Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ideasmirrour · 31/08/2022 15:14

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 12:45

So, I dont know a lot about trans stuff. But I do know about ‘biological sex’. What defines biological sex? Really think about this as a scientific exercise. What?

Chromosomes? Are we chromosome testing these kids? I don’t think we are, but even if we were there are well documented, decades old cases of chromosomes not correlating with physical presentation of sex. WTAF? Really? Yes really. Because genes are just blueprints. On their own, they don’t do anything. They need to be switched on. And some people’s don’t. We don’t know why.

Man. OK, lets look at internal sex organs. They’re pretty important. Ovaries and whatnot. Except they control sex by producing hormones. And some people don’t produce high enough levels of hormones for their chromosomal sex and their appearance to correlate. Hermaphratidism in people happens. Some people have a mix of sexual organs. Some people are born girls, because they don’t have penis’ and that’s as far as anyone looks and then hormones levels surge at puberty and they display male characteristics.

OK then, hormone levels. But they vary widely between people. They are controlled by things that are not sex-dependent. PCOS is super common (like 10% of women, I think?) I have PCOS and the only hormone that’s out of normal range is my testosterone. It’s high. But I’m definitely still female. It affects things like facial hair and weight and stuff, sure, but I still look female, despite an elevated male hormone and some definitely masculine features. Plenty of other hormones can be affected by all kinds of things. They must be, otherwise we couldn’t alter them with medications. Some times, the levels are normal, but some people are more sensitive than others, so even an objective hormone range isn’t definitive.

Bugger. External sex organs? Y’all know blokes with boobs, right? And anyway, they don’t always correspond with chromosomes, which is the ultimate biological sex, even though it isn’t always accurate. So we’ve come full circle.

So, we need a real mix of characteristics to define sex. It’s much more nebulous scientifically than people seem to think. And while wild discrepancies are well documented in the medical literature, as it’s so complex its hardly surprising there are more mild cases of gender fluidity. Because gender is different from sex anyway. It’s not physical, is a societal construct. It’s how we treat people based on their appearance, which is never a good thing, is it?

I don’t really care how people define themselves. I really don’t care who uses what bog. Just don’t piss on the seat. There are massively bigger issues in society. Should we be ensuring children’s health is protected and teens have good mental health support? Hell yes. Should we be protecting women’s spaces and (especially) sporting events? Yep, for sure. Are there likely to be other issues. Yep. Can we solve is without all this hyperbole and hysteria around ‘knowing what a woman is?’ Of course, if people calm down and stop being so childish about it. Are this issues more important for women than stopping the world being run by and for old, rich white men? Nope. Are they part of it? Yep.

So by all means be sceptical about trans people. But don’t claim it’s a scientifically sound position on gender, because it’s not. And don’t claim that it’s feminist position either. It’s a patriarchal strategy to divide and rule, as always. We are going to end up with a patriarchal Tory government (again) because they have successfully convinced the large majority of women that a tiny sub-set of trans women threaten their rights and identity. When the actual problem is, as it always has been, the patriarchy.

Oh yeah. Except — trans women also are “the patriarchy”.

And your patronising “science” on biological sex is also very schematic and simplified.

Maybe you could quit the lecturing tone telling other women what they should think and what should be important to them and to feminism?

Tuilpmouse · 31/08/2022 15:11

This quote from the article stood out to me:

"She would refuse to wear boy clothes and have tantrums because she was so young, she knew what she wanted but didn’t have the words to say it."

It seems that because "she" wasn't happy at a young age with wearing clothes that society and fashion arbitrarily identified as being for boys, "she" couldn't be a boy who happened not to like boy's clothes, "she" had to be girl because "she" didn't wanted to wear girls' clothes!

This mentality is so fucked up, and so backward, it's crazy. All these supposedly modern liberal types can't seem to cope with gender non-conformity... No! Liking lipstick, frilly dresses, baking cakes etc. seems to be what defines you as a girl, not your sexual organs and chromosomes!

ASDstruggles · 31/08/2022 15:10

As the mother of a pre teen daughter with ASD the idea that my daughter is prone to trans ideology being pushed onto her is fucking terrifying. The thought of the likes of mermaids getting their hands on her confused, prepubescent brain and pumping it full of their ideas keeps me awake at night.

when she reaches 25 and her brain is fully matured she can make whatever decisions she wants and I will love her just the same, but the thought of my tomboy being persuaded to make permanent, life changing decisions that she later regrets and I have to go along with otherwise I’m an abusive TERF scares the shit out of me.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 15:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 15:07

I will not respond to any more nonsense

MbatataOwl · 31/08/2022 15:05

Woman = adult human female.
Female = of the sex that bears children. (That doesn't mean every female gives birth, but only females give birth).

It's really, really simple.

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 15:05

Anyway OP yes I think it is worrying

It's lying to the child - a female who doesn't get their period should be worried, a male who thinks he gets a period should be in hospital

It reinforces stereotypes and the idea that a female brain is less than a man's in some fields

It leads to unnecessary surgery and all it's risks

And as you say the association with things like autism or abuse should not be ignored

christmascook · 31/08/2022 15:04

Emmelina · 31/08/2022 10:16

I think there are some parents out there who see their child do something that is stereotypically not associated with their gender and go “oh well they must be X inside!”
show me a 3,4 year old who doesn’t like glitter and bright colours!
I was a bit of a tomboy growing up - hated dresses because it stopped me from climbing trees without showing my knickers, which of course wasn’t ladylike according to my mum! I preferred my hair short as I didn’t like the feel of my hair being pulled back tightly. I was rarely a ‘clean’ little girl.
If I was a child today I’m sure someone would plant the “maybe you’re really a boy?” seed!

I agree, I was very much a football mad tomboy and hated anything girly. I often say that if I was a child today I'd be made to feel I was in the wrong body.

It doesn't sit well with me that a child wants to make such big decisions, I know how fickle mine are. When I was young it was accepted that I was a tomboy. I think in todays world with everything we need available to us immediately that the next generations think if they feel/want/need something then it must happen straight away instead of considering options and waiting.

I'm not necessarily comparing having a sex change to getting a same day Amazon order but I think the days of waiting and being sure in your decision making have long gone.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 15:03

A hysterectomy is an exclusively female experience.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 15:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 15:01

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 14:59

Don't you dare suggest there is a lady brain and expect me to have any respect for any argument you can give

I am beyond pissed at people who think there is a lady brain and with that are totally happy to discount any female who can do things that don't fit the lady brain stereotypes and use that as an excuse to pay women less, ignore them, abuse them as less good then men

Female is about reproductive biology and fuck all else

I'm loving your posts!

And the worse thing about calling it lady brain is they then excuse me from simple fucking tasks blaming it on male brain.

Men can do things - society hasn't expected them too because they think they are the superior sex.

It's all bollocks

Ofcourseshecan · 31/08/2022 15:01

So if a woman is what we all came out of, someone who hasn't had anyone coming out of them is... not a woman? Don't think that one quite works, does it?

Of course it doesn't work, and no one has suggested it does except you.

Every labradoodle is a dog. Not every dog is a labradoodle. Just as everyone who gives birth is a woman or girl, but not every woman or girl gives birth. As you know.

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 14:59

Don't you dare suggest there is a lady brain and expect me to have any respect for any argument you can give

I am beyond pissed at people who think there is a lady brain and with that are totally happy to discount any female who can do things that don't fit the lady brain stereotypes and use that as an excuse to pay women less, ignore them, abuse them as less good then men

Female is about reproductive biology and fuck all else

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 14:59

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 14:49

It doesn't matter about corner cases in any definition - women is that adult human female which is basically anyone with xx or xxx chromosomes

Sone people have chromosome defects - these are rare , and utterly irrelevant to being transgender

Humans have 2 legs. So some are born without 2 legs - it means there is something wrong with them not that there is ambiguity about how many legs a human has

If the definition wasn't clear then people with DSD would not have any disorders would they ?

Good post and excellently presented points

TinaTeaspoons · 31/08/2022 14:59

You're not wrong OP. It is very worrying indeed. Weird times we are living in right now. Especially as you get cancelled for expressing your concerns about it all.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 14:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 14:57

They didn't need to it's been patently fucking obvious for centuries and still is

Totally!

I doubt once in history they've observed a child born with a penis and said "well check their chromosomes just to see if they can vote or not".

That's why I get so frustrated at "assigned sex at birth"

You aren't assigned sex. You are born with a penis or vagina.

The few cases where neither were formed clearly do have medical intervention and sex is assigned.

But it's not 50% of the population like stonewall would try and make us believe.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 14:56

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Ofcourseshecan · 31/08/2022 14:55

x2boys · 31/08/2022 10:13

There was certainly a lot of male musicians in the 70,s and 80,s that had long hair and wore makeup some of that was glam rock and Boy George and Marilyn later came out as Gay ,but it was never insinuated they were anything other than male

Exactly. Girls could wear workboots, boys could wear eyeliner, no one gave a damn. My favourite toy as a child was a toolkit, one of my little-boy friends loved dolls. No one grew up thinking they were in the wrong body.

So when did the genderists dig out the old sex-stereotype straitjacket and force children into it? And why are they being allowed to do it?

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 14:53

Adult human female

Female - of the type expected to be able to give birth at sone point in their lives

Not had given

Not has the capability

But expected to have the capability

To the extent that if they can't make a baby doctors will investigate

Whereas a man who can't get pregnant - well that doesn't need investigation does it?

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 14:52

Adult human female.

Not every woman and girl has a baby. But only women and girls have babies.

VestofAbsurdity · 31/08/2022 14:51

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

You had zero problem defining one in an experience you had which you told on another thread though, didn't you?

Topgub · 31/08/2022 14:51

Humans have 2 legs. So some are born without 2 legs - it means there is something wrong with them not that there is ambiguity about how many legs a human has

This.

The existence of humans without 2 legs doesn't mean humans can be spiders

OldCrone · 31/08/2022 14:51

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Saying that all people who have given birth are women is not the same as saying only people who have given birth are women.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 14:51

I think both of them are grim thoughts.

The first one is the kind of simple fact we'd all do well to remember