Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that DM is moving 7 hours away

259 replies

Smarshian · 31/08/2022 20:20

So DM and Step Dad currently live around 1 hour away and visit often (approx 1-2 times per month) for sometimes an afternoon, or a day, occasional overnights.
They have just announced that they are moving 7 hours away. It’s a dream of theirs and I REALLY don’t begrudge them. The place looks amazing and it really is a wonderful place to be, but I am SO gutted that they won’t be around to see the kids more often and just to see them myself. They are not young, 70s, and have not thought about how they might need help in years to come.
we have 2 young DC (4&5) who are going to miss out on so much time
with their grandparents. AIBU to be absolutely gutted by this announcement

OP posts:
heyjood · 08/09/2022 10:35

Public transport is so crucial.... my parents are in their 80s and live in a big city where public transport is fantastic and free. They are in great health and have a full and active life compared to many of their friends.... some of this is luck but in all honesty I think it's a lot to do with buses!

Wouldloveanother · 08/09/2022 10:20

If I had a pound for every older person who said to me that they don’t want to bother their children but have made no alternative plans whatsoever and have chosen to live somewhere with limited public transport and 45 mins and 3 buses from the nearest hospital because they ‘always wanted to live near the sea’ . What happens ; the dc end up having to come to the rescue often reluctantly but there is no alternative other than the parents sink further and further into chaos or die in squalor ( sorry to be blunt)

Absolutely this.

Its all part of this odd British mentality where elderly people want to live rurally or in their family homes which are by this time completely unsuitable for their needs, with family members/the NHS/social care picking up the pieces. They’re trying to hang on to their younger years but it actually ages them very quickly, cut off from life and physically unable to do much.

Wouldloveanother · 08/09/2022 10:11

YANBU. Most of these comments are your typical MN ‘I’m not in your position so can be all philosophical and detached about it and say YABU’ ones.

You say they’re in their 70s, and I assume they’re moving somewhere either rural or totally unsuitable for their needs in (not that many) years to come? What a stupid decision.

I would do what you’re doing, make it clear I won’t be dragging my kids 7 hours across the country for regular visits, and warn them that they can’t expect to maintain the same relationships with them that they’ve enjoyed this last however many years. They shouldn’t be surprised if they ping back in 10 years desperate for care and support only to find their grandkids don’t really know them and are reluctant to help.

As for you, I wouldn’t feel overly obliged to do much for them either. Keep in contact by all means and stay on friendly terms but I wouldn’t go out of my way to help when the inevitable happens.

user1477391263 · 08/09/2022 09:50

The houses have all been bought up by retirees so no carers can afford to live here either.

And this, too. Housing has gone up and up in price in this country, especially in places like Cornwall that many people think it would be nice to retire too. It's not going to be easy to get cleaners, gardeners, nurses and other helpers in such circumstances. If people living right outside the elderly people's area are hired and have to drive all the way in, the cost of transportation will have to be factored into the cost of all this.

The UK should have spent the past few decades developing inner city sites (brownfield land, parking lots) into dense, senior-friendly housing areas, featuring accessible flats with elevators to ensure elderly people can live independently as long as possible. Flats could be set within walking/scootering distance of hospitals, shops and services, and this would also mean that the carers, cleaners and the like could live locally and access elderly people's homes easily. And we should have been creating public transport that can be accessed easily by the frail and elderly, like trams that are flat to the ground level enabling people with mobility scooters and walkers to use them.

Elder care is set to be a massive issue anyway, due to demographics; the very least we could do would be to ensure that older people can manage by themselves as long as possible, so that adult daughters don't wind up spending half their lives driving their parents about from place to place.

As usual, though, everyone just puts their heads in the sand and waits until a crisis develops.

user1477391263 · 08/09/2022 09:39

One thing that is jumping out at me, reading all the comments from adult children struggling with supporting aging parents, is the issue of car dependency. The UK is going to really struggle with this in years to come, as so much of the UK is designed so that people simply can't get things done without a car--yet as people age and develop all kinds of health and mobility issues, it gets riskier and riskier for them to drive. Adult children (mostly daughters) will end up taking up the slack.

Xmasbaby11 · 07/09/2022 23:36

I'd be gutted too op. They have obviously been planning it for a long time but 70s is a late stage in life to be moving away from loved ones. You won't see them as much and it will be harder to maintain the closeness with the grandkids. That's a v long journey for you and as they age, your dp may struggle with traveling to you. My dp are in their 80s now - dm no longer drives and df does, but gets tired. A 7 hour drive would be over 2 days and he'd find it tiring. Public transport is not always easier either.

Whether or not you feel inclined to help them when they age depends on a lot of factors. Try not to worry about it now as it's impossible to know how things will pan out.

saraclara · 07/09/2022 22:41

My in-laws moved to a random part of the country which takes us 35 mins to get to. They are in their 80s, have both had serious health problems and DH is an only child. It is a nightmare

35 minutes ?! That's less than my daily commute to work! Hardly selfish of your in-laws @Chorusgirl . And random part of the country? It's probably in the same county as you!
It's hardly the 7 hours that the OP will have.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 07/09/2022 22:25

whatthefunkisgoingon · 07/09/2022 20:59

OP, I haven’t read every comment on this thread but I HAVE read every post of yours. I have to say, you sound incredibly selfish and entitled. You won’t be prepared to help them in later life because they won’t be around to help you now and again while your DC are small? You WON’T be visiting them when they move?
Stop being stubborn and selfish.
You need to get a grip and realise your DM has a life of her own. Let her do what makes her happy ffs

Oh FFS are you one of the OP's parents????? Hmm

As a pp said, how come it's SELFISH for the OP to say she won't bother looking after her parents 10-15 years down the line when they need it as they clearly CBA to be there for her now... But it's NOT selfish for them to fuck off 100s of miles way and be nowhere near the OP for parental support? Disingenuous much???!!! Hmm

singingintheshower · 07/09/2022 22:25

I see what you're saying @locke360 but a long weekend only works if OP & her DH are both prepared to make the journey with their young children/book time off work - otherwise it's the poor OP doing it alone. 7 hours is such a long time in a car on one day! Bad traffic /accident/bad weather could make that even longer tbh. 2 full days would be spent travelling. No fun at all! Parents & kids have commitments at weekends too - swimming lessons 0/football/parties. My kids would have hated doing that journey at that age. & that's just the journey logistics. My parents only lived 3 hours away but when they were both ill/dying (at 72 yrs & 77 yrs - 4 years apart from each other) it was an absolute nightmare for me racing up & down the M1 every other weekend when my kids were younger (8 & 12 when DD was dying & 12 &16 when it was DMs turn 😪). Fortunately my 2 DSis & various relatives lived in same town as my DP so they were able to help out more (& I offered instead to sort out stairlift /carers /cleaners etc etc that I could do over the phone. I'm not suggesting your DM/DStepD will get ill as young as mine did OP but I think they are bonkers to think such a move is going to work out. They will have no network of support at all. If its rural Cornwall they might not have many neighbours nearby. Do they like driving at night cos roads are winding & no streetlights. I'm only 47 & I hate night driving now. I can totally see why you feel blindsided by their decision OP! That's a huge journey for your elderly parents to make too! How many more years will they be able to drive for/want to drive on big motorways for? I personally hate the M4.

Ghodavies · 07/09/2022 22:13

I think maybe I need some time to adjust to the idea, but I can’t see myself staying with them regularly whilst I am working.

I do have the benefit of WFH currently so May be able to stay with the kids during half term etc in the future. Kids are currently 4&5 so lots of years where childcare and help (the odd hour to get a haircut etc) would be useful. If they then move back in 10 years and want help themselves I may be frankly less inclined to help.

Are u actually for real???
Maybe they sense the one way in the situation and are going to enjoy themselves!
I appreciate you are genuinely shocked and upset but your sense of entitlement and the inconveniencing you is horrible.
Life is not only about helping people that help you - don’t be so self centred

Darbs76 · 07/09/2022 21:52

I live 5hrs away from my parents (just my mum now) and I feel I’ve spent more quality time with them since moving 20yrs ago. I stay there every half term and enjoy that time. My mum still hates me being so far away though.

Banana2079 · 07/09/2022 21:49

My Grandparents moved their native country when I was about six or seven we went and visited every summer and I absolutely had a great relationship with my grandparents I think you’re talking nonsense

Banana2079 · 07/09/2022 21:47

They only come round once a month anyway So your kids are hardly seeing them regardless so what’s the difference if you go and sees them once a month instead
How are you to take it in turns one month you go up and the other month they come down

seven hours is a long time but it’s doable kids arent babies anymore and you/ they can stay overnight

Chorusgirl · 07/09/2022 21:22

Sorry- de facto childcare/parents

Chorusgirl · 07/09/2022 21:21

You are so NOT being unreasonable. I get that this is for them, no one would begrudge them that. And we don’t have the right as adult children to expect our parents to be de facto grandparents. HOWEVER. To move that far away from family in your 70s and expect you guys to make space, time and money in your lives to visit for a week at a time to make their dream work. Nope. My in-laws moved to a random part of the country which takes us 35 mins to get to. They are in their 80s, have both had serious health problems and DH is an only child. It is a nightmare. This happened because they didn’t want to be a burden by moving near us. That would have been easier!! They see their one and only grandchild once every two weeks if we can manage. Conversely, my parents moved away from my childhood home in order to be close to me and my siblings, be hands-on with the grandkids and see as much of them as possible. It does rather make you view parents from a differing perspective when priorities are so vastly different.

MamaBearof4 · 07/09/2022 21:10

It's not unreasonable to be upset that your mum will be so far away after having her close for so long, that's a natural reaction. But let them go honey, it's their dream and who knows how much longer any one of us have left to fulfill our dreams. They may live the rest of their lives there, enlisting local help if health or ability falters. Or they may stay a few years and return, but don't begrudge them their happiness, their adventure.
Are you refusing to visit because its a reaction to the hurt you're feeling at being almost 'abandoned'? Could you not turn it into an adventure? Drive halfway, so a night somewhere interesting then drive the rest next day? Spend time - a break, a holiday with them. The time you spend will become that much more precious once you can't almost stop by every couple of weeks.
My son-in-law's father did similar a couple of years ago while he and DD were expecting their first child. It was his dream, he had opportunity and so he took it. S-i-L drives up to see him twice a year and while he and s-i-l's stepmum might not be on- hand any more, they zoom, call and write and still get to see the children grow up 😊

whatthefunkisgoingon · 07/09/2022 20:59

OP, I haven’t read every comment on this thread but I HAVE read every post of yours. I have to say, you sound incredibly selfish and entitled. You won’t be prepared to help them in later life because they won’t be around to help you now and again while your DC are small? You WON’T be visiting them when they move?
Stop being stubborn and selfish.
You need to get a grip and realise your DM has a life of her own. Let her do what makes her happy ffs

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 02/09/2022 12:34

Agree @cyclamenqueen. Whether your DC are down the road or in Australia, as you age, you have a responsibility for making sensible arrangements for old age. IME as a HCP, people with no available children (bc no kids or not able to help for whatever reason) typically face up to this better, because they don't have the DC as a safety-net.

From the OP's POV, she may end up much better off with distant parents, who have to make their own arrangements, than having them an hour away as now and expecting her to look after them.

Wombat27A · 02/09/2022 12:20

It does become a case of "your lack of planning is not my emergency..."

I had Fil going on about "living his life", ignoring mil's cognitive decline & the decisions made have impacted her severely. Then came covid, we couldn't travel & it's a complete shit show

But they can roll the dice & it'll all work out swimmingly. Problem here is not knowing...

cyclamenqueen · 02/09/2022 11:56

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 11:42

For every one person (I am one) dealing with their aging parents, there are 2 or 3 others who aren't. Not all children opt in for elder care, some don't live close enough, others don't want to do it, others have their hands full and can't do it. Whatever the answer is, it's not just expecting / hoping your kids will pick up the pieces.

No but it is about organising your life so that your dc don’t have to do it because you haven’t thought to put sensible alternative arrangements in place. There will soon be no choice .

If I had a pound for every older person who said to me that they don’t want to bother their children but have made no alternative plans whatsoever and have chosen to live somewhere with limited public transport and 45 mins and 3 buses from the nearest hospital because they ‘always wanted to live near the sea’ . What happens ; the dc end up having to come to the rescue often reluctantly but there is no alternative other than the parents sink further and further into chaos or die in squalor ( sorry to be blunt)

There literally no care home places in our small picturesque ‘retirement town’ . The houses have all been bought up by retirees so no carers can afford to live here either.

all I saying is that people need to think about these things and not assume that they will be able to manage.

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 11:42

For every one person (I am one) dealing with their aging parents, there are 2 or 3 others who aren't. Not all children opt in for elder care, some don't live close enough, others don't want to do it, others have their hands full and can't do it. Whatever the answer is, it's not just expecting / hoping your kids will pick up the pieces.

forrestgreen · 02/09/2022 11:40

I don't think either of you are wrong, it's just important for them to be aware how much you will visit.

Ask them how often they see you and the children making a 14 hour round trip to see them. And how often they will do the same to come back. Have a frank discussion.

Kite22 · 02/09/2022 11:33

Well said @cyclamenqueen

saraclara · 02/09/2022 11:02

Every single one of us is now dealing with supporting parents

Yep. For the best part of a decade, any socialising with my peers has revolved around the stress of caring for/supporting elderly parents. To the point that all pleasure in meeting up with friends started to wane for me, as I wanted to escape the stress, not listen to others dumping their similar stress. (Not that I blamed them, it was their way of coping, just as mine was trying to put it out of my mind). It's only starting to get more like socialising as the parents die off, to be honest.

It's no good either generation putting their heads in the sand.

Marvellousmadness · 02/09/2022 10:57

My parents moved to the other side of the world. My kids see them 1 time a year. I think you are right to be sad. And I get it! But it could be worse.

8 hours you can drive that in 2 days. Spend 2 weeks there for holidays etc. It will be different but it could be an adventure for the kids as well. Or something like that. I dunnow. Im trying to find the silver lining