Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for only leaving my son the house?

443 replies

macadams · 31/08/2022 20:13

Since my ex wife and I recently got divorced I changed my will to leaving equal shares of my assets (aside from the house) to my three children instead of all to my ex. The only thing I hadn't changed in the will was to leave the house solely to my eldest son, Thomas.

After I had everything finalized I ended up sending the updated will to my ex so she could keep it for her records. She was quite upset when she read it. She says that it is unfair and that all my assets, including the house, should be split equally between all three kids in the event of my death.

My reasoning for only leaving Thomas the house is because he is actually the son I had with my late wife. The house was from her parents. Being that Thomas is the only one of my children that was also their grandchild I feel it is only right that he inherit the house.

My ex wife knew about the history of the house, but had mistakenly assumed all these years that all three children would get an equal stake in the property. I had actually told her to look through the previous will when we first got married, but apparently she only glanced at it. Obviously there was a lack of proper communication, but we cant change the past. So here we are.

Am I being unreasonable here? or is my ex wife?

OP posts:
Zonder · 02/09/2022 23:23

the youngest son has no connection to the house.

Yes he does. His dad owns it.

RainbowToucan · 02/09/2022 23:07

I think you’ve made the right decision for Thomas and honouring the memory of your late wife and her parents. Your other two DC will surely inherit something from your ex wife’s side of the family at some point anyway?

kateandme · 02/09/2022 23:00

GunsNShips · 02/09/2022 16:31

I’ve not read all the replies but have read all of the OPs posts.

I completely understand the stance you are taking, however, as you have been able to live rent free since your late wife died have you built up any assets for your other two to inherit? Or have you effectively used that to create a better life for everyone? I think I would view the house and belonging to you and your ex wife. Her half goes to Thomas and your half goes wherever you choose. If you specifically want Thomas to have the house then can you adjust other assets to match and equivalent amount?

People aren’t reading the ops posts.
he’s already said the new wife and family never lived in Thomas house as it didn’t feel right. So actually the two younger kids have no memory’s or sentimental or other ties to the house! Op moved to a new home when he re married and rented Thomas house out. This changes things massively and really means it’s nothing at all to do with new family and kids.

Stripedbag101 · 02/09/2022 22:48

In the same way Thomas will not inherit from his half brothers other grandparents.

Stripedbag101 · 02/09/2022 22:47

The youngest son has never lived in the house. It has been rented out.

the youngest son has no connection to the house. It would seem odd for him to inherit half a house that the grandparents intended for Thomas. The youngest son wasn’t in any way connected to thomass grandparents or Thomas’s mother. Why would he get half the home they have to their child and grandchild?

Zonder · 02/09/2022 22:30

The grandparents left the house to their daughter and her husband. OP says they gave it to "us".

Then OP says this:
My late wife left everything to me. She did not leave anything specifically for Thomas.

So the house passed from the grandparents to the parents, and then just to the husband ie the OP.

The house now belongs to the OP. And he is going to leave it to just one of his children. It's the youngest son I feel sorry for. Presumably this is the house he has grown up in so far.

Tohaveandtohold · 02/09/2022 21:20

I think you’ve done the right thing. I would have done the same thing as you in those circumstances

MRex · 02/09/2022 21:13

HermioneKipper · 02/09/2022 17:42

If I was Thomas’ mother or grandparents then I would be rolling in my grave if my house went to some other children I had no connection to

I think this is a key perspective point. Just to add to it - when I die, I have a lot to leave my DS. I want DH to have lifetime security and that could include spending some if he ever had any difficulties, so it should go to him first, but if I die then I'm really not happy with the idea of it going to a.n.other random and their kids rather than to DS. I can readily imagine the perspective of a low income second wife with kids who feels jealousy that they want children to be treated "equally", but it isn't and was never DH's money, it's mine because I earned it before I met him (will just work part-time now until I retire). He has his own money that he can share out, and as I mentioned upthread a little discretion for small sums can be sensible, but my own son should have the bulk of the money that was mine.

HermioneKipper · 02/09/2022 17:42

If I was Thomas’ mother or grandparents then I would be rolling in my grave if my house went to some other children I had no connection to

HermioneKipper · 02/09/2022 17:41

SilentHedges · 02/09/2022 16:49

Agree with @GunsNShipsabove . If Thomas absolutely is to have the house, adjust all the other assets in a way to level up some fairness.

Otherwise on your death you chuck a massive hand grenade into their future relationships. Your other kids will spend the rest of lives questioning how much you actually loved them. I think this will happen unless the split is 100% fair.

Ideally though, I would split everything equally between the kids, house, everything. It's admirable that you're honouring dead relatives wishes, but I think it's more important to honour the feelings of your living children.

But other children have no connection to the house which was a gift from Thomas’ dead mother and grandparents.

it’s only fair it goes to him.

Both my husband and I have clauses in our wills that if we are to remarry that our half of the property/assets is ringfenced for the children in case of remarriage/further children.

id like to think 100% that my husband would protect our children’s interests but I’ve seen it go awry too many times, including in my own family.

SilentHedges · 02/09/2022 16:49

Agree with @GunsNShipsabove . If Thomas absolutely is to have the house, adjust all the other assets in a way to level up some fairness.

Otherwise on your death you chuck a massive hand grenade into their future relationships. Your other kids will spend the rest of lives questioning how much you actually loved them. I think this will happen unless the split is 100% fair.

Ideally though, I would split everything equally between the kids, house, everything. It's admirable that you're honouring dead relatives wishes, but I think it's more important to honour the feelings of your living children.

GunsNShips · 02/09/2022 16:31

I’ve not read all the replies but have read all of the OPs posts.

I completely understand the stance you are taking, however, as you have been able to live rent free since your late wife died have you built up any assets for your other two to inherit? Or have you effectively used that to create a better life for everyone? I think I would view the house and belonging to you and your ex wife. Her half goes to Thomas and your half goes wherever you choose. If you specifically want Thomas to have the house then can you adjust other assets to match and equivalent amount?

MacarenaMacarena · 02/09/2022 16:21

crowdedout · 01/09/2022 12:13

Did your second wife bring thomas up or was he practically grown by the time she came into his life?

If she did then the 4/6th to thomas 1/3 to each sibling model might be fair. Otherwise the house should go to thomas 100%.

Surely the property was dealt with in the divorce though.

How has the huge advantage to the second wife been addressed? She probably never had to work thanks to the dead wife's house being there for her to live in... How much of a house that you left for an only child would you expect them to give up to children unrelated to you? When those other children have their own relatives who will leave them all their worldly goods, and nothing to Thomas... Despite them growing up in Thomas's house and having a stay at home mum nice and comfortable there.. Presumably after the divorce the ex wife has a perfectly reasonable settlement and ongoing share of husband's pension etc... None of which she is likely to share with Thomas in life and certainly not in her will. Despite her huge advantage in her married life of Thomas's house being there for her to live in. It would be a cruel travesty for Thomas to share his house with half siblings who stand to benefit from their own relatives.

I8toys · 02/09/2022 13:59

Totally fair.

Euridicefortuna · 02/09/2022 13:54

I can't believe the hypocrisy. If you have a look through the feeds on Stepfamilies on this site. Most step-mothers will justify why their step children are not receiving anything in their will and why it is just being left to their biological children (they are not their mother).Yet the same people are trying to tell you to leave the house in equal parts to all three of your children.

You are doing the right thing.You can't guarantee that your ex-wife will leave anything to your son.Does she even see him as her son the way you see her daughter as yours? Why should your late wife's legacy benefit children she is not related to. Step mothers are often told on this site to do the best thing for their child and you are right in doing the same for yours.

MacarenaMacarena · 02/09/2022 06:43

All this time your ex wife and the children have all benefited enormously from the house... They owe some thanks to Thomas! Logically and fairly, the house goes to Thomas, and assets acquired during the marriage should be split between the 3 children. Along with a nod to the fact the debt-free gift of a property gave a lot of comfort and freedom to your family and ex wife... I expect that advantage meant she was not obliged to work and put her own children in day care, there were more holidays and toys and less pressure... She benefited enormously from Thomas's grandparents gift. A gift to Thomas.
How might your ex wife consider Thomas's position in her own parents' will, given they do not like him and are unlikely to leave him anything? I suspect she'll be happy to exclude him.

kateandme · 01/09/2022 21:54

I think what changed it all for me was the fact it wasn’t ever actually a family home.my resistance at first was slightly wondering because if it was also where your new wife moved in and you grew the two youngest there.so all thought it was your late wife’s it was now there home too.
hut since you’ve said that house has never actually had anything to do with them,there is no sentiment or memories or anything that stretches them too it.they shouldn’t even be involved.it is your sons house.
the other two would get a share of what yours now and the new home they grew up in.if that can’t be because it’s rented that is by the by.they have no involvements to the old house at all.

Tiani4 · 01/09/2022 19:23

Thomas has already lost his mum and this was his maternal grandparents house left to his mum then to you. You've split all other assets 3 ways between 3 DCs

Your DC2 and DC3 still have a mum who can leave them her house . She can also split her other assets three ways to all 3 DCs including her DSS

It's not up to her how you decide your will

Sushi7 · 01/09/2022 18:46

ColouringPencils · 01/09/2022 17:51

It's obviously really complicated and you are trying to do the right thing by everyone @macadams. I kind of feel for your younger son though as it sort of feels like he has been demoted to match your step-daughter's position instead of being elevated to position of the elder biological son.

I thought this too. I think @macadams should give the house to his eldest son (it is rightly his). His assets should be divided between both of his biological sons. He shouldn’t give equal amounts to his youngest son and former step Dd considering he has only known the step Dd for 3 years and has already divorced her mum.

ColouringPencils · 01/09/2022 17:51

It's obviously really complicated and you are trying to do the right thing by everyone @macadams. I kind of feel for your younger son though as it sort of feels like he has been demoted to match your step-daughter's position instead of being elevated to position of the elder biological son.

Clarklette85 · 01/09/2022 16:04

Didnt see updates have changed my mind, but would try to split equally between two biological children.

Clarklette85 · 01/09/2022 16:01

By not dividing everything equally you could quite easily be creating a rift between your children. Family and those relationships should be held above all other things and creating possible rifts between siblings should be avoided at all costs. Split equally.

Zonder · 01/09/2022 15:54

Are you the ex?

Don't be ridiculous.

As pps have pointed out, the people who have gone before have gone. The house was left to the OP, not to the son. It's now his house. The wife left it to her husband. She didn't leave it to Tom. And now it's his and he has more than one child.

Bubbleguppette · 01/09/2022 15:46

The OP has already said he didn't adopt his stepdaughter and that her dad is not involved.

He has also said that his son Thomas's maternal grandmother is alive. (People keep assuming his maternal grandparents are both dead.)

MRex · 01/09/2022 15:26

The step daughter is a different story altogether. If OP has adopted her, then she is now his child. Alternatively, if her father and his family are entirely uninvolved but OP has taken on parental responsibility and takes her with his son throughout their childhood to continue raising her. In either of those situations she has every right to still be treated equally in the will. If there is actually a father on the scene, or if OP isn't continuing to act as a parent, then a smaller % of the estate would be fairer to the older and younger sons.