Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
whatsthestory123 · 02/09/2022 23:58

Facecream · 31/08/2022 20:43

Oh and for the record I am “on benefits “.
My daughter (seriously disabled physically and mentally) qualifies for higher rate DLA and mobility component (which goes on our WAV).
I get Child benefit and carer’s allowance.
So, my income is whatever child benefit is £86 or whatever plus £270 a month for carer’s allowance.
My DH is self-employed and warns about £20,000.
Believe me I struggle for money.
I haven’t been to a hairdresser since January 2020.
Im still wearing Next jogging sand T-shirts I bought after I had DD (five years ago).
We don’t eat out or get takeaway (other than recently when DH had hand surgery).
I go nowhere and my hobby is reading or drawing/painting- the items for which I get as birthday and Christmas presents.
Please give me some tips on how to live a life of luxury on benefits!!!

I spend £130 on therapy and Sertraline per month (at least) - mostly arising from PTSD caused by an assault by a hospital consultant.

I’ve had to pay £500 court fees to take the matter to court. Pay £60 phone. About £40 (minimum) on petrol each month. £30-£40 on incontinence products for DD).

Not much left after that..
And I have heard nothing about getting a “lump sum” from the government.

What we did get was most of my daughter’s care in terms of physiotherapy and OT and regular doctor appointments cut.

What kind of benefits benefit people I wonder? 9 years ago I had a salary of upwards of £45,000 and that was a starting point for me.
so, I’d take work over carer’s allowance (and the corresponding situation for my family) any day.

dont you get tax credit or universal credit ?????
your DLA for your daughter must be £500 a month £80 cb £240 ca

kateandme · 02/09/2022 23:41

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 22:42

I am on benefits due to MH issues, as are a lot of my friends. None of us complain as it has been a thing for us for years anyway.
That does not mean we are not struggling, or are "rolling in it".
We would all happily swap our MH issues for the shot at a normal life.

Flowers for you and your son. He is lucky to have you.

I get it. And I’m sorry. And it infuriates me when I see these posts and posters and wonder how your holding it together reading such vile bullshit. I cannot and they cannot imagine the struggle those like yourselves live off. And I’m beyond angry every day that the help is so dam little and not even close to being able to live off. Not without fear,doom and dread almost every dam day.and I don’t get how people cannot see the pay you get and get it into their head how horrific it is.

TheHateIsNotGood · 02/09/2022 23:23

Some very interesting discussions here - I particularly found the recollections of the less than rosy life that many people (boomers?) had in the 60s/70s/80s the most poignant - some of these have done very well out of it but many haven't; they still have to struggle whilst they see their retirement age move further and further away - needing to find work until then but pretty much scrapped before they can get there.

And I don't really think that dynamic will ever change really - there may have been short periods of baubles and gadgets for the lower classes - but my local Council are paying the Refuse and Recycling Workers just £9.58 ph!

For one of the most necessary jobs that society needs, start at 6.15am, out in all weather, picking up people's crap. All day, every day.

It's not even part of the Doctor vs Dustman debate - to offer just £9.58 is obscene. Hello? Calling the 19th Century, we haven't moved on much.

RunningSME · 02/09/2022 22:59

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 16:40

How is it bollocks. You said that @antelopevalley was lying about her married friend needing her husband to co-sign on a mortgage in the 1990s because you as a single woman didn’t need to get anyone else’s signature when you got a business loan. I have just posted proof that even today many lenders will require a married woman to get their spouse to co sign on a mortgage. The reason why that is hardly matters, the facts still remains if you’re a married woman you can be required by a lender, even today, to get your husbands co signature to get a mortgage loan.

@Discovereads its a totally different scenario to the one you described. I cant explain it any more cleaely ypu either get it or you dont 🙄

saveforthat · 02/09/2022 22:53

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 13:26

It was a business loan and no her house was not security.
She got the loan for her business but had to get her husband's signature.
You can call me a liar all you want, it is true.
She is a feminist and was raging about it and very vocal.

I don't think anyone is calling you a liar but you are either mistaken or your friend has not given you the whole story. Business (or any other loans) did not require a husbands signature in the 90s unless secured on a joint asset.

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 22:42

Ffsmakeitstop · 02/09/2022 21:13

My son lives on benefits due to his mental health issues. He gets £78.00 a week. He gets his rent paid but has to pay £40 council tax, £30 water plus gas and electric every month. I help him with food and extra electric. He already only pays gas standing charge and doesn't put his heating on. So please kindly fuck off with not knowing anyone struggling on benefits.
Yes he got the cost of living payment and bought an extra duvet and new underwear because the only time he gets new clothes is Christmas.
Am I cross that I won't get any help because I work full time? Yes I am but I'm bloody grateful I am better off than some and don't begrudge them the help.

I am on benefits due to MH issues, as are a lot of my friends. None of us complain as it has been a thing for us for years anyway.
That does not mean we are not struggling, or are "rolling in it".
We would all happily swap our MH issues for the shot at a normal life.

Flowers for you and your son. He is lucky to have you.

RunningSME · 02/09/2022 22:34

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 16:59

Thank goodness we will never be burdened with the £600,000 house 🙄

Ffsmakeitstop · 02/09/2022 21:13

RosetteNebula · 31/08/2022 20:12

Exactly what me and my Mum have been saying. It's workers who will suffer. I'm willing to believe they exist but I don't know a single pensioner or person on benefits who is struggling for money.

My son lives on benefits due to his mental health issues. He gets £78.00 a week. He gets his rent paid but has to pay £40 council tax, £30 water plus gas and electric every month. I help him with food and extra electric. He already only pays gas standing charge and doesn't put his heating on. So please kindly fuck off with not knowing anyone struggling on benefits.
Yes he got the cost of living payment and bought an extra duvet and new underwear because the only time he gets new clothes is Christmas.
Am I cross that I won't get any help because I work full time? Yes I am but I'm bloody grateful I am better off than some and don't begrudge them the help.

XingMing · 02/09/2022 21:05

@qualitychat the big difference is that your mum has mainly completed the 40 years of her work life. Her pot is now fixed, except for government/inflation/indexation uplifts, and she has 20-odd years of stretching that out ever thinner before she dies. You can still decide to work a few more hours or take a second job and stuff your earnings into a personal pension (the option I would recommend), but her physical condition may prevent her from doing any of that.

XingMing · 02/09/2022 20:56

Well, actually an admin still had to do that but the online companies provided compliant templates that made issuing letters and asking for opt ins or outs much easier. I was the person who did it.

XingMing · 02/09/2022 20:42

Auto enrolment was a huge step forward. But the admin was too complex for SMEs until they were forced into it. If the entire company is four people and they are all doing the job, who picks up the paper? It wasn't until there were online options that small businesses could choose a pension fund manager that didn't require a dedicated administrator to send and file all the letters to maintain the paperwork trail.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 17:27

And of course, pensioners have more assets than a 35-year-old as a group. Many have paid off their mortgages and many have private pension pots. A 35 year old will still be paying into a pension and mortgage.

The government's figures show the average net pensioner's income is £150 a week once rent or any mortgage still owed is deducted. Hardly living it large.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 17:06

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 12:54

Also @Rosscameasdoody if people have assets to pay for their care they will be taken. It’s only if people have no assets that the state pays.

Yes, I’m aware of that - it’s the whole point of the argument !! You are still missing the point. How can I make it any clearer ? Assets are not ‘taken’ in their entirety on entering full time care. The care fees are set and paid periodically from the funding source provided by the sale of the property. The people who have their own private funding pots in this way are charged more for their care than those who rely on the state. My relative pays £4000 a month and the LA is charged £3000 per resident - the levy is a contribution to cover their costs. So if my relative were to live three years in the care home, she will have contributed £36000 to other peoples’ care. If there was a dedicated and ring fenced care tax which everyone paid - similar to national insurance - then there would be funding available to top up the LA costs, instead of making those who have saved or have property, pay out of their own private funds. It’s not a question of making the young pay for the old, it’s about asking people to at least partly fund their own care at a rate they can afford. When the time comes, if they have no property to sell and not enough income to afford the fees, the LA pays, and the fund tops it up.

woodhill · 02/09/2022 17:02

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 16:58

@Justdancers Those stats that talk about pensioner millionaires look at households and take into account their pension pot. So a couple with individual pension pots of £200k paying out an annual pension, and a house paid off worth £600k fit this definition. But the pension pot is to pay an annual private pension.
Other pensioner couples have a small pension pot, a more modest house, but a business of a certain value on paper. Some friends are in this position, but in reality, they would never be able to sell the business in the current climate for its supposed paper worth.

If you took out of the equation pension pots in an annuity and houses people live in, the income level of your average pensioner is far lower. Indeed there is a real issue with pensioners who are asset rich i.e, have a fully-owned house, but not much cash.

Yes definitely that

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 16:59

Full fact check
fullfact.org/economy/millionaire-pensioners/

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 16:58

@Justdancers Those stats that talk about pensioner millionaires look at households and take into account their pension pot. So a couple with individual pension pots of £200k paying out an annual pension, and a house paid off worth £600k fit this definition. But the pension pot is to pay an annual private pension.
Other pensioner couples have a small pension pot, a more modest house, but a business of a certain value on paper. Some friends are in this position, but in reality, they would never be able to sell the business in the current climate for its supposed paper worth.

If you took out of the equation pension pots in an annuity and houses people live in, the income level of your average pensioner is far lower. Indeed there is a real issue with pensioners who are asset rich i.e, have a fully-owned house, but not much cash.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 16:50

ToxicCuntMum · 02/09/2022 16:19

Hardly a pension scheme is it? Just really a payroll facility

The employers I worked for did not, so it must have been based on the size of employer given one of them was a law form.
But I agree a payroll facility is not worth anything.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 16:38

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 14:23

Support focused soley on age is odd

Somewhere between 25-20% of people over 65 are classed as millionaires. Depending on what stats you look and what you class as a millionaire.

They are the age group with statistically the highest level of net worth (generally 3x that of a 35 year old), with average savings being at least double of any other age group (including the usually wealthy 55-64 group)

Its odd that so much is focused on that age group simply via age alone, and not taking into account any form of personal wealth.

Its no coincidence that they are the highest voter group and that parties pander to the idea that old= poor

It seems insane that once you hit pension age, people from Richard Branson to a struggling person become automatically entitled to many things. Ive no doubt that many pensioners do struggle, but why is it not means tested like any other age group? If someone was half their age and had anywhere near the average level of savings they wouldnt be entitled to UC etc

Pensioners can’t claim UC. State pension is an income replacement benefit, as is UC and you can’t claim both. You haven’t been specific about what exactly pensioners are claiming for that bothers you. Pension credit is means tested and only those who have no other income, and savings under the threshold are entitled - savings allowance starts at £10,000 but tapers at the rate of £1 deducted for every £500 of savings over £10,000, and rises to £2 over £11,000. PC is slightly more generous for those who have a disability and claim attendance allowance or disability living allowance.

The only other benefits appropriate to someone on state pension would be AA/DLA - which as a matter of interest is all included in the financial assessment for local authority carers. In addition, anyone in receipt of carers allowance will lose it on claiming their state pension - again, it’s an income replacement benefit, and you can’t claim both. If you start means testing disability benefits (classed as universal payments and designed to cover the extra cost of a disability) you’d have to include all claimants because singling out pensioners for means testing would be age discrimination.

So there’s not really that much for rich pensioners to claim, when you actually get down to it. Unless, of course you are advocating that pensioners who are property ‘rich’ should have the value of the property they are living in classed as savings for means testing purposes? That would mean that even those with modest means probably wouldn’t qualify for anything and it would force them into full time care sooner - for which then have to sell their homes to pay the fees. Three cheers for divide and rule - it works doesn’t it ?

RP2211 · 02/09/2022 16:21

Not everyone is entitled to what your mom is entitled to and a lot of pensioners will need that extra support as there pension will not cover all the bills. They are more likely to be at home so use more energy than me and you.

ToxicCuntMum · 02/09/2022 16:19

MsPincher · 02/09/2022 14:34

Employers didn’t have to contribute but have had to offer at least a stakeholder pension to employees. Look it up.

Hardly a pension scheme is it? Just really a payroll facility

ToxicCuntMum · 02/09/2022 16:14

@Justdancers How much of this is tied up in their main property?

My mother would love to downsize from her four bedroom house but a two bedroom bungalow in her village is more expensive

And no she’s not a millionaire her house is worth about 200k

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2022 16:07

worriedatthistime · 02/09/2022 11:45

Also as other posters have said some on benefits / dla do seem to do better than others it makes no sense

Tell me how. Someone on a middle income can’t compare their income to that of someone solely on benefits when there’s a benefit cap, set at £15,400 for single people and £23000 for couples - and that’s for inner London, it’s less everywhere else. You’re not affected by the cap if you or your partner:

get Working Tax Credit (even if the amount you get is £0)
get Universal Credit because of a disability that stops you from working or you are caring for someone with a disability
get Universal Credit and you and your partner earn £658 or more a month combined, after tax and National Insurance contributions. The only benefits apart from UC exempt from the cap are State Pensions and disability benefits.

And can you tell me what doesn’t make sense about those on DLA/PIP/ AA getting extra - given that the ‘extra is gobbled up by the cost of living with a disability. Which is why it’s paid.

Zebedee55 · 02/09/2022 15:52

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 14:23

Support focused soley on age is odd

Somewhere between 25-20% of people over 65 are classed as millionaires. Depending on what stats you look and what you class as a millionaire.

They are the age group with statistically the highest level of net worth (generally 3x that of a 35 year old), with average savings being at least double of any other age group (including the usually wealthy 55-64 group)

Its odd that so much is focused on that age group simply via age alone, and not taking into account any form of personal wealth.

Its no coincidence that they are the highest voter group and that parties pander to the idea that old= poor

It seems insane that once you hit pension age, people from Richard Branson to a struggling person become automatically entitled to many things. Ive no doubt that many pensioners do struggle, but why is it not means tested like any other age group? If someone was half their age and had anywhere near the average level of savings they wouldnt be entitled to UC etc

It costs a fortune (Admin wise) to means test claims. Many pensioners are asset rich, ( their homes), but cash poor.

Taking money from a pensioner won't make you any richer.😗

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 14:42

Although it initially only employed to large firms with steps added every year. The smallest employers did not have to provide a pension until 2017. That is what I remember. It was part of my job at the time to research pensions schemes for my employer and write a paper of recommendations as to the scheme they could adopt.

antelopevalley · 02/09/2022 14:40

@MsPincher I have just googled. The law was passed in 2008, but not until 2012 did workplace pensions become mandatory.