Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Floisme · 31/08/2022 18:26

I decided I was going to be a boy when I was about 9 or 10. I had heard some stuff about 'the facts of life' and it sounded pretty freaky, plus boys just seemed to have more fun. So I adopted a boys' version of my name and went through a phase of only answering my parents if they used it.
I was absolutely serious but, luckily for me, this was over 50 years ago so people just rolled their eyes and it never even occurred to me to try it in school. When I think of how that might end now, it gives me the chills.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 18:22

Oh dear... and more wine spat!

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 18:17

Somehow the male ego and its associated willy waving stupidity trumps a discussion about the welfare of children, which is at risk due to male entitlement and ego.

It seems fitting really when you put it like that. Just more of the same. Nothing to see here.

But it is a very valid point.

A major part of this issue with children is that it involves experimental treatments. Currently, clinicians are also raising the alarm in growing numbers around the world that the treatment being pushed by WPATH, in fact, attempting to be forced in the UK through ambiguous 'conversion therapy' laws - that is Affirming Only, is not working.

Affirming Only is also only an iteration of the Dutch Protocol that it is based on. And at least one of the authors of the Dutch Protocol has stated very clearly that even the 'Dutch Protocol' seems to be not to be producing the results for the majority of the current cohort of young transitioners as they are represented today.

That is because that current cohort seeking treatment is dominated by young females.

And females have a higher risk for any of the medicalised treatments. For life shortening negative effects, for life limiting negative effects and for this treatment to not work.

But, Affirming Only has been pushed through by males.

Because it benefits male transitioners (and still, not ALL and it seems a declining % considering the growing number of detransitioner males who have many less negative health outcomes, but still have significant ones.)

And it has been males who have led the policy changes too in many instances. The OIC committee was dominated by males making policy for female athletes. They accepted a very poor quality study from a transitioned male as being the height of scientific evidence and made the changes that we have seen ripple out.

This has been happening across many different sectors.

However, I find that it is so much more concerning when it comes to the health of our children. Clinicians and policy makers have now admitted that they have effectively experimented on our children. This is not hyperbole. This is not hysteria. This is what has happened and what has been admitted.

Floisme · 31/08/2022 18:15

No Trying20, that was not me. I am sorry my posts made so little impression on you but them's the breaks.

Now I will respectfully wish you a good evening but I would like you to kindly stop wasting any more of my time.

Ship · 31/08/2022 18:08

My niece did not like wearing ‘girly’ clothes at 2. Refused all things pink and frilly and has never worn a skirt since. She has her hair cut into a Bob and has never grown it. She liked to wear stereotypically boy clothes and shoes. Not wanting to wear pink at age 2 didn’t make my sister decide she wasn’t a girl; she just let her wear the clothes she wanted as opposed from shouting from the rooftops that her child is infact a boy. We’ve always said we wouldn’t be surprised if she ever said she felt like a boy as she has said said she wished she was one before now. My sister has reassured her she can do anything she likes- she does boxing, football and other stereotypically male sports. Interestingly at the age of 10, she is exploring make up and a new interest in clothes and seems keen to wear more typically girly clothes. It would have really messed up her up I think if we all had declared her a boy at age 2. Instead we just let her be interested in her interests and comfortable in her choice of clothing

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 18:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Floisme · 31/08/2022 18:04

Somehow the male ego and its associated willy waving stupidity trumps a discussion about the welfare of children, which is at risk due to male entitlement and ego.
Yes, I understand how some men get enjoyment from winding up women on the feminist board, but taking over a discussion in which mothers are voicing concerns for their children - I think that's of a different order and I'm pretty disgusted.

Anyway let's get back on topic.

NeedToKnow101 · 31/08/2022 17:57

"I found it hugely telling that the one potential downside for men in all this, patriarchal inheritance, was quietly exempted from gender identification legally. They sorted themselves out and now couldn't give a rats ass what it means for women."

Me too. This shows that government knew it was bollocks from the start. Just a way to give men more options, and women less, and to colonise women's spaces.

WaveyHair · 31/08/2022 17:55

Floisme · 31/08/2022 17:28

Oh hello Trying20.

I really wish there was some way I could claim back the time I spent on what I thought was a robust but respectful exchange of views last night. I am at a time of life when I kind of resent wasting any of it, you know?

I know. Typical male entitlement at its best. Somehow the male ego and its associated willy waving stupidity trumps a discussion about the welfare of children, which is at risk due to male entitlement and ego.

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 17:55

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

If you say your a male and a lesbian I'd say you're even more,confused than you're coming across here WinkGrin

Although quite frankly you could "say" you're the queen of England. Doesn't make it true!

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:44

It is always for the lurker eresh.

Anyway, HopefulRose I think that this is a very sad situation. And I expect that child will take a great deal of time as an adult to process their childhood.

Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

My teenager told me that there is security in fitting in with pinning those labels onto yourself.

I was very interested in Lu901 comments. Having had 5 friends within a group of 7 of my teen's friends declare trans identities over covid, I have seen first hand just how this can happen.

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 17:40

Oh look a man is here to tell us how knowing what a woman is just so gosh darn difficult isn’t???

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids
ideasmirrour · 31/08/2022 17:38

Can we solve is without all this hyperbole and hysteria around ‘knowing what a woman is?’ Of course, if people calm down and stop being so childish about it. Are this issues more important for women than stopping the world being run by and for old, rich white men.

But how will we know who the old rich white men are, @Trying20 , what with biological sex being SO complicated?

I wonder if it’s super complicated when we want to be “knowing what a woman is”, but really very easy when we want to know about men! Knowing about men is important and straightforward and all this woman stuff is just getting in the way of where our focus should be — firmly on men. Old white rich men! Where are they? What are they doing? Where are they going?

In any case, the existence of intersex/DSD conditions in complicating biological sex has zero relevance to transgender ideology. Because the entire point is that men want to claim they are in fact women despite any “biological” evidence at all. Their argument is that gender is a spiritual state of mind, not anything to do with biology.

The entire ideology is so riddled with holes, hypocrisy, contradictions, idiocies and logical fallacies that arguing with genderwoo enthusiasts is like shooting fish in a barrel, to be honest.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 31/08/2022 17:34

Oh look a man is here to tell us how knowing what a woman is just so gosh darn difficult isn’t??? Goodness how on earth has the human species managed to survive & reproduce when its soooo hard to tell

funny how men had no problem knowing who to deny the vote too or who not to give a mortgage too without a father or husband to guarantee it

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 17:33

I don't even know why you're entertaining this guy, he knows perfectly well what a woman is. The fact that we're all even entertaining this as a serious question and tying ourselves in knots trying to explain it to a guy pretending he's confused is a win for them I'd imagine.

It was more for the lurkers as I didn't want his gotcha nonsense to go unchallenged, but I take your point.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:33

ASDstruggles · 31/08/2022 15:10

As the mother of a pre teen daughter with ASD the idea that my daughter is prone to trans ideology being pushed onto her is fucking terrifying. The thought of the likes of mermaids getting their hands on her confused, prepubescent brain and pumping it full of their ideas keeps me awake at night.

when she reaches 25 and her brain is fully matured she can make whatever decisions she wants and I will love her just the same, but the thought of my tomboy being persuaded to make permanent, life changing decisions that she later regrets and I have to go along with otherwise I’m an abusive TERF scares the shit out of me.

Flowers

I understand very much where you are coming from.

Floisme · 31/08/2022 17:32

Please don't waste your wine Helleofabore - wasting time is bad enough.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:31

CrossStichQueen · 31/08/2022 17:29

This is the second thread this week Trying has successfully derailed the thread and somehow made it all about them.....

yes. When I started to process what happened on the other thread and looked at the progression of that thread into the night, it was very very enlightening. I wonder if others noticed the same....

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:30

Floisme · 31/08/2022 17:28

Oh hello Trying20.

I really wish there was some way I could claim back the time I spent on what I thought was a robust but respectful exchange of views last night. I am at a time of life when I kind of resent wasting any of it, you know?

Grin

I just spat out my wine!

CrossStichQueen · 31/08/2022 17:29

This is the second thread this week Trying has successfully derailed the thread and somehow made it all about them.....

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 17:29

Oh FFS!

I cannot believe we are still in discussion with anyone about what a 'woman' is.

As posters have stated. A woman is an adult human female.

Now I will just rip this out of my bloody long essay of a post to continue:

A female human has a body formed around the production of eggs, the large gamete that is needed to reproduce, whether that body has ever, will ever, or is producing those large gametes. The stage of production is irrelevant for the categorisation of those females being categorised as females. (It matters very much on a personal level for that individual, but not for the sex categorisation.)

Female bodies come with a very wide range of differences. But they are ALL formed around that specific function.

No male can change sex. Ever.

There are no third sexes.

There are no humans producing a third gamete, and nor are they self-fertilising.

And having body parts removed or not functioning does not make any difference at all to the categorisation of whether a body was formed for producing large gametes from ovaries (whether those ovaries function or even there) or small gametes from testes.

Floisme · 31/08/2022 17:28

Oh hello Trying20.

I really wish there was some way I could claim back the time I spent on what I thought was a robust but respectful exchange of views last night. I am at a time of life when I kind of resent wasting any of it, you know?

AryaStarkWolf · 31/08/2022 17:25

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

I don't think I said any of that or are you talking to @Ereshkigalangcleg ?

stode · 31/08/2022 17:17

TheElementsSong · 31/08/2022 17:14

I'm invoking Bunbury.

This

Topgub · 31/08/2022 17:15

@Trying20

Why would anyone object?

You keep doing you hun.