Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunches

106 replies

HintofVintagePink · 31/08/2022 17:17

My child’s school dinners cost £2.55 a day. Given the rising cost of food I’m not sure I can make him a big enough and nutritious enough packed lunch for the same cost. He is nearly 10 and eats almost as much as DH.
He has always had a packed lunch but I’m considering making the change to school dinners (plus it saves all the lunchbox faff!)
Am I just being lazy and unimaginative or is that reasonable?

OP posts:
MintyGreenDreams · 31/08/2022 19:36

I agree with pp about portion size.I work in a primary and often think wtf to the meal sizes

ChocolateCakeYum · 31/08/2022 19:34

Ds is moving to packed lunches.

He’s a fussy eater so at school will only eat a cheese sandwich or some pasta (occasionally some chips). It costs £2.60 a day. It’s ridiculous how much I’m paying for him to eat a bloody sandwich especially as they don’t provide fruit or a yogurt to go with it. With a packed lunch he’ll be having sandwich, fruit, yogurt and a cookie and will cost me half of what it does currently.

BooksAndHooks · 31/08/2022 19:30

Packed lunches for my three certainly don’t cost anywhere near that. I certainly don’t spend nearly £40 a week on packed lunches. It’s half that cost.

Caterina99 · 31/08/2022 19:17

My kids have school dinners and I love it due to the lack of faff. Kids seem happy enough and don’t really know any different as the majority of children have them. However we’re in scotland and they’re free up to p5 currently I think.

If I had to pay £2.50 a day I might reconsider. I’m pretty sure I could make pretty substantial packed lunches for that price. I’d probably be happy to pay for the convenience though if I could afford it

Icannever · 31/08/2022 19:14

School dinners where we are are just awful stodge, I would not call them nutritious at all. Plus the kids eat as little as they can get away with so they can go out and play whereas they can take their lunch box out with them as eat as they go. You pay the whole £2.75 even if they decide to just eat a plain roll!
school lunch is £2.75 here and packed lunch is way less than that. Sandwich, apple, crisps and cereal bar is about £1.

Nat6999 · 31/08/2022 18:57

At ds school if you weren't at the front of the queue very often there was hardly anything left by the time you got served. Packed lunches for a week cost less than £12.75, a loaf £2, pack of ham £2.50, cheese £2.80, 5 apples £2.00, multipack of crisps £2, could be done cheaper if you use things like massive packs of pasta or leftovers.

Dogandacat · 31/08/2022 18:55

A couple of years ago we had some teachers from UK over to see how our school system works. They just could not seem to get over the free food, and took pictures every day of their food on their plates. 😂

Ragwort · 31/08/2022 18:54

I never understand the angst about packed lunches on Mumsnet ... my DS had almost the same lunch every day throughout his school life - one or two (large) ham rolls and a banana ... I never added snacks, treats, fizzy
drinks etc .... of course it's cheaper than a school lunch. And unless you are very lucky school lunches are really not very nutritious.

Dogandacat · 31/08/2022 18:52

I’m not in the UK but I would do school dinners if the quality of food is good. Here school dinners are free from age 1-19 and it’s basically buffet style so they can eat as much as they want. Older children often have 3 different dinners go pick from and the food is often lovely and healthy (you would not on your life see chips or baked beans or processed food). Staff can usually eat for free too, some schools charge staff £2-3. Today we had boiled potatoes, oven baked fish in a lovely sauce and 8 different vegetables. Fruit for dessert.

I think it’s a pity UK don’t do the same, it’s guaranteed at least all children no matter parents income have a proper cooked meal every day. During covid (we had no lockdown but school for 17-year olds and up were digital some weeks, half of the pupils went to school for one week and the rest had digital classes with their teachers and the week after they swapped) the pupils studying from home could pick up free lunches from school or were given coupons for local restaurants to give them support.

solarbirdscalm · 31/08/2022 18:40

School dinners are small plus DS' experience last year was as one of the older ones they got their dinner last... so there often was barely anything left, or what they had left was an odd mix of what should have been available. My youngest will probably have some school lunches this year (Year 4) but not bother by next year.

Having said that obviously it varies by school. Can he not just try a few days and find out what its like?

Phos · 31/08/2022 18:34

I think it depends on the school. My daughter's school does different portion sizes for older kids and the food is cooked fresh on site. She also prefers having a hot lunch and sandwich tea rather than the other way around. I quite liked making her packed lunches for holiday clubs over summer but it was a novelty!

Her school don't allow packed lunches anyway but even if they did, I think we'd still plump for dinners.

EcoCustard · 31/08/2022 18:31

The school dinners at DC’s primary school aren’t great. I have helped at lunchtime and they remind me of plane food. They aren’t cooked on site as no kitchen so bought in, they vary from warm to cold. Small portions & a repetitive menu which gets smaller as costs increase. Dc1 & 2 are very grumpy on the occasions they have them as they are still hungry. 1/2 a jacket potato which is luke warm and the cheese doesn’t melt. Packed lunches all the way for my 4Dc. Packed lunch is more cost effective for 4dc though than £2.60 per day and they would still need a cooked dinner at night as they would be hungry.

MatildaJayne · 31/08/2022 18:28

Flatmountains · 31/08/2022 18:24

Dd's school want to finger print her if she wants school lunches. No amount of relief from faffing will make me allow this.

My secondary finger prints everyone for catering. They don’t actually have a copy of their prints, you do realise? The program will recognise a few points on their print is all. They can’t reverse engineer it and turn it into a fingerprint.

Caspianberg · 31/08/2022 18:27

I think the portion size is a consideration. But they will be more convenient

Otherwise buy a decent hot food flask. Hot tomato pasta with veggies and meatballs. Special fried rice. Minestrone soups. Sausage and butter bean casserole. Would cost the same to make, and you can make enough for you to have for lunch, and freeze some for other easy lunches.

Flatmountains · 31/08/2022 18:24

Dd's school want to finger print her if she wants school lunches. No amount of relief from faffing will make me allow this.

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 31/08/2022 18:23

Primary school dinners are tiny to be honest plus I have a fussy eater so primary school was a nightmare with constantly convincing her to try the school dinner option.

She is now in secondary school and is taking a small flask to school with hot pasta bake, chicken rice pilaf etc so eating much better, much lower costs and she is old enough (13) to heat and pack it herself! Bonus!

It's been a while since I've done primary packed lunches but I'm sure there will be some people more knowledgable than me along with cost saving ideas.

Clutterbugsmum · 31/08/2022 18:23

MatildaJayne · 31/08/2022 18:16

I used to do some lunch time supervision on top of my TA job. Portions really weren’t that big. I can remember the ‘home made pizza’ slices were sometimes a bit dry a couple of inches around the crust and they only got one slice! With old fashioned veg on the side but…

Ours used to do pizza 2inch square and an inch thick , some plain pasta and a few peas.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 31/08/2022 18:22

Ds 9 takes hot food to school 3 times a week pasta, sausage and mash, and curry and only likes menu on 2 days roast dinner day and fish day the portion sizes are very small and the older age groups eat last so half the time not enough food left too

Clutterbugsmum · 31/08/2022 18:21

HeyMicky · 31/08/2022 17:55

Packed lunches for both DDs would cost me £24 a week. I can absolutely do it cheaper than that, with a range of fruit and veg and protein.

Exactly when you take into account the monthly cost of school meals and what it would cost to buy the things to make lunch it does work cheaper.

TheTeddyBears · 31/08/2022 18:19

Aw my little one has just started school too and I hate doing packed lunches. Even worse she doesn't eat it mostly eats half a sandwich! What's even worse than that is in Scotland they get free school dinner up to and including primary 5 which I think is age 8/9.

If he likes the school dinner I wld be tempted to just go for that everyday! Ours is only £2.00 too for the older kids 10-12 that need to pay for them, bargain!

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/08/2022 18:19

I agree the meals at the end of primary weren’t big. A number of the parents said the same. She asked me to get her a food flask, which she used in years 5 and 6. It was a bit of a faff admittedly but I kept portions of batch cooked meals and heated them up.

MatildaJayne · 31/08/2022 18:16

I used to do some lunch time supervision on top of my TA job. Portions really weren’t that big. I can remember the ‘home made pizza’ slices were sometimes a bit dry a couple of inches around the crust and they only got one slice! With old fashioned veg on the side but…

Clutterbugsmum · 31/08/2022 18:15

I found school dinners are just not enough for year 5/6.

As a former lunch supervisor the meals are just so small.

For example a roast would be a slice of meat, 2 small roast potatoes, a desert spoon of veg and a tiny Yorkshire pudding. Pudding would be a small yogurt or a piece of fruit or a small cake about an inch and half square.

When mine got to this age I changed them to packed lunch as they were just so hungry when they got out of school.

PollyEsther · 31/08/2022 18:15

YABU: school dinners are tiny and leave children hungry. They are exceedingly poor value for money and often not remotely nutrionally balanced. That's not for lack of effort or hard work by lunch time staff, they are fabulous, but the funding allocated for the food is shocking compared to what parents pay.

My children have packed lunches, I save a fortune. We make use of leftovers from dinner, a food flask, creativity and batch cooking. I spent today cooking things such as quiche, puff pastry pinwheels and savoury muffins to keep in the freezer and grab quickly in the evening/morning.

TrashPandas · 31/08/2022 18:09

If he has the appetite of an adult male, school dinners really won't be enough for him.