Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
RunningSME · 01/09/2022 10:19

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 10:13

Exactly. My mum when she was working full time could have afforded a mortgage but had no male guarantor. As a divorcee shunned by her family nobody would lend to her.
People forget how recently things have changed for women. A friend setting up her own business in the nineties could not get a loan without her husband's signature agreeing on the loan.

Yeah I’m afraid that isn’t true, 1994 I left school at 18 and got a mortgage on my own and a loan to set up a business sorry to spoil a good story.

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 10:19

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:58

I don’t think the class living in true poverty are bigger than the working class, no.

25% of the U.K. population is working class socio-economically speaking, and 22% of the population are also in poverty, leaving only 3% of the population being working class and not in poverty.

Your experience represents only 12% of working class reality, whereas @antelopevalley ’s experience represents 88% of working class reality.

It complicates things a bit that 47% of people who have middle class income & wealth identify as working class.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 10:17

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/09/2022 10:15

ilovesooty · Yesterday 20:29
So many people looking for other people to criticise and look sideways at. Heaven forbid anyone should get something they don't - or they're perceived as getting "handouts"

divide and conquer. Never fails, does it?

Well, yeah Hmm you can’t blame people who work really hard but are getting increasingly skint for not wanting to subsidise people who are on already fairly generous benefits, can you?

(I know they’re not all generous)

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/09/2022 10:15

ilovesooty · Yesterday 20:29
So many people looking for other people to criticise and look sideways at. Heaven forbid anyone should get something they don't - or they're perceived as getting "handouts"

divide and conquer. Never fails, does it?

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 10:13

ancientgran · 01/09/2022 10:08

Very true, my MIL became a widow in the 1940s, he died as a result of war injuries so although he died in 1949 she was classed as a war widow and got a pension from his country, much higher than she would have got if he had been in the British forces. She couldn't get a mortgage, she had a good job, she had a very secure pension but as she had no male guarantor she couldn't get a mortgage. She lived in a council house until her death. If she had been able to get a mortgage in the 50s 60s or even 70s her financial situation would have been so different.

Exactly. My mum when she was working full time could have afforded a mortgage but had no male guarantor. As a divorcee shunned by her family nobody would lend to her.
People forget how recently things have changed for women. A friend setting up her own business in the nineties could not get a loan without her husband's signature agreeing on the loan.

RunningSME · 01/09/2022 10:09

@Discovereads I set my children’s pensions up for the day they were born in 2000 it was common knowledge by that point pensions were going to be required I was certainly not what you would call financially savvy at 23 years old but I knew I was going to need to give my kids pensions to make sure they would be okay.
incidentally I put five grand in each of them in 2000 and 2002, neither of them need to contribute another penny for the rest of their lives and they will have an adequate retirement.

ancientgran · 01/09/2022 10:08

justasking111 · 01/09/2022 09:25

Such an excellent post. I know widowed women with children who never caught up financially. My own parents divorced went from a lovely home to renting then sheltered accommodation as they aged. People who lost businesses in the 90s folks have forgotten that recession. So many reasons

Very true, my MIL became a widow in the 1940s, he died as a result of war injuries so although he died in 1949 she was classed as a war widow and got a pension from his country, much higher than she would have got if he had been in the British forces. She couldn't get a mortgage, she had a good job, she had a very secure pension but as she had no male guarantor she couldn't get a mortgage. She lived in a council house until her death. If she had been able to get a mortgage in the 50s 60s or even 70s her financial situation would have been so different.

RunningSME · 01/09/2022 10:01

Sally99 · 31/08/2022 20:10

There are no extra hours or pay rises to be had for those of us who already work full time, just tightening of belts.
I'm not convinced that you live in real life

@Sally99 there is the lowest unemployment rate since ww2. 3%
Theres never been a better time to find a better paying job or ask for a payrise

ancientgran · 01/09/2022 10:01

pd339 · 31/08/2022 20:48

It makes me sick how the pensioners (who vote Tory on average) get more than a fair share of help. It's so bloody cynical.

If a pensioner becomes disabled they don't get DLA, just AA which is much lower. How is that them getting more than a fair share? Different for the OPs mother as she became disabled before retirement age so she continues with the DLA.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 10:00

@Wouldloveanother I agree. I know if you are born into poverty class you likely stay in it. I got out, but it was very hard. I suspect few people outside this class understand what it is like to be written off by society, including even your teachers when you are still a young child in primary school. Our Headmaster in primary even said publicly that most of the kids ins school would amount to nothing. I could feel that little was expected from any of us in school except to behave and not cause a problem. They had zero ambitions for us.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:58

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 09:54

@Wouldloveanother

@antelopevalley experience isn’t unusual. You forget that society is a pyramid, the class below you is always much larger than the one you are in. So the upper working class who with hard work and a bit of luck manage to accumulate property wealth and high pension incomes, and thus get a foot in the door for an almost middle class retirement is the unusual case here. Not the life @antelopevalley describes. Most people in poverty are born, live and die in poverty no matter how hard they struggle. You are thinking the uncommon success you know of is more common than it is in reality.

I don’t think the class living in true poverty are bigger than the working class, no.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:57

@antelopevalley then they’ll have to sell their homes. What else is there? Yes I talk in sweeping terms because there simply isn’t enough time to discuss every single individual pensioner’s circumstances.

vivainsomnia · 01/09/2022 09:55

This thread is so pointless because everyone is just put in boxes that assume all experience the same level of income.

The only added differentiation I’d make is for single occupancy / single parent households, which overall are at much greater risk than couples or families etc. This group should be prioritised for help no matter what their age
This is a perfect example:
Single parenthood comes with very different income. The single mum on benefit to two disabled child, who owns her home mortgage free (say through divorce) and gets over £1000 in child maintenance will be much better off than a single mum working in a professional job who gets no maintenance at all, have a mortgage of £1000 and childcare costs of £1000 too.

You then have all the single parents in between. There is no such thing as whole single parents, whole pensioners, disabled, working people.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:55

@Wouldloveanother But you made a sweeping statement that any pensioner who does not own their own house were just bad at managing money. Now when I give you a specific example to show that is not the case, then you say that does not count.
The majority of pensioners do own their own home. There are reasons for those who do not, some will be bad financial decisions, others for good reasons.
By the way the worst housing in the country is privately owned houses by pensioners. Too many are asset-rich but cash poor and unable to pay for maintenance or sign up for equity release schemes. This is not my view. Research into housing stock finds this demographic of housing to be the worst maintained housing stock in the country.

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 09:54

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:46

@antelopevalley but you’ve proved my point - while I have total sympathy for your mums position, it was unusual - not even typical of working class (lower earning) people. There are always people in history who don’t fit the narrative, but broadly speaking people do. We can’t have this discussion in such specific terms because that’s not how society works. You discuss the whole and the overall picture.

@Wouldloveanother

@antelopevalley experience isn’t unusual. You forget that society is a pyramid, the class below you is always much larger than the one you are in. So the upper working class who with hard work and a bit of luck manage to accumulate property wealth and high pension incomes, and thus get a foot in the door for an almost middle class retirement is the unusual case here. Not the life @antelopevalley describes. Most people in poverty are born, live and die in poverty no matter how hard they struggle. You are thinking the uncommon success you know of is more common than it is in reality.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:51

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:23

I repeat. If you are living together which it sounds like you are, and he is earning over £50k, but you would be better off alone on universal credit, then he is financially abusing you. He is paying for childcare but is leaving you to fund the total cost of your and your children's other costs. You do not get child benefit because the state assumes he is paying a lot towards the children, not simply the childcare bill.
No one living with a partner earning over £50k should be better off if they were alone on universal credit. You said the amount you would get in universal credit seems loads to you. That is really worrying.
Financial abuse is very common and rarely talked about.

When did I say he lets me find my kids costs? You’re making stuff up then criticising the outcome to sound as dramatic as possible, because you would rather do this than admit maybe some benefits aren’t as stingy as you want people to believe 😂 would you like me to do a breakdown of who pays for what?

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:47

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:41

And coming from Burnley and Hull is no big deal. Rich people and poor people live there.

Where was your estate?

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 09:47

mum2jakie · 01/09/2022 09:13

@Discovereads I think you make some valid points about pensions but the age group you are referring to seems way out. I'm mid forties and was certainly aware of the need for a private pension as soon as I started work. I don't think I was particularly financially savvy so would suggest that attitudes towards pension planning changed much earlier than you think? My OH is in his fifties and similarly made private pension provision from his early twenties even when on a very low wage. I think we're in the majority rather than the majority so think your "people over forty" grouping is way off.

I think demographics also play a part. It’s certain though that in the 1990s/2000s that the message you need a private pension had not reached the majority of Britons because even in 2012 when auto enrolment was started, only half of Britons had a workplace or private pension. So obviously pre-2012, this was less than half of Britons, and so the majority either did not think they needed anything above and beyond the state pension or had no access to a workplace pension.

It all results in the same thing though, the majority of Britons were NOT making private pension provisions until after 2012. So no, you are not in the majority on a population level. You may be for your social circles, but we all live in our own social bubbles dependent on geography, job, income, education and culture.

When you have population level statistics like that, you don’t have a leg to stand on to say that an expectation for and having a private pension provision in the 1990s/2000s were representative of the majority of Britons working then who are currently over 40.

The watershed was post 2012 because that is the point after which we glide into the majority of Britons having a workplace/private pension and only then is it true to say that there is a societal expectation to have a pension that is in addition to the state pension imho. Everyone who started work from 2012 onwards is currently under 40.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:46

@antelopevalley but you’ve proved my point - while I have total sympathy for your mums position, it was unusual - not even typical of working class (lower earning) people. There are always people in history who don’t fit the narrative, but broadly speaking people do. We can’t have this discussion in such specific terms because that’s not how society works. You discuss the whole and the overall picture.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:41

And coming from Burnley and Hull is no big deal. Rich people and poor people live there.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:40

@Wouldloveanother You are judging her. I come from poverty class, not working class. My gran was in and out of mental asylums her whole life. People with mental health problems or disabilities were treated terribly then and many have ended up as pensioners in real poverty.
If you come from a background of working-class people in decent jobs then it sounds like you do not understand the poverty-class families I grew up with. And nobody would have bought their council house where I grew up, anyone decent was trying to get out of there. The estate was knocked down by the mid-eighties as it was notorious. I grew up around nightmare chaotic families, people who had a hard time because of disability or divorce, and lots of migrants trying to build a better life. There was no public transport, one of the reasons my mum dropped us off early is she had to walk one and a half miles to the nearest bus stop.
I have improved my life and that of my family and clawed my way up to the respectable working class you are talking about - and it was hard work to do so. People who all work reasonably paid jobs, living in reasonable areas and with decent lives. You have zero understanding of the families I grew up around. Even the teachers in my school thought all the kids would amount to nothing and that the best we could hope for was a factory job.
It is easy to judge people and say they should now own their own house or have a decent private pension, when you know nothing of their struggles.

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:26

@antelopevalley im not judging your mum, and I’m certainly not in an ivory tower.

Your mum’s story however is not typical of that generation. It was far more normal to get married in early 20s, give up work to have a few kids, and go back part time once they were in school, if they ever really did. I don’t move in particularly wealthy circles, this has very much been the case for my Nan and MIL’s friends, quite a solidly working class bunch (from Burnley and Hull respectively). Of course there was the odd divorcee and I’m not saying that life wasn’t hard for them; I acknowledge it would’ve been harder than being divorced now, by a long shot. But the pensioners I know who are skint, frittered their money away when working and didn’t seriously give any thought to a pension or paying off the mortgage. The ones who did, however modest at the time, are doing really well.

Eskarina1 · 01/09/2022 09:26

I think it's unreasonable to make this a competition. It should be a given that, in a country like ours, people shouldn't have to worry about having a home, being warm or having enough to eat.

My mum is a disabled pensioner. She lives in rented sheltered housing with inefficient heating. Last year she was scared to put the heating on because she struggled to afford it. She has already cancelled her care because despite being entitled to it the only providers locally cost £10 an hour more than the council will pay. And they are not overcharging- they can't keep staff because they can't pay enough. I've been through her finances, she has nothing left to cut out.

That doesn't mean the rising costs are affordable for "middle income" families. I got a 7k pa pay rise with a promotion in May and I don't feel a penny better off for it, just incredibly grateful.

The proportion of the country who are having to cut back on fairly fundamental things is ridiculously high and that needs to be addressed as a whole

justasking111 · 01/09/2022 09:25

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:16

People forget how women used to be treated. My mum was shafted in her divorce when the man's pension was usually ignored in the divorce - the only asset he had as he spent every penny he got. She was supposed to get maintenance but got none. There was no afterschool clubs or nurseries. She worked by cobbling together help from a few neighbours - her family ostracised her as she was divorced - the stigma was real then.
Through working and bringing up children alone with only help from a few neighbours who looked after us for money, she managed to pay for everything. But I see so many people here with partners say how hard they find it bringing up children with no other family help. My mum left for work at 8 am in the morning after dropping us off at a neighbours and then picked us up at 6pm. As soon as she was back from work she had us 24/7. She had zero help from anyone.
Women were still often paid less than men legally until 1970 and even then illegally for quite a bit after, various court cases changed that.
She rented. Not because she relied on the state. If she had she would never have worked. But because she when younger could not get a mortgage without a male guarantor and had none. And by the time that had eased, she was getting bad arthritis and knew she would be unlikely to be able to work until 60, the retirement age. She did have to leave work young as the arthritis especially in her hands made simple tasks like turning a tap on and off extremely difficult, she could not use a laptop to work.

I find some people pronounce from their ivory tower about what people should or should not have done with zero understanding of real people's lives. Another relative was also divorced and never worked, instead living on benefits and buying her council place. You would see her as more worthy because she owned a property. A property incidentally that she did not have enough money to maintain and over the years it deteriorated badly.

Such an excellent post. I know widowed women with children who never caught up financially. My own parents divorced went from a lovely home to renting then sheltered accommodation as they aged. People who lost businesses in the 90s folks have forgotten that recession. So many reasons

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 09:23

Wouldloveanother · 01/09/2022 09:09

Not at all. I simply put in the figures if we were to split, but he carries on paying for childcare (as he does at the moment). In my hypothetical situation, I would be living in my own house (I live rent free in his house but still own my house from before we got together), with no childcare costs (he pays). I would get £800p/m UC simply because on paper my income is much less than his. I would also get child benefit which we don’t claim because his income means we’re over the threshold to make it worth it.

I repeat. If you are living together which it sounds like you are, and he is earning over £50k, but you would be better off alone on universal credit, then he is financially abusing you. He is paying for childcare but is leaving you to fund the total cost of your and your children's other costs. You do not get child benefit because the state assumes he is paying a lot towards the children, not simply the childcare bill.
No one living with a partner earning over £50k should be better off if they were alone on universal credit. You said the amount you would get in universal credit seems loads to you. That is really worrying.
Financial abuse is very common and rarely talked about.