Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wish DD was more like me?

93 replies

Namechanged147 · 31/08/2022 12:35

NC because it sounds mean but AIBU to wish DD was more like me?

Backstory:
I was always quite intelligent growing up, loved reading, won scholarships, that sort of thing. I always dreamed of having a daughter with whom I could share my knowledge.
Fast forward 11 years and my DD is anything but what I was like. She says reading is "boring" so I can't share my favourite books with her. And whereas I used to receive glowing teacher reports her's all come back saying she talks too much in class but has potential.
I just wish she would put in more effort. Of course I still love DD but AIBU?

OP posts:
Baggyeye · 31/08/2022 16:48

I understand where you are coming from OP as I have an avid reader and one who finds reading a complete chore. Same gene pool, same environment, different personalities.

My concern is that my DC who doesn't read has not found any 'joy in learning'! (@BlueEggsAndBacon glad to hear that it came to you later in your studies.) I know everyone is saying to make the most of your child as they are (which I agree with) but when they find everything about school(and out of school pursuits) 'boring' it's not a particularly positive ongoing conversation.

Are there any English teachers on here? How do pupils get on who never read for pleasure? Any tips on how to support teens to write & converse well outside reading? Note emphasis is on support I am not forcing them to be a certain way but being articulate helps in life.

topcat2014 · 31/08/2022 16:27

I could cheerfully never read another book. I am literate etc but hate books.

In fact most of what passes for culture I hate.

I'm a chief finance officer so have played to my strengths over the years.

Dd15 is never working in an office ever..

Currently she wants to be a pilot.

In fact I love how different she is to me!

FourTeaFallOut · 31/08/2022 16:08

I have three kids, three FFS, and not one of them likes watching movies. I mean, watching movies - this isn't a niche interest here. Occasionally I can bribe one to come to the cinema with me under the guise of an abundance of junk food and I pretend they aren't just humouring me.

NewDiary · 31/08/2022 16:02

We also live in the countryside. Something I always wanted to do when I was her age and she's told me countless times she's escaping to the city one day!

Well, in this regard she seems quite like you, wanting what she hasn't got.

I'm a lawyer and tried to get her into debating but it was apparently 'boring too

Well, yes 😂 DH and I are both lawyers and we think teen DS would make a great lawyer. We're trying very, very hard not to say this to him, or hardly at all, as I can't think of anything less likely to make him want to do it (and in any event wouldn't want him to do it if it wasn't freely chosen).

I think maybe you're trying too hard to bring out the sides of your daughter that are more like you and she's finding it a massive turn off. Not many girls want to be just like their mums, certainly not past about 8. She may yet discover a love of reading or of academic achievement but part of the joy of that has to be the excitement of finding her own way. I'd back right off on the reading and debating etc etc, encourage her to do her best at school, celebrate who she is and the things she enjoys. That's both the right thing to do in itself and a way of giving her space to discover those aspects of herself which happen to be more like you.

WeAreAllLionesses · 31/08/2022 15:59

I had DD after 3 boys and couldn't wait to share spa days with her...she hates the idea and can't stand her feet being touched whereas to me it's an absolute treat and I always have a pedicure!

Really not what I had imagined 😂people are very different...

Hawkins001 · 31/08/2022 15:55

Sounds like you would make an excellent step mum, I love the countryside, and learning debating methods and technical aspects of law etc, (got influenced by the good wife, series)

All the best op, @Namechanged147

RitzyTitzy · 31/08/2022 15:43

Both my dds are like this and they come from 2 academic high achieving parents. Couldn't care less about reading. Hate school. Everything is boring. They like clothes and make up. I have never been interested in either. I'm actually intrigued by them and try and to see it as a chance for me to get a close up opportunity to see what it's like to be like them. I did always wonder growing up what the girls who were like them at school had going on in their heads and now I'm hearing exactly what's going on in their heads every minute of every day. Conversely my ds is very like me and I do have to really try to not make it obvious I'm more interested in debating something with him than I am discussing a mind numbing so called make up life hack with one of my girls Grin

Namechanged147 · 31/08/2022 15:39

Just realised it sounded like I was saying I never told my DD I loved her! I meant I never told her any of the things I mentioned in this thread 😂😂

OP posts:
Namechanged147 · 31/08/2022 15:38

Thanks for the opinions. Of course I love my DD and have never told her this. When I posted this I had just had a conversation with someone and we were reminiscing. I remember reading and talking about books and other shared hobbies with family and just felt a little sad that I couldn't have that with her. Maybe I can though, it's early days with the gymnastics but I will try and show more interest in that. Thanks mumsnet.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 31/08/2022 15:34

This is the sort of post I imagine my mother would have written about me when I was school age. She thought of her kids as an extension of her not people in their own right.

There is nothing wrong with me. We are just different. Unfortunately she never tried to hide her abject disappointment. My younger sister was exactly what she wanted. It seemed like I was considered the first defective effort before she "got it right".

Love the child you've got, not the one you think you wanted!

My kids aren't much like me either and I adore them.

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 31/08/2022 15:31

YABU.

Wakinguptooearly · 31/08/2022 15:29

I don't think you are being unreasonable to feel this way. We feel how we feel. I also think it can be quite bewildering and sad when your child dismisses the things we love.
It would however be unreasonable to allow her to know you feel this way.
Find the things you do have in common and use those as a basis to build a strong relationship.

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 31/08/2022 15:27

Daughters often go on the opposite direction to their mums, you might get your wish with grand children? In the meantime appreciate her for who she is her self assurance relies on you so much.

mycatisannoying · 31/08/2022 15:24

YABU.

Sparklesocks · 31/08/2022 15:22

As others have said, our kids are not an extension of us - they are their own people with their own personalities. Your DD sounds like she is happy and comfortable in who she is and what she enjoys. You can be different from her but still appreciate her as an individual. I’m sure there’s more common ground than you think, but it’s about seeking that out rather than moulding her into who you’d like her to be.

Blindsblindsblinds · 31/08/2022 15:17

Bet your daughters pretty disappointed she’s got you as a mother

SheeWeee · 31/08/2022 15:17

Do you really think kids are going to be interested in debating as an actual thing?

Considering the array of debating trophies adorning a shelf right behind me with two of my DC's name on, I would have to say, why would they not be?

wafflesandeggs · 31/08/2022 15:16

Forgot to add, you can also take your daughter along with you to a selection of different classes or hobbies to see if you can find something you both like. What do you like about living in the country? Can you do something related to that?

wafflesandeggs · 31/08/2022 15:14

Why does she need new clothes every 2 weeks?!

I never had much in common with my family growing up because they never made an effort to learn about anything I cared about. If I mentioned an instrument/language/skill, they told me it was a waste of time or money and that was it. Now years later I am learning these things myself.

My parents were also very naive about different career paths. Someone up thread mentioned their son only liking video games and manga. Someone has to create, translate, review, promote, etc these things. If your child has a genuine interest in something then instead of trying to push them away from it, help them going into it deeper and think about how they could incorporate this into their working life, even if only as a side income (multiple possible income streams are a very good thing to set your child up with).

Regarding living in the country, your child might not be away themselves of how important working hard is and what money can get you (or leave you without) or the vast range of possible careers open to them.

dottiedodah · 31/08/2022 15:09

My DD is very different to me too.Not caring for reading(Is that because of phones/computers though,) Not liking Horror films myself she adores them! More scary the better!(Hubby likes them too) She loves White Knuckle rides) We both share a love of Animals though, and love shopping/lunch out.Maybe find some middle ground.Everyone is so different and unique which is to be celebrated .

goldfinchfan · 31/08/2022 14:43

I am similar to you OP.
Now my DD is in her 40's the differences between us are even wider.

She is a fairly cold detahed person. I am over emotional and like to connect with other people.
I enjoy lots of different activities, she doesn't.

I really thought that being my child and brought up by me we would be close. We are not.
I do love her but the way she is often hurts me.

I don't even have any advice. She is her. I am me.

Sunnytwobridges · 31/08/2022 14:41

I totally get this. I'm a big reader and so was everyone in my family. Some of my fondest memories are of me and my fam sitting around reading together. And me and my DM would discuss the books together. My DD on the other hand is not interested in reading at all. She prefers to be active and doing stuff and I'm not like that at all. It makes me sad that we dont share the love of reading, but I've finally made peace with it (well for the most part lol).

GoneWithTheWine1 · 31/08/2022 14:37

This is very sad.

I have a family member whose turned her DD into a mini her... and you know what? She's the most spoilt little brat I've ever met.

Encourage your daughter to do what SHE likes. You don't have kids to make them into a miniature you. Sorry to say.

Ivyy · 31/08/2022 14:34

I find this very sad op, I have a dd the same age and I don't understand wanting a mini me child? Why? Is it a kind of perfect family dream? I think I also feel sad for your dd because I grew up with a dm with very high expectations of me that would fit with her ideals, and she did everything she could to mould me into the daughter she wanted. She still can't accept me the way I am in my 40's, or her grandchildren. It's one of the reasons we have a very poor relationship, to this day I'm still not good enough and sadly she has continued this with her gc!
Not saying you're like that at all op, your words just triggered some sad feelings in me. I love seeing my dd grow into herself as her own unique person, our kids are individuals in their own rights who should have autonomy and encouragement in the things they enjoy doing imo.

OverTheRubicon · 31/08/2022 14:34

Like another pp, one of my DCs is a lot like a parent (their dad, in our case), and I think that has a lot of challenges too, with the child bending themselves to fit a mould, and so many people in the family just assuming that their good and bad traits are exactly the same, instead of taking them as their own person.
On the other hand, he and I are very dissimilar and it can be hard sometimes, to try to find the fairly few shared interests as they get older.

It's great that you've given her the support she needs to be confident being herself. And you may be surprised by what you do have in common in the end.

What do you have for now? Maybe you could both enjoy the theatre or musicals - more active than a book, but also very literary. Similarly with debating, if you're a lawyer and she's a chatter then you could be a match made in heaven. If it's social media, I bet she'd love to show you some 'hilarious' tiktoks/youtubes (only if you can try to put any judgement aside, which can be hard with early teens, but is also the best way to learn what she's looking at). Or if she'd actually rather play cricket, then you can bring your book to a match and be the mum who always made it to her games and took the time to learn about spin bowling. She may be older, but your attention still matters a lot.