Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 23:54

I can see that for a (relatively) few women there are real issues with trans-women who would previously have been excluded from women’s spaces

It's not a relatively few women. It's most women. Your view is the fringe one.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/08/2022 23:52

The key point here are that sex is not as biologically black and white as people think.

Most people here aren't unaware that disorders of sex development can occur. But there are only two sexes, because there are only two reproductive roles, and two gametes, ova and sperm.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 31/08/2022 23:35

My feeling on this is if everyone shaved their hair and walked around naked they would either be visibly male or female (bar any genetic anomalies) everything else is just a social construct

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 23:27

I can see that for a (relatively) few women there are real issues with trans-women who would previously have been excluded from women’s spaces (but that these were largely caused by plain vanilla men in the first place and working on crimes against women by men would be addressing this problem more fundamentally)

The unfortunate truth is that we've had millennia to 'work on crimes against women by men' and not achieved anything like safety for them. Rather than live in lalaland, better to defend their spaces.

However what you (and indeed many, many others) are saying here is that you don't give too many shits about these women. Which, while utterly depressing, is good insight into how women can actually fight back here. In a twisted way we need to focus on the female 'winners' in things like women's sports, rather than the very vulnerable. So thanks for helping to clarify that for me.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 23:21

I agree with this, and it’s very well expressed.

😂 😂 😂

The barrel scraping from you today

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 23:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 23:15

I said was possible to fit definitely in neither catergory.

Thats not true either. There's no such thing as a true hermaphrodite human. Individuals with DSD may have imperfect expression of their sex, but they do still fit into one category or another, at a fundamental level.

Some people feel very masculine despite having a feminine body. Or vice versa. No biggie. (Which is how I interpret ‘being born in the wrong body’)

How does anyone 'feel' masculine or in the 'wrong body' if they've never been in a masculine body. They can't know how that feels. The only thing they're responding to are societal stereotypes of femininity or masculinity, which is what would should be tackling rather than giving 'wrong body' narratives airtime

It seems such a hysterical response with people talking about being ‘terrified’ that their children will be exposed to this ideology by ‘captured’ schools

You don't think it's natural to be extremely worried about pathways of care for confused teens that can encompass puberty blockers, hormone treatment and surgery, that may leave people infertile and incapable of full sexual pleasure? You don't see issues with that?

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 23:09

But that still doesn't explain why gender becomes everyone else's problem. It physically does not work unless others play along.

Why is anyone else responsible. Why set these kids up to become needy and reliant on others.

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 23:00

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 13:31

But the scientific evidence is NOT that there are two completely discrete and mutually exclusive sexes, where every single person falls into one category or the other. There are proven, HUMAN outliers that fall between categories.

They have disorders of sexual development which impacts presentation of sexual characteristics.

They are still, at a chromosomal level one sex or another.

True human hermaphroditism doesn't exist. Neither does some third sex or fluctuating between sex.

Even if it did, it doesn't mean anyone can change sex. That's not scientifically possible.

So let's not obfuscate from the point. Sex in mammals is binary and immutable.

It’s not possible to change sex. I certainly never implied it was. I said was possible to fit definitely in neither catergory. The key point here are that sex is not as biologically black and white as people think. But that really doesn’t matter, because we are discussing gender. Which is far, far more about social issues than biological ones. I often wonder if we had no sexism - if sexes were truly treated equally - whether there would be any issues at all. I think misogyny is a far, far bigger issue, affecting far more women that trans issues, and that the hysterical back lash against trans women is just an attempt by the patriarchy to divide all women, and continue the misogyny that has worked well for them for so long. So I can’t get all that excited about it as a problem. It seems such a hysterical response with people talking about being ‘terrified’ that their children will be exposed to this ideology by ‘captured’ schools and ‘chilling’ tales of people living trans lives. The language is a bit cult-like, and I can’t understand the strength of feeling behind it. Some people feel very masculine despite having a feminine body. Or vice versa. No biggie. (Which is how I interpret ‘being born in the wrong body’ @najene. You can’t really define someone who is the other sex in their own mind if you can’t define sex as a category anyway. I think I may have been responding to someone who quoted your post. Apologies for any confusion)

@Whatwouldscullydo it’s also relevant to consider that science of any sort is not ‘finished’ there can’t just be a blood test or a brain scan for lots of problems. Even physical ones. Let alone complex psycho-social ones. We can’t just do a brain scan and diagnose someone with depression, or anorexia, but they are definite problems with real effects. There might even be some completely undiscovered physical discrepancy. Maybe there’s a genetic disorder in some people’s brains which renders them hyper-sensitive to sex hormones and makes them ‘feel’ very much of one sex or another. But it’s a sensitivity, not an actual hormone imbalance, present in the brain, but not the body, the way that type 2 diabetes is a problem with insulin sensitivity not production. Maybe in 50 years we’ll be horrified at how trans people were treated because it’s a measurable thing. Or maybe we’ll be horrified because society changes and we’ll look in the outrage people feel now the way we look at racism in the seventies. I don’t know. I’m not saying either is right or wrong I’m just saying we don’t know everything, and it’s possible, and the scale of the reaction feels very disproportionate to me.

I’m fairly neutral about trans people. I know a couple. They’re harmless enough. I can see that for a (relatively) few women there are real issues with trans-women who would previously have been excluded from women’s spaces (but that these were largely caused by plain vanilla men in the first place and working on crimes against women by men would be addressing this problem more fundamentally) I’m uncomfortable with self ID, because of the potential for abuse (which is also a misogyny issue) and there are obvious issues with fairness in sport. But I can’t really see policing or licensing of gender change going well, either. I still think it’s a smoke-screen for bigger issues. And the hysteria really doesn’t seem to match the practical scale of the issues. I’m certain more women would benefit overall if the energy against transwomen was redirected toward the patriarchy.

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 22:56

She is the Attourney General. The topic is gender ideology. Why would anything else matter?

You don't have to know her personally before you quote her words.

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 22:28

Totally missing the point!

I agree with her speech around the laws of this. I thought it was very well out across.

But as a person and MP I wouldn't personally be aiming to quote her or put her on a pedestal in a general sense.

If you know her and have met her or ever had to deal with her - you'd understand why.

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 22:02

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 20:01

Well quoting her in this matter.

I wouldn't quite her over most things she's says.

She's currently in her FB page throwing her toys out the pram as she's been accused of voting to stop dumping sewage in our coasts.

She's been very rightly called out on her blatant lies. Someone even listed her name of the list of MPs who voted against the lords wanting to bring in legal amendments to article 48.

She's is 100% right on this matter on her point in law as AG. I suppose even she had to get it right at some point.

The rest of her voting record is dire.

You'd look a right twat if you quoted sewage dumping when talking to a school about gender ideology wouldn't you?

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 20:50

@najene that’s an excellent post!

DdraigGoch · 31/08/2022 20:30

If I chopped off the bottom half of my body (and somehow survived) so I suddenly lose half my mind?

I might say that you have lost your mind if you did go ahead and chop half of your body off, but that's just in the metaphorical sense.

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 20:02

Voting against dumping 🤦🏼‍♀️

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 20:01

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 19:46

Ooh, 'I'm a gay man but I have no idea what either a man, a woman, a gay man or a lesbian' - I just fumble round in the dark and if I say I'm gay then anyone I fancy is automatically a man. Utter bullshit.

Everyone knows what fucking sex they are. Even kids until teachers start telling them they could be the other sex, or no sex, if they want.

This needs to be out of schools. People need sacking. Some need jailing. But for now, you should be quoting Cass, quoting Suella Braverman and stopping your schools from spouting this nonsense to your kids.

Well quoting her in this matter.

I wouldn't quite her over most things she's says.

She's currently in her FB page throwing her toys out the pram as she's been accused of voting to stop dumping sewage in our coasts.

She's been very rightly called out on her blatant lies. Someone even listed her name of the list of MPs who voted against the lords wanting to bring in legal amendments to article 48.

She's is 100% right on this matter on her point in law as AG. I suppose even she had to get it right at some point.

The rest of her voting record is dire.

itsgettingweird · 31/08/2022 19:56

Topgub · 31/08/2022 19:12

In previous debates on different sm I've been attacked and told its utterly ridiculous to suggest that anyone thinks trans people can actually change sex.

They know they can't

Its just transphobic and abusive to point it out.

So, essentially, everyone just has to pretend.

Because its not fair other wise.

And that's the crux of it isn't it.

It's all this "my truth" bollocks.

"I've said it's true - therefore it is".

Whereas I was raised and have raised my ds with the expression "anyone can say what they like. Doesn't make it true".

Goes right back to when kids are daft and testing winding each other up and know which kids will be annoyed that they continuously state the sky is pink. They'll use all sorts of whataboutery and words and twist facts.

The sky is still blue.

Which is why I've always taught ds - as I was - that sometimes the best way to win and argument is to not argue Grin

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 19:46

Ooh, 'I'm a gay man but I have no idea what either a man, a woman, a gay man or a lesbian' - I just fumble round in the dark and if I say I'm gay then anyone I fancy is automatically a man. Utter bullshit.

Everyone knows what fucking sex they are. Even kids until teachers start telling them they could be the other sex, or no sex, if they want.

This needs to be out of schools. People need sacking. Some need jailing. But for now, you should be quoting Cass, quoting Suella Braverman and stopping your schools from spouting this nonsense to your kids.

Toseland · 31/08/2022 19:46

I hope everyday that something will stop the forward march of gender-ism. That not one more child is confused, lied to, harmed or surgically altered and is allowed to have counselling. That children can grow up to be adults with normal sexual function. That parents and families can look forward to their grandchildren being born and breastfed.
I was a tomboy - I would have not had the chance to have my intimate relationships, children, breastfeeding achievements, sports achievements, safe spaces, if I was a young girl growing up today and that is criminal. #sexmatters #transgendertrend

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 19:33

I think what surprises many posters who support the prioritising of trans rights over those of females (and they will deny they are doing it sometimes too), is that more and more people who have never said anything about it before to them, have some very perceptive views and opinions.

I know that it certainly has stopped (along with polls that make it clear) the ‘you who say that the rights of women and children are negatively impacted by trans demands are the minority’ … sometimes followed by an added ‘and you are all dinosaurs and will die out soon!’

But we still get the posters who post like they have digested that American scientific blog post that they call an ‘academic paper’. That discuss similar arguments to the post we saw up thread.

And we still get posters who have not read widely, listened or discussed with any robustness who applaud those posts like they are well evidenced:

and yes, najene you are right and we need reminding of that regularly.

Tuilpmouse · 31/08/2022 19:24

@najene

Great post!

scorpiogirly · 31/08/2022 19:15

You are not alone.

I have a 4 year old daughter and this stuff makes me sick to my stomach.

The parents are trans... well there we are. Dangerous ideology being pushed onto your children. I absolutely dread to think of that poor child in years to come woth the damage that has and will be done.

I don't believe anyone is born in the wrong body. I believe in dysphoria but its part of a wider issue. It's a mental health issue.

Children are being indoctrinated in schools as young as 4 now.

There is a huge growing number of detransitioners speaking out. They're devastated that they were allowed to do this to their bodies. Young people who are now old enough to realise they will never have children. Their bodies have been mutilated. They will never return to how they used to be. My heart breaks for them.

Topgub · 31/08/2022 19:12

In previous debates on different sm I've been attacked and told its utterly ridiculous to suggest that anyone thinks trans people can actually change sex.

They know they can't

Its just transphobic and abusive to point it out.

So, essentially, everyone just has to pretend.

Because its not fair other wise.

najene · 31/08/2022 19:07

A few words about "woman" and science.

Sure there is science about men and women; part of biology. And, sure enough, it is a scientific fact that humans, like other mammals, are sexually dimorphic, and that there have never been any simultaneous or sequential hermaphrodite humans.

It's also true that a dictionary definition of "woman" is "adult human female".

But none of this is really relevant to (failed) attempts to get trans ideology off the ground.

No-one thinks it worth scientifically investigating whether there are any married bachelors. Why? Because "a bachelor is an unmarried man" is not a falsifiable proposition. Nothing exists that would count as a married bachelor. Anyone who speaks English knows this: they know what "bachelor" means (whether or not they can quote a dictionary definition).

Likewise, there can be no joy in attempting a scientific investigation into whether there are any women who were not born female. Why? Because "a woman was born female" is not falsifiable. Nothing exists that would count as a born-male woman. Anyone who speaks English knows this: they know what "woman" means (whether or not they can quote a dictionary definition).

It's worth saying this because it points up how trans ideology fails on a level before we start looking at any of the science of sexual reproduction, of chromosomes or DSDs and so on. Trans ideology fails to make sense ... it fails on the level of sense, of meaning, which is prior to any consideration of scientific investigation.

"2 + 2 = 5" isn't a scientific false statement. It just doesn't make sense - it means nothing. Likewise "I was born in the wrong body" means nothing. And "a transwoman is a woman" means nothing.

Of course you can give such propositions meaning by (re)defining what you mean (by "5"? "body"? "woman"?). But then you're Humpty Dumpty: '"When I use a word," Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, "it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less."' And words don't work like that; that's Carroll's (or perhaps Dodgson's) point.

So, by all means read "Alice" to your children. But don't let them think there's any sense to men being or becoming women, or to someone being born in the wrong body. There just isn't. And it's bad for children to pretend there is.

VestofAbsurdity · 31/08/2022 18:29

Floisme · 31/08/2022 18:04

Somehow the male ego and its associated willy waving stupidity trumps a discussion about the welfare of children, which is at risk due to male entitlement and ego.
Yes, I understand how some men get enjoyment from winding up women on the feminist board, but taking over a discussion in which mothers are voicing concerns for their children - I think that's of a different order and I'm pretty disgusted.

Anyway let's get back on topic.

True colours always come out, bad enough when the targets are women beyond awful when they are children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread