Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SpinCityBlues · 31/08/2022 17:15

Will there be Bunbury cakes?

TheElementsSong · 31/08/2022 17:14

I'm invoking Bunbury.

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 17:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 17:11

Trying if you are a gay man surely you do know what a woman is? And a man is?

Because if you don't how do you know you are homosexual and sexually attracted to men and not woman?

You've literally answered you're own inflammatory question!

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:09

Eeksteek

I am sorry this is long, but I wanted to reply to your long post since you put so much effort into it.

Chromosomes? Are we chromosome testing these kids?

Hermaphratidism in people happens.

Please do not bring people’s differenced in sex development into this as a counterpoint. Maybe you got it from your biology degree, but it was a weak argument there for destabilising known science about sex in humans.

In fact, the overwhelming majority of those with differences in sex development are in fact categorised into male and female due to their specific medical condition. Something you would know from your degree.

Please take notice of those across the internet with these medical conditions, and stop using them for your own political purpose. Whatever that is.

Hermaphratidism in people happens. Some people have a mix of sexual organs.

No one is born with both ovaries and testes that both work. That is point. And very miniscule numbers of people with differences of sex development are born with both. About 500 people have had ovotesticular disorder from a study I have read. And about two thirds of those have a combined tissue of ovotestes. I am sure you must know this if you studied it in your degree.

But, I am very happy to see other facts about this. I would love to see the information that convinced you.

hormone levels.

Yes. PCOS is a female medical condition and it produces an increased amount of testosterone. The increase barely touches, if at all, the male range. It is normal within the female range. I have attached a chart below, apologies that it is unclear. I believe the person who produced it has been suspended from twitter for stating biological sex exists. It comes from some of the information contained in this paper though.

academic.oup.com/edrv/article/39/5/803/5052770

Dr Handelman is an Endocrinologist and his particular speciality is testosterone and its impact on human bodies.

Again, I don’t feel that PCOS is not a strong enough reason to say that males can be female etc. It does not weaken what defines a female or a male in terms of reproduction, which is the purpose of sex categories.

And again, adding artificial sex organs or removing sex organs is just that. Adding artificial sex organs to any person is a male or female with artificial sex organs. And same with the removal. Of course, it does not change the genetic make up of the body.

Plenty of other hormones can be affected by all kinds of things. They must be, otherwise we couldn’t alter them with medications. Some times, the levels are normal, but some people are more sensitive than others, so even an objective hormone range isn’t definitive.

If a male artificially changes their hormone levels, they are simply males with artificially changed hormone levels. They are not female. If a male retains their testes, and stops suppressing their testosterone, their cells will revert to producing testosterone. If they remove their testes, they will still not be female… just males without testes who need supplemental hormones.

Again, it does not weaken proven science on the reproductive needs of the human race.

External sex organs? Y’all know blokes with boobs, right? And anyway, they don’t always correspond with chromosomes, which is the ultimate biological sex, even though it isn’t always accurate. So we’ve come full circle.

Of course, males have breasts. Breasts on females are there to feed infants and have a different tissue arrangement to do this. Males do not have all these components within the breast. Yes, they may secrete a substance, but it is not designed to feed nutrition to a child at a specific age, under specific conditions. It is not comparable as a nutrition source to infants.

So… yes, they have breasts, but that doesn’t influence whether they can change sex. Males have moobs too. Still not a female breast.

So, we need a real mix of characteristics to define sex. It’s much more nebulous scientifically than people seem to think. And while wild discrepancies are well documented in the medical literature, as it’s so complex its hardly surprising there are more mild cases of gender fluidity. Because gender is different from sex anyway. It’s not physical, is a societal construct. It’s how we treat people based on their appearance, which is never a good thing, is it?

Sex is binary. You require a sperm and an egg to create a new life. There is no third sex and never has been.

I am happy if you have other information though, please do share it.
A female human has a body formed around the production of eggs, the large gamete that is needed to reproduce, whether that body has ever, will ever, or is producing those large gametes. The stage of production is irrelevant for the categorisation of those females being categorised as females. It matters very much on a personal level for that individual, but not for the sex categorisation.
Female bodies come with a very wide range of differences. But they are ALL formed around that specific function.

No male can change sex. Ever. There are no third sexes. There are no humans producing a third gamete, and nor are they self-fertilising.
And with that female body, comes negative sexist discrimination, bodily control and abuse. Because of the female body.

Should we be ensuring children’s health is protected and teens have good mental health support? Hell yes. Should we be protecting women’s spaces and (especially) sporting events? Yep, for sure. Are there likely to be other issues. Yep. Can we solve is without all this hyperbole and hysteria around ‘knowing what a woman is?’ Of course, if people calm down and stop being so childish about it.

If you cannot have a stable definition of what is a female in law, you cannot protect females.

We have seen this already through many instances where the word ‘woman’ has been used to allow males access into female single sex spaces, sports, roles set aside for females for a variety of needs and the list goes on. This is not a drill. This has already happened in the UK in some areas of policy. You can call it hyperbole and hysteria, however, some of us will work towards reversing these changes that are already beginning to cause harm where sex actually does matter.

The harm has already been done to our children, it is too late for some, but not for others. The changes are now underway because of that very ‘hyperbole and hysteria’ you are denouncing.

If you are untouched by these changes, then in my opinion, you are in a privileged position in this instance. Others have been harmed, I am about working to strengthen their protections and get their needs met.

So by all means be sceptical about trans people. But don’t claim it’s a scientifically sound position on gender, because it’s not.

I don’t believe anyone who has followed this closely makes that position. Sex is scientifically proven to be either male and female and this has not changed for millennia or more. Gender is completely different.

And don’t claim that it’s feminist position either.

Sorry, what is this feminist position you are referring to please?

It’s a patriarchal strategy to divide and rule, as always. We are going to end up with a patriarchal Tory government (again) because they have successfully convinced the large majority of women that a tiny sub-set of trans women threaten their rights and identity. When the actual problem is, as it always has been, the patriarchy.

Sure. The Patriarchy. … who are they again? Which people are the patriarchy please?

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids
Trying20 · 31/08/2022 17:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 17:09

I was slightly sympathetic to our new friend on the thread the other day, but the mask is beginning to slip here, so no more.

Its not even relevant to the main subject of this thread, which isn't about the ideology at all, more about the appropriateness of transing toddlers.

SpinCityBlues · 31/08/2022 17:05

Luckily some people - even academics - still know what chromosomes are.

AryaStarkWolf · 31/08/2022 17:03

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 17:00

So it's getting more refined now; I'm getting a clearer picture.

So, a person who can't have a baby, in a country with limited medical provision meaning there is no investigation, is not a woman?

No. Try reading posts. If a female person wants to have a baby but can't investigations will be done. Those investigations will look at her female reproductive system and ability to produce ova. They won't be testing sperm, because that would mean the person was male.

I don't even know why you're entertaining this guy, he knows perfectly well what a woman is. The fact that we're all even entertaining this as a serious question and tying ourselves in knots trying to explain it to a guy pretending he's confused is a win for them I'd imagine.

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 17:02

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 17:00

So it's getting more refined now; I'm getting a clearer picture.

So, a person who can't have a baby, in a country with limited medical provision meaning there is no investigation, is not a woman?

No. Try reading posts. If a female person wants to have a baby but can't investigations will be done. Those investigations will look at her female reproductive system and ability to produce ova. They won't be testing sperm, because that would mean the person was male.

He is winding the little women up. He knows what one is.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 17:00

So it's getting more refined now; I'm getting a clearer picture.

So, a person who can't have a baby, in a country with limited medical provision meaning there is no investigation, is not a woman?

No. Try reading posts. If a female person wants to have a baby but can't investigations will be done. Those investigations will look at her female reproductive system and ability to produce ova. They won't be testing sperm, because that would mean the person was male.

stode · 31/08/2022 16:55

How on earth did humans manage to reproduce for millennia when they had no idea what male and female was Grin

You can philosophise anything into and out of existence - that's the power of rhetoric. But it doesn't change actual reality.

Keyansier · 31/08/2022 16:54

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 16:48

Gay men know what women are. Otherwise how would they know they are gay in the first place?

Anyway back to the topic at hand. How on earth do you get this ideology scrubbed from your kids' schools, is the question everyone should be asking.

Sadly, by not voting anything other than Conservative.

And before anyone comes in with the "but this is happening under a Conservative government" line, I am aware of that. I am also aware that they are the only mainstream party (including Lib Dems and Greens - not sure about UKIP) who have been vocal about challenging this ideology. The others, if they got into power, would crank the dial to ten before you could blink.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 16:53

If I chopped off the bottom half of my body (and somehow survived) so I suddenly lose half my mind? Half my personality? Memories? Intelligence? Obviously not.

When it happens, let us know.

RayneDance · 31/08/2022 16:52

It's insidious and as another poster on.a different thread said...their liberal self never picked up on what's going on behind it.

Same here...and yet I am horrified by what's going on ,stone wall....what's being pushed.

We need to wake up!!
School need to wake up!!

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 16:48

Gay men know what women are. Otherwise how would they know they are gay in the first place?

Anyway back to the topic at hand. How on earth do you get this ideology scrubbed from your kids' schools, is the question everyone should be asking.

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 16:44

Also if people aren't making stuff up I am slightly worried about what's being taught in biological science degrees these days.

I think there’s a lot of “making stuff up”. IIRC, Stonewall tried to say fairly recently that “the science hasn’t caught up yet”, which I think translates as “We haven’t got any evidence for whatever load of old cobblers we’re trying to peddle today, but we’re hoping the mere mention of the word “science” will make you think our stance is justified.”

Sunnyqueen · 31/08/2022 16:43

najene · 31/08/2022 13:17

I'm not really trying to argue with you. But you say "born in a woman's body but should have been born in a man's" as though it means something ("quite simply"), when I can't make head nor tail of it.

If I was born in a woman's body, then anyone born in a man's body is someone else and not me. So what I am I to make of "I should have been born in a man's body"?

... This seems to be the same as saying, "I should not have been me." But, really, if this is so, what am I to make of it? "I am me" is something that cannot be false: "I am not me" looks like a mistake (a grammatical mistake, in all likelihood, given the connection between "I" and "me" in grammar), so likewise "I should not have been me" just makes no sense at all.

Do you see?

Let me break this down for you. I am not saying that the small minority who believe they are born in the wrong born body from birth (as opposed to those who are just jumping on the tiktok/needing a group to belong to bandwagon) should deal with those feelings by transitioning. At all. Intensive therapy would probably be the best answer just like it is for any dysphoric disorders.

You are trying to argue with someone who also believes it's all bollocks. I am not remotely trans, neither are my children I have no dog in this fight, therefore no answers or insight into how a trans person thinks. You are wasting your time preaching to the converted.

Do you see?

VestofAbsurdity · 31/08/2022 16:35

Yet no one ever questions what 'man' is.

Especially not our hypocritical poster Trying20, never any doubt, complexity or room for manoeuvre there. Good old patriarchy.

On the thread subject this ideology should absolutely NOT be pushed onto children at all. No other ideology would be.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/08/2022 16:24

It's so funny how, now some males want to pretend they are part of our sex class, 'woman' has now somehow magically become completely indefinable with much hand wringing and confusion and discussion about what a woman actually is and pretence that it 'complicated'

Yet no one ever questions what 'man' is.

The good thing about Trying's posts is that they show all the women who lurk on these threads the absurdity of the ideology.

The idea of mind/body being cleanly separated in function and role is a fallacy

Yep, and actively encouraging children to mentally dissociate with their sexed body is anything but healthy. They see their body as the enemy instead. Something they can detach from or punish.

Just another form of self harm.

midgetastic · 31/08/2022 16:19

Ah but

Sone people have XXX or a single x they are female

Some people have xxy ( male but with low androgen (?) sensitivity may be considered to be female )

Other options that we could help with ?

This may also help

I find it quite telling that the term male and female are used with no difficulty

www.nhs.uk/conditions/differences-in-sex-development/

WifeMotherWorker · 31/08/2022 16:12

A woman is someone with XX chromosomes and a man is someone with XY chromosomes.
You can love who you want, dress as you please, identify and label yourself to your hearts content and have bits chopped off and added on. Biological gender cannot be argued.
Women (XX) are entitled to safe spaces (toilets, changing facilities, hospital wards, refuges, rape crisis centres and prisons) and should have a fair and equal opportunity in Sport (XX should NOT be competing against XY where strength and speed are concerned).
I just don’t support this ideology and the harm it is doing to our children’s generation and women! I’m team JK Rowling… the majority are.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 16:09

Interesting thread. Not least because it's still here!

Yes! Fingers crossed that continues

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 16:08

Social contagion absolutely rude in my kids school too. 10% are saying they are trans / non-binary. It’s the cool thing to be these days

And here's another issue. According to official Stonewall (I believe) figures, the proportion of trans people is very small (well under 1%). Yet we're seeing many multiples of that among certain teen/young adult groups. There appears to be little in the way of investigation into this or questioning of affirmative care.

Plasmodesmata · 31/08/2022 16:06

Also if people aren't making stuff up I am slightly worried about what's being taught in biological science degrees these days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread