Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Make me feel better about staying in London please!

139 replies

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 17:40

Partner and I are going to move out of our London flat as we want more space / garden for the toddler and baby.

I’m desperate to use this as a way to leave London and head for a smaller city, think: a Cathedral city so somewhere with culture, history and an identity - basically York or Norwich, but probably York. Somewhere we can get a slightly bigger cheaper house, have a calmer pace of life, make new friends, grow our own veg and not raise children who may be entitled London brats.

Reasons being I find London life annoying is I’ve been here 13 years and it’s increasingly fast paced, crowded, polluted and competitive. Don’t like being so far away from the countryside, living in the same city as friends but it taking an hour and a half to get to them because it’s so bloody big, no real sense of community, the general feeling of stress and busyness that seems to scent the London air.

Partner is not keen to leave, at least not now and gives very sensible reasons. We’d have to find new jobs / retrain as we both have London centric careers and while we do want to retrain now is probably too soon. We don’t have friends of family outside London in the places we’d like to move and raising young kids with no friends or family close by (which would be the case if we moved) is bloody hard. Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould.

I know in my heart that partner is right, and if they also wanted to leave I’d be voicing some of their reasons for staying. But I still get a horrible pang of longing whenever we leave London, or conversely view a house In London that costs double what a bigger house would cost elsewhere.

Help! Convince me that London is worth staying in and that the dream life doesn’t lie in York

OP posts:
LBFseBrom · 31/08/2022 21:29

I don't get the 'entitled London brats' comment which strikes me as a sweeping generalisation.

Having lived in London all my life, albeit on the outskirts, I would not want to live anywhere else. There is plenty of green space within London and just outside it. I do understand that, when it comes to property, you can buy more for your money outside London but salaries are generally lower.

It's quite easy to get around in London, public transport is good. There will be more to interest your children as they get older.

Think about it seriously from all angles before making a decision.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:28

NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 21:22

You trying to influence the factors in your children's lives IS parenting. That's part of what parenting is; the decisions you make for them.

I wasn't claiming anything other than if your children turn out entitled brats that won't be because of the city they live in. It will be HOW they live in that city. And HOW they live is down to you and your parenting. You're no more likely to raise a brat in London than you are in Norfolk or York.

But I’m talking about trying to influence the external factors in my children’s lives by moving or not moving cities, to somewhere we could afford a better lifestyle and they could go to a more socially mixed school. Which is both parenting, and doing what I can in my limited capacity to change their outside influences

I think we’re essentially agreeing here. Just differing on definitions of what is just parenting and what is down to outside factors which can be partially but not fully influenced by parents choices.

OP posts:
BerryTiredMama · 31/08/2022 21:23

Born and bred Londoner, possible brat, lived in a buzzing part of the city all my life and now decided to move to Harrow for kids. Offers really great schools, lots of parks/greenery and village feel as we will be between Pinner and north harrow. Harrow/kenton have great housing stock, the plots are big with large gardens, links on the met line are amazing if you want to get into the city.

Suggest you look at greater burbs of london, whichever take your fancy, I think that will be a good compromise for you and your partner.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:22

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 31/08/2022 21:14

I could never leave London. If there's a major show or major band or major exhibition it's right there on my doorstep along with so much culture and vibrancy as well as the amazing transport links to get to them. I'll keep my smaller garden to always have that available.

Excellent reasons to add to my list - thanks

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 21:22

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 20:46

These are all examples of parents / caregivers trying to influence the other factors in their children's lives like location, peers, schools etc.

You were claiming that parenting was more or less the only influential factor in a child’s life, and that my kids would turn out the same no matter what the other factors in their life (beyond parenting) were if our parenting was the same. If that was the case my kids would have exactly the same life / personal outcomes if they went to a private school in Highgate with posh friends, music and chess lessons and no money worries vs if we moved them to Bradford, with a mix of friends and sent them to a school in special measures and that didn’t have a chess club or music lessons. Because we their parents would be the same and would be teaching them the same values / they’d be learning from our example.

Its just not the case.

You trying to influence the factors in your children's lives IS parenting. That's part of what parenting is; the decisions you make for them.

I wasn't claiming anything other than if your children turn out entitled brats that won't be because of the city they live in. It will be HOW they live in that city. And HOW they live is down to you and your parenting. You're no more likely to raise a brat in London than you are in Norfolk or York.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:19

JasmineIndigo · 31/08/2022 21:16

I guess you were hoping for some
mindless London bashing OP, sorry you didn’t get it 🙄 If you can’t manage to raise your children not to be entitled brats, it doesn’t really matter where you
live 🤷🏻‍♀️

I asked for exactly the opposite of mindless London bashing actually @JasmineIndigo. Did you read my post? I was asking for reasons to feel glad about staying in London, beyond the sensible ones my partner had articulated.

Why so disingenuous?

OP posts:
JasmineIndigo · 31/08/2022 21:16

I guess you were hoping for some
mindless London bashing OP, sorry you didn’t get it 🙄 If you can’t manage to raise your children not to be entitled brats, it doesn’t really matter where you
live 🤷🏻‍♀️

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 31/08/2022 21:14

I could never leave London. If there's a major show or major band or major exhibition it's right there on my doorstep along with so much culture and vibrancy as well as the amazing transport links to get to them. I'll keep my smaller garden to always have that available.

Maireas · 31/08/2022 21:12

Whereabouts do you live in London?

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:09

PlanetNormal · 31/08/2022 21:05

Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould.

Stay in London, OP. Seriously. The rest of the country really doesn’t want insular, ignorant Londoners with ridiculously stereotypical attitudes about the world outside the M25.

I’m a northerner

OP posts:
Mum4all · 31/08/2022 21:07

I was born in London, now living outside of London, very happily!

London's a wonderfully diverse city, diversity does not always equal community. All of my family still live on London so I have very strong ties.

We are all free to come and go, but it makes me sad that people blow into London, live the life and then feel I can't live here anymore, it's to this or to that.....

I left London because DH, who loves the energy of London wanted the countryside also. He is not a Londoner.
We do go to London regularly, good commute service. He says we have the best of both worlds. I just feel that London has lost and will continue to loose sense of community because those that can afford to live there, believe me I know it is expensive - eventually feel that they do not want to live there anymore.

For those born in London who have no choice or that are quite happy to continue living in London, there is community. It is often messy, but it's community, that's how I grew up in London.

I love living in the countryside and am part of a wonderful community here.

Cities, everywhere are challenging, brilliant places to live.

PlanetNormal · 31/08/2022 21:05

Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould.

Stay in London, OP. Seriously. The rest of the country really doesn’t want insular, ignorant Londoners with ridiculously stereotypical attitudes about the world outside the M25.

tiredmum83 · 31/08/2022 21:00

@Okeydoky what area is that please? It sounds great!!

Bingisamoaner · 31/08/2022 20:59

Move to Hertford. You'll have 2 train lines into London but a more relaxed way of life.

Pamparam · 31/08/2022 20:58

I live in a 'cheap' (relatively speaking) bit of unfashionable London borough and the community vibe is strong! You haven't met people through your kids nursery etc? If you volunteer for community stuff then that also helps you meet people. I thought I wanted to move out of london when I had kids but actually I think they'll love growing up here. Just wish my tiny terrace garden was bigger and the air quality a bit better! But the multicultural experience is worth it imo

mondaytosunday · 31/08/2022 20:56

I live in London. We have a community - I was here just a couple months when people I met dog walking put me on our street's WhatsApp group and I was invited to a coffee morning.
Halloween is like the movie ET - loads of little kids running around trick o' treating! My neighbours are friendly and welcoming.
My daughter commutes to central London for school. It's a selective private girls school, but there are plenty who I would not describe as 'London brats'.
I also have lived outside London. And there I met plenty of non white non Christians.
I love London. It has everything- culture, great shopping, the centre of finance, amazing food. I love the buzz, the pace, the atmosphere. I don't have to be in the West End every day to enjoy that.
If none of that is appealing then off you go.

sevengoodthings · 31/08/2022 20:50

I've lived in central and outer London and don't recognise your description. The great thing about a big city is that there are so many different social groups and communities out there and you can find one you like and fit into. There's no need to hang out with people who like a fast paced lifestyles, there's no need to have 'London brats' (whatever they are?). There is a sense of community if you find the right place and friends, and you can have local friends too. But there are also plenty of places outside London where it's perfectly acceptable and normal to not be straight, white or Christian. I wonder if your own expectations and prejudices might be influencing how you see these places - you expect 'London brats' and frenetic lifestyles, so that's what you see?

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 20:46

NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 20:39

Yes obviously parents are the biggest influence on kids lives. But where they live, their school, their peers, their wider family, how much money they have or don’t have etc. obviously all also have a big influence. If these things didn’t matter nobody would ever move to a different catchment area or pay for music lessons or try to gently steer them away from troublesome friends no?

But these are all examples of parenting aren't they? Picking a school, deciding on music lessons or not, your financial situation, how you deal with troublesome friends are all parenting decisions, they're not rooted to what city you're in. You can have music lessons or make bad friends in London or Norwich or York or in fact any other UK city (and I'm sure any city in the world). It's not London based.

These are all examples of parents / caregivers trying to influence the other factors in their children's lives like location, peers, schools etc.

You were claiming that parenting was more or less the only influential factor in a child’s life, and that my kids would turn out the same no matter what the other factors in their life (beyond parenting) were if our parenting was the same. If that was the case my kids would have exactly the same life / personal outcomes if they went to a private school in Highgate with posh friends, music and chess lessons and no money worries vs if we moved them to Bradford, with a mix of friends and sent them to a school in special measures and that didn’t have a chess club or music lessons. Because we their parents would be the same and would be teaching them the same values / they’d be learning from our example.

Its just not the case.

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 31/08/2022 20:46

It’s the wealthiest bit of the UK? Having more tends to lead to expecting more.

The list of top 20 (even top 10) local authorities wih highest indices of deprivation features a high number of London boroughs. A lot of wealth and economic activity is generated in London, doesn't mean the people living there are the wealthiest in the UK.
I second the PP who said London is like hundreds of connected villages. You clearly don't like the village you are in and I would suggest finding another village that gives you the sense of community you crave (and yes, it may be a less affluent area)

NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 20:39

Yes obviously parents are the biggest influence on kids lives. But where they live, their school, their peers, their wider family, how much money they have or don’t have etc. obviously all also have a big influence. If these things didn’t matter nobody would ever move to a different catchment area or pay for music lessons or try to gently steer them away from troublesome friends no?

But these are all examples of parenting aren't they? Picking a school, deciding on music lessons or not, your financial situation, how you deal with troublesome friends are all parenting decisions, they're not rooted to what city you're in. You can have music lessons or make bad friends in London or Norwich or York or in fact any other UK city (and I'm sure any city in the world). It's not London based.

edwinbear · 31/08/2022 20:37

OK, I understand where you’re coming from now, generally being surrounded by huge amounts of wealth and wanting to keep up.

South of the river is your friend here….generally perceived as the ‘poor’ bit of London but I find it much more down to earth. (DSis is in Highgate). Some very affordable houses in Hither Green & Lee Green, 15 mins into London but obviously no tube. 20 min drive and you can be in Kent, we drove an hour to get to the sea last weekend (Whitstable) which was fantastic!

Joshanddonna · 31/08/2022 20:36

Entitled London brats?
What an obnoxious thing to say. If your kids are brats it’s down to you not London.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 20:35

NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 20:24

I think you need to stop blaming the city you live in for how you feel or how your kids turn out.

If you raise entitled brats that will be your parenting not London or York or Norwich. You.

If you're stressed or don't feel part of a community or feel in competition with people that's all you. It's not where you live.

Maybe talk to a counsellor. Make some inward changes.

Yes obviously parents are the biggest influence on kids lives. But where they live, their school, their peers, their wider family, how much money they have or don’t have etc. obviously all also have a big influence. If these things didn’t matter nobody would ever move to a different catchment area or pay for music lessons or try to gently steer them away from troublesome friends no?

I don’t think finding London more stressful than smaller places, or harder to feel part a community than smaller places is that uncommon? Aren’t levels of loneliness and stress supposed to be highest in London? Which is not to say I shouldn’t also try to change my attitude @NuffSaidSam, one of the reasons I started this post was to ask people to share their reasons to feel good about living in London, to see what I could glean. It was meant to be lighthearted.

OP posts:
TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 31/08/2022 20:26

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 20:16

Yes I half suspect I might be the same. But the yearning for hypothetically greener pastures is hard to tamp down.

Must remind self of all the lovely things about London and stop aching for proper wild countryside and the “rose tinted” friendly northerners of my youth…

Family
Friends
Good museums
Really good theatre
Polish restaurants
Well connected airports
Lovely architecture
Mix of people
Turkish greengrocers
Amazing parks
Lots of jobs
Several symphony orchestras
24 hour chemists / corner shops
Great transport network
Afghan restaurants
Jewish Ethiopians
Injera
Synagogues
Friends who come and visit from other places

good list, plenty more you could add to it!!

great pubs
thai restaurants
fabulous book shops
variety of cafes

there is always something going on.

I sum it up with one word. LIFE.

I cannot emphasise just how much I regret moving out.

... you don't know what you've got till it's gone...

yes I'm only an hours train ride away, but by the time you've driven to the station, parked, waited for the train, got to Waterloo & then gone to where I actually want to be, I'm looking at 2/3 hours & ££££. All to just 'be there' instead of rolling out of bed & being a 5 minute walk to a buzzing area.

<deep envy of those living in London>

NuffSaidSam · 31/08/2022 20:24

I think you need to stop blaming the city you live in for how you feel or how your kids turn out.

If you raise entitled brats that will be your parenting not London or York or Norwich. You.

If you're stressed or don't feel part of a community or feel in competition with people that's all you. It's not where you live.

Maybe talk to a counsellor. Make some inward changes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread