Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
MsPincher · 02/09/2022 14:39

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:36

I know what a personal guarantor is and so did she. No it was not about the house.
We all asked these questions at the time. It was purely because she was married and needed her husbands signature that he agreed.

It’s not true. At the very least she misunderstood. It was illegal to deny women finance without the consent of their husbands (unless required to charge joint assets etc) in the 90s and it wasn’t the practice of any bank in the uk.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 14:35

@antelopevalley for over 20 years. Employer pensions have been mandatory for that long.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 14:34

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:16

@MsPincher Not true. Employers did not have to make contributions to pensions until recently. I got my first employer's contribution I think about five years ago.

Employers didn’t have to contribute but have had to offer at least a stakeholder pension to employees. Look it up.

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 14:23

Support focused soley on age is odd

Somewhere between 25-20% of people over 65 are classed as millionaires. Depending on what stats you look and what you class as a millionaire.

They are the age group with statistically the highest level of net worth (generally 3x that of a 35 year old), with average savings being at least double of any other age group (including the usually wealthy 55-64 group)

Its odd that so much is focused on that age group simply via age alone, and not taking into account any form of personal wealth.

Its no coincidence that they are the highest voter group and that parties pander to the idea that old= poor

It seems insane that once you hit pension age, people from Richard Branson to a struggling person become automatically entitled to many things. Ive no doubt that many pensioners do struggle, but why is it not means tested like any other age group? If someone was half their age and had anywhere near the average level of savings they wouldnt be entitled to UC etc

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:36

I know what a personal guarantor is and so did she. No it was not about the house.
We all asked these questions at the time. It was purely because she was married and needed her husbands signature that he agreed.

MrsDanversRidesAgain · 02/09/2022 13:33

Was her husband signing as co-owner of their house? if she was raging then it sounds like the bank didn't explain the need for her husband's co-signature.

www.purbeckinsurance.co.uk/blog/personal-guarantee-insurance-more-than-just-insurance-0

So what is a personal guarantee and what can you do to mitigate the personal risk to you as a co-signatory without direct involvement in the business?
A personal guarantee gives the lender an unsecured written promise made by a director or number of directors to accept liability for a company’s debt.
You may also have to sign the guarantee if you co-own the family home.
In practice, this means that if your partner’s business defaults on a loan (or lease) your personal assets (including your home), credit ratings and future access to finance may be at risk too.
The impact on family relationships can be devastating.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:30

MrsDanversRidesAgain · 02/09/2022 13:25

as for not knowing anyone from the boomer generation who ever had a workplace pension - they certainly had them available to them for the most part and much better schemes than are available now.

I'll say. I am a boomer with one of those infamous gold plated final salary pensions (only worth £ 2,500 a year because a couple of years after I started paying in the company changed it). I also have pensions from jobs that I started in 1977. Every job I had from that date had a pension scheme.

It depends on the kind of places you worked. Until five years ago the only job I ever had that had an employers pension scheme was a job for a local council. I joined that one.
About fifty per cent of people work for small employers. I have for most of my working life. None of those I worked for offered a pension.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:26

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 13:20

That’s rubbish that married women couldn’t get loans without permission from their dh. Presumably she was trying to mortgage property etc in both their names (or over which there were occupancy rights such as the family home). Loans absolutely were available to both single and married women on the same basis as men in the 90s.

It was a business loan and no her house was not security.
She got the loan for her business but had to get her husband's signature.
You can call me a liar all you want, it is true.
She is a feminist and was raging about it and very vocal.

MrsDanversRidesAgain · 02/09/2022 13:25

as for not knowing anyone from the boomer generation who ever had a workplace pension - they certainly had them available to them for the most part and much better schemes than are available now.

I'll say. I am a boomer with one of those infamous gold plated final salary pensions (only worth £ 2,500 a year because a couple of years after I started paying in the company changed it). I also have pensions from jobs that I started in 1977. Every job I had from that date had a pension scheme.

EveningOverRooftops · 02/09/2022 13:21

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:45

Also as other posters have said some on benefits / dla do seem to do better than others it makes no sense

I’m on benefits. Carers allowance to be exact. A parent carer.

I seem to do better because I have no debts. I do not have loans or overdrafts. I live under my means. I save for what I need.

I also don’t have a car or excessive transport costs atm because I am able to walk.

I actually think the zero debt is the crux of the issue. We’ve become so accustomed to borrowing for whatever we want and living right up to our means. That anyone, benefits or not, is going to struggle when they have debts that are increasing due to inflation on top of other rises.

however when you compare groups of people on benefits there’s lots to take into account including where they live and how old they are.

If you’re in London or any other city your transport links and ability to find a cheap supermarket or even traditional markets within walking distance is far easier than for rural or those in smaller towns.
the transport is often more affordable in larger cities too. a return ticket here is £5 for an adult. Someone on jobseekers element of UC that’s a big chunk of their budget. If you’re disabled or have a disabled child or are time limited because of school runs you have no choice but to pay that fare because there isn’t time to walk. Not all disabled people get the free bus pass either.

where I live now I have farmfoods and lidl within 20 mins walk. I can get my shopping done in 40 mins if I use taxi £7 to bring the food back. If I have to carry it it’s easily over an hour.
where I used to live my only option was to spend 20 mins on a bus to any supermarket. The free supermarket there has since gone according to a friend.
food prices are different according to the type of store. If your closest shop is a Tesco metro the prices are a little higher than a standard Tesco store.

water rates here in the southwest are double that of places like London. We get a govt contribution but it’s not cutting those bills down significantly.

Here where I live everyone on benefits has to pay a percentage of their council tax whereas other councils people on benefits get it all funded. Each council is different.

energy prices. When they’ve been talking about energy prices very little has been said about the regional variations on the price rises. The April rise was 54% here iirc and other places it was lower. I’m not sure about the oct rise but there are regional differences in that one too.

rent payments via benefits. Each council has its own percentage of a rent it’s going to fund based on local averages iirc. The rest is up to you to top up. If you’re in the north rents are generally cheaper than here in the south west so a rent top up for someone in the north will be less of their monthly income from UC than someone on the southwest.
If you’re in social housing then usually the full rent is paid unless you have extra bedrooms then you have to top it up.

all this contributes to how well or not someone will appear to be on benefits.

how well someone is able to adjust to poverty levels of living or not eg can they give up all their luxuries and be OK or would they struggle also influence how people perceive them.

some people don’t know how to budget. Some do. but a lot of people when they’re on their absolute arses with no hope for the future they tend to live for that day and at a glance can appear to be living it up. But behind closed doors they’ve no heating, no working cooker, washing clothes in bath water, carpets that are threadbare and only have one good set of clothes and shoes they keep scrupulously clean and wear the worn out stuff when no one’s looking putting on a brave face because shame around poverty and being poor still exists.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 13:20

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 10:13

Exactly. My mum when she was working full time could have afforded a mortgage but had no male guarantor. As a divorcee shunned by her family nobody would lend to her.
People forget how recently things have changed for women. A friend setting up her own business in the nineties could not get a loan without her husband's signature agreeing on the loan.

That’s rubbish that married women couldn’t get loans without permission from their dh. Presumably she was trying to mortgage property etc in both their names (or over which there were occupancy rights such as the family home). Loans absolutely were available to both single and married women on the same basis as men in the 90s.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:16

@MsPincher Not true. Employers did not have to make contributions to pensions until recently. I got my first employer's contribution I think about five years ago.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 13:14

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 09:08

I guess it depends on your demographic and what financial literacy your parents taught you. As I can say with surety that no one I know from my parents generation (boomers) had any workplace pension their entire working lives. As I said too, the messaging in the 1980s was that if you had a workplace or private pension, you were encouraged to opt out of SERPS (the state pension). That was the expectation I started work under- that you don’t need both one or the other will do and I’m in the over 40 but under 65 bracket. So 35 years ago it was very much a case of you don’t need a private/workplace pension to fund your retirement so long as you have NI towards a full state pension. The baby boomers were by the 1980s in their mid-30s to mid-40s. Not to mention of those who were married women most were told pre-1977 to pay a reduced rate and claim state pension off their husbands records..and most baby boomer women were having their children in the 1970s. So the whole first half of their careers plus their time out for child rearing they were definitely not expected to even have the full state pension via their own working history and certainly not to have a private or workplace pension on top.

In addition, while awareness grew in the 1990s that people should not just rely on a state pension, but also opt into a workplace pension over half of Britons had no workplace pension available to them and many of those that did there were no employer contributions. Yes not all workplace pensions were raided and disappeared due to lack of regulation, but even those that were not raided did not really increase much in value. There were repeated crashes starting with the .com bubble in 2001, then a crash in 2004, the big crash in 2008 which devastated even those pension accounts that survived. So even if in the 1990s boomers did get access to workplace pension, and paid attention to the changed advice they were already mid 40s to mid 50s by then. How much can you realistically save when you only have 15-20yrs work life left assuming you stay in good health (and by this age disability/chronic health condition rates hover around 40% of the age group). These are the reasons why the average pension pot for pensioners is only £66k not due to lack of planning as you imply.

So it’s not really a matter of “should have prepared better” for many over 40/65s today it’s the fact that the messaging wasn’t there, the opportunities weren’t there, the regulation of private pensions wasn’t there, the employer contributions did not exist, and by the time they did for only HALF of Britons, the boomers were already over half way to pensioner age.

What nonsense. You cannot be in your 40s and claim that pensions are a new thing. Offering employees at least a stakeholder pension has been compulsory for over 20 years. I’m in my 40s - My parents taught me nothing of pensions and I chose not to contribute when I was younger. Old age seemed long away and pensions were boring. But it was available to me and it was my choice.

And messaging absolutely was there - I remember many government adverts on tv in newspapers etc over the years promoting pensions certainly over 20 years ago.

at some point you need to take responsibility for your own choices.

as for not knowing anyone from the boomer generation who ever had a workplace pension - they certainly had them available to them for the most part and much better schemes than are available now. Actually one of my (boomer) parents decided not to join a public sector scheme. It would have been absolutely lucrative given the contributions. She made a choice not to join though - she did know of its existence and was asked if she wanted to join. It was her choice and she can’t blame anyone else for it.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 02/09/2022 13:11

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 20:48

I will be fine, I can pay my bills, I just won't go on holiday or buy luxuries, which will have a knock on effect to the economy and I won't be the only one.

How many of those with disabilities on PIP or DLA ever go on holiday?

Try finding truly accessible accommodation. Or have you ever tried getting on a train, or aeroplane? No thought not.

Easy to bash others though.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 02/09/2022 13:03

Heronimo · 31/08/2022 20:12

Yanbu. Those on benefits will get too much help. Those working full time in middle income jobs are screwed.

What extra help do you think the disabled are getting for the extra equipment that needs electricity and keeps them alive. They don't have a choice to just not use it.

The answer is nothing.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:00

Most people do not go into care homes, most people receive any care through carers visiting at home or care from relatives - usually partners.
And many who go into care homes do not live long.
So only a small number of people see all assets swallowed by care home fees do. Those that do are usually people with dementia. People with advanced dementia need 24 hour care and are often physically healthy, so can live a relatively long time.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 12:54

Also @Rosscameasdoody if people have assets to pay for their care they will be taken. It’s only if people have no assets that the state pays.

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 12:52

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 11:14

When most people will have to sell their homes for elderly care in later life, there won’t be many people inheriting property anyway. Unless they’re rich. And that’s the point isn’t it ? The rich have accountants to set up trust funds so property can’t be touched for care fees. The average Joe can’t, so loses his home and can’t leave anything to his kids. Can I just clarify - I was the original poster advocating for a dedicated care tax. I wasn’t suggesting that a home that can no longer be lived in shouldn’t be used to pay for care. What I’m saying is that at the moment there is no compulsion for people to make provision for later life care. So in practical terms if they can’t or won’t, they end up relying on the Local Authority to provide it. And the Local Authority in turn raid the funding sources of people who have the means to pay, to contribute to those who don’t. To the tune of £12000 a year in most cases - £1000 a month. A dedicated care tax would mean everyone would have to contribute at a rate they can afford. Everyone pays, regardless of whether they will ever need care or not, including those who have property to sell to pay for it. The fund is then used for people who eventually need care, but have no property or income to cover the fees. In practice, the Local Authority would probably still have to support them but the top up will come from the care fund provided by the tax, instead of from someone else’s funding source.

It’s very rare that people put properties in trust to avoid iht as trusts have their own tax issues. Also if you live in it it would be unlikely to work to avoid care fees anyway.

I am a former tax advisor and am afraid your idea of people avoiding care fees with creative accountants is just fiction.

as i explained already a care tax would be the young paying for the elderly care. Why should they pay so you can inherit more? It’s not the case that an elderly person in private care is necessarily subsiding public residents anyway - many are in all private homes.

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:49

@Horcruxe working people cannot always do that at all
Its not so easy to just get another job , if you have experience in one field you can't just pop over the a better paid job in something you know nothing about
You can't increase hours if you need childcare , work hours are set, your job doesn't allow you to have a 2nd job , retraining / education costs money
Its not as simple as that
Plus surely if you have 2 adults working full time as we do , i think I should really be able to stick my heating on a couple hrs a day without thinking . Its not like i am wanting several foreign holidays just some basic standards in living

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:45

Also as other posters have said some on benefits / dla do seem to do better than others it makes no sense

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:44

This is a typical pensioners bash thread
Pensioners have worked and paid their taxes
Those who own their own homes bought and paid for them , they weren't gifted to them
Many many pensioners help out their children/ grandchildren
Many many pensioners struggle and are on basic pension or pension credit
Stop bashing pensioners and concentrate on getting the giverment to understand this fuel crisis pretty much everyone needs help

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:39

Many of us cannot get a second job as our main job does not allow it

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 11:14

gyurghle · 01/09/2022 06:39

Even worse, why should they pay tax so someone can inherit a property when they won’t themselves?

good point, there will be more inequality, as so much will depend on if & when you inherit.

When most people will have to sell their homes for elderly care in later life, there won’t be many people inheriting property anyway. Unless they’re rich. And that’s the point isn’t it ? The rich have accountants to set up trust funds so property can’t be touched for care fees. The average Joe can’t, so loses his home and can’t leave anything to his kids. Can I just clarify - I was the original poster advocating for a dedicated care tax. I wasn’t suggesting that a home that can no longer be lived in shouldn’t be used to pay for care. What I’m saying is that at the moment there is no compulsion for people to make provision for later life care. So in practical terms if they can’t or won’t, they end up relying on the Local Authority to provide it. And the Local Authority in turn raid the funding sources of people who have the means to pay, to contribute to those who don’t. To the tune of £12000 a year in most cases - £1000 a month. A dedicated care tax would mean everyone would have to contribute at a rate they can afford. Everyone pays, regardless of whether they will ever need care or not, including those who have property to sell to pay for it. The fund is then used for people who eventually need care, but have no property or income to cover the fees. In practice, the Local Authority would probably still have to support them but the top up will come from the care fund provided by the tax, instead of from someone else’s funding source.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 10:56

Rosehugger · 01/09/2022 10:56

Quite a few "workers" are on benefits as wage rises have been so pitiful for the last 15 years, the government has subsidised what employers should have been paying in the first place.

Most pensioners are on a fixed income. Those just receiving the state pension will be on 10k a year. Even in a one bed flat their energy costs will be 20% of their income come next month.

It isn’t a new thing. When national assistance topped up low wages as well as paying benefits. Then was replaced by supplementary benefit, income support and now UC. Tory governments have mainly introduced the significant changes to income support benefits. Why should their mates in big business pay decent wages when the tax payer can do it for them ?

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 10:49

kateandme · 01/09/2022 23:06

If it’s about the money tot up what that poster would be getting a year! No many would be ok with that from their employment. And that’s for the very disabled. There are those who’s disability might not be so severe but will still stop the ability to thrive and have a job. But will get much less.

You’re missing the point. It’s still not ‘extra’ money because it’s gobbled up by the cost of the disability, so they are no better off.