, they will need to facilitate that help and living nearby may be part of it.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 01/09/2022 11:29

There is quite a bit of ageism on this thread: expectations that older people should defer to what is convenient for their adult children.

It’s not a question of convenience in the sneering way you phrase it. DH and I work full time and for me that means a six day week. If my parents were happily looking after themselves living miles away from every other member of their family, that would be fine and I’d think ‘good for them’. But they’re not. They can’t cope any longer but refuse to move, are resisting outside help (carers etc) but expecting me and my siblings to do the carer’s role instead and now we’re all trapped in a nightmarish situation of trying to do as much as we can mostly remotely.

I’m not expecting that they should defer to what is convenient to me, ffs. But neither am I in a position to give up my job and my family and move across the country to care for them. What is the solution - without being ‘ageist’?

SenecaFallsRedux · 01/09/2022 11:13

BUT I do think older folks expecting family assistance ad they age have a responsibility to consider the family they want help from and should move closer not farther away.

I don't expect it. Knowing my children as I do, I think they will probably want to help. Lots of people help facilitate moving older relatives closer when they reach the point that they need help.

There is quite a bit of ageism on this thread: expectations that older people should defer to what is convenient for their adult children. DH and I are planning to move away for a few years after I retire next year (he is already retired). Happily, our children are fully supportive.

Smarshian · 01/09/2022 08:36

We really don’t get lots of help from them in terms of childcare, an occasional hour here and there and usually a couple of days in the holidays. We will manage just paying the extra for those. It’s just that they won’t see us at all for months at a time. They won’t know the kids, the relationship will change. It’s going to be really hard and I need to manage their expectations of us visiting as it will be really difficult.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/09/2022 08:36

Mumwithsons · 01/09/2022 01:41

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee even once a year. It’s the whole ‘I can never visit even though I really care about and miss them’ that I find a mismatch. I get the feeling of disappointment. But we have to meet our family half way, always don’t we? Even if they do things we might think isn’t great.

We can't always meet our family halfway. I am frustrated at the refusal from some posters to admit that and I think maybe OP is too with her parents refusal to admit that.

I mean this on a literal, practical sense.

Once a year may well mean no holidays ever again during the kids childhood. That is not meeting the family halfway is it?

Yes it's unlikely that they will never be able to visit but you can easily see why it feels like that to someone. Especially when this has been sprung on them.

A virtual relationship is not as good. I have lots of family abroad, my kids don't really know the ones they don't see. Not in the way we know the ones we do see.

We need to stop trying to change reality to make this less of an issue than it really is.

My hope for OP is that her parents are being more realistic than she fears and will be visiting regularly and never pressuring the OP to visit them. It is entirely possible that they have put these sort of plans in place.

WildWombat · 01/09/2022 08:20

I get what you're saying, I really do. But speaking as someone who has never had any family to help with childcare or household I can honestly say you just manage. There are loads of us in this position. It will be hard as you've got used to having your parents around nearby, but you'll adapt and so will the kids.

fortygin · 01/09/2022 07:41

OP, I totally understand. Slightly different story but my parents and younger sister moved to another continent when I was 19.
I stayed as I was working and they couldn’t get a work visa for me.
They were there 25 years and through that time I got married, had four dc and broke up with a cheating dh after a 23 year relationship.
i had to do all these things alone ( they visited, of course, but the planning and coping was me alone) and I have to be honest I became quite resentful of my younger sister who had the support of my parents and who helped her through pregnancies and with her DC.

They retired back home 3 years ago and it’s been extremely hard for me.
they have decided not to drive and passively aggressively ask for lifts and as they are getting older ask for help and support.
as a single mum, I’m growing my own career and to be honest am less inclined to offer help as I feel once I was of age, I was left to fend for myself.
of course it’s your parents decision to live their dream, but it does come with consequences and that includes having to work out what will happen in their older years in terms of care etc.
god luck

saraclara · 01/09/2022 07:40

You say you will miss them, then that you'd be so petty as to not help if they return to live near you in 10 years time.

No she didn't. She said she'd not be able to help them in 10 years time if they live seven hours away.

And that's just realistic. I was entirely unable to care for my mum when she had her stroke at her isolated cottage seven hours away. I worked (had no option) and had kids at home as well as a husband with cancer. What do you suggest I should have done @Nobetterthansheoughttobe ?

It's not just the parents who move whose health and general situation might change. The offspring left behind also have changes in their life which mean they can't did what they might have done. I can't tell you how stressful that time was with my mum so far away, my DH with stage 4 cancer and chemo, and my kids to support, knowing they were losing their dad.

These decisions are always made in a spirit of optimism. But unfortunately life throws stuff into the mix, and you have to try to project and understand the what ifs.

Smarshian · 01/09/2022 07:31

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 01/09/2022 07:07

So you only want to see them on your terms? How bloody selfish
My parents live several hours away from me, but I still visit despite the difficulties involed in the journey
You say you will miss them, then that you'd be so petty as to not help if they return to live near you in 10 years time. Dear sodding god
If they are sensible they will make their own care arrangements

I don’t see how it’s selfish to say we will struggle to visit them for weeks at a time. I have 4 weeks annual leave a year. Usually 2 of those will be used for odd days off and childcare and then we may have 1 week away as a family in May and August.
that’s it. So in order to visit for a week I will have to give up one of my family holidays. It’s not a simple visit for a weekend. It’s at least 7 hours each way. I would never drag the kids that far for even a 3 day weekend and we would all be exhausted.

OP posts:
Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 01/09/2022 07:07

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 20:34

I think they have this dream we will come and stay for a week/ weeks at a time. But we just won’t. And I made that clear when they first suggested moving. It would be quicker and easier to visit them in Spain.

So you only want to see them on your terms? How bloody selfish
My parents live several hours away from me, but I still visit despite the difficulties involed in the journey
You say you will miss them, then that you'd be so petty as to not help if they return to live near you in 10 years time. Dear sodding god
If they are sensible they will make their own care arrangements

Tippexy · 01/09/2022 07:06

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 21:32

Perhaps this isn’t coming across very well as I have a real mix of emotions going on.
I will be GUTTED that they are moving away. I think to the point that I will struggle to speak about it to DM. Yes we have had ups and downs but have found a good relationship over the past few years. I am devastated for myself and the kids who are so close to her (and my step dad).
I am just fully aware that we won’t visit like she thinks we will. It just won’t happen. We have limited holiday which must be taken in school holidays, due to childcare issues. DM has previously helped with childcare, although not on a regular basis. I don’t expect masses from her, but I will not be prepared to be giving lots of time and support to her in 10 years time if she has chosen to move 7 hours away.

You have at least 28 days’ holiday, like the rest of us.

I knew opening the thread that this was going to be about childcare, and I was right! 😁

olympicsrock · 01/09/2022 07:00

It is tough. I moved last year and am now about 6 hours from my mum to an amazing part of the UK.
It’s too far for a weekend. It has meant that she has ti do the visiting as it is not really worth the effort for less than 4 nights.
we have arranged to meet I Spain for a ‘Christmas holiday’ meet up as cheaper and quicker flights compared to train tickets.

JasmineIndigo · 01/09/2022 06:41

It's a really crap situation OP. My in laws did something similar - they moved 5 hours away to be near their daughter who had moved up north with her husband. The other three children and their families are all still in the same area where they grew up and where my in laws are from. We just don't really see them anymore, it's too far a trip to just go for the weekend and there are frankly other places we want to go to in the school holidays, as where they have moved to isn't really somewhere where you would go on holiday too. It was like a form of grief for a while but we eventually just got used to not having them around.

locke360 · 01/09/2022 06:38

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 21:40

This is it. I don’t want them to give up their dreams AT ALL. I just honestly feel like my DM has told me I am not important enough to her life. It probably sounds ridiculous but that’s how I am feeling right now.
im sure that given time I will feel differently but I am feeling massively rejected and I can’t even begin to break it to the DC.

I have this situation in the other direction - I moved away from my family.

I had to do it, to live the life I want to live, but it doesn't mean I don't love/ miss them a lot, or that they are 'not important enough'. It's just the area where they live would have sucked the life out of me. I couldn't have stayed there.

Your parents are doing what they need to do in order to live fulfilling lives. It doesn't change how they feel about you - it's most likely nothing whatsoever to do with that.

They are in their 70's and probably aware that time is short to do the things they want to do in life.

I know it's hard to understand from their perspective when you are feeling hurt/ rejected, but please try to. They are not rejecting you at all. Our family ties and the lives we want to lead are sometimes two different things and we can't always easily have both, so we have to make the best of things.

Also, 7 hours isn't the end of the world, it's easily doable for a long weekend, and if you can work from their place as well then it's fine!

Sometimeswinning · 01/09/2022 06:00

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 21:09

I think maybe I need some time to adjust to the idea, but I can’t see myself staying with them regularly whilst I am working.
I do have the benefit of WFH currently so May be able to stay with the kids during half term etc in the future. Kids are currently 4&5 so lots of years where childcare and help (the odd hour to get a haircut etc) would be useful. If they then move back in 10 years and want help themselves I may be frankly less inclined to help.

I had a feeling a comment like this would come up! Yabu.

EmmaH2022 · 01/09/2022 05:50

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 01/09/2022 05:45

I think so many posters on this thread giving you a hard time, OP, have absolutely no idea of what it’s like trying to care for elderly parents when you live a long way away from them and have a full time job and your own family to manage. I’m in that situation now, with parents who made no plans or provision for old age, and it is an absolute nightmare, let me tell you. The constant worry and sense of helplessness is making me ill.

Cross post
that's awful for you. Can they move? I know a few people whose parents have done that.

EmmaH2022 · 01/09/2022 05:48

Dibbydoos "I am going to relocate to an island, Brecon or the Highlands when I retire. It's what I want to do. Frankly, my DCs can sort themselves out!"

just out of interest, why did you want children? Not a criticism - it's just I never wanted children so when people make comments like this, I wonder why they had them. (Of course I realise many people do it and regret it).

pp are mentioning OP other posts, I haven't read any, but I see her point re care, based on the info in this thread.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 01/09/2022 05:45

I think so many posters on this thread giving you a hard time, OP, have absolutely no idea of what it’s like trying to care for elderly parents when you live a long way away from them and have a full time job and your own family to manage. I’m in that situation now, with parents who made no plans or provision for old age, and it is an absolute nightmare, let me tell you. The constant worry and sense of helplessness is making me ill.

HeartofTeFiti · 01/09/2022 04:05

I'm on your side OP. It sounds like it is far too late to stop them going and I would also feel very hurt and devastated. A relationship over Facetime is nothing like a F2F relationship for a young child. My mum managed a great relationship with my overseas DB's kids but only because she made the effort to go to his home and be their summer holiday childcare provider every year when they were little. Even with that effort though, the relationship still wasn't the same quality as the one my kids had with my mum, as we lived close together and saw her all the time, often dropping in spontaneously. So I can completely understand why, if you had in your mind a close easy relationship between you, the DC, DM and SD you are now in shock at what you all lose when they leave.

Have they purchased the new property ahead of selling up locally and moving? I'm surprised they've been able to keep it quiet if they are relocating in a week's time! Maybe that means the move will be staggered?

I also have to say, if they do fully relocate I very much doubt they will move back for you to support them. By the time they realise they need the support, the practicalities of moving will likely be beyond them.

Being so far away really takes the option for you to ever help them out of your hands. Is that maybe part of your mum's thinking, so she won't ever become a burden?

I hope you can have a sensible conversation with them to get reassurance they have thought past the dream to the realities, along the lines of how close are they to a GP, pharmacy and hospital; what is elderly care like where they are moving; and what is it like socially where they are moving to (in case one of them dies and they are alone there).

I know a lady who moved with her DH to the countryside in their early 70s. Beautiful cottage down little winding lane just outside a village, with some land and room for chickens etc. All was fine for a few months, but unexpectedly the guy got diagnosed with cancer which he battled for several years. Wife didn't like driving, and struggled with the hospital logistics and caring for him at home. They found it almost impossible to get cleaners or private carers to help them as they were in a remote location. Winters were especially lonely and depressing for them - their kids worked in jobs that only allowed time off in summer so the kids and GC only came to visit once a year or so in the fine weather. The kidswere helpless when their dad was unwell, as simply too far away to do anything except offer moral support. When her DH eventually died she felt marooned knowing there would be no one to help her if she got sick. She felt forced to relocate again to a nearby town. She never really got her chance to live the dream. It's a huge gamble at that age, to trade the support networks you've got in your local community for the chance to follow a dream hundreds of miles away.

FixItUpChappie · 01/09/2022 03:06

Whatiswrongwithmyknee even once a year. It’s the whole ‘I can never visit even though I really care about and miss them’ that I find a mismatch. I get the feeling of disappointment. But we have to meet our family half way, always don’t we?

unfortunately people get limited vacation time and also want to do other things with that limited time than visit family that have chosen to move 🤷‍♀️If they are retired and this is their choice I think the onus is on them tbh - that’s not to say OP should never visit but I certainly see her point

Nesbo · 01/09/2022 02:40

You sound like you are working your way through the stages of grief after what feels to you like a break up.

You’ve had denial (never thinking they would actually do it), and are now in anger with a bit of bargaining thrown in (“if you did this instead, you’d get this in return”). When you talk about them not having a relationship with the grandchildren, or not being cared for by you when they need it later on in life that sounds like you mentally rehearsing withdrawing what would otherwise be their “reward” for staying.

My parents live on the other side of the planet, about a 30 hour journey away. They love my kids, and my kids love them very much. When they see each other in person it is wonderful and they are very close. Otherwise they speak on FaceTime. Relationships can be maintained at a distance when you put in the effort.

I think you are very much looking at this from the point of view of how it affects you, and resenting it as an unwelcome change to your status quo. For your mum however, this is an exciting, and probably frightening opportunity to do something for herself before it is too late. When you reach her age you may view this moment very differently, and understand her perspective a little more.