Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for only leaving my son the house?

443 replies

macadams · 31/08/2022 20:13

Since my ex wife and I recently got divorced I changed my will to leaving equal shares of my assets (aside from the house) to my three children instead of all to my ex. The only thing I hadn't changed in the will was to leave the house solely to my eldest son, Thomas.

After I had everything finalized I ended up sending the updated will to my ex so she could keep it for her records. She was quite upset when she read it. She says that it is unfair and that all my assets, including the house, should be split equally between all three kids in the event of my death.

My reasoning for only leaving Thomas the house is because he is actually the son I had with my late wife. The house was from her parents. Being that Thomas is the only one of my children that was also their grandchild I feel it is only right that he inherit the house.

My ex wife knew about the history of the house, but had mistakenly assumed all these years that all three children would get an equal stake in the property. I had actually told her to look through the previous will when we first got married, but apparently she only glanced at it. Obviously there was a lack of proper communication, but we cant change the past. So here we are.

Am I being unreasonable here? or is my ex wife?

OP posts:
HTH1 · 07/09/2022 22:32

I would say:

  1. house to Thomas.
  2. rest of estate to younger son (assuming this doesn’t exceed the value of the house), hopefully to include some of the rent money received from the house to even things up.
  3. nothing to the step-daughter you briefly knew.
MooDee12 · 07/09/2022 22:11

This

Johnnysgirl · 07/09/2022 21:09

Zonder · 02/09/2022 23:23

the youngest son has no connection to the house.

Yes he does. His dad owns it.

Oh, stop it... 🙄

Redladybirdbaglady · 07/09/2022 21:08

YNBU. If anything were to happen to me, everything would go to my husband due to inheritance tax etc. but with the full expectation that he will leave at least my half to my daughter in the same circumstances, especially given that it's an additional asset not the family home. In fact, I just read this to him precisely so I could make sure he knew that.

mathanxiety · 07/09/2022 20:55

The ex wife and the children you had with her had the benefit of the house while you were married. The house presumably had no mortgage so the fact that it was a gift benefited the family both by being four walls and a roof (in the physical shelter sense) and by allowing the family to use income for the benefit of all without a large chunk going to a bank even month.

It contributed to the quality of life of its occupants in every way.

The other two children will inherit cash - enough to give them a down payment on property of their own? Will they get anything from your ex wife's parents?

If there's a huge disparity in the value of their inheritance and that of Thomas I would ask myself if you would have considered things in a different light if you and your ex wife hadn't divorced.

Mumofferralkid3 · 07/09/2022 20:54

This sounds very much like you have a lot more to give than she does and she doesn't want her children to be disadvantaged.
The house is actually nothing to do with her so she shouldn't have any say over who it is given to. The middle child is extremely lucky as it sounds like she will get something from you that she won't get from her birth father. And your littlest will get the same as his sister.

There is a huge age gap ampngst the siblings so I assume that they aren't close anyways so the fact the different sums of money won't be a big problem anyways. Could you gift the house to your eldest whilst still alive and place it in trust until he has time to think what to do with it? That way, when it comes to diving the will it all looks fair.

What you do with you affairs whilst still alive won't interest your 2 little kids especially as it will be a fair while before they even understand the actual value of it all.

The exW sounds like she is only interested in the value of the money. Perhaps she's not confident in the legacy she will leave behind? I would also worry if I thought I wasn't leaving my kids provided for. However it wouldn't be anyone elses obligation to sort.

Mumofferralkid3 · 07/09/2022 20:41

I'm so sorry for your situation. But totally agree woth your POV. People can be ruthless when monies are involvedand your biggest priority is your child. Speaking from experience, I lost my mum and money makes it complicated. It's great you've had opportunity to secure your daughters inheritance.

Bluebellsparklypant · 07/09/2022 20:34

You are doing the right thing OP

can you explain to your children or even leave them letters by way of explanation if they are still young

I have inherited 2 houses from my family, I have 2 older step children and 1 DS with my partner. I would want my inheritance to go to my DS only, this is the only thing I can leave him and he has no other family, where as my step children still have their mother and GP.

MRex · 07/09/2022 20:27

macadams · 01/09/2022 10:29

@endofthelinefinally the last will was made specifically because of the the marriage.

I do plan on revisiting this once Thomas is more settled in life. Right now he is still in school and we don’t know where he’ll end up. If he’ll want to live in the house or use the money from the house to pay for one somewhere. Could still be a few years so I thought having the will like this until he’s ready made the most sense.

It most likely will make more sense to transfer the house to Thomas sooner, so that it's all long forgotten later in life. It makes more sense to the others as you being simply a custodian for his inheritance from his mum too. Only you know if he's sensible enough for this yet.

Tierne · 07/09/2022 19:35

I was team "equal split three ways" until I read you were actually only with your ex for three years.

If these kids had grown up together as full siblings despite the different backgrounds I would say it should definitely be equal (that's the case in my sibling group by the way).

But three years... They aren't exactly nuclear family-style siblings so the division should be more nuanced. It's right IMO that Thomas inherit his mothers house.

whumpthereitis · 07/09/2022 18:20

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 18:00

I don’t know. I can see both sides. We have four children between us - one’s mine, three are his. I paid off the mortgage with my inheritance. All our assets are being left equally four ways. It feels like the only fair way to me. I think if you’re leaving your house to one of your children, the other assets should be split between the other two.

Nobody will agree with me because MN is firmly convinced blood is thicker than water.

But that’s something you can only consider fair if you subscribe to the view that blended families must mimic nuclear ones. Is it fair that one child inherits from two parents, while three inherit from three, or four? Is it fair that the younger brother is compensated for being unlucky enough to have a living mother that doesn’t have assets to leave him?

Pilosella · 07/09/2022 18:16

Do you think of the house as yours or Thomas'?
Your little ones are too young to have any expectations to be dashed. You could start referring to it as Thomas' house now and then they never will, especially if it isn't home to any of you any more and never was to them.
If you feel you've just been holding it for Thomas then why not hand it over to him now? Let him have the rental income or sell it or live in it as he chooses - he's old enough - it needn't be in your will at all any longer.
But if you think of it as yours then the younger kids will likely pick up on that as they grow up and take the same view as their mother.

Wheresthebeach · 07/09/2022 18:11

HollyGoLoudly1 · 31/08/2022 20:39

Totally fair in the circumstances.

The poor boy lost his mother, he shouldn't lose his inheritance from her too.

Your other 2 children will inherit from their mum presumably.

Yep. Although I think you were bonkers to send the will to your ex. This is your decision, and yours alone.

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2022 18:00

I don’t know. I can see both sides. We have four children between us - one’s mine, three are his. I paid off the mortgage with my inheritance. All our assets are being left equally four ways. It feels like the only fair way to me. I think if you’re leaving your house to one of your children, the other assets should be split between the other two.

Nobody will agree with me because MN is firmly convinced blood is thicker than water.

Lavenderflower · 07/09/2022 17:56

I think you are doing the right thing. I think your wife is being unreasonable to expect her children to inherit a property when her children do not have any relation to previous wife or her parents.

Flutterbybudget · 07/09/2022 17:47

Could you afford to buy another property now in your own name?
just thinking that the house could be rented out now, and the rental money split between the children, while the house itself would go to your son in your will.

Madamecastafiore · 07/09/2022 17:45

I think you're doing the right thing. The only thing that seems a bit odd is your step daughter benefitting from you and presumably her father and her mother which could mean she gets 3 lots of inheritance whereas your youngest child will only get 2.

Banana2079 · 07/09/2022 17:33

This is a tricky one the house no longer belongs to your ex-wife’s parents and it does not belong to your ex wife, It has nothing to do with them anymore -it is your house.
Therefore you should really be dividing it equally between all of your children
As it is YOUR asset not your ex-wife’s or her parents’s
However as it is YOUR House you can leave it to whoever you want, But I don’t think your reasoning is fair

impossible · 07/09/2022 17:29

This sounds about right to me. Your oldest DS is inheriting from his late mother, your younger children will inherit from their mother apnd all DCs will inherit equal shares of your other assets. I would just make clear why you are doing this so all DCs understand and it doesn't seem like favouritism.

I suppose an important question is who is your ex wife leaving her estate to? If she's sharing it between all your DCs including Thomas maybe you should think again. Perhaps you should ask to see a copy of her will.

mam0918 · 07/09/2022 17:28

After reading the post this is so baffling.

So you DS is an adult, she is NOT a mother too him and only met his when he was an adult and appeared, married you and devorced you in under 3 years (I mean come on).

Your other bio son is 2 so no clue of any of this.

Your SD is 6, you have been in her life half her short life but in terms of lifespan not long at all and are not her bio father or even step father anymore (where is her bio dad?).

You leave house to oldest, split the rest between oldest and your other bio DS.

She splits her stuff between her daughter and and your bio DS together.

Anything else is unnessacerily complex - the only reason she wants the house split is because her kids 'win' more while yours loses out.

The way your going on in your OP you make it seem like you where both the full time main equal custodian parents of children for a long period (it read for example as if you had married when you DS was 3 and raised him together then gone on too have 2 bio kids who where raised at normal siblings and then devorce when you DS was a teen), but you where not, you where together less than 3 years and 1 'child' is already an adult and one isn't yours.

You have your kid, she has hers and you managed to pop one out together in that short period but she has no stake in your adult child (who she is essentially nothing too) inheritance at all.

Karenaki · 07/09/2022 17:24

I would split the house in half - half to your late wife and half to you. . Thomas to get a full half as the only offspring from his birth mother. Your half you then split between your three kids, Thomas included. So he’d get 4/6. If that makes sense?
that way your two other children still get some of your house, but not the bit that was from Thomas’ mum.

Meatshake · 07/09/2022 17:24

Options are as thus:

You leave the full house to Thomas.

You take the view that and your wife each owned a 50% stake in the house. Your son should get his mother's half and a third of your stake, so 2/3rds of the property overall. Your other two children should split the remaining 1/3rd to give them 1/6th each.

You split it equally between all three.

I think that as it's a property that's come through the maternal line that the the property should continue in that vein- it's Thomas's house. I think you should explain when the other two are old enough that it was never your house to give to them- it was his grandparents and his mothers. Even though it is in your name, you are honour bound to respect their intentions for the property.

Fink · 07/09/2022 17:19

I think it partly depends on whether you inherited a mortgage-free house or whether your PIL's 'gift' was a deposit on a house which you have continued to buy since. Your posts imply the former, so that's what I'm assuming, but if it's the latter then I think there's a stronger case for splitting it between the children. As is, absolutely right to leave the house solely to Thomas.

puffyisgood · 07/09/2022 17:14

Wills are often tricky.

This is a close call IMO. I think OP's plan is the slightly better thing to do on balance but it wouldn't be ridiculous to argue it the other way. A lot turns on just what level of additional benefit the other kids are likely to get from having an extra set of grandparents to OP's eldest.

mam0918 · 07/09/2022 17:12

So eldest is your ex-wifes step child?

Is she splitting everything equally between the 3 or only her 2?

If her stuff only goes to her two then the house from his bio mother obviously goes to him and her house goes to her two.