Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:16

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:01

Pensioners, like everyone else, won’t enjoy the same quality of life as others if they make bad financial decisions. They were dealt much better cards to achieve this than we have - if they are renting in later life, it tends to be because they haven’t made sensible decisions throughout their working life and have relied on the state pension to ‘save’ them at the end of it.

And I think a lot of people forget just how astronomically high the cost of living is if you have small children. Full time nursery is a minimum of 1k p/m. It’s utter madness. So posters on here with a couple of young kids on £60k could actually be doing worse than people who rely on benefits.

People forget how women used to be treated. My mum was shafted in her divorce when the man's pension was usually ignored in the divorce - the only asset he had as he spent every penny he got. She was supposed to get maintenance but got none. There was no afterschool clubs or nurseries. She worked by cobbling together help from a few neighbours - her family ostracised her as she was divorced - the stigma was real then.
Through working and bringing up children alone with only help from a few neighbours who looked after us for money, she managed to pay for everything. But I see so many people here with partners say how hard they find it bringing up children with no other family help. My mum left for work at 8 am in the morning after dropping us off at a neighbours and then picked us up at 6pm. As soon as she was back from work she had us 24/7. She had zero help from anyone.
Women were still often paid less than men legally until 1970 and even then illegally for quite a bit after, various court cases changed that.
She rented. Not because she relied on the state. If she had she would never have worked. But because she when younger could not get a mortgage without a male guarantor and had none. And by the time that had eased, she was getting bad arthritis and knew she would be unlikely to be able to work until 60, the retirement age. She did have to leave work young as the arthritis especially in her hands made simple tasks like turning a tap on and off extremely difficult, she could not use a laptop to work.

I find some people pronounce from their ivory tower about what people should or should not have done with zero understanding of real people's lives. Another relative was also divorced and never worked, instead living on benefits and buying her council place. You would see her as more worthy because she owned a property. A property incidentally that she did not have enough money to maintain and over the years it deteriorated badly.

mum2jakie · 01/09/2022 09:13

@Discovereads I think you make some valid points about pensions but the age group you are referring to seems way out. I'm mid forties and was certainly aware of the need for a private pension as soon as I started work. I don't think I was particularly financially savvy so would suggest that attitudes towards pension planning changed much earlier than you think? My OH is in his fifties and similarly made private pension provision from his early twenties even when on a very low wage. I think we're in the majority rather than the majority so think your "people over forty" grouping is way off.

yossell · 01/09/2022 09:12

When the UK's billionaires worth has risen 8% over the last year, while the wealthy employ accountants to dodge every bit of tax they can, while the average worker has seen nothing but a steady decline in his/her spending power since austerity 10 years ago, I think it's a big mistake and a wasted opportunity for those of us who are suffering to fall out and point the finger at each other.

There are real inequalities and injustices in the UK, but the ones between the pensioners and mid-to-low earners is not the genuine problem here.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:09

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:03

If your DP is giving you less than you would get under UC for you and your children, including paying mortgage/rent and bills, then he is treating you badly.

Not at all. I simply put in the figures if we were to split, but he carries on paying for childcare (as he does at the moment). In my hypothetical situation, I would be living in my own house (I live rent free in his house but still own my house from before we got together), with no childcare costs (he pays). I would get £800p/m UC simply because on paper my income is much less than his. I would also get child benefit which we don’t claim because his income means we’re over the threshold to make it worth it.

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 09:08

MsPincher · 01/09/2022 08:38

It’s not true that » many » pension schemes went bust. A few did - the pension schemes that did have financial difficulties were generally private sector defined benefits schemes - not available to the younger generation.

It was expected to save for a pension before auto enrolment just lots of people didn’t do it.

its not easy to save for a pension of course with many competing demands on income. But I take issue with your claims that over 40s were not expected to save and that today’s pensioners didn’t have workplace provision. As a whole they did, at least for most of their working life. So basically there was an opportunity to save at least something for most and certainly easier than for today’s youngsters.

I guess it depends on your demographic and what financial literacy your parents taught you. As I can say with surety that no one I know from my parents generation (boomers) had any workplace pension their entire working lives. As I said too, the messaging in the 1980s was that if you had a workplace or private pension, you were encouraged to opt out of SERPS (the state pension). That was the expectation I started work under- that you don’t need both one or the other will do and I’m in the over 40 but under 65 bracket. So 35 years ago it was very much a case of you don’t need a private/workplace pension to fund your retirement so long as you have NI towards a full state pension. The baby boomers were by the 1980s in their mid-30s to mid-40s. Not to mention of those who were married women most were told pre-1977 to pay a reduced rate and claim state pension off their husbands records..and most baby boomer women were having their children in the 1970s. So the whole first half of their careers plus their time out for child rearing they were definitely not expected to even have the full state pension via their own working history and certainly not to have a private or workplace pension on top.

In addition, while awareness grew in the 1990s that people should not just rely on a state pension, but also opt into a workplace pension over half of Britons had no workplace pension available to them and many of those that did there were no employer contributions. Yes not all workplace pensions were raided and disappeared due to lack of regulation, but even those that were not raided did not really increase much in value. There were repeated crashes starting with the .com bubble in 2001, then a crash in 2004, the big crash in 2008 which devastated even those pension accounts that survived. So even if in the 1990s boomers did get access to workplace pension, and paid attention to the changed advice they were already mid 40s to mid 50s by then. How much can you realistically save when you only have 15-20yrs work life left assuming you stay in good health (and by this age disability/chronic health condition rates hover around 40% of the age group). These are the reasons why the average pension pot for pensioners is only £66k not due to lack of planning as you imply.

So it’s not really a matter of “should have prepared better” for many over 40/65s today it’s the fact that the messaging wasn’t there, the opportunities weren’t there, the regulation of private pensions wasn’t there, the employer contributions did not exist, and by the time they did for only HALF of Britons, the boomers were already over half way to pensioner age.

Givemesunshines · 01/09/2022 09:05

Horcruxe you said that working people can increase their income , but once you are on a pension thats it , there is no.way you can increase your income.
Thats not true. We are on a pension and both work pt !

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:03

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 08:55

I just worked out that if I wasn’t with DH (but he contributed to DC in the same way he does now), I would get ~£1000 p/m in UC and other benefits. and would be better off than I am now. Which seems really generous to me. Need to re evaluate our relationship 😂

If your DP is giving you less than you would get under UC for you and your children, including paying mortgage/rent and bills, then he is treating you badly.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:01

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:13

You need to factor in that pensioners don’t have the same costs though, so no childcare and for a lot if they have had a mortgage it’s paid off so no mortgage or rent to pay. Privately renting pensioners are the ones that will struggle most though

Pensioners, like everyone else, won’t enjoy the same quality of life as others if they make bad financial decisions. They were dealt much better cards to achieve this than we have - if they are renting in later life, it tends to be because they haven’t made sensible decisions throughout their working life and have relied on the state pension to ‘save’ them at the end of it.

And I think a lot of people forget just how astronomically high the cost of living is if you have small children. Full time nursery is a minimum of 1k p/m. It’s utter madness. So posters on here with a couple of young kids on £60k could actually be doing worse than people who rely on benefits.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:00

ThreePotatoFloor · 01/09/2022 01:45

God I miss 2019 😩

Me too!!

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 08:55

I just worked out that if I wasn’t with DH (but he contributed to DC in the same way he does now), I would get ~£1000 p/m in UC and other benefits. and would be better off than I am now. Which seems really generous to me. Need to re evaluate our relationship 😂

MsPincher · 01/09/2022 08:38

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 00:16

I didn’t say workplace pensions were new, simply that they were not expected nor mandated. Whole entire industries had no workplace pensions at all until it was mandated in 2012. In 2012, only 50% of workers even had a workplace pension, that rose to 80% in 2020.

Thé previous generation of boomers had much better work pension provisions which is not available at all to me or my generation.

Rubbish, you could have joined the civil service, military or NHS. Not all the defined benefit pensions are gone even now. And not all boomers “had much better work pension provisions” due to lack of availability of workplace pensions and lack of regulation of private pension schemes. Many pension schemes went bust and millions lost all they had saved until government regulation was enacted in the late 1990s…which would have been when todays over 65s were mid career in their 40s. How would you feel if your pension when to £0 now and you had to start over? How much to you think you could save from now?

It’s not true that » many » pension schemes went bust. A few did - the pension schemes that did have financial difficulties were generally private sector defined benefits schemes - not available to the younger generation.

It was expected to save for a pension before auto enrolment just lots of people didn’t do it.

its not easy to save for a pension of course with many competing demands on income. But I take issue with your claims that over 40s were not expected to save and that today’s pensioners didn’t have workplace provision. As a whole they did, at least for most of their working life. So basically there was an opportunity to save at least something for most and certainly easier than for today’s youngsters.

gyurghle · 01/09/2022 07:37

@BluePassportsAreBollocks god post

RomeoOscarXrayIndigoEcho · 01/09/2022 07:31

Tigerstigers · 31/08/2022 20:27

Yanbu me and DH both work as many hours as possible, he earns just over 50k, I earn around 12-15k working everyday around the school runs, evenings and weekends. Because dh earns over 50k, we don't qualify for any sort of help, we don't even get full child benefit. (Although a family with both parents earning £49k do?!) It's pretty disheartening when we're struggling, but know families who aren't feeling the pinch because they're on lower incomes, and benefits, so subsequently means they get additional government help. We own our home, and have lots of repairs, maintenance etc that we're having to put on hold because we simply cannot afford to with the increase of everything else, it's going to become increasingly hard to stretch out payday. We'd be so much better off if we were alot richer or poorer, but as an "average family" we're being financially screwed.

@Tigerstigers

If your DH earns just over £50k and has pension deductions coming out of his salary then you should still get full child benefit.

It doesn't take a lot of pension deductions to get below the limit. Benefits you now (child benefit) and in the future (pension savings)

TigerRag · 01/09/2022 07:27

Does anyone know how expensive being disabled really is? I had to take out a loan (interest free, thankfully) to buy a piece of equipment just to enable me to fucking read.

If anyone wants to swap my life (2 undiagnosed medical conditions, slowly losing my vision, hearing loss plus a load of neurological shit that no one understands) then you can. But then you'd constantly be in and out of hospital having tests done because no one has any idea what's wrong.

As an ordinary working person, you have the option to change your job. What option do carers and disabled people have?

bewilderedhedgehog · 01/09/2022 07:20

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 02:10

Average usage is skewed towards those well off enough to be in a well insulated, energy efficient home. It’s not reasonable at all if your aim is to make energy costs “affordable for everyone”. It will make energy costs more expensive for those least able to afford it. Except for the ultra rich who can afford to be high users- who let’s face it are far fewer than the millions in fuel poverty.

It’s not really a level most people have managed to pay when you look at those in fuel poverty. These people are simply turning off their heat, fridges, lights,…eating cold tins of food rather than warm them up. Thousands are not topping up their prepayment meters so literally have no gas and no electricity at all.

I don’t agree with your analysis but just came on to say that interestingly this has now been proposed on radio 4 and the view is that it would very much benefit low income families.

Colourfulrainbows · 01/09/2022 07:16

The most a person who is disabled will get is 619 uc and 600 pip. That is 1219 a month.

That is the highest award. On that award the needs will be so high they will not be able to live independently.

Therefore family's support rather than putting them in a residential which cost thousands a week in tax payers money.

Often carers give up there job or take work for less because of the carers working rule of earning over 123 a week ( do the maths at minium wage here).

Or if in couple then based on their income as well. If the carer goes work has to find childcare or help which again cost more money than average ( childminders charge more for sen as loose how many they can take).

Never mind using annual leave for appointments ( hospital, echp, med reviews or if they get sick which they do more than most). Called being disabled.

Annoys me when someone on 40k a year. 40k. Is jealous of disabled getting some support from government without actually knowing the facts.

I work my partner works my adult son is disabled. I have a degree.

Yes he will get the support from the government. He is at home with me rather than me putting him in residential which would actually cost the government more.

This household brings in a lot less than the OP does. Yet people are jealous of my son getting support? You know exactly what benefits were set up for? To help the ill the inferm the elderly years ago. Rather than workhouses and homes.

I would rather be earning 40k a year. I would rather my son was able to work. I would take him not having his disability over the additional payments.

But hey ho be jealous of this? It's very very odd thing to be jealous of. To judge and people need to check themselves and realise what they have.

Sorry this thread annoyed me. Never ever get people who think being elderly or disabled is a life of luxury. Ignorant at best.

cansu · 01/09/2022 07:14

In fact even though I have never campaigned in my life I am prepared to go door to door in the next election to highlight why no one should vote for the tory Party.

cansu · 01/09/2022 07:12

I think many people will struggle. However my son is on disability benefit and ESA. EDF have just sent a bill saying his direct debit needs to go from 200.00 to 626.00. It isn't a question of struggling. It is impossible for him to pay that. He would not have money to eat. I am incredulous that the government have sat on their hands while we listen to Liz Truss prattle on about tax cuts.

BluePassportsAreBollocks · 01/09/2022 07:11

I work in a related field and there are a lot of myths, misunderstandings and misinterpretations on this thread as well as some pretty bold generalisations. I can’t address every one of them but:

  1. Anyone on middle or low income no matter where it comes from will suffer in months ahead. One of the reasons that the options we have to address the problem are to provide help to EITHER benefits claimants (which includes all pensioners as the State Pension is a benefit… this is the controversial bit because they don’t all need it) or to all households eg via tax cuts is because of the mechanisms involved. It’s easy to determine who gets added help because they’ve either been through qualification via benefit system already, or else we make it universal. Much harder to start working out payments based on income and there are always people who will try to game the system. Personally I think a mix of tax cut and a benefits uplift are good approaches.
  2. Benefits for people over State Pension age are substantially higher than for people of working age. The age group with the fastest growing risk of poverty are people who have had to leave work (eg due to caring or ill health) before reaching State Pension Age. Don’t forget that many current pensioners also have considerable earnings related State Pension income so the “full” State Pension for many people is much more than the standard amount. The gap between working and State Pension age benefits has been widening for years, and PPs are correct that households are estimated to need around 2/3 of working life income to maintain living standards.
  3. The only added differentiation I’d make is for single occupancy / single parent households, which overall are at much greater risk than couples or families etc. This group should be prioritised for help no matter what their age.
  4. PPs are correct that previous generations of workers have had considerably more generous pensions than workers today. Most pensioners had DB pensions for which employer contributions averaged around 20-30% (including public sector which is still around this level). They’ll pay out for the rest of the beneficiary’s life (and often their spouse’s too) with no risk to the beneficiary. For people in their 40s / some in their 50s and below, most will retire on DC pensions which are essentially savings pots that you have to make last yourself - you best all the risk yourself and one day it will run out. The main difference and the reason they were introduced was purely because DB was too expensive (ie too generous). Employer contributions to DC pensions are around 8%, a bit more if you’re lucky. That’s what makes up the biggest difference in pension outcomes over and above your own contributions. Add onto that tax relief. So it’s not true that someone in their 40s had same chance to build up equivalent pension wealth to a baby boomer. Almost all DB pensions are now closed, and public sector pensions are still by far the most generous pensions out there even if some changes have been made.
  5. As for the intergenerational debate, personally I think we should start taxing wealth more at all ages, all including property. It’s simply unsustainable to think that our only mechanism of redistribution (which is ultimately what is funding the help that people are calling for) is to tax income, particularly when SO much wealth has been disproportionately accumulated through tax free gains in pensions (yes income is taxed but at a lower rate than the reliefs applied) and property over generations. I’m a traditional conservative voter who is now floating and I think it’s time to start redistributing vertically as well as horizontally.
DinosApple · 01/09/2022 07:08

There should never be a situation where a household with two working adults are struggling financially to pay basic bills, and yet that's where we are heading.

The fact that the middle is being squeezed with little support, is a political failing, not the fault of those claiming benefits.

flapjackfairy · 01/09/2022 07:03

we have 2 children with complex needs who.have to be kept warm and have a hospital ward full.of equipment between them to keep them alive. plus endless washing due to incontinence etc
we are paying over 6000 now for our energy before even October's rise so by jan we are going to be paying goodness knows how much. in fact I am trying not too think about it but it will be over 10000 !
we will get the 650 and 150.each child. and
I am v grateful but that will not even cover a month if the prices keep rising as predicted. .
We have cut down on anything non essential but for disabled people these are v worrying times.

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:51

gyurghle · 01/09/2022 06:41

Less than 1 million over 65s can work out of a population of 12 million

and yet the young can look forward to a higher state pension age so I assume the majority of them will have to work.

Over 65s is a huge age range though going from 65 up to 100 plus. I would hazard a guess most of the over 65s working are in the 65 to 70 range so it’s a much higher percentage working of that age range than looking at it as less than 1 million out of 12 million.

malificent7 · 01/09/2022 06:48

What a lovely thread......let's just get rid of those pesky pensioners and disabled people like in the 3rd reich.

Mind you i do find it galling when my rich, retired dad bangs on about how great it is not to work then votes tory/ brexit etc.

runtothesun · 01/09/2022 06:48

YANBU. Most of my friends receive benefits and while they do not live extravagant lifestyles, I know for a fact that they are not struggling. I’m sure there are many people who are struggling to feed their families but there seem to be a lot of families on benefits who do okay too. Perhaps the threshold for the benefits system needs to be looked at.

gyurghle · 01/09/2022 06:41

Less than 1 million over 65s can work out of a population of 12 million

and yet the young can look forward to a higher state pension age so I assume the majority of them will have to work.