Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Make me feel better about staying in London please!

139 replies

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 17:40

Partner and I are going to move out of our London flat as we want more space / garden for the toddler and baby.

I’m desperate to use this as a way to leave London and head for a smaller city, think: a Cathedral city so somewhere with culture, history and an identity - basically York or Norwich, but probably York. Somewhere we can get a slightly bigger cheaper house, have a calmer pace of life, make new friends, grow our own veg and not raise children who may be entitled London brats.

Reasons being I find London life annoying is I’ve been here 13 years and it’s increasingly fast paced, crowded, polluted and competitive. Don’t like being so far away from the countryside, living in the same city as friends but it taking an hour and a half to get to them because it’s so bloody big, no real sense of community, the general feeling of stress and busyness that seems to scent the London air.

Partner is not keen to leave, at least not now and gives very sensible reasons. We’d have to find new jobs / retrain as we both have London centric careers and while we do want to retrain now is probably too soon. We don’t have friends of family outside London in the places we’d like to move and raising young kids with no friends or family close by (which would be the case if we moved) is bloody hard. Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould.

I know in my heart that partner is right, and if they also wanted to leave I’d be voicing some of their reasons for staying. But I still get a horrible pang of longing whenever we leave London, or conversely view a house In London that costs double what a bigger house would cost elsewhere.

Help! Convince me that London is worth staying in and that the dream life doesn’t lie in York

OP posts:
MarthaChuzzlewhit · 01/09/2022 02:40

Felixfriend · 31/08/2022 17:47

“Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould” 🤨🤨🤨

Have you ever even left London? I think it’s time you did tbh. Your sweeping statements about both the capital and the rest of the country are ridiculous. Time to broaden your horizons.

Unfortunately I think OP is right… some of the smaller places in particular.

VioletToes · 01/09/2022 02:39

I felt this about London. It was just getting too busy for me. We left the UK and now live an hour outside another big city as dh career is also very City-centric.

It's drives me crackers having to be even this close to a city, but any longer commute for dh 3 times a week would be unfair.

I think when you're ready to move, as you seem to be, it's hard to see the positives of staying.

Personally, I'd work harder on changing your DP view 🙂

VirginiaWool · 01/09/2022 02:32

Tbh York is pretty insular and chavvy. Extremely white. And a popular hen and stag destination. It's ancient and pretty, but that's kind of a backdrop to the Blackpool type behaviour. Really the main industry is booze tourism.

Stay in London. London is a globally important city. There is loads of stuff to do. You and your kids can reinvent yourselves a hundred times over there. It's a nice place.

I get that it can grind you down. But really the alternative is being surrounded by people who think that saying "ow much" counts for a personality or, if they're middle class, that varying their order at the supposed chi chi bakery is decadently daring.

Fuck those guys. Stay in London.

Donehere · 01/09/2022 02:02

@Okeydoky also keen to hear where you live!

Luredbyapomegranate · 31/08/2022 23:49

There are twats everywhere OP, something that is well illustrated any Saturday night in the centre of York 😁. I don’t know Norwich, but I do know it’s an arse to get to from anywhere else.

I think you are being a wee bit bratty teen Op, everywhere has its up and downsides. I know you’ve been torn a new one for suggesting that london kids are more bratty than others (rightly), and for suggesting everyone outside the capital is white and straight (again, rightly) but it is equally daft to suggest London doesn’t have a sense of community. The entire place is made up of little communities. South East is quite green, affordable and with lots of communities, so start there and go and find one. It’s rare and lucky that life just falls into place, whether you are in Swansea or Streatham, mostly you have to make it work,

fivehundred · 31/08/2022 23:45

A lot of people who've moved out of London are super-defensive about their decision. Secretly they regret it and they are dead inside.

terfenerf · 31/08/2022 23:38

yawn yawn yawn
est city on earth why would anyone leave?
brattier the better i say.

fancytulip · 31/08/2022 23:20

Who is this white straight Christian mafia you're talking about and what makes you think those characteristics makes someone automatically intolerant or unable to mix with entitled London brats?

OGLittlePickerWithTheMassiveKnickers · 31/08/2022 22:55

Growing veg is boring as shit. But maybe get an allotment if you love it so much.

FKATondelayo · 31/08/2022 22:49

My kids too, Fiddle.

London kids often DO have an air of self-confidence and sophistication. I suppose it compensates for the stabbings and air pollution.

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 31/08/2022 22:40

I love London, albeit my kids are a bit bratty. I love all the different food, I love my friends (both old and new) and family nearby. I love the countryside walks 15 min drive, and the Covent Garden restaurant date nights with my husband. I love the ethnic diversity and feel a bit othered in more rural places. Am in SE London.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 22:39

Yubgftr · 31/08/2022 22:19

This

Yea as I’ve said up thread, I grew up in Yorkshire and the Midlands, and as an adult have lived in London, Mumbai, Nairobi and a few other places.

If you honestly think that there aren’t places in the UK where it is harder to live if you don’t look / worship / love like the majority do, then I’d suggest that it’s you who has probably never left Islington

OP posts:
Sudbury · 31/08/2022 22:35

NewDiary · 31/08/2022 22:14

But it doesn’t make any sense- if you want your kids to go to state schools and know poor children, we have both of those in London. It’s not a reason to move to Yorkshire. (Not offering a view on what you should do btw- I’m also a Yorkshire-born woman living in London and I love both places. Just don’t like stereotypes.)

yes I wasn’t saying I wanted to move to Yorkshire so my kids would “know poor people”. There are other reasons why I’d like to move back to Yorkshire. The poster I was replying to had more or less said, how your kids turn out is entirely down to you, not where they live. My response was an (exaggerated to extremes) example of how raising the same kids with the same parents in different environments would affect them, and that how kids turn out is down to a mix of parenting and external influences. It was a complete sidebar to my main post. Not related to reasons to go to Yorkshire or not

OP posts:
hellokittyface · 31/08/2022 22:32

York is a nice city but it would take some getting used to after London. It can be a bit "villagey" as it is not a very transient or diverse city.

It can be hard to make friends in York but as you have kids I suppose there will be opportunities through their activities to meet people who are looking for friends.

York is cheaper than London but it is still expensive compared to other places in Yorkshire.

Personally I would move to a suburban place near London so that you have the best of both.

BerryTiredMama · 31/08/2022 22:29

😂 @FKATondelayo i think the OP isn’t white which is why she has a fear of moving away from london, which is justified. Many places in the UK are still racist but lets not get into that! Even if you are white OP i can see why you love Turkish grocers, the bread 🥖 is divine.

FKATondelayo · 31/08/2022 22:21

Family
Friends
Good museums
Really good theatre
Polish restaurants
Well connected airports
Lovely architecture
Mix of people
Turkish greengrocers
Amazing parks
Lots of jobs
Several symphony orchestras
24 hour chemists / corner shops
Great transport network
Afghan restaurants
Jewish Ethiopians
Injera
Synagogues
Friends who come and visit from other places

This list reminds me of that part in Gone Girl when Nick & Amy moved to a small town and he said that Amy only really missed NYC's ethnic diversity as it was part of her brand / lifestyle.

Yubgftr · 31/08/2022 22:19

Felixfriend · 31/08/2022 17:47

“Other places may be less open / accepting of people who don’t 100% fit the straight, white, Christian mould” 🤨🤨🤨

Have you ever even left London? I think it’s time you did tbh. Your sweeping statements about both the capital and the rest of the country are ridiculous. Time to broaden your horizons.

This

NewDiary · 31/08/2022 22:14

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:44

Yes they are exaggerated extremes, that was the point. I was using them as extreme examples of different environments that kids could grow up in to illustrate a point that kids are influenced by their environment, as well as by their parenting.

I didn’t say either was typical of all London or all Yorkshire. I picked extreme opposites to make a point. Probably chose the Bradford one because I grew up very near there and my uncle taught in one of those schools, and the London one because that’s close to how I see some of the kids living near me growing up

But it doesn’t make any sense- if you want your kids to go to state schools and know poor children, we have both of those in London. It’s not a reason to move to Yorkshire. (Not offering a view on what you should do btw- I’m also a Yorkshire-born woman living in London and I love both places. Just don’t like stereotypes.)

Snowiscold · 31/08/2022 21:55

I live in London and my DC grew up here -they went to state schools. London is really great for children and teens. My home town is York and I return regularly. My parents live there. I love it, and for a long time I wanted to leave London and return to York. London is so expensive and my now-adult DC have no hope of ever being able to buy a flat of their own in their home city. It makes me sad, and worried.

Hercisback · 31/08/2022 21:48

You can choose the school they go to in London, and you are likely to have more choice than being in Bradford.

I wouldn't move away from family when you have children. The support can be invaluable.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:44

NewDiary · 31/08/2022 21:40

that was the case my kids would have exactly the same life / personal outcomes if they went to a private school in Highgate with posh friends, music and chess lessons and no money worries vs if we moved them to Bradford.

Why on earth are you equating being a London kid with being privately educated, and being a Yorkshire kid as going to a sink school in Bradford 😭 London is full of state schools, plenty of desperately poor kids as well, while Yorkshire has its share of rich, privately-educated children. Ridiculous stereotypes.

Yes they are exaggerated extremes, that was the point. I was using them as extreme examples of different environments that kids could grow up in to illustrate a point that kids are influenced by their environment, as well as by their parenting.

I didn’t say either was typical of all London or all Yorkshire. I picked extreme opposites to make a point. Probably chose the Bradford one because I grew up very near there and my uncle taught in one of those schools, and the London one because that’s close to how I see some of the kids living near me growing up

OP posts:
NewDiary · 31/08/2022 21:40

that was the case my kids would have exactly the same life / personal outcomes if they went to a private school in Highgate with posh friends, music and chess lessons and no money worries vs if we moved them to Bradford.

Why on earth are you equating being a London kid with being privately educated, and being a Yorkshire kid as going to a sink school in Bradford 😭 London is full of state schools, plenty of desperately poor kids as well, while Yorkshire has its share of rich, privately-educated children. Ridiculous stereotypes.

Sudbury · 31/08/2022 21:40

Sandinmyknickers · 31/08/2022 20:46

It’s the wealthiest bit of the UK? Having more tends to lead to expecting more.

The list of top 20 (even top 10) local authorities wih highest indices of deprivation features a high number of London boroughs. A lot of wealth and economic activity is generated in London, doesn't mean the people living there are the wealthiest in the UK.
I second the PP who said London is like hundreds of connected villages. You clearly don't like the village you are in and I would suggest finding another village that gives you the sense of community you crave (and yes, it may be a less affluent area)

Yes I didn’t say all the kids in London were entitled brats. Just that my kids might be more likely to become that way if we stayed where we were. Perhaps it’s the fact that London is a series of villages, and that one village tends not to blend much with another is part of the issue. Notting hill six bedroom townhouses in one village, high rise estates in the next village over, but their kids usually not mixing much. I grew up somewhere much more mixed and blended, which is the environment I’d rather have for my kids. But hey ho, we are where we are.

It was intended as a light hearted remark but clearly I’ve misjudged the tone, as some people on here have taken it pretty personally as a judgement of their kids or a sweeping statement about all London kids. Sorry if anyone has taken genuine offence. It wasn’t meant.

OP posts:
TaraRhu · 31/08/2022 21:37

I'd also look at the pros more. London will offer your kids better opportunities when they are older. There's so many jobs.

I find the ability to change jobs really positive. You can change pretty much when you want and get to know another area / part of the city.

It's pretty hard to get bored which I love. Plus the mix of people and cultures is really inspiring.

TaraRhu · 31/08/2022 21:32

Just move somewhere commutable. Your London friends can come to visit and vice versa.

St Albans, Cambridge, Oxford, or any number of market towns in the commuter belt.

You have young kids - this will help you make friends.

London also doesn't have to be stressy. Would you consider/ are you able to reduce your working hours ? I've done that and it's a game changer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread