Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
Elfen · 31/08/2022 22:09

We'll, surely, if government's had listened and increased our renewable energy resources decades ago when warned the current situation was coming, this wouldn't be an issue.

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 22:09

Appleyard8 · 31/08/2022 22:03

MIL is a classic boomer, she bought the house for peanuts and now it’s worth over £1m. Since FIL passed away she’s looking to ‘downsize’ into another 5 bed detached for £800k. She has hundreds of thousands in the bank. Yet still concerned about fuel costs allegedly. Thankfully she pays our nursery fees and some of our mortgage so I can’t be too harsh on her. But I agree middle incomes will suffer. DH and I earn 90K between us working full time and would really struggle without the additional help. MIL has never even worked full time but is cashing in on pensioner credits.

The three other houses on our estate are all owned by pensioners, all in 4 or 5 bed homes. All have new cars outside, shopping in M&S, don’t seem remotely concerned about energy prices. We will never see wealth like this in our lifetime IMO DH and I will work until we drop dead.

Not on 90k with your mortgage and childcare paid for, you won’t,

Cyclemarine · 31/08/2022 22:08

rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 21:01

Sadly nobody cares - it’s all about hard working families. During lockdown I went months and months living alone without being able to touch anyone or have them over to see me. Same thing will happen here. Even if the middle incomes are given help, it’ll be based on dependants and those without won’t matter.

This is so true, it's utterly disgusting when I hear the politicians go on about 'hardworking families' as if you need to be in a family for them to care about you.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 22:06

busybusy10 · 31/08/2022 21:54

Hi

YANBU. I am probably classed as an average earner but have to count the pennies every month. Family members claiming seem to have more money than I do. Why are they getting payouts to help with the cost of living but I can't. Dreading the next few months coming up.

What do you think an average earner is? I suspect you are above that.

justasking111 · 31/08/2022 22:06

I listened to a retired gentleman tonight being interviewed about Sellafield being upgraded. He was angry because the land was RSPB land a SSSI birds would be threatened as well as other wildlife.

It occurred to me not for the first time that if we did have rolling power cuts this winter would he be talking like this publicly . Would extinction rebellion be celebrating thinking of all the energy we weren't using. Or would they be lynched??

BaileySharp · 31/08/2022 22:05

I think the big problem is many small businesses will go bust. Their energy rates are increasing too and everyone will have less money to spend. High streets will be emptier than ever

Cyclemarine · 31/08/2022 22:05

ohdearnotme · 31/08/2022 20:49

People are getting handouts tho...

I know someone who works 20 hours a week minimum wage but with her UC which includes housing benefit she actually takes home nearly £35k a year.

Rent round here is ridiculously high and a large proportion does go on that, but she is not struggling by any stretch, plus she benefits from all the freebies UC people get, plus the top ups.

No judgement on my side, she worked full time her entire life before her divorce and can't make childcare work to do it again, so has little choice but to take the handout. But it most certainly is a handout.

In this instance it sounds as if it makes sense since she is a single parent, but I know people who do the same and have a partner and their kids are all teens or older now as well.

I can imagine they are taking in a lot on housing benefit and wouldn't be much better off working full-time, but I believe the root problem is high rents.

Were rents more reasonable, perhaps it would be more affordable and appealing for people to work full-time and pay for everything themselves? If we dealt with this housing crisis, I think the squeezed middle who tend not to be on housing benefit etc would benefit greatly.

Recently a gov minister said people on 45K would be needing assistance to get them through this, there is something wrong with the system if people earning 45K are being forced to depend on the government for 'handouts' what they need is to get a grip of energy and housing so we can all afford to pay our own way.

Flutterbybudget · 31/08/2022 22:05

And this is what the “ruling classes” want
Me and you, the people struggling to make ends meet, blaming each other, squabbling over the crumbs that fall from the tables of the rich.
instead of envying a disabled pensioner for a one off payment, that might help them for one month, why not protest against the MPs who get to claim their bills on expenses, in addition to their £83k salaries and second home allowances?

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 22:04

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 22:02

Reject it all you like. I’m not saying that we shouldn’t pay for our own care - it’s the system that is the problem. It should be properly funded so that everyone pays what they can afford in the form of a social care tax or similar. I’ve had this conversation on several threads. An elderly relative has recently gone into a care home and because she is a self funder, she is charged £1000 a month more than LA funded residents for exactly the same facilities. When we queried this we were told it’s standard practice and the extra charge goes towards funding those who can’t pay themselves. If our relative lives five years she will have paid £60,000 towards other people’s care. From her own funds, provided by the sale of her home which she worked hard to pay for. Yet if she runs out of funds she will have to throw herself on the mercy of the LA and will probably be moved to cheaper accommodation if the home she is in isn’t on the list of facilities funded by the LA. I agree that elderly care has to be paid for, but this isn’t a fair or sustainable way to do it.

So working age people should pay for elderly care and ‘suck it up as that’s what society is’, but the same sentiment doesn’t apply to your relative contributing financially towards other elderly people?

Morph22010 · 31/08/2022 22:04

Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:53

Yes exactly. There are huge numbers of disabled pensioners on disability benefits sitting on large amounts of savings accumulated before they became disabled, so that is why it's only £150. I regularly do benefit checks for pensioners on disability benefits and they have 50 k in the bank. This is not unusual at all. Or a second home that they rent out to supplement their pension.

I get dla for my son so I’ll get the £150 but at the minute because of how things have aligned with school etc both me and his dad are managing to work full time so our household income is about £85k.

Appleyard8 · 31/08/2022 22:03

MIL is a classic boomer, she bought the house for peanuts and now it’s worth over £1m. Since FIL passed away she’s looking to ‘downsize’ into another 5 bed detached for £800k. She has hundreds of thousands in the bank. Yet still concerned about fuel costs allegedly. Thankfully she pays our nursery fees and some of our mortgage so I can’t be too harsh on her. But I agree middle incomes will suffer. DH and I earn 90K between us working full time and would really struggle without the additional help. MIL has never even worked full time but is cashing in on pensioner credits.

The three other houses on our estate are all owned by pensioners, all in 4 or 5 bed homes. All have new cars outside, shopping in M&S, don’t seem remotely concerned about energy prices. We will never see wealth like this in our lifetime IMO DH and I will work until we drop dead.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 22:02

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 21:32

we’ve pretty much farmed out elderly care to private companies who gouge the elderly for care fees to the point where they have to sell everything they own before they get help

why shouldn’t they pay for their care? We have this bizarre mindset in the U.K. that the elderly shouldn’t have to pay for anything, that they’ve ‘done their bit’ (even though the proportion of SAHMs back then was much much much higher, how much tax did they pay?!) and to expect them to fund anything in unreasonable. I reject that.

Reject it all you like. I’m not saying that we shouldn’t pay for our own care - it’s the system that is the problem. It should be properly funded so that everyone pays what they can afford in the form of a social care tax or similar. I’ve had this conversation on several threads. An elderly relative has recently gone into a care home and because she is a self funder, she is charged £1000 a month more than LA funded residents for exactly the same facilities. When we queried this we were told it’s standard practice and the extra charge goes towards funding those who can’t pay themselves. If our relative lives five years she will have paid £60,000 towards other people’s care. From her own funds, provided by the sale of her home which she worked hard to pay for. Yet if she runs out of funds she will have to throw herself on the mercy of the LA and will probably be moved to cheaper accommodation if the home she is in isn’t on the list of facilities funded by the LA. I agree that elderly care has to be paid for, but this isn’t a fair or sustainable way to do it.

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 22:02

Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:43

I think everyone is panicking about what is to come and turning against each other and resenting each other. Even people who are better off are panicking as no-one really knows what this is going to come to.

The Tories may be the monsters, but they haven’t just appeared out of thin air overnight have they?

They’ve been in power for 12 years. They’ve won 4 elections. They have spent the entirety of that time stripping public services to the bone and grinding down our quality of life, while appeasing their wealthy donor overlords and their main voting base - pensioners and the over 60s.

It is the elderly vote that keeps them in power, that will continue to keep them in power. The boomer generation, even with their incredibly healthy assets and pensions beyond what working age people can dream of, is still happy to watch their kids and grandkids struggle so they can rake in a extra few quid to continue feathering their already gigantic nests.

To rub salt in the wound, we then get the ‘Buy less avocados’ ‘snowflakes just hate hard work’ comments, so set satisfied are they that their incredible fortune is down to some unique genius on their part rather than sheer luck.

So sorry; I will continue to complain about both the oppressors, and the people who instruct them.

YES I KNOW that doesn’t apply to every pensioner, but I am talking in sweeping generalisations, as I see it.

edwinbear · 31/08/2022 22:00

@gyurghle honestly, I have no idea. And I should, I’m an economist, I work in banking surrounded by other economists. I worked through the formation of the Euro, the Argentinian debt crisis, 9/11, the 2007/2008 financial crisis and obviously, Covid. I’ve seen so many economic cycles and have honestly never seen anything like it and neither have any of my colleagues. Usually, there are pockets of positive news - in a couple of sectors, in other countries, but I honestly can’t see anything. And you can see it in the huge variations of forecasts between economists, because for the first time in my career nobody has a clue. Ultimately, it’s Russia and the awful situation in Ukraine - it needs to stop by whatever means.

PureBlackVoid · 31/08/2022 22:00

People I know just think what’s the point in trying to work more hours, if it’s going to barely make a dent in fuel and other rising bills. I earn just over 22k. I looked at a job for 27k, it’s more stress, responsibility, longer hours etc. It sounds like quite a decent pay rise, yet after tax and other deductions, it’s about an extra 200 a month. Extra travel costs would eat into that too, so it would probably work out to £100 on top of what I earn now.

Just a few months ago, it might have been worth the jump, but now, what is the point in making the majority of my waking hours more stressful, when I’ll still either have to be cold and miserable at home, or get into debt over bills.

girlfriend44 · 31/08/2022 21:59

busybusy10 · 31/08/2022 21:54

Hi

YANBU. I am probably classed as an average earner but have to count the pennies every month. Family members claiming seem to have more money than I do. Why are they getting payouts to help with the cost of living but I can't. Dreading the next few months coming up.

It sometimes dosent pay to have money or savings does it?

Morph22010 · 31/08/2022 21:55

Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:51

My 85 year old dad is not disabled in the slightest. He will be getting £300 winter fuel payment ( that he normally gets), plus an extra £300 winter fuel payment, plus £400 that every household is getting. That is £1000. He is not struggling, he is always trying to give money away to keep his saving lower than the amount where he would need to pay for care should he need to. The cost of this will be eyewatering and not always being targeted where needed most.

Isn’t the issue that there is a high proportion of pensioners entitled to pension credit thst don’t claim so by targeting only those in receipt of benefits they’d be missed.

busybusy10 · 31/08/2022 21:54

Hi

YANBU. I am probably classed as an average earner but have to count the pennies every month. Family members claiming seem to have more money than I do. Why are they getting payouts to help with the cost of living but I can't. Dreading the next few months coming up.

Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:53

Morph22010 · 31/08/2022 21:51

Dla and pip isn’t means tested so I’m guessing that’s why. If a disabled person or family with disabled children are on low incomes then they will most likely also get another means tested benefit such as universal credit so will get extra from that too

Yes exactly. There are huge numbers of disabled pensioners on disability benefits sitting on large amounts of savings accumulated before they became disabled, so that is why it's only £150. I regularly do benefit checks for pensioners on disability benefits and they have 50 k in the bank. This is not unusual at all. Or a second home that they rent out to supplement their pension.

Morph22010 · 31/08/2022 21:51

caringcarer · 31/08/2022 20:18

If Truss is leader she is saying tax cuts is way to go by raising base level at which people have to pay tax. ATM it is set at £12500 free pay before tax kicks in. I don't know what level she may raise it to but £14000 would be good. This way all those working benefit. Those on benefits already had a hand out and are getting another one end of September. Disabled are getting £150, not sure why they did not get same amount as those on UC or PC. Carers nothing.

Dla and pip isn’t means tested so I’m guessing that’s why. If a disabled person or family with disabled children are on low incomes then they will most likely also get another means tested benefit such as universal credit so will get extra from that too

Babyroobs · 31/08/2022 21:51

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 21:47

This is my point. The government are spinning this to make it look like all disabled people will get up to £1200 extra help and it’s simply not true. Only those who qualify for means tested benefits will qualify. Disabled people who work and are above the thresholds for income top ups via UC won’t qualify for anything apart from the £400 universal payment and £150 council tax rebates we all get unless they qualify for PIP, DLA or AA, in which case they will get an extra £150. Any other support will only be paid if they are in receipt of means tested, income related benefits.

My 85 year old dad is not disabled in the slightest. He will be getting £300 winter fuel payment ( that he normally gets), plus an extra £300 winter fuel payment, plus £400 that every household is getting. That is £1000. He is not struggling, he is always trying to give money away to keep his saving lower than the amount where he would need to pay for care should he need to. The cost of this will be eyewatering and not always being targeted where needed most.

woodhill · 31/08/2022 21:49

idonotmind · 31/08/2022 21:00

Of course some boomers won't be affected even if their energy costs double. Because they are not paying for childcare costs, transportation, food, etc.

They have fewer outgoings.

I get the whole 'I've worked hard, i deserve it' argument.

But they didn't work hard enough because we're fucked now with the energy/rising costs. Only our grandparents worked hard enough to make it comfortable for the boomers.

How is it anyones fault that the energy prices are rising?

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 21:47

5zeds · 31/08/2022 21:28

I thought that the suggestion was the disabled on disability benefits would receive a single payment of £150 extra. Do you imagine that’s the increase that they will experience?

This is my point. The government are spinning this to make it look like all disabled people will get up to £1200 extra help and it’s simply not true. Only those who qualify for means tested benefits will qualify. Disabled people who work and are above the thresholds for income top ups via UC won’t qualify for anything apart from the £400 universal payment and £150 council tax rebates we all get unless they qualify for PIP, DLA or AA, in which case they will get an extra £150. Any other support will only be paid if they are in receipt of means tested, income related benefits.

gyurghle · 31/08/2022 21:47

There is a really nasty theme to some threads recently based on resentment of what other people might have/can claim that you can't.

Whilst I agree the gov encourages division I think one of the important things from these & similar threads is that so many people are feeling disenfranchised.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 31/08/2022 21:47

I work full time 40 hours. People saying you can't get extra hours do you mean in your main job? I have had to take an extra two jobs working weekends and evenings.

We've talked about DH taking on another job -or just something with regular pay - but can't see how we can do it at the moment as we have a school refusing 9 year old and if DH isn't around I can't work my contracted hours. It's a nightmare, but from the outside it must look like we can easily increase income.