Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Beowulfa · 31/08/2022 14:18

I'm really losing patience with the earnest "but sex is actually really complex and difficult to define" line.

Throughout history half the population have been denied the right to own property, to vote, to be educated. So how did the men in power know who to oppress?

Funny how it's crystal clear who a woman is when a man doesn't want her to have something, but it suddenly becomes all blurry and vague when it suits a man to call himself a woman.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 14:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/08/2022 14:07

I am not scientifically illiterate. This is information from my biological sciences degree

Do you think a human can change sex?

because they have successfully convinced the large majority of women that a tiny sub-set of trans women threaten their rights and identity

Do you think that Stonewall and other trans groups actively lobbying for the removal of all female legal protections and right to single sex anything isn't a threat?
You can't let 'some' men in. It's all or nothing. And when 'trans' is no longer allowed to be defined with any remotely logical or meaningful criteria, how do we separate the types of men when we must take them solely by their word? Which it seems holds much more weight than any woman's. Funny that eh?

Do you not think that an ideology that convinces children that their bodies are wrong and must be surgically altered because they don't follow the societal stereotypes enforced on their sex is incredibly damaging?

Males telling women what a woman is.
Males telling us we can no longer define ourselves by our biology as a separate and distinct sex class with our own needs.
Males claiming their feelings or presentation somehow make them the same as us.
Males enforcing sexist female sex role stereotypes because without them, 'gender' is meaningless.

They are the patriarchy.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 14:04

Penguintears · 31/08/2022 13:57

This is such a good point. Its also like saying you were born with the wrong colour skin.

To be fair there are people who somehow believe they are the wrong colour. There have been a few of cases of " trans race" someone trying to look korean. Someone who went as far as injecting is it melanin? Or something to make their skin darker. Rachel.dolzeal is a famous case of a white woman claiming to be black.

Then we have had trans age. And now we have people trying to look like cats and aliens.

Most if its seem for what it is. Delusional. Offensive. A mental illness etc

Bit for some reason with " gender " we are meant to believe with out question

Penguintears · 31/08/2022 13:57

SILdidittoo · 31/08/2022 11:26

@Sunnyqueen

What do you mean "born in the wrong body"? Does this just apply to trans people or does it include physically disabled people as well?

This is such a good point. Its also like saying you were born with the wrong colour skin.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 13:54

This is a grim thought.

How is it not entirely true though?

There isn't another body for you to teleport into. You aren't a free floating mind or soul that can exist without one.

Your body is everything there is.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 13:47

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Riapia · 31/08/2022 13:45

You don’t have a body you are a body.

AmyandPhilipfan · 31/08/2022 13:44

With regards to the OP I think it's disturbing that the child's mother has allowed her ten year old child to get into runway modelling when I wouldn't have thought that's an environment that's suitable for children. And slathered in makeup. If the child had been born female surely there would be complaints about sexualising a young girl? But because this child was born a boy that's apparently ok for him to be presented in this way?

My own daughter spent a full year saying she was a boy between 2 and 3. Consistently claiming to be male. If she had been born into a different family she could be living a very different life now. But as she was born to me I just always told her she was a girl (she had two big brothers so was obviously not yet quite sure what made someone a boy or girl) and eventually she matured enough to understand she js a girl and at 5 would never now claim to be a boy instead.

Musti · 31/08/2022 13:39

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:58

And then once you’ve started and you have your people, it must be hard to change.

Quite. Which is very well expressed by this piece, already posted

pitt.substack.com/p/true-believer

This is a chilling read. I know 4 people whose daughters identify as boys. They have changed their names and wear boys clothes. And one whose son identifies as a girl - both the mother and child are autistic.

My eldest had a female friend at primary who always wore neutral clothes and had short hair. She always hung out with the boys and was interested in boys stuff. She also had mostly male friends. This was before the current trend so that’s all it was. She was allowed to do what she enjoyed and dress how she wanted without any pressure or labels.

Teens go through periods of being goths or dressing up as anime characters or whatever. And they are part of a group. People like being part of groups and want to be accepted. Some carry on for life and many don’t. They grow out of it as other things interests them.

Ive gone from being very pro trans to being horrified by it. As in, I have absolutely no issues with people identifying as they want and want them to have rights and ability to do so, but really worried at the amount of kids whose lives will be irreversibly adversely affected by this. And can imagine that there will be a lot of suicides. Sacrificing your ability to reproduce and to gain sexual pleasure should not be allowed until they are very much an adult. I mean they don’t even give sterilisation to women of childbearing age who’ve had children if they are still young, in case they regret it. Why the f are kids being allowed to have this done to them??

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 13:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

najene · 31/08/2022 13:36

Eeksteek: " ... by all means be sceptical about trans people. But don’t claim it’s a scientifically sound position on gender, because it’s not."

I'm not sure how your post is a comment on mine; I didn't mention any scientific positions.

There may or may not be good scientific grounds for assimilating or differentiating 'gender' and 'sex'. Be that as it may.

I asked for an explanation of what 'born in the wrong body' might mean. Do you want to try?

It does seem that sorting out what on earth it is we're talking about is prerequisite for any sort of discussion about the scientific merits of what we're saying. I think talk of 'born in the wrong body' makes no sense, and that giving it a sense is prerequisite for discussing its scientific status. So, Eeksteek, what on earth are you talking about?

CrossStichQueen · 31/08/2022 13:34

What exactly are you afraid of?

Is that to the OP or everyone ami?

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 31/08/2022 13:32

What exactly are you afraid of?

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 13:31

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 13:26

I am not scientifically illiterate. This is information from my biological sciences degree. It doesn’t invalidate the anti-trans/pro women/whatever argument. I don’t care about trans stuff. I think its a very small issue. But the scientific evidence is NOT that there are two completely discrete and mutually exclusive sexes, where every single person falls into one category or the other. There are proven, HUMAN outliers that fall between categories. It may come to light that trans people are more subtle and complex presentations of this. Or it may not. I don’t care. Be anti or pro trans as you wish. Just don’t claim it’s a scientific position.

Clarity in arguments doesn’t mean you can discount evidence or facts that don’t suit you.

For every complex issue, there is answer that easy, and simple, and wrong.

Then surely a brain scan or blood test would show any issue?

Funnily enough there are no medical tests that have been carried out that prove anything. If there were genetic or chromosomal anomalies that explained trans status then these tests would be done. But they arent because what you have is people of one sex claiming to be another sex with only their word required.

In fact one trans person took a brain scan as part of a documentary. It did not prove a thing.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 13:31

But the scientific evidence is NOT that there are two completely discrete and mutually exclusive sexes, where every single person falls into one category or the other. There are proven, HUMAN outliers that fall between categories.

They have disorders of sexual development which impacts presentation of sexual characteristics.

They are still, at a chromosomal level one sex or another.

True human hermaphroditism doesn't exist. Neither does some third sex or fluctuating between sex.

Even if it did, it doesn't mean anyone can change sex. That's not scientifically possible.

So let's not obfuscate from the point. Sex in mammals is binary and immutable.

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 13:26

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:51

So, we need a real mix of characteristics to define sex.

Look, this is nonsense. At a chromosomal level we are all one sex or another. There is no 'third' option or fluidity. There are DSDs, but they affect the presentation of sex characteristics, they are not indicative of sex being anything other than binary and immutable.

The kind of scientific illiteracy you are spouting isn't helping this debate. We need clarity in arguments, not obfuscation.

That's not to say that people should be able to present as they choose in terms of gender stereotypes, but quite how that applies to two year olds is anyone's guess.

I am not scientifically illiterate. This is information from my biological sciences degree. It doesn’t invalidate the anti-trans/pro women/whatever argument. I don’t care about trans stuff. I think its a very small issue. But the scientific evidence is NOT that there are two completely discrete and mutually exclusive sexes, where every single person falls into one category or the other. There are proven, HUMAN outliers that fall between categories. It may come to light that trans people are more subtle and complex presentations of this. Or it may not. I don’t care. Be anti or pro trans as you wish. Just don’t claim it’s a scientific position.

Clarity in arguments doesn’t mean you can discount evidence or facts that don’t suit you.

For every complex issue, there is answer that easy, and simple, and wrong.

UnimpeachableBravery · 31/08/2022 13:25

I'm still working through thoughts on this but I was very dysphoric for a very long time and the thing that changed that was giving birth to a female child.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 13:24

najene · 31/08/2022 13:17

I'm not really trying to argue with you. But you say "born in a woman's body but should have been born in a man's" as though it means something ("quite simply"), when I can't make head nor tail of it.

If I was born in a woman's body, then anyone born in a man's body is someone else and not me. So what I am I to make of "I should have been born in a man's body"?

... This seems to be the same as saying, "I should not have been me." But, really, if this is so, what am I to make of it? "I am me" is something that cannot be false: "I am not me" looks like a mistake (a grammatical mistake, in all likelihood, given the connection between "I" and "me" in grammar), so likewise "I should not have been me" just makes no sense at all.

Do you see?

Isn't it weird how its always the brain

If nature screws up this way why do we never see men with female left arms.or women with a man's ears. Its always the brain.

najene · 31/08/2022 13:17

Sunnyqueen · 31/08/2022 12:21

As in people who think that because they were born in a female body but should have been born in a man's quite simply or vice versa.
I used that line because it seems to be the go to line trans people use to say how they feel about their dysphoria. My point was I agree that there will be a tiny minority who genuinely do feel that way from birth but not the masses we have now. The ones who do say it no I don't know how they would answer the disability argument and I don't really care either way if they have an argument or not does not affect me in the slightest.

No point trying to argue with me about it I'm very happy in my body always have been, always will be as a straight female.

I'm not really trying to argue with you. But you say "born in a woman's body but should have been born in a man's" as though it means something ("quite simply"), when I can't make head nor tail of it.

If I was born in a woman's body, then anyone born in a man's body is someone else and not me. So what I am I to make of "I should have been born in a man's body"?

... This seems to be the same as saying, "I should not have been me." But, really, if this is so, what am I to make of it? "I am me" is something that cannot be false: "I am not me" looks like a mistake (a grammatical mistake, in all likelihood, given the connection between "I" and "me" in grammar), so likewise "I should not have been me" just makes no sense at all.

Do you see?

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 13:11

I don’t really care how people define themselves. I really don’t care who uses what bog. Just don’t piss on the seat. There are massively bigger issues in society. Should we be ensuring children’s health is protected and teens have good mental health support? Hell yes. Should we be protecting women’s spaces and (especially) sporting events? Yep, for sure. Are there likely to be other issues. Yep. Can we solve is without all this hyperbole and hysteria around ‘knowing what a woman is?’ Of course, if people calm down and stop being so childish about it. Are this issues more important for women than stopping the world being run by and for old, rich white men? Nope.

I disagree with so much of this. I do care what bog someone uses when it means I could be alone in an isolated space with someone who has nefarious intentions. You say that women’s spaces should be protected - well, a loo is one of those.

I don’t agree that there are bigger issues - this is one of the biggest issues facing women and children. It affects safety, health, and even basic identity.

I don’t agree that there is “hyperbole and hysteria”, or that people should “calm down and stop being childish”; that’s just a way of shutting down an opinion you don’t like. It’s up there with “Both sides are as bad as each other” Hmm

I don’t agree that “knowing what a woman is” isn’t a big deal. If no-one knows what a woman is, how can same sex attracted women be protected? How do we identify sex discrimination when we can’t identify sex? Why should the identity of “woman” be up for debate when those who would want to include themselves in an extended definition could just choose another definition?

And I do think that this is as big, if not bigger an issue than the idea of “the world being run by rich white men”. I - and many like me - can care about both.

Iliveonahill · 31/08/2022 13:10

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:45

*Seriously this whole trend has gone too far but as the movement is so powerful no one will, or can, argue against them

I honestly cannot fathom how we got to this stage. Can anyone shed any light?

Because stonewall were given grants by govt and then they have managed to infiltrate every public sector org, police, judiciary, etc etc. We were all advised to delete “sex” and use gender instead. Women for years have been abused if they questioned this. Drag events at schools are the norm now. Lesbians being erased. The word woman erased from cervical cancer posters, women’s sport, kids being told there are 100 genders, etc etc. It’s been slowly happening and we all ignored it because we were told to be kind and inclusive.

Being born in the wrong body - how do you even know what the right body feels like?
Strict gender stereotyping has caused this. Pink for girls, blue for boys. Just go into any toy shop and you can see it. Try buying a non pink dress for a baby?

We have all walked into this nightmare together.

Tell the poor Indian girls who sit in period huts that they were born in the wrong body.

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 13:08

If nothing else, the rigid enforcement of gender stereotypes is so unbelievably regressive, I barely know where to start.

Absolutely 100% agree with this.

I've always said this in identity discussions.

What exactly is identifying as a woman or man?

Is it clothing? Music tastes? Entertainment tastes? Friendship groups?

Is it biology? Do I identify as a woman because I have XX chromosomes? Or because I have breasts? I have no cervix or womb.

Because I wouldn't say I identify as anything - except I identify as me! However I AM a woman because I was born with woman sex chromosomes.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 13:05

And can you imagine how confusing it is for these kids? So much attention and pressure! I see a lot on tik tok - glamourising lgbt, almost making Hetero seem boring and uncool. I can imagine how a young kid getting really influenced by it. And then once you’ve started and you have your people, it must be hard to change

In any other circumstances this would be recognised as < insert banned word here. Horses and brushes > and love bombing.

The willfully blindness here is disturbing

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:58

And then once you’ve started and you have your people, it must be hard to change.

Quite. Which is very well expressed by this piece, already posted

pitt.substack.com/p/true-believer

Swipe left for the next trending thread