Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that DM is moving 7 hours away

259 replies

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 20:20

So DM and Step Dad currently live around 1 hour away and visit often (approx 1-2 times per month) for sometimes an afternoon, or a day, occasional overnights.
They have just announced that they are moving 7 hours away. It’s a dream of theirs and I REALLY don’t begrudge them. The place looks amazing and it really is a wonderful place to be, but I am SO gutted that they won’t be around to see the kids more often and just to see them myself. They are not young, 70s, and have not thought about how they might need help in years to come.
we have 2 young DC (4&5) who are going to miss out on so much time
with their grandparents. AIBU to be absolutely gutted by this announcement

OP posts:
cyclamenqueen · 02/09/2022 10:49

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 09:24

@cyclamenqueen well let's hope all your self sacrifice pays off. You can devote you life to serving your children and grandchildren in the hope theyll be around to assist you in old age but there are no guarantees that that is how it will work out.

I am not serving my children and grandchildren I am setting up my life so that I can be as independent as possible for as long as possible . I was out for lunch yesterday for a 60th birthday, we have all had busy careers and have parents who have been super independent and had careers themselves.

Every single one of us is now dealing with supporting parents , two of us have a parent with dementia , two others are in the midst of helping parents to downsize, sadly several have parents who are now alone and have lost confidence and /or grieving and are needing a lot of emotional support. One has a parent with a debilitating and distressing terminal illness.

we reflected at length on the fact that services, especially in areas that people traditionally ‘retire to’ are stretched to nonexistent. Domiciliary care ; dream on, home helps are just not around , hospital transport non existent, public transport in rural areas has been cut massively over the past two years. Even getting GP appointments for many other clinics such as diabetes and memory is a battle .

I also work in social care and a report today says that 96% of care homes are at risk of closing in the next 12 months. There is a massive crisis coming over the hill and families will inevitably end up bearing more of the burden, they won’t have a choice.

frankly some of the people on this thread are living in cloud cuckoo land . Social care will not be there god people now in their 70s unless there is a massive change in government and society’s attitudes to care .

JoshuaTree36 · 02/09/2022 10:34

I have to admit, I feel you may be being unreasonable.

Your Mum needs to live her own life, and she knows full well that this will change things between her and you+grandkids. Things will not be the same

But this is what she has chosen

Kite22 · 02/09/2022 10:31

saraclara · 02/09/2022 08:26

When children move away, they are responsible for themselves. Their parents might miss them, but they don't have any responsibility for them

When people in their 70s move away, they (generally) only have a limited window of truly independent life. And if they have children, those sons and daughters feel an obligation to support them. So yes, making that incredibly difficult for them to do, is selfish to a certain degree. And as it turned out with my mum, protestations on leaving of "I don't want or expect you to look after me" turn out to be entirely hollow.

I don't know the answer. I can't say it's right to stop people living where they want (we totally understood my mum's wish to go and didn't make any attempts to prevent her doing so or make her feel bad about it). But parents doing that are sending a message, whether they mean to or not.

All of this.

But your point was not required because i was referring to the statemeny I correctly quoted - OP was being petty in saying she would be less inclined to help because they had moved to have some quality of lifexand it didn't suit her.

We are going round in circles a bit now, but surely that is a natural reaction to helping anyone? Someone who has been around for me and supported me in whatever way they can is someone I would move heaven and earth to help when they needed help. Someone who chooses to do things other than help out, then I would help out if it were convenient for me. Now, I'm the first person to offer help to people (have been mocked for it many times on MN when I says I am happy to give lifts or help other parents out - people always call me a mug / soft touch / say I'm being taken advantage of when I just think everyone should 'be nice' and treat other people like they would like to be treated - but I now prioritise looking out for older folk who have "been there for me" over those who haven't. Yes, that means my (now adult) dc have a far closer bond with two or three 'adopted grandparents' than they do some older folk who are actually related to us. It is going to be far easier for any of us, logistically to help out a neighbour from our street than it is a relative who lives a 14 hour round trip away.

hewouldwouldnthe · 02/09/2022 10:10

It's very sad, but nothing you can do except visit her and they visit you for longer than a few days at a time. I'm assuming they are near the beach so you having a long holiday in the summer would be do able?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 02/09/2022 10:09

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 02/09/2022 09:30

She later said that if they returned in 10 years time, she would be less inclined to help them.
That's selfish
The fact that while she has wrtten about not having a terribly close relationship with her mum, yet she is outraged that they are moving
That's selfish
Op has not once acknowledged that relationships can be maintained through social media, facetime etc. Some of us had parents/grandparents abroad well before the days of the internet - when a phone call to that country had to be booked in advance, yet we managed to maintain a relationships
She has not acknowledged that they may want a change of scenery and to live the life they have left on their own terms - and why the fuck shouldn't they? Why should the few years they (or any parent) have remaining spent worrying about where they live and if that is convenient for for their child/children. And what if children are scattered around the country/world - where do the parent live then to suit everyone's needs
So yes, she is being selfish

So she should look after her parents in 10 years or that's selfish but her parents doing nothing to help now is not selfish?
Face time etc is a poor substitute for contact as lockdown taught us. Better than nothing yes but OP not saying anything about it doesn't mean she's vetoed it.

saraclara · 02/09/2022 09:46

yet she is outraged that they are moving
That's selfish

She's not outraged. She wants them to be happy, but she's sad that out turns out that her mum and SD don't want to be a regular part of her and their grandchildren lives.

Despite waving my mum off to her seven hours away, respecting her choice and being happy for her, I felt the same. That I and her GCs weren't as important to her as I thought. It was a bit of a shock.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 02/09/2022 09:39

StoneofDestiny · 31/08/2022 21:03

80sMum

nobody would do anything independently if that was the case.

People should fulfil their dreams and live their lives, not feel obliged to live out other peoples dreams.
The OP can still see her family if she makes the effort to travel, even if it's meeting them half way for a break.
Certainly I'd be happy if my parents were able to live out their dreams like that. 70 isn't ancient by any means.

I completely agree.
Good for them for living their lives! Of course you can visit, it’s hardly the other side of the world 🙄
I wonder what they would have said if it had been you moving?

BadNomad · 02/09/2022 09:38

Nw22 · 02/09/2022 08:49

@BadNomad wow you sound horrible

Because I don't think women should martyr themselves for others? Ok then.

Cloudonthemountains · 02/09/2022 09:31

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 09:24

@cyclamenqueen well let's hope all your self sacrifice pays off. You can devote you life to serving your children and grandchildren in the hope theyll be around to assist you in old age but there are no guarantees that that is how it will work out.

Yes. And of course as a result, the children will feel tied to where the parents are, unable to move elsewhere in pursuit of their own happiness.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 02/09/2022 09:30

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 02/09/2022 08:33

Can you explain what in that quote you believe is selfish?

OP said they can't visit because of when they can take leave, and that she is going to miss them. What's selfish about that?

She later said that if they returned in 10 years time, she would be less inclined to help them.
That's selfish
The fact that while she has wrtten about not having a terribly close relationship with her mum, yet she is outraged that they are moving
That's selfish
Op has not once acknowledged that relationships can be maintained through social media, facetime etc. Some of us had parents/grandparents abroad well before the days of the internet - when a phone call to that country had to be booked in advance, yet we managed to maintain a relationships
She has not acknowledged that they may want a change of scenery and to live the life they have left on their own terms - and why the fuck shouldn't they? Why should the few years they (or any parent) have remaining spent worrying about where they live and if that is convenient for for their child/children. And what if children are scattered around the country/world - where do the parent live then to suit everyone's needs
So yes, she is being selfish

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 09:24

@cyclamenqueen well let's hope all your self sacrifice pays off. You can devote you life to serving your children and grandchildren in the hope theyll be around to assist you in old age but there are no guarantees that that is how it will work out.

Cannotmakeadecison · 02/09/2022 09:13

Another who can see both sides. I understand you feeling sad that you inevitably won’t see them as often and that your kids won’t have quite the same relationship with them that they did BUT they will still have a relationship, it’ll just take a bit of effort on both sides. Look at it from another point of view. How would you feel if you and your kids couldn’t move to your dream area because your parents didn’t want you to as they would miss out on the close relationship with their grandkids? Also think of your own lives and what you see in the future when your kids are grown. You may want to travel the world and not want to be tied to the same place forever.
Incidentally, both my dad and mum moved to Cornwall and Devon respectively and are so happy there. Their quality of life has improved enormously and they have made new friends and new support networks.

Cloudonthemountains · 02/09/2022 09:09

cyclamenqueen · 02/09/2022 08:15

Sadly in todays society it will be, especially if as I suspect she is talking about Cornwall. I have been in this exact scenario.

it is hopeless to pretend that as people get older they won’t need support because it’s as sure as night follows day, even if it’s just lifts. Plus the cost of fuel or public transport is rising so for families already facing a massive cost of living crisis travelling long distances monthly is likely to just be impossible .

what happens when the parents can no longer drive so all travel is to them, when they need to get to appointments, when they fall unexpectedly etc. I know all of this is boring to contemplate and everyone thinks it won’t happen to them but the reality is that it more than likely will.

we will be putting our children first and living in the convenient place even if it’s not ideal for us . Social care and the NHS do not fill gaps anymore

We are not going to live our lives around being where our children could care for us in case of infirmity. They have their own lives and careers, we don't want to be a burden to them. How could they take us to appointments when they work full time?

We have moved somewhere with all the facilities we need within a few minutes walk, if we can't walk, there is a community bus or a taxi. Our house is suitable for when we get older. If we need care, and social care isn't available by then, we are in a position to pay for some level of support and would downsize to release further funds

I wouldn't dream of being near family solely in expectation of them having to care for us alongside their own families and careers.

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 08:59

Nw22 · 02/09/2022 08:49

@BadNomad wow you sound horrible

She posed quite a good question going by opinions in this thread

safetyfreak · 02/09/2022 08:56

Not many of us want or plan for our children to provide a caring role for us in older age however, the chances are they will!. Even if its just to advocate for your them to other professionals.

I would warn your parents, you will not be able to provide a caring role for them in 5-10 years time if they do move. I would ask how they will cope when the mobility decreases etc? what their plan? are they going be living in supported living or a flat with a warden?

I do think its silly of them in their 70s to move away from their family.

Ellemnope · 02/09/2022 08:55

My parents live a 4 hr drive away and I find it very difficult since DF got ill with long covid and heart attack. They live in the middle of nowhere and DF said he will never move back as they live by the sea and that me and DH should move there despite us having jobs (no DC yet as TTC) and there not being many jobs around where they live!
I find FaceTime helps so if they don’t know how to use it, teach them.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 02/09/2022 08:54

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 08:48

It is selfish to refuse to use leave to visit someone whilst at the same expecting that someone to make themselves available - alter how they want to live at a to make themselves suitable to the OP for visits

OK, so not selfish for parents to move away but selfish for OP to not want to never have a holiday again?

OK, I see where we disagree.

Personally I think parents have the right to do what suits them but they can't expect others to give up things in life to protect them from some of the consequences of that. I mean natural consequences, not dreamt up punishments. OP has said that she will visit, it will just rarely be possible - unsurprising for a trip which takes most of a day (it's cornwall, 7 hours is probably good going in the school holidays).

Nw22 · 02/09/2022 08:49

@BadNomad wow you sound horrible

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 08:48

It is selfish to refuse to use leave to visit someone whilst at the same expecting that someone to make themselves available - alter how they want to live at a to make themselves suitable to the OP for visits

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 08:45

Imagine staying at one place all your life in case your kids need you and thinking you might need help when you get old and then... You get nothing. Life opportunities wasted.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 02/09/2022 08:41

It is hopeless to pretend that as people get older they won’t need support because it’s as sure as night follows day, even if it’s just lifts

As someone who works with older people, I can assure you that it’s a complete fantasy that all older people rely on family help. Many, many older people get little or no support from their family, or have no one available (no kids/kids abroad/ kids CBA).

It would not be fair for the OP’s mother to expect help from the OP if she is at the other end of the country. But it’s also unfair to assume that she would expect that. As usual on MN, this thread is full of negative stereotypes about needy, selfish older parents. Just like any age group, some older people make unreasonable demands (my DM was an example), but many older people are fiercely independent and never receive family support.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 02/09/2022 08:33

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 02/09/2022 07:40

Your selfishness is overwhelming. I do hope your children think slightly more of you and treat you with a little more regard when they are adults

Can you explain what in that quote you believe is selfish?

OP said they can't visit because of when they can take leave, and that she is going to miss them. What's selfish about that?

cyclamenqueen · 02/09/2022 08:31

It’s not about giving up on life, it’s about structuring your life in a practical way such that you don’t unnecessarily place a burden on others, however unwittingly, but are still able to live a fulfilling life yourselves. It is possible but requires thought and planing , we are in our late fifties and are already discussing how to do this. We will still be travelling ( budget allowing) and doing lots of the things we wanted to do but we will not be moving to an entirely new area where we have little knowledge of services available or a support system in place. ( remember there will be no local friends etc to jump in if needed , it can be very lonely when you first move)

saraclara · 02/09/2022 08:26

When children move away, they are responsible for themselves. Their parents might miss them, but they don't have any responsibility for them

When people in their 70s move away, they (generally) only have a limited window of truly independent life. And if they have children, those sons and daughters feel an obligation to support them. So yes, making that incredibly difficult for them to do, is selfish to a certain degree. And as it turned out with my mum, protestations on leaving of "I don't want or expect you to look after me" turn out to be entirely hollow.

I don't know the answer. I can't say it's right to stop people living where they want (we totally understood my mum's wish to go and didn't make any attempts to prevent her doing so or make her feel bad about it). But parents doing that are sending a message, whether they mean to or not.

cyclamenqueen · 02/09/2022 08:15

midgetastic · 02/09/2022 07:41

I think if my daughter was worried about how she could care for me as I got older I'd be moving further away

It's not her job

Sadly in todays society it will be, especially if as I suspect she is talking about Cornwall. I have been in this exact scenario.

it is hopeless to pretend that as people get older they won’t need support because it’s as sure as night follows day, even if it’s just lifts. Plus the cost of fuel or public transport is rising so for families already facing a massive cost of living crisis travelling long distances monthly is likely to just be impossible .

what happens when the parents can no longer drive so all travel is to them, when they need to get to appointments, when they fall unexpectedly etc. I know all of this is boring to contemplate and everyone thinks it won’t happen to them but the reality is that it more than likely will.

we will be putting our children first and living in the convenient place even if it’s not ideal for us . Social care and the NHS do not fill gaps anymore

Swipe left for the next trending thread