Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Because I'm a gypsy

375 replies

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:29

Today I was in a bakery and it was empty. I ordered what I wanted and the man behind the counter made small talk as he prepared it. He said to me, referring to my accent "you're not from around here are you?". He smiled as he said it. I simply said yes I've lived here all my life, I'm a gypsy that's probably why I sound different.

After this his entire demeanor changed. No more smiling and small talk, he dropped my order on the counter and made it clear he was in some way upset/offended by my presence.

To be honest I'm no stranger to racism against me and I have more tales of blatant racism than I care to count, but this encounter felt really upsetting.

Everything was fine until he found out my ethnicity. Why are people so hateful against gypsies? Do people seriously still tar us all with the same brush, when the whole world is fighting against racism to other minorities?

I'm just so sick of being one of the only cultures who just have to accept racism.

OP posts:
FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:30

PeasOff · 31/08/2022 21:21

Seems like here is the same as another popular parenting board. The words traveller or gypsy are mentioned and everyone goes gung-ho with their 'personal experiences' as to why they're awful people.

It’s the faux-sympathetic hand-wringing as people gleefully share their rants that really gets me. ‘Oh it’s such a shame, I don’t want to hate gypsies, but they just behave so badly that they make me simply HAVE to hate them! Now let me let you all about the horrid gypsies I know and how awful they all are (but I’m definitely not racist, racism is bad, how awful that someone was racist to you today OP)’

It’s making my blood boil.

XelaM · 31/08/2022 21:30

My ex-husband a Romanian gypsy and he and his very big family lived up to all the stereotypes, so I don't have a good experience with the "culture", sorry. I don't tell people that my daughter is half-gypsy.

WorriedMillie · 31/08/2022 21:29

I’m so sorry you had to endure that OP, what a vile person. please raise it with his employees, they need to know

Parsley1234 · 31/08/2022 21:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

user927 · 31/08/2022 21:28

People will literally post "just seen some gypsies in X place, lock up your valuables" how is that even accepted?!

The problem is, many, many people have first hand experience of violence, anti social behaviour, theft, animal abuse and the disgusting mess left behind in public (and sometimes private) areas by some travellers including a great deal of human excrement. Our area has had nothing but trouble from travellers taking over public areas and leaving them destroyed for the last decade, and the police won't go near them for fear of violence so they just get away with stuff. Petty theft also sky rockets and pubs will shut and restaurants change to payment on ordering because they have experienced so much damage and so walk outs without paying

Now that's not to say all travellers are like that, but this isn't the same small group of people, it's lots of different groups (some of them pretty large) so people will of course make judgements based on their lived experience

RewildingAmbridge · 31/08/2022 21:23

@LangClegsInSpace nope think you've hugely misinterpreted what I said! I was just correcting OPs assumption that all non gypsy travellers are Irish. As I said my best friend of many years and her family identify as being at part of the travelling community, they prefer their distinct ethnicity as showmen to be recognised, not just be lumped in with Irish travellers who have their own distinct ethnicity

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:23

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 21:21

Thank you for this!

I came here to talk about my experience of racism and people decide to comment with more! I suppose it just proves how prevalent the problem is.

I feel really upset on your behalf reading this thread so I can’t imagine how you must feel. I hope you’re ok.

KweenieBeanz · 31/08/2022 21:22

I find this really tricky because I really want to think my experiences to date are of a minority of travellers, but I have simply never had a positive experience yet. However I am clear that Roma and Irish Travellers are NOT one and the same - my grandmother once mentioned a tiny bit of Roma heritage waaay back many generations in my family but I haven't actually (that I know of?) ever met any Roma.
However, some groups of Irish Travellers visit our area annually and sadly like other PP the story is always the same. They illegally enter a public space such as a park, playing field (this has been going on a decade), generally damaging gates or posts to gain access. They let horses loose to roam in the space and are very aggressive and use threatening foul language meaning other members of the community feel unsafe to use the space.
Despite lots of public bins around, a huge amount of litter is left as well as human poo, and I have witnessed them many times walk straight from their temporary encampment into the adjacent supermarket and shoplift what they like.
A few years ago a permanent, serviced site was created for groups in recognition that there was a lack of halting places for them in the area but they refuse to use it.

The rational part of my brain knows there must be lots of traveller groups who don't behave in this way, surely these are the exception? But then, why are so many communities up and down the country having exactly the same experience?
I know a PP has commented that you have to have a permanent address to use the tip - lots of the rubbish left could be put in an ordinary public bin. Some will argue there is a lack of toilet facilities they can use - the supermarket I have seen thefts in has lovely clean toilets that are free to use.
I actually wish that the rest of the traveller groups, who I'm sure don't behave in this way, could be featured in a TV programme or be brought to much greater public prominence so that the negative perceptions could be reduced. It seems so unfair that some groups are tainting perceptions when as lots of PP recognise, the word 'traveller' is attached to several very different communities both ethnically and culturally.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 31/08/2022 21:22

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 21:17

So you're admitting you and everyone you know is racist? Nice.

Not sure why my post was deleted me. I haven’t said anything that others haven’t wrote.

Im not admitting to being anything at all. I’m admitting that the only behaviour Iv ever seen hasn’t been good and from those examples alone it would be pretty clear why myself & others would be wary of gypsies.

CoffeeLover90 · 31/08/2022 21:22

There's lots of gypsies where I live and I love 99% of them. They're kind, generous, polite and hard working. Also so immaculate, I'm jealous. I don't know the correct term for them, some live in houses but have the accent, horses, the trailers etc and then there's a caravan park too. Now what I hate is, there's been a lot of new estates built round here over the last 10 years, the cheap prices have attracted people from out of the area. So along they come, offended beyond reason when they see a horse and cart, when the drive past the caravan site or when they meet up in their usual places to travel to horse fairs. Now trying to drive them out. With all due respect snobby arses can p*ss off back to where they come from, I'd rather the gypsies any day of the week.
There's good and bad in every race, religion, ethnic... because we're human.
And that man's a twat BTW.

PeasOff · 31/08/2022 21:21

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:17

Maybe people could resist the urge to turn OP’s thread about a racist incident she experienced today, into a jolly old rant about all the gypsies and travellers in their local areas? It’s pretty insensitive and, believe it or not, OP does not have to act as a spokesman for her entire community and answer for all the issues you have ever encountered with people who have nothing to do with her.

Seems like here is the same as another popular parenting board. The words traveller or gypsy are mentioned and everyone goes gung-ho with their 'personal experiences' as to why they're awful people.

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 21:21

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:17

Maybe people could resist the urge to turn OP’s thread about a racist incident she experienced today, into a jolly old rant about all the gypsies and travellers in their local areas? It’s pretty insensitive and, believe it or not, OP does not have to act as a spokesman for her entire community and answer for all the issues you have ever encountered with people who have nothing to do with her.

Thank you for this!

I came here to talk about my experience of racism and people decide to comment with more! I suppose it just proves how prevalent the problem is.

OP posts:
Whoopwhoop22 · 31/08/2022 21:19

We have a traveller site in the village we live in since around 2016. we have 5 pubs and in all honesty probably 2 Sunday's a month the travelling community attend the pubs and cause absolute mayhem with fighting (each other and others) they've smashed up pubs, smash small independent shop windows on a regular basis including our local bakery so yep by me you'd definitely be judged in our bakery....is it right to tar all with the same brush....no absolutely not, some of the community are genuinely really nice people but are massively let down by others in their community. Our village is mainly older residents that have had their property damaged been sworn at, spat at and threatened in the street. 2 drunk travellers robbed our independent opticians recently violently assulting the middle aged lady that works there. I've seen first hand the behaviour, I have had to stop my husband from being attacked for absolutely no reason in the pub just because someone wanted a fight so yeah I can see why people pass judgement and fear travellers, you don't know previous history that man in the bakery has had with travellers. Most people won't attend the pubs by me now myself included. Many of these people frequented the pubs regularly for as long as I can remember but don't now and landlords feel powerless to do anything because they worry about the repercussions. Some have tried to ban the trouble makers not because they are travellers but because of their behaviour and one had his car smashed up for his efforts.

On the other hand in the local hair salon we have 2 traveller sisters working there who are the loveliest people you can meet and who are extremely and I mean extremely talented hairdressers and they have been embraced by everyone who uses the salon plus many other people in the village. They take part in community events, school events, their children are much loved by other kids in the school and in the after school clubs, they are sweet polite intelligent kids who are completely included and apart of the local community.

There is good and bad everywhere but travellers are feared because people see them as lawless.

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:17

Maybe people could resist the urge to turn OP’s thread about a racist incident she experienced today, into a jolly old rant about all the gypsies and travellers in their local areas? It’s pretty insensitive and, believe it or not, OP does not have to act as a spokesman for her entire community and answer for all the issues you have ever encountered with people who have nothing to do with her.

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 21:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So you're admitting you and everyone you know is racist? Nice.

OP posts:
COPPER3 · 31/08/2022 21:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PeasOff · 31/08/2022 21:16

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:11

I’m depressed by the number of posts here that decry racism against gypsies but then basically say ‘I’m sure not all gypsies are like this but…’ and go on to talk about the badly behaved gypsies they’ve encountered at some point in their lives, who unfortunately give all gypsies ‘a bad name’ or have made them feel wary of gypsies in general.

Just imagine for one second that we were talking about any other race, religion or ethnic group and you’ll realise that what you’re spouting with your anecdotes IS racism.

’I know not all black people are like this but my friend was mugged by a black man so I understand why a lot of people don’t trust black people’

’I’m sure most Jews are lovely, but I knew a horrible Jewish chap once, so I’m a bit wary of Jews in general’

’Of course there are lots of lovely Chinese people but my Muslim neighbours are very loud and obnoxious, they give all Chinese people a bad name’.

It’s racism, plain and simple.

Pathetic isnt it? And yet, you call them out and people accuse you of reporting them when their racist posts get removed 🙄

PotatoHammock · 31/08/2022 21:15

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:11

I’m depressed by the number of posts here that decry racism against gypsies but then basically say ‘I’m sure not all gypsies are like this but…’ and go on to talk about the badly behaved gypsies they’ve encountered at some point in their lives, who unfortunately give all gypsies ‘a bad name’ or have made them feel wary of gypsies in general.

Just imagine for one second that we were talking about any other race, religion or ethnic group and you’ll realise that what you’re spouting with your anecdotes IS racism.

’I know not all black people are like this but my friend was mugged by a black man so I understand why a lot of people don’t trust black people’

’I’m sure most Jews are lovely, but I knew a horrible Jewish chap once, so I’m a bit wary of Jews in general’

’Of course there are lots of lovely Chinese people but my Muslim neighbours are very loud and obnoxious, they give all Chinese people a bad name’.

It’s racism, plain and simple.

Tbh, this is exactly how I find antisemitism often presents. "Listen, I'm sure most of them are perfectly nice people. We had a Jewish accountant at work once, and he was a right laugh, and didn't take all that kosher business too seriously. But you have to admit, it's pretty dodgy how the whole world seems to be run by Them."

SunnyD44 · 31/08/2022 21:14

Can I ask what area this is?

I live in Cornwall and most of us are pretty tolerant with other races and religions, as basically we don’t have much culture down here and so we can’t really blame or be angry at a race when they can’t cause any problems.

But the amount of racism aimed at Gypsies/travellers is disgusting!!

On Facebook someone posted that the police were called because someone with an Irish accent went to their business and wanted to use their services - there was No rudeness or any indication that this man was dodgey and most of the comments underneath were saying to be careful because they saw a gypsy the other day etc.

Another time a ‘traveller’ (no actual proof) had gone into the dump to dump stuff like everyone else but he had a white van which apparently means he uses it to steal peoples dogs and someone also said they kidnap children.

Honestly the amount of arguments I’ve had with people over it is insane. But I guess like all racists they’ll never see your point of view because they’re just too stupid.

You always here things like they met a gypsy/traveller and they were rude or they left rubbish etc but that’s the exact same as treating all black people the same.
Just because 1 is a dick or a criminal doesn’t mean the rest are.

When people talk about white privilege that’s one of the things they mean - that someone can commit a crime and the entire race doesn’t get blamed for it.

PeasOff · 31/08/2022 21:14

hattie43 · 31/08/2022 21:11

@PeasOff

You've got no decent argument except report . How sad you are

I don't do reporting, never have, never will.

People's own shitty behaviours and opinions will out without me pressing a button (as yours have).

Funny that you didn't address my points though!

CrabbitBastard · 31/08/2022 21:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 31/08/2022 21:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:12

FirewomanSam · 31/08/2022 21:11

I’m depressed by the number of posts here that decry racism against gypsies but then basically say ‘I’m sure not all gypsies are like this but…’ and go on to talk about the badly behaved gypsies they’ve encountered at some point in their lives, who unfortunately give all gypsies ‘a bad name’ or have made them feel wary of gypsies in general.

Just imagine for one second that we were talking about any other race, religion or ethnic group and you’ll realise that what you’re spouting with your anecdotes IS racism.

’I know not all black people are like this but my friend was mugged by a black man so I understand why a lot of people don’t trust black people’

’I’m sure most Jews are lovely, but I knew a horrible Jewish chap once, so I’m a bit wary of Jews in general’

’Of course there are lots of lovely Chinese people but my Muslim neighbours are very loud and obnoxious, they give all Chinese people a bad name’.

It’s racism, plain and simple.

Oops, I fudged my last example there but you get what I mean!

Onceuponaheartache · 31/08/2022 21:12

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:59

Thank you, Facebook groups are the worst.

People will literally post "just seen some gypsies in X place, lock up your valuables" how is that even accepted?!

I'm really sorry you have experienced this.

I think ignorance over travellers v romany people is probably at the core of the issue.

Where I grew up we had a lot of issues with the travelling community. Lots of violence and theft by them. I was subjected to an unprovoked attack that was followed into my school. The police were involved etc. However, it was 1 group of idiots and does not represent the entire community.

It winds me up when people post ruse comments about "dirty gypsies" on our local Facebook pages when they park up. I know the stereotype is that they leave a mess behind but actually when I have seen them locally they have been litter picking and ensuring the area was tidy.

I am so cross that these sort of racism is granted as acceptable. It is just as bad (and sometimes worse) than condemning Jews to death just for their religion, or all people with non white skin being considered inferior to those who are white.

One day people will allow others to live their lives without persecution.

Ilovelurchers · 31/08/2022 21:11

So sorry you went through this OP. My partner is a traveller and has experienced similar. It's a form of racism that somehow seems to still be considered acceptable by many - it's utterly disgusting. And thank you for sharing this and highlighting it. The more it is talked about the better - I am convinced that, shocking as it sounds, some people don't realise that their anti-traveller prejudice is a form of racism....