Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that DM is moving 7 hours away

259 replies

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 20:20

So DM and Step Dad currently live around 1 hour away and visit often (approx 1-2 times per month) for sometimes an afternoon, or a day, occasional overnights.
They have just announced that they are moving 7 hours away. It’s a dream of theirs and I REALLY don’t begrudge them. The place looks amazing and it really is a wonderful place to be, but I am SO gutted that they won’t be around to see the kids more often and just to see them myself. They are not young, 70s, and have not thought about how they might need help in years to come.
we have 2 young DC (4&5) who are going to miss out on so much time
with their grandparents. AIBU to be absolutely gutted by this announcement

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 01/09/2022 17:38

"I am just fully aware that we won’t visit like she thinks we will. It just won’t happen. We have limited holiday which must be taken in school holidays, due to childcare issues."

YANBU on this score at all. i always wonder about this watching Location, Location... when older couples 'need' four-beds in the middle of nowhere with bucolic fantasies of their grandkids all coming to stay, and I think... will they? For more than a few days here and there over the years? I think your mum may be kidding herself, but there'll be no telling her now. They've obviously done this in secret so that nothing like that kind of reality check will hold them back. Leave them to it. You sound very realistic about the prospect and they'll have to adjust.

Exit123Strategy · 01/09/2022 16:58

If your DM & SD have been discussing for 10 years
2 of those years were during lock down
Many people have looked at the world & their lives differently after covid
Perhaps they thought, now or never !
They may move back in the future

Would you want someone telling you, that you could not follow your dreams ?

saraclara · 01/09/2022 15:51

Rosehugger · 01/09/2022 15:29

YANBU. Are they going somewhere nice to visit though? Perhaps you could go and stay and have quality time with them and nice holidays instead of the daily mundane stuff.

My DP used to live on the Isle of Wight. That was handy of them! Lots of nice family holidays when DDs were small and they were so happy to have us there.

OP had already addressed all your questions.

Rosehugger · 01/09/2022 15:29

YANBU. Are they going somewhere nice to visit though? Perhaps you could go and stay and have quality time with them and nice holidays instead of the daily mundane stuff.

My DP used to live on the Isle of Wight. That was handy of them! Lots of nice family holidays when DDs were small and they were so happy to have us there.

Snowiscold · 01/09/2022 15:26

My parents live over five hours away. The difference is, they have always lived there. I moved away in my early 20s, before I had DC. My DC have a good relationship with their grandparents, though clearly they couldn’t do any regular childcare. Most people I know don’t have parents particularly nearby. If my parents need care -they are in their 80s - I’m not sure what we would do. In fact, I have much worse health than them and it’s more likely that I’d need care before them.

CambsAlways · 01/09/2022 15:18

Good luck to them, they have wanted to do it for ten years , I hope they will be very happy in their dream home, of course you will miss them that’s natural, but be happy for them

saraclara · 01/09/2022 15:09

Candleabra · 01/09/2022 14:49

The caring in old age would worry me. My parents were incredibly young vital and independent until they both got very ill. Suddenly I was at their beck and call it felt like every hour of the day. They became completely dependent on me. And quickly too.
People become very selfish when they’re ill, they can’t help it, but they do.

Yep. My mum was super fit and active before her stroke. And she'd said to us all through life that we must never feel responsible for her or have her live with us (she'd had a hard time with my Gran who moved in with us when she had dementia, and didn't want us to go through the same).

But after her stroke, when we brought her back from her remote cottage, she demanded that my brother take her in (to his tiny two bed bungalow that could no way accommodate her electric wheelchair, hospital type bed, and hoist. Never mind that he has the tiniest bathroom I've even seen. And a wife who my mum has always hated (for no good reason).

She was absolutely furious when he said it wasn't possible, and we had to go through the motions of having an occupational therapist visit it and make a full report, so that a professional was saying that she couldn't live there, rather than just my brother.

Candleabra · 01/09/2022 14:49

The caring in old age would worry me. My parents were incredibly young vital and independent until they both got very ill. Suddenly I was at their beck and call it felt like every hour of the day. They became completely dependent on me. And quickly too.
People become very selfish when they’re ill, they can’t help it, but they do.

Calmdown14 · 01/09/2022 13:44

I live a similar distance from my mum and my kids have a great relationship with her.
They come to see us a couple of times a year, I go to them sometimes but often we meet in the middle.

We meet up for UK holidays so the kids get good time with them. Often caravan parks so they book their own..

We've had some lovely February half term meet ups in cheap premier inns and explored new cities as a result.

My kids love seeing a more urban place and they like the Highlands so it's great

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 13:32

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/09/2022 13:22

Did your parents do a 14-hour round trip to get you there or did your grandparents?

No. Because that would be more than it takes to cross my country☺️. It was just 4. Went up on sat early, they drove back sunday afternoon. Came back 2 weeks later. Sometimes grandma picked us up by train. Same came sat morning, left sun or Monday with us, parents drove 2 weeks later. Other set of grandparents was usually with is in cabin 4.5 hours away where they spent summers, they drove so it was sometimes them, sometimes parents.
My friend still does this between few EU countries. Each set is about 8 hours drive.

saraclara · 01/09/2022 13:30

Nesbo · 01/09/2022 13:15

These poor doddery 70-odd year olds who can’t be trusted to use a lifetime of experience to make a sensible fucking decision about how to live their lives!

Someone mentioned ageism above and I think it is all over this thread. I’m mid 40’s at the moment and I’d be pretty pissed off if someone started patronising me suggesting that perhaps I hadn’t properly considered the consequences of my decisions, particularly ones I’d been thinking about for the last decade.

I’m pretty sure that in another 25 years my reaction will be pretty much the same. And yet there are people on here who seem to think that once you hit your 70’s, rather than being respected you should be treated like an errant child who can no longer be fully trusted to run your own life.

Fuck. That.

I'm 66 and the first to call out ageism. But unfortunately my life was entirely fucked up by my mum following her dream without a sensible thought in her head, at 73 and then expecting me to pick up the pieces from seven hours away.

It's great to have a positive outlook at that age, but we also need to be realistic. My passion is independent long haul travel. I'm doing as much of it as I can now, because experience tells me that I won't always be as fit and mobile as I am now.

If I move, it will be with an eye on the services I might need and the suitability of my home in ten or twenty years time.

If I'm like my Auntie who's 90, still traveling and still independent, that'll be great, and I won't have lost anything.

saturdaymorningbored · 01/09/2022 13:26

If they then move back in 10 years and want help themselves I may be frankly less inclined to help.

Good god, what an awful attitude you have op

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/09/2022 13:22

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 12:19

Kids can still have relationship. We used to stay with GPs couple of weeks in summer. It was great and we love each other still

Did your parents do a 14-hour round trip to get you there or did your grandparents?

escapingthecity · 01/09/2022 13:20

One set of our GPs live 400 miles away and it's about a 7 hour drive (shorter flight/train journey). It is hard. We do a lot of video calls. They are v good at coming down to see us/combining trips to us with other things they want to do. They understand that as they are retired and we both work and have 2 v young DCs they can be more flexible. As the kids grow up I'm hoping they will still be up to having them to stay for a few days during school holidays. You can make it work, it just takes a bit of understanding on both sides about the constraints of the other.

WalterWexler · 01/09/2022 13:19

Can totally relate OP.

DM and DF moved 6hrs away. They have never had the closest relationship with their grandkids.

We see them maybe 1 or twice a year because of the distance and yet always moaning no one see them.

We've naturally become closer to the in laws as they are the closest relatives now, and often have them over at the weekend. I can tell DM silently seethes over this though.

After 5 years, they've Announced they're moving closer to us now. I think they've realised their "dream" life wasn't all its cracked up to be.

Nesbo · 01/09/2022 13:15

These poor doddery 70-odd year olds who can’t be trusted to use a lifetime of experience to make a sensible fucking decision about how to live their lives!

Someone mentioned ageism above and I think it is all over this thread. I’m mid 40’s at the moment and I’d be pretty pissed off if someone started patronising me suggesting that perhaps I hadn’t properly considered the consequences of my decisions, particularly ones I’d been thinking about for the last decade.

I’m pretty sure that in another 25 years my reaction will be pretty much the same. And yet there are people on here who seem to think that once you hit your 70’s, rather than being respected you should be treated like an errant child who can no longer be fully trusted to run your own life.

Fuck. That.

BadNomad · 01/09/2022 13:07

You sound like a horrible daughter. Your mother is in her 70s and finally doing something she has wanted to do for years, but because it doesn't suit you're not going to help her out in the future if she needs it. Are you going to be a martyr to your own children all their lives? Are you going to wash your hands of them if they decide to move away from you when they're older? Will you refuse to visit them?

saraclara · 01/09/2022 12:41

entropynow · 01/09/2022 12:22

Your personal experience is your personal experience and only that. In any case, my point was that the idea of 'everyone' having to go into sheltered housing etc simply isn't the case even for those with care needs, who are themselves a minority.

But experience (and those of others) is what we use to decide whether a course of action is sensible or not. I won't be doing what my mum did and moving seven hours away from my support system to a remote location and a house that is hazardous if you're not fully mobile and agile.

I'll also ensure that I have easy proximity to public transport, so that I'm neither isolated not dependent on others, needlessly.

Assuming never ending good health and agility when you're making plans in your 70s is simply unwise.

entropynow · 01/09/2022 12:22

saraclara · 01/09/2022 12:15

The only old people in my family who managed to stay in their homes with carers coming in, were/are only able to do so because they are also supported by family members, or in one case a wonderful neighbour.

Four visits from carers doesn't get shopping done, the house cleaned, the washing done, bills paid, personal admin etc etc etc.

My SIL had to give up her job in order to spend half the week with my MIL, two hours away, so that she could stay in her own home with 4x daily carer visits. My SIL did everything around the house, cooked meals for the carers to heat up for MIL and basically everything that enabled MIL to manage for the other half of the week.

Your personal experience is your personal experience and only that. In any case, my point was that the idea of 'everyone' having to go into sheltered housing etc simply isn't the case even for those with care needs, who are themselves a minority.

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 12:19

Kids can still have relationship. We used to stay with GPs couple of weeks in summer. It was great and we love each other still

saraclara · 01/09/2022 12:15

entropynow · 01/09/2022 12:09

@FineWordsForAPorcupine

Nothing brutally honest or even true about your prediction. I used to work in adults social care and even those getting multiple care calls a day were majority staying in their own homes. Healthier old people almost exclusively do.

The only old people in my family who managed to stay in their homes with carers coming in, were/are only able to do so because they are also supported by family members, or in one case a wonderful neighbour.

Four visits from carers doesn't get shopping done, the house cleaned, the washing done, bills paid, personal admin etc etc etc.

My SIL had to give up her job in order to spend half the week with my MIL, two hours away, so that she could stay in her own home with 4x daily carer visits. My SIL did everything around the house, cooked meals for the carers to heat up for MIL and basically everything that enabled MIL to manage for the other half of the week.

Gherkingreen · 01/09/2022 12:15

@Smarshian we live 6 hours away from MIL, she lives in a beautiful part of the UK and has done for 30 years. We visited a couple of times a year when DCs were small, perfect for family holidays.
But she's been very unwell for the past two years and has no family nearby. She's 30 miles from nearest hospital. Services to support the elderly have been stripped back so trying to access health and social care support is nigh on impossible. Public transport is poor.
We're at the stage of discussing whether MIL should move nearer to us, but she's understandably resistant. However the current state of things can't continue as DH has regularly stayed with her for weeks at a time after she's been in hospital to look after her, only possible while he's been able to work remotely. That's the reality of it for us, sadly.

WhereYouLeftIt · 01/09/2022 12:14

"I am just fully aware that we won’t visit like she thinks we will. It just won’t happen. We have limited holiday which must be taken in school holidays, due to childcare issues."
I think this is the point you have to get across to your mother. I wonder if she thinks that because she's going to Cornwall and Cornwall is a holiday destination, she has some sort of rosy fantasy that you and the children will automatically come to visit as your actual holiday? And be resistant to the idea that you wouldn't see that as a holiday at all, but a family visit?

It's already been mentioned that when someone moves away, the family 'left behind' fill the gap left in their lives with other people, and the relationship with those who have moved changes. It's not deliberate, it's not malicious, but it is inevitable. I always remember what a 'left behind' said to me about the person who had moved - "did she think that when she moved, the rest of us were wrapped in cotton wool and put into a drawer, only to be taken back out when she came back?" And I saw what they meant. The returner couldn't quite get that those they'd left behind, their lives had moved on, and as life does, their lives had diverged from the life of the leaver. There were no shared memories or events from the years they'd been away, just letters and phone calls. The retutner was a bit hurt that they no longer held a central place in the life of the family they'd left behind. But what was the alternative? That those they'd left behind would live with an unfilled hole for years?

Is your mother prepared for the inevitable lessening of their connection to you and your children? Is she even aware of the possibility?

KettrickenSmiled · 01/09/2022 12:11

80sMum · 31/08/2022 20:36

If I were that mum, I just couldn't do it. As much as I would yearn to go and fulfil my dream and move to my dream home, I wouldn't be able to bring myself to seek my own happiness at the expense of someone else's. I'm not saying that the OP's mum shouldn't go where her heart desires, just that I would feel bad if pursuing my own dream caused another person's life to be less happy. Knowing that would take away all of the joy, for me.

Women - have you experienced parturition?
Then STAY IN YOUR LANE.

Your life is no longer your own & must be sacrificed to everyone else's happiness.

entropynow · 01/09/2022 12:09

@FineWordsForAPorcupine

Nothing brutally honest or even true about your prediction. I used to work in adults social care and even those getting multiple care calls a day were majority staying in their own homes. Healthier old people almost exclusively do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread