Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:59

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:18

Where do you get those figures, My mum is 91 and gets pension credit on top of her state pension - it’s still nowhere near £200. And you’re missing the point. State Pension is intended as a income replacement because you have reached retirement age and no longer work. UC is not.

www.gov.uk/pension-credit/what-youll-get

the above link explains your mum gets at least £185.

at 90 she will get other benefits too. Also if she gets pension credit that will act as a gateway benefit to other benefits like housing benefit (no bedroom tax for pensioners of course).

Uc is intended for people who don’t work who are below retirement age. Uc claimants are entitled to £77 a week. Pensioners get £185 and no work requirements.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:55

And many older people who paid into private pensions had no employer contributions.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:54

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:43

Why should the younger generations, many of whom will never be able to afford homes, pay extra tax so people who don’t live in their houses and will never have to again don’t have to sell their homes? Even worse, why should they pay tax so someone can inherit a property when they won’t themselves?

And why should the younger generations be allowed to get to the point where they’re elderly and haven’t made provision for their own care, so have to rely on the state, who in turn impose what amounts to a tax on the funding sources of those who can ? The point of a social care tax is that your own care is funded when you need it. Not saying fully funded - yes if you have your own home then you can afford to pay, but you would no longer be expected to subsidise those who can’t/won’t. The system is broken, partly because there is no compulsion for people to make provision for later life care. There should be.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:50

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:44

Also, plenty of older people lost their private pensions when their companies went bust. Private pensions did not use to be legally protected.

That happened to very few people in fact.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:48

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:42

Paying into a private pension wasn’t expected for the people who are over age 40 now, much less those already aged over 65! The U.K. state pension isn’t low because it was expected and mandated that people would have private pensions, it was set low because the assumption was that most people would be mortgage free home owners by retirement and not need any money towards housing costs. There would be a few impoverished pensioners who didn’t own their home, but that’s where the welfare state would step in. They didn’t want to set state pension for everyone assuming rent costs in old age, because that would be unaffordable for society to fund.

That’s rubbish I’m afraid. I’m over 40 and all my working life I was expected to pay into a pension. And I did.

Thé previous generation of boomers had much better work pension provisions which is not available at all to me or my generation. Many very generous final salary schemes even if the private sector. Most are gone now but paying out good pensions to current pensioners.

Sorry but if you didn’t prepare for your retirement it’s not because workplace pensions are a new thing. They’re not.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:45

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:43

Why should the younger generations, many of whom will never be able to afford homes, pay extra tax so people who don’t live in their houses and will never have to again don’t have to sell their homes? Even worse, why should they pay tax so someone can inherit a property when they won’t themselves?

I agree people going into care homes should have to sell their homes to pay for the care. I also think inheritance tax should be much higher.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:45

Wouldloveanother · 31/08/2022 22:23

Plus hospitals are full to the rafters with ‘social’ patients who don’t want to fork out for their own care, so rely on the NHS picking up the pieces whenever they have accidents etc. I read somewhere that if all these patients could be moved on, there wouldn’t be a bed shortage in hospitals.

This is just ridiculous. There are elderly people bed blocking in the NHS, for no other reason that they are not safe to be discharged into their own homes because it’s unsafe. You probably did read somewhere that if all these patients could be moved there wouldn’t be a bed shortage in hospitals. But this is because there is a shortage of care home places and patients have to wait for an appropriate place to become available before they can be discharged. Not because they don’t want to pay for care. If they are assessed as being able to pay, then they have to pay.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:44

Also, plenty of older people lost their private pensions when their companies went bust. Private pensions did not use to be legally protected.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:43

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:38

And by the same token why should someone who has worked/saved for that home and is using it to fund their care, also be expected to support care funding for someone who hasn’t? Not suggesting the state or the tax payer foots the bill - I’m suggesting a dedicated tax paid by everyone at a rate they can afford, to go some way towards fixing a broken care system which relies on the slightly better off ‘have’s to fund the ‘have nots’.

Why should the younger generations, many of whom will never be able to afford homes, pay extra tax so people who don’t live in their houses and will never have to again don’t have to sell their homes? Even worse, why should they pay tax so someone can inherit a property when they won’t themselves?

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:42

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:35

Again you are wrong. Paying into a private pension is expected and even mandated (you can opt out). However if you pay the minimum contributions for 35 years you will get the state pension. It is not means tested and will not reduce if you receive other pension income.

yes some older state pensioners get less state pension but they can also get more under the old system if they paid serps (also previous system only required 30 years contributions not 35).

If they do get less state pension than £185 and have no other income and savings below £10,000 you can claim pension credits to make up the difference.

these are really things that should be taught in schools imo.

Paying into a private pension wasn’t expected for the people who are over age 40 now, much less those already aged over 65! The U.K. state pension isn’t low because it was expected and mandated that people would have private pensions, it was set low because the assumption was that most people would be mortgage free home owners by retirement and not need any money towards housing costs. There would be a few impoverished pensioners who didn’t own their home, but that’s where the welfare state would step in. They didn’t want to set state pension for everyone assuming rent costs in old age, because that would be unaffordable for society to fund.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:40

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:25

Well You can work and keep all of your state pension. Uc is far less generous. Also you are forced to work on uc unless you have caring responsibilities. So yes, state pension much better.

But still not the same thing - which is why you can’t claim UC top ups to state pension.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:39

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:30

Very few people of state pension age can work though, you act like there’s a choice there where that is only true for a privileged few with good health and with certain niche professions. Less than 1 million over 65s can work out of a population of 12 million.

You have no idea how many over 65s can work. Also there are other benefits for pensioners like disability benefits and attendance allowance.

also the state pension is supposed to be a minimal income. The majority of current pensioners have additional pension income (which doesn’t affect their state pension).

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:38

Teder · 31/08/2022 23:11

Why should the tax payer / state pay for housing someone when they have a home? Rightly, a person with a privately owned home won’t pay for carers at home or day services if they have very low income even if they own a property as long as they are using it.
I don’t see why a home should sit empty while the state funds the ‘hotel’ costs of the homeowner and local authority care home beds are in very short supply.

And by the same token why should someone who has worked/saved for that home and is using it to fund their care, also be expected to support care funding for someone who hasn’t? Not suggesting the state or the tax payer foots the bill - I’m suggesting a dedicated tax paid by everyone at a rate they can afford, to go some way towards fixing a broken care system which relies on the slightly better off ‘have’s to fund the ‘have nots’.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:35

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:27

WRONG.
State pension is £185 a week for new pensioners who have worked for 35 years and not paid into a private pension.
The state pension was raised a couple of years ago. Anyone retiring before then got less.

Again you are wrong. Paying into a private pension is expected and even mandated (you can opt out). However if you pay the minimum contributions for 35 years you will get the state pension. It is not means tested and will not reduce if you receive other pension income.

yes some older state pensioners get less state pension but they can also get more under the old system if they paid serps (also previous system only required 30 years contributions not 35).

If they do get less state pension than £185 and have no other income and savings below £10,000 you can claim pension credits to make up the difference.

these are really things that should be taught in schools imo.

Anon778833 · 31/08/2022 23:32

The government has said that everyone will get help up to middle earners.

Dreamingcats · 31/08/2022 23:31

I think over half the country will be squeezed. We have a good income and no mortgage, but will still have to hugely cut back on our normal life to afford our energy bills. Last year we were paying £70/month. The current prediction for April next year puts us at over £1000. A huge percentage of our income - I can't see how most people can afford that. I am very worried about the country.

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:30

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:25

Well You can work and keep all of your state pension. Uc is far less generous. Also you are forced to work on uc unless you have caring responsibilities. So yes, state pension much better.

Very few people of state pension age can work though, you act like there’s a choice there where that is only true for a privileged few with good health and with certain niche professions. Less than 1 million over 65s can work out of a population of 12 million.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:30

Viviennemary · 31/08/2022 23:16

Your Mum must have considerable health problems to receive these benefits.

Exactly. People are under the impression that you can ‘blag’ your way into disability benefits, but that’s just not true any more. They are rigorously assessed and claims require robust medical evidence to support them. The original post comes across as petty jealousy that mum manages on disability benefits paid almost to the level of the OP’s wage. What she conveniently forgets is that these benefits are only paid for substantial disability, which results in much higher costs. The funding isn’t a luxury - it pays for essential extra costs. As an example a friend of ours is substantially disabled, has to contribute towards local authority carers and has essential equipment which either has to remain plugged in, or recharged overnight. She’s also incontinent, which necessitates extra washing/tumble drying and bathing. Unless people live it, they have no idea.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:29

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:22

It’s not designed as an income replacement benefit in the way that state pension is, because it’s means tested and the rate you get depends on your other income. State pension isn’t.

Also state pension is a minimal income in retirement. It’s not intended to replace wages nor was it ever. It’s also expected that most people will have some other provision.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:27

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:23

wrong - state pension is currently £185 a week. You only get pension credit if you didn’t actually work 35 years (even at the most minimal incomes) and so don’t qualify for a state pension. Of these 35 years - 12 can be spent child rearing if you claim child benefits.

WRONG.
State pension is £185 a week for new pensioners who have worked for 35 years and not paid into a private pension.
The state pension was raised a couple of years ago. Anyone retiring before then got less.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:25

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:22

It’s not designed as an income replacement benefit in the way that state pension is, because it’s means tested and the rate you get depends on your other income. State pension isn’t.

Well You can work and keep all of your state pension. Uc is far less generous. Also you are forced to work on uc unless you have caring responsibilities. So yes, state pension much better.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:25

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:15

No it’s not. UC is penalised starting at just £6000 and tapers off at £16,000. Pension Credit allows £10,000 with no penalty and assesses every additional £500 as £1 of income, and reduces entitlement accordingly.

Sorry, I thought it was the same. I guess they are allowing a bit extra as most older people save for a funeral. The extra £4k would cover that.

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:23

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 23:12

State pension is lower than that. The £182 a week is including pension credit that you only get if your total income is less than this amount and you have less than £10k in savings.

wrong - state pension is currently £185 a week. You only get pension credit if you didn’t actually work 35 years (even at the most minimal incomes) and so don’t qualify for a state pension. Of these 35 years - 12 can be spent child rearing if you claim child benefits.

Rosscameasdoody · 31/08/2022 23:22

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:18

£185.20 a week is pretty good as a minimum yes. And uc is designed to replace income too.

It’s not designed as an income replacement benefit in the way that state pension is, because it’s means tested and the rate you get depends on your other income. State pension isn’t.

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:21

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 23:15

It is the same circumstances. Also at that level of income having more than double - an extra hundred quid a week makes a massive difference. It’s a scandal that single people on uc are supposed to live on £75 a week when pensioners get nearly £200 as a minimum.

No it’s not the same circumstances at all. You can’t seriously compare a young able bodied person of working age and to a pensioner that is too old to work. Age is the great disabler of us all in the end. You’d know this if you’d ever actually seen the struggle of the elderly just to get dressed or wash a plate and cup, to walk, to see, to hear, to exert themselves physically for more than a few minutes.

And single people on UC (with no savings) usually get more than £75/wk as that is just the basic job seeker allowance. There’s usually a housing element too.