Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for only leaving my son the house?

443 replies

macadams · 31/08/2022 20:13

Since my ex wife and I recently got divorced I changed my will to leaving equal shares of my assets (aside from the house) to my three children instead of all to my ex. The only thing I hadn't changed in the will was to leave the house solely to my eldest son, Thomas.

After I had everything finalized I ended up sending the updated will to my ex so she could keep it for her records. She was quite upset when she read it. She says that it is unfair and that all my assets, including the house, should be split equally between all three kids in the event of my death.

My reasoning for only leaving Thomas the house is because he is actually the son I had with my late wife. The house was from her parents. Being that Thomas is the only one of my children that was also their grandchild I feel it is only right that he inherit the house.

My ex wife knew about the history of the house, but had mistakenly assumed all these years that all three children would get an equal stake in the property. I had actually told her to look through the previous will when we first got married, but apparently she only glanced at it. Obviously there was a lack of proper communication, but we cant change the past. So here we are.

Am I being unreasonable here? or is my ex wife?

OP posts:
MRex · 01/09/2022 15:20

Zonder · 01/09/2022 15:11

Ok it's the youngest son being left out that I find odd. The girl who has been step daughter for 3 years, well it depends on how the relationship continues now you are divorced from her mother.

Basically the house will be yours by the time you die, and you will be leaving it to one of your children. That's just not on, I think.

The first child has a dead mum and dead grandparents, who can only access his inheritance from them if his father remembers to pass it on. The second and third child have a living mother and her family, as well as their father, who they will inherit from. Now you think fairness equals taking away the first son's inheritance from his own dead mum and her family, meaning he grows up without a mum AND inherits less than his siblings due to them being given their brother's inheritance as well as their own.

Are you the ex?

AryaStarkWolf · 01/09/2022 15:15

Zonder · 01/09/2022 15:11

Ok it's the youngest son being left out that I find odd. The girl who has been step daughter for 3 years, well it depends on how the relationship continues now you are divorced from her mother.

Basically the house will be yours by the time you die, and you will be leaving it to one of your children. That's just not on, I think.

It's still inheritance from the oldest childs family though so I think he's right. I don't think he should be splitting the rest equally with the step daughter though, it seems like he's treating his second son as bottom of the pile

Zonder · 01/09/2022 15:11

Ok it's the youngest son being left out that I find odd. The girl who has been step daughter for 3 years, well it depends on how the relationship continues now you are divorced from her mother.

Basically the house will be yours by the time you die, and you will be leaving it to one of your children. That's just not on, I think.

Vikinga · 01/09/2022 15:10

With your updates, and the fact that you were only together for a few years, then absolutely Thomas should get the house.

I think you're generous to split your assets with your step daughter considering how few years you were together.

macadams · 01/09/2022 15:02

@KosherDill I was told it would be better so there wouldn’t be any surprises after I died.

OP posts:
angieloumc · 01/09/2022 14:30

Dotcheck · 31/08/2022 20:20

How do you think your children would feel?

Are you going to equalise by giving the others a bit more of other assets?

It does seem unfair. If you decide to go ahead with this, you should explain it to your other children

Why is it unfair? The other DC aren't his late wife's children.

KosherDill · 01/09/2022 14:29

Your plans for the house are fine but giving your ex a copy of your will was ill-advised. Why on earth did you do that?

AryaStarkWolf · 01/09/2022 14:26

I was all ready to say YABU because I really am a split everything equally kind of a person but in your circumstances I think you're right. Is your ex wife planning on leaving Thomas an equally share of her assets or just her own 2 children because it's the same thing, that house is from his mother in reality

Runningslow · 01/09/2022 14:23

i also missed the update, and think what you are doing is ok, although I would leave more to your own children than a 3year long step child.

aSofaNearYou · 01/09/2022 14:01

*He actually did not. Middle child is not his, but if being receiving 1/3 of OPs asserts because OP seems like a truly loving and generous man.

iP was married for 3 years though. Non-bio child is no relation at all to Thomas and ywt an asset from Thomas grandparents, through his dead mother, should be shared 3 ways? No way*

Yes, I missed a couple of updates when I made my comment, including the fact that one of the children isn't his and that his ex wife never lived in the house or contributed to it. Those things do change my opinion a bit, and they also make the situation really complicated and messy.

I do still think it's a bit much to leave the whole house to one of his children and, as a result, significantly less to his other biological child. It doesn't seem right, unless I suppose he never contributed to the house making it his wife's rather than his. It seems uneven, I would probably be looking at selling the house, so that I could leave deceased wife's portion of it to Thomas and split OPs between his biological children. But I don't know if he ever put money into that house, perhaps he was just in a position where he was living in a house that was entirely his wife's.

The step child element of it is another complication. Personally I wouldn't expect to be giving inheritance to a child whose life I was only in for three years, I'd be astonished if ex wife genuinely did that for Thomas. It's OPs choice if that's the route he actually wants to go down I suppose, but his youngest son is coming out quite short changed in all of this.

blisstwins · 01/09/2022 12:49

aSofaNearYou · 01/09/2022 09:08

Personally I think it's fair that you leave the house solely to your eldest but you should be giving more of your other assets to your younger children, so all three end up with a similar monetary value. You chose to have two more.

He actually did not. Middle child is not his, but if being receiving 1/3 of OPs asserts because OP seems like a truly loving and generous man.

iP was married for 3 years though. Non-bio child is no relation at all to Thomas and ywt an asset from Thomas grandparents, through his dead mother, should be shared 3 ways? No way

blisstwins · 01/09/2022 12:44

crowdedout · 01/09/2022 12:13

Did your second wife bring thomas up or was he practically grown by the time she came into his life?

If she did then the 4/6th to thomas 1/3 to each sibling model might be fair. Otherwise the house should go to thomas 100%.

Surely the property was dealt with in the divorce though.

Practically grown, she never lived in the house. One of the children is not biologically related to Thomas or OP at all, the marriage only lasted 3 years…..

I think the ex-wife was very out of line to guilt OO about this. OP seems generous, thoughtful, and loving to all children including the non-bio child he has accepted as his own.

rhomas is more than a decade older than these children. I can’t wrap my head around some of the opinions, which is what makes mumsnet fun actually.

crowdedout · 01/09/2022 12:13

Did your second wife bring thomas up or was he practically grown by the time she came into his life?

If she did then the 4/6th to thomas 1/3 to each sibling model might be fair. Otherwise the house should go to thomas 100%.

Surely the property was dealt with in the divorce though.

Cattenberg · 01/09/2022 11:20

So it’s not true that her wishes have already been fulfilled and should now be disregarded.

Cattenberg · 01/09/2022 11:17

Agreed. But it’s likely that Thomas’s mum couldn’t have left the family home to Thomas when she died.

InsertPunHere · 01/09/2022 11:16

I think your MIL (your first wife's mum) would be justifiably angry if you left the house she and her husband gave you, ultimately intending it for Thomas, to another woman's children.

The house should very clearly be left to him only.

endofthelinefinally · 01/09/2022 11:09

Hopefully the OP has made sure the house is entirely in his own name.

Cattenberg · 01/09/2022 11:05

Sharrowgirl · 01/09/2022 08:47

If I died, I'd want my own family assets to go to my own children, not my husband's new children / step children

Then you draft your will accordingly. It’s that simple!

If you’re married and your home is jointly owned, can you even leave your half directly to your child? I don’t think so. I think your half would pass automatically to your spouse unless you were tenants in common.

Castleheights · 01/09/2022 10:46

YANBU. I was on the fence until I read your ds is 16 and it was only a short marriage anyway. Ex wife is v v unreasonable given those details. If she raised him as her own then I can kind of see her point. I think, I can’t articulate why tbh. Maybe because you are placing deceased wife memory as priority over your children’s feelings. However in the grand scheme she has not been gone too long.

I do wonder about the motive for telling your ex wife about the will? Did she need to know? I hope it wasn’t a low blow because it has opened a can of worms.

I would not tell your ds tbh because you do not know what the future holds, you might need the money yourself. I actually dated someone who knew he would inherit in same circumstances you describe. It seemed to add an air of arrogance because they had a “ready made” house already waiting.

endofthelinefinally · 01/09/2022 10:38

Not really relevant to this situation, but just an illustration of what can happen if wills are not sorted out properly. My mother lost her own mum when she was a child. Her father married again later in life, to a woman who had her own children. He died suddenly, having never made a new will when he married. The second wife and her children sold off every single brick and stick of furniture, even my late grandmother's wedding ring. They destroyed photographs and keepsakes. My mum had absolutely nothing by which to remember her mother and father. It was a source of great sadness for the rest of her life.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/09/2022 10:33

macadams · Yesterday 20:37
It was mentioned when they first gave us the house how one day it would be Thomas's“

in which case, you’ve done the right thing.

Sushi7 · 01/09/2022 10:29

@macadams so within the last 3 years, you met, married, had a baby and divorced a woman? I agree that the house should go to your eldest son because he went through the trauma of losing his mum at a young age and should inherit from his mum and grandparents. Your youngest son will inherit from you and his mum (as you’re his bio parents) and your ex’s Dd will inherit from her parents and grandparents.

I think the house should go to your eldest ds. The rest of your assets should be divided between your sons. You have only known your step Dd for 3 years so she could get a token amount if you wish to leave her something.

macadams · 01/09/2022 10:29

@endofthelinefinally the last will was made specifically because of the the marriage.

I do plan on revisiting this once Thomas is more settled in life. Right now he is still in school and we don’t know where he’ll end up. If he’ll want to live in the house or use the money from the house to pay for one somewhere. Could still be a few years so I thought having the will like this until he’s ready made the most sense.

OP posts:
Crazycrazylady · 01/09/2022 10:27

To avoid an issue, I would gift the house to Thomas when he turned 21 as his inheritance from his "Mom"
I would then treat them equally in your will.

caringcarer · 01/09/2022 10:23

So you were only married to ex wife for 3 years and she got equal share of your family home together. The 6 year old is your stepchild and 2 year old your biological child. A 3 year marriage is very short and the house from your late wife was not counted in divorce settlement for a reason. It should go to Thomas from his late Mum. Try to make sure you devote time to 2 other children as they grow up.