Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think more MNers are using the pronoun 'they' in threads despite knowing the sex of the person?

60 replies

PieceofKate · 31/08/2022 14:48

It's really starting to wind me up. I keep seeing threads where a PP refers quite clearly to a person as 'he' or 'she', or 'my mother', 'my daughter', 'my son' etc - but then people responding switch to 'they'.

I've just seen one. A poster whose neighbour is moving her post. She refers to him as 'he'. A few replies in and he's suddenly a 'they'.

OP posts:
Carrieonmywaywardsun · 31/08/2022 18:59

TeenDivided · 31/08/2022 15:31

'More inclusive' is not necessarily good when it is less precise and loses and obfuscates meaning.

Though I agree 'they' is useful when you can't be bothered to go back and check the OP.

I'm sure any confusion can be cleared up by asking a question such as "you referred to someone as they, what is their gender and preferred pronouns?" If you really must know such details

Caminante · 31/08/2022 17:56

10HailMarys · 31/08/2022 14:56

'They' has been used in English as a singular pronoun since around the 14th century, regardless of whether the person's gender is known or not. It is not a new development.

You simply notice it now because Mumsnetters are constantly in a tizzy about gender issues and think that any use of the word 'they' is some sort of eraser of biological sex, when in fact it's just a linguistic quirk of informal English that's been around and in daily use for about 700 years.

This. It's been there all along as part of our usage of English.

Breezycheesetrees · 31/08/2022 17:56

A colleague did this to me recently - referred to me as they in an email to a third party which I was copied into. She's met me numerous times, she knows full well I'm a woman, I've got an unambiguously female name, so I'm puzzled as to why she did it. I think perhaps she didn't want to get it wrong, as she doesn't have her pronouns in her signature either - several of our colleagues do but it's a minority. It irritated me though.

DappledThings · 31/08/2022 17:53

Definitely getting more common and mostly sounds really awkward when he or she would flow more naturally.

You get it with DC as well. Whole opening posts saying, " DC is 5 and likes swimming. Yesterday DC went to the pool with MIL and DC said later that they wanted an ice-cream. DC knows that they are only allowed that once a week. MIL said that DC got really cross" etc. Normal speech would be to replace a few of those "DCs" with he or she.

Snoozysnoozy · 31/08/2022 17:52

Not quite the same but...

I have 2 girls and a boy, as well as that we have multiple pets that are mainly male with the dog being a female.

One of my daughters has declared themselves non binary with pronouns of he/they. All of a sudden my partner refers to all of the other females in the house as they/them while my boy of still he/.

wackamole · 31/08/2022 17:47

I know the singular 'they' is as old as the hills but I've never known it to be used to refer to a specific person who has already been referred to as him or her.

This was the crux of your post, and a lot of the replies have missed or misinterpreted it.

Of course it makes sense to be vague about the sex of your child, partner, neighbour, boss, colleague, relative, etc. if you don't want it taken into consideration in the replies. And of course it's OK for the replies to be more general than the OP, or to use different terminology than the OP did. However, it IS confusing if someone switches pronouns for a specific person within one post while explaining a situation. I'd assume it's a mistake (poster perhaps meant to present the question without mentioning sex but accidentally did mention it). Easy to do when you're composing your post on the site, and may be editing for clarity/brevity but miss something. I like the (new with the last Site Update) PREVIEW function for this, but not sure if there might still be bugs with it as I don't use the app.

notnownorma: Oh, dear, shock horror, the trans agenda is taking over, the sky is falling, etc etc etc. yawn This is a weird and ahistorical reach. Intentionally using more general language in the cases where sex is irrelevant is an old feminist tactic which goes back to the 1960s at least; nothing to do with "the trans agenda", whatever that is. Also not relevant to the OP's post.

PieceofKate · 31/08/2022 17:16

notnownorma · 31/08/2022 15:36

Oh, dear, shock horror, the trans agenda is taking over, the sky is falling, etc etc etc.

yawn

No shock, horror or falling sky. Just mild irritation.

OP posts:
notnownorma · 31/08/2022 15:36

Oh, dear, shock horror, the trans agenda is taking over, the sky is falling, etc etc etc.

yawn

mummabubs · 31/08/2022 15:35

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 31/08/2022 14:51

I use it when I forget if the OP has said their gender. And on the app you can't see the OP without deleting everything you've written. Plus they works for everyone, even if you know the pronoun. More inclusive speak is a good thing

I was going to make a similar point - I only do it when a) I can't remember the sex from the OP and don't want to lose what I've written as I only use the android app (which is terrible but that's a different thread) or b) If I'm posting about someone I know and want to increase anonymity. For me personally it's not an assumption or suggestion of gender neutrality.

BeanieTeen · 31/08/2022 15:34

So I'd say 'If someone feels ill, find them a chair' but I wouldn't reply to 'I'm taking my daughter shopping' with 'what are you going to buy for them?'.

This is what I mean with it depending on how well or if you know someone. To me, when I think about it carefully, that’s how it works anyway.

If said ‘daughter’ was maybe you’re niece who you know, I agree that would be odd way for you to reply.
But if it was a colleague maybe, and you didn’t know her daughter, I think that would be a normal reply.
Thing is, on MN, most of us don’t know each other personally. Therefore we are always talking about people we don’t know or that other posters don’t know. So it’s more prevalent here to use ‘they’ than in a real life context.

TeenDivided · 31/08/2022 15:31

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 31/08/2022 14:51

I use it when I forget if the OP has said their gender. And on the app you can't see the OP without deleting everything you've written. Plus they works for everyone, even if you know the pronoun. More inclusive speak is a good thing

'More inclusive' is not necessarily good when it is less precise and loses and obfuscates meaning.

Though I agree 'they' is useful when you can't be bothered to go back and check the OP.

PieceofKate · 31/08/2022 15:29

Sparklingbrook · 31/08/2022 15:26

Another vote for this.

Sorry - meant to quote this message. Makes sense to me.

OP posts:
PieceofKate · 31/08/2022 15:28

This makes perfect sense.

OP posts:
PieceofKate · 31/08/2022 15:27

Thanks for all the responses. It sounds like I am being rather over-sensitive. I know the singular 'they' is as old as the hills but I've never known it to be used to refer to a specific person who has already been referred to as him or her. So I'd say 'If someone feels ill, find them a chair' but I wouldn't reply to 'I'm taking my daughter shopping' with 'what are you going to buy for them?'.

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 31/08/2022 15:26

ThisisCollie2022 · 31/08/2022 15:13

I use it when I forget who OP is talking about and I don't want to lose what I've already typed up by going back to the OP.

I'll happily continue to use "they" :)

Another vote for this.

xogossipgirlxo · 31/08/2022 15:26

OMG, how come I didn't know it. There was a thread that mother can't sleep due to newborn making noises and she said "DC is 10 days old. They..." and I thought she had twins and was wondering why people in replies refer to twins as it's one child. Kill me 😂

chillipenguin · 31/08/2022 15:25

ThisisCollie2022 · 31/08/2022 15:13

I use it when I forget who OP is talking about and I don't want to lose what I've already typed up by going back to the OP.

I'll happily continue to use "they" :)

Same

Thatswhyimacat · 31/08/2022 15:21

I think it's a strange thing to get wound up about.

MrsTerryPratchett · 31/08/2022 15:18

I hate it when it's a vague attempt to anonimise. I mean really?

toastofthetown · 31/08/2022 15:14

The singular they has been around for longer than any of us.

I assume in a lot of those threads the OP is trying to obscure the gender either to be more anonymous or stop people forming assumptions and they slip up after a while. And for me, sometimes I respond with a ‘they’ because I can’t remember if it was a he/she and MN glitches when I try to scroll up and I don’t want to lose the response I’ve typed.

BeanieTeen · 31/08/2022 15:14

Not really. It’s just regular English so why would it be noticeable or something to wind you up? It’s generally used in the context that you don’t know someone or the person you’re talking to doesn’t know the person you’re talking about I think. Is English your second language? I guess the way I explained it makes it sound more confusing than it is, but the start of a sentence should give you the context of whether someone is referring to ‘he’ or ‘she’.

Changechangychange · 31/08/2022 15:13

Goldshelfie · 31/08/2022 15:02

The attempt to be more inclusive has the effect of reducing clarity of communication.

It sometimes matters if a person is male or female. Not always, but when it does matter then we must be able to make the distinction. The fashion for obscuring the facts will not age well.

If it matters, the speaker can use he or she. If it doesn’t matter, they can use he, she or they, as they see fit. We aren’t speaking German, it doesn’t matter.

Do you get equally exercised about singular “you” and plural “you”, and formal/informal pronouns? I hope you are using thou and you to differentiate between speakers older and younger than yourself, imagine if you had to work it out from the context!

ThisisCollie2022 · 31/08/2022 15:13

I use it when I forget who OP is talking about and I don't want to lose what I've already typed up by going back to the OP.

I'll happily continue to use "they" :)

amyneedssleep · 31/08/2022 15:10

10HailMarys · 31/08/2022 14:56

'They' has been used in English as a singular pronoun since around the 14th century, regardless of whether the person's gender is known or not. It is not a new development.

You simply notice it now because Mumsnetters are constantly in a tizzy about gender issues and think that any use of the word 'they' is some sort of eraser of biological sex, when in fact it's just a linguistic quirk of informal English that's been around and in daily use for about 700 years.

A perfect response!

Theimpossiblegirl · 31/08/2022 15:09

I agree that it has always been this way but people are more aware because of the current issues around chosen pronouns. I can't get worked up about this.