Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know this will be contentious - cost of living rise

561 replies

qualitychat · 31/08/2022 19:57

My mum is a pensioner and gets Disability Benefit and Mobility Benefit and Pension Credit. She receives almost what I get in a month. She is moaning about the Government not doing enough about the cost of gas and electricity, which I agree with. The thing is they have said that people on benefits and pension credit will be given lump sums towards their bills. I am a middle earner and so is my husband. We will likely get nothing. Do you not think it will be the ordinary working families who will be squeezed the most if something is not done?

OP posts:
gyurghle · 01/09/2022 06:39

Even worse, why should they pay tax so someone can inherit a property when they won’t themselves?

good point, there will be more inequality, as so much will depend on if & when you inherit.

Msloverlover · 01/09/2022 06:35

My mum is on a state pension, no savings but gets just over the threshold needed for pension credit so will not be getting the extra £650 (which she will desperately need). Everyone’s circumstances are different.

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:32

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:21

@antelopevalley if I earned over about £120 a week I wouldn't. It would all be taken off so you're not actually paid anything at all (carers allowance) but I think you can still 'claim' without receiving the money for the pension credits, I think?

You wouldn’t need to claim to get the ni credits that come with carers if you were working and no longer able to claim carers as you’d get the ni credit from your salary instead

itsnotdeep · 01/09/2022 06:31

I hate threads like this which seem to be more and more common on Mumsnet these days. bashing both boomers and people in receipt of benefits. The situation isn't their fault. Boomers - welll so what?

I know middle earners will be squeezed, but the answer isn't to take away support for those who are on really low incomes (and contrary to the myths on this thread, most people on benefits are either working or looking for work - only a very few - usually the disabled or those with babies - aren't working) it's to add support for those on middle incomes. Benefits recipients don't live a lovely life. It's fucking miserable and hard on benefits. it doesn't give you enough to live on, and even more so now. (and stop with the myths about your neighbours and their flat screen tvs and all that shit).

It's the cost of living, low wages, and a completely immoral Tory govt that have caused this situation, not your boomer mother, or your disabled neighbour. The answer isn't to deprive them, it's to increase support for everyone. And to vote the fucking Tories out of office.

gyurghle · 01/09/2022 06:31

Rubbish, you could have joined the civil service, military or NHS. Not all the defined benefit pensions are gone even now.

The vast majority of these schemes are nowhere near as good as they were in the past.

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:27

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 00:16

I didn’t say workplace pensions were new, simply that they were not expected nor mandated. Whole entire industries had no workplace pensions at all until it was mandated in 2012. In 2012, only 50% of workers even had a workplace pension, that rose to 80% in 2020.

Thé previous generation of boomers had much better work pension provisions which is not available at all to me or my generation.

Rubbish, you could have joined the civil service, military or NHS. Not all the defined benefit pensions are gone even now. And not all boomers “had much better work pension provisions” due to lack of availability of workplace pensions and lack of regulation of private pension schemes. Many pension schemes went bust and millions lost all they had saved until government regulation was enacted in the late 1990s…which would have been when todays over 65s were mid career in their 40s. How would you feel if your pension when to £0 now and you had to start over? How much to you think you could save from now?

they should have had a pension scheme available for those who wanted to join since 2001 as thsts is when stakeholder pensions were available. It was 2012 when auto enrolment started so it was mandatory to have a scheme and opt people in but employers were required to have schemes available before then

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:20

Discovereads · 31/08/2022 23:42

Paying into a private pension wasn’t expected for the people who are over age 40 now, much less those already aged over 65! The U.K. state pension isn’t low because it was expected and mandated that people would have private pensions, it was set low because the assumption was that most people would be mortgage free home owners by retirement and not need any money towards housing costs. There would be a few impoverished pensioners who didn’t own their home, but that’s where the welfare state would step in. They didn’t want to set state pension for everyone assuming rent costs in old age, because that would be unaffordable for society to fund.

That’s garbage about paying into a private pension not being expected for the over 40s. I’m nearly 50 and have know all my life I’d need a private pension to top up as state wouldn’t be enough and it’s always been actively encouraged by government of the day to have a private pension throughout my whole working life. Various methods of trying to get the take up were tried and they’ve finally got to auto enrolment where it’s opt out rather than opt in

FourTeaFallOut · 01/09/2022 06:18

Is it fair?

If you look at it from a purely monetary perspective, no it isn't fair.

But if you look at it from a health perspective - what is the potential health outcome of living in fuel poverty? - then a disabled pensioner is right up there in terms of vulnerabilities and the potential expense of nursing them back health is far more likely and costly to society than a household full of working age people who do not have health issues so severe as to be in receipt of disability benefits.

Beezknees · 01/09/2022 06:13

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:08

I do think those on benefits can actually be better off than two working adults with DC.

I get £1900 in UC. Plus £600 DLA for my son. Plus carers of about £260. That's a total of about £2700 a month. Admittedly my rent does have to come out of that but I'm secure in my assured tenancy as it's a housing association property.

Meanwhile my SIL has 2 DC (not disabled), but both her and her husband work full time. They have to pay for childcare. And have 0 left at the moment after bills. Their car is 15 years old. They will get no extras to help pay their bills

But in all honestly I don't really 'need' an extra £150 a month. I won't sniff at it though as the cost of gas and electric is eye watering. But there are so many working families who are actually far worse off

Most people don't get that much, I used to get £1100pm on benefits and had to pay all my rent and bills out of it.

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:13

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 00:51

“Very generous” meaning a whopping average of £148/week or £7,696 per annum for the lucky ones who had them.

Keep in mind, you don’t get pension credit if your workplace pension gets you to or over the full state pension of £185/week. Which will apply to the vast majority of pensioners, especially women.

But even looking at the very very few better off pensioners who have this £148/wk and also get the full £185/wk from state pension- that puts their huge amounts of wealth at £17,316 per annum.

Compare that to the average wage of £29,600 per annum.

You need to factor in that pensioners don’t have the same costs though, so no childcare and for a lot if they have had a mortgage it’s paid off so no mortgage or rent to pay. Privately renting pensioners are the ones that will struggle most though

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:03

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 01:10

You would get the DLA and carers if you are working or not. It has nothing to do with being on other benefits.
Your benefits are £1900 UC.

No you don’t get carers if you are working and earn over £132 a week as I would be entitled but don’t get purely due to income. Dla is not means tested though

Morph22010 · 01/09/2022 06:00

MsPincher · 31/08/2022 22:50

that’s double what non pensioners in the same circumstances get though. Surely that’s pretty good when you take that into consideration

Well not really as pensioners don’t generally have the option to work instead, as they reach a point where it’s not physically possible. Non pensioners who can’t work through physical disability can claim pip but pensioners can’t claim pip unless they were disabled before they retired

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 02:10

bewilderedhedgehog · 01/09/2022 01:02

Fair point but any solution is not going to be perfect and I agree we should invest in infrastructure but in the short term we have to have affordability for everyone. Average usage seems reasonable and takes account of the current housing stock. It is also a level that most people have managed to pay and you would still have protections for low income disability etc

Average usage is skewed towards those well off enough to be in a well insulated, energy efficient home. It’s not reasonable at all if your aim is to make energy costs “affordable for everyone”. It will make energy costs more expensive for those least able to afford it. Except for the ultra rich who can afford to be high users- who let’s face it are far fewer than the millions in fuel poverty.

It’s not really a level most people have managed to pay when you look at those in fuel poverty. These people are simply turning off their heat, fridges, lights,…eating cold tins of food rather than warm them up. Thousands are not topping up their prepayment meters so literally have no gas and no electricity at all.

ThreePotatoFloor · 01/09/2022 01:45

God I miss 2019 😩

Nat6999 · 01/09/2022 01:33

The proposed tax changes won't help people on benefits because the majority don't pay tax. The only hope we have is that inflation & the RPI are high in October so that benefits will be increased by a suitable amount.

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:30

@Nat6999 so sorry, it is horrendous for people like you. I feel for you

Nat6999 · 01/09/2022 01:25

I'm on disability benefits & have a small ill health pension. Before the cost of living crisis I had £93 a month left after paying everything I have to pay, now my balance of rent I have to pay has gone up, my energy bills have gone through the roof, food has gone up, my money won't stretch to cover everything. Yes I got £1200 towards my energy costs but I worked out that even just with the October increase, the fact I'm in credit, my monthly dd & the £1200 by March I won't have paid for my full usage, take in the January increase & I don't know how I will manage. I switch off as much as I can but I need my home to be warm because of my health conditions, the only answer may be to stay in bed all day, what kind of life is that?

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:23

Which I cannot do due to being a FT carer. And I have no option to work even PT for now. It is very sad. Knowing I am at the mercy of what the state deem I'm worth giving. I so wish I could work. But it just isn't a reality

Still though, I am better off than a lot of families with 2 working adults

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:21

@antelopevalley if I earned over about £120 a week I wouldn't. It would all be taken off so you're not actually paid anything at all (carers allowance) but I think you can still 'claim' without receiving the money for the pension credits, I think?

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 01:10

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:08

I do think those on benefits can actually be better off than two working adults with DC.

I get £1900 in UC. Plus £600 DLA for my son. Plus carers of about £260. That's a total of about £2700 a month. Admittedly my rent does have to come out of that but I'm secure in my assured tenancy as it's a housing association property.

Meanwhile my SIL has 2 DC (not disabled), but both her and her husband work full time. They have to pay for childcare. And have 0 left at the moment after bills. Their car is 15 years old. They will get no extras to help pay their bills

But in all honestly I don't really 'need' an extra £150 a month. I won't sniff at it though as the cost of gas and electric is eye watering. But there are so many working families who are actually far worse off

You would get the DLA and carers if you are working or not. It has nothing to do with being on other benefits.
Your benefits are £1900 UC.

howtotrainam · 01/09/2022 01:08

I do think those on benefits can actually be better off than two working adults with DC.

I get £1900 in UC. Plus £600 DLA for my son. Plus carers of about £260. That's a total of about £2700 a month. Admittedly my rent does have to come out of that but I'm secure in my assured tenancy as it's a housing association property.

Meanwhile my SIL has 2 DC (not disabled), but both her and her husband work full time. They have to pay for childcare. And have 0 left at the moment after bills. Their car is 15 years old. They will get no extras to help pay their bills

But in all honestly I don't really 'need' an extra £150 a month. I won't sniff at it though as the cost of gas and electric is eye watering. But there are so many working families who are actually far worse off

bewilderedhedgehog · 01/09/2022 01:02

Fair point but any solution is not going to be perfect and I agree we should invest in infrastructure but in the short term we have to have affordability for everyone. Average usage seems reasonable and takes account of the current housing stock. It is also a level that most people have managed to pay and you would still have protections for low income disability etc

Dibbydoos · 01/09/2022 01:00

Completely agree OP. The thing is it's not even middle earners who will be left out in tge cold (excuse the pun 🥶). You only need to earn £1more than benefitthreshold to get nothing except the payment that our suppliers have been given!

I personally earn a relativeky big income, but I spend about £2k a month keeping my DD afloat. She is unable to work - has cfs and anxiety . She gets no benefits, nothing as she moved to the Isle of Man. Ut even in uk she received less than her rent was! I'm self employed, my current contract ends in Nov and I fear things might get bad for contractors...

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 00:56

bewilderedhedgehog · 01/09/2022 00:43

So I don’t know why we can’t have a system where average usage less 10% to incentivise reduced usage is priced at pre October levels for everyone. Then above that the price per unit rises steeply. So higher users pay more. Protection for vulnerable groups. Everyone then has a basic affordable level. What do you think?

Because the majority of people in fuel poverty are also high users due to substandard housing with low EPCs and old/not energy efficient at all boilers and other appliances- fridges, ovens, hobs.

So having a lower rate for lower than average users would benefit those not in fuel poverty because they are in better housing with high EPCs and brand new top of the line energy efficient boilers and appliances.

Discovereads · 01/09/2022 00:51

MsPincher · 01/09/2022 00:01

Most did. And many had very generous final salary schemes. So no, pensions are not new at all!

“Very generous” meaning a whopping average of £148/week or £7,696 per annum for the lucky ones who had them.

Keep in mind, you don’t get pension credit if your workplace pension gets you to or over the full state pension of £185/week. Which will apply to the vast majority of pensioners, especially women.

But even looking at the very very few better off pensioners who have this £148/wk and also get the full £185/wk from state pension- that puts their huge amounts of wealth at £17,316 per annum.

Compare that to the average wage of £29,600 per annum.

Swipe left for the next trending thread