Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CanaryShoulderedThorn · 01/09/2022 12:54

OfficiallyBroken · 31/08/2022 10:52

Trans ideology goes hand in hand with reinforcement of negative and regressive stereotypes. Anyone championing trans ideology is deep down saying that girls/women should be soft, feminine and only like pretty things and boys/men must be strong, masculine and be into sports.

It's fucking nuts and I can't believe that people of reasonable intelligence buy into it.

I was a "masculine" girl. Short hair, BMX, climbing trees, exclusively wore boys clothes, joined the army, hated having periods. At no point in my life did I ever think that made me a boy/man because the message I grew up with was that being my version of me was perfectly fine. Kids now are being bombarded with the message that if they don't confirm with stereotypes they can't possibly be a boy/girl and must be the opposite. How the hell people think this is right I have no idea.

I completely agree with all of this.

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 12:51

Actually you've reminded me that Rachel Rooney book is a fantastic start

YouSetTheTone · 01/09/2022 12:47

YANBU op My three year old son is currently an admirer of the Carly Simon video where she sings Nobody Does it Better on an outside stage. She wears a beautiful simple flared peachy dress. He loves the dress and he comments on my dresses often (although most of the time I wear jeans - I must be very confused with my gender identity). He loves Dashi's hair clips from Octonauts and also Elsa's long hair on Frozen. He has requested to wear hair clips (and gets bored of them as they feel uncomfortable) and likes glittery trainers and pink tops as well as the tops he has in many different colours. He is a perfectly bright three year old but of course, he has no real understanding of the stereotypes and social norms that dictate that girls and boys are 'supposed' to wear different things. If he said he wanted to be a girl, it wouldn't be because he is rejecting his sex as a boy, it would be because he thinks dresses and glittery things look lovely - because sometimes they do!! He is absorbing the messages from society around him rather than articulating his own inner desires.
I just let him wear what he wants and admire what he wants. He knows perfectly well that he is a boy and has a penis. We read 'My Body is Me' by Rachel Rooney so he knows that we should respect our bodies and love them because we only have one, we don't have a spare.

The idea that some parents would take my son and call him a girl and set him on a pathway to surgery and life long medication horrifies me.

As a pp says - when it comes to teenagers we should remember that discomfort with who we are, our identities and our changing bodies is actually an integral part of puberty itself! For god's sake. It is part of a natural and healthy process. Twisting this, confusing teenagers further and potentially harming them and their bodies in the process is such a scandal.

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 12:36

I think the reason it’s bothering me is because I don’t feel I can safely discuss this in public due to fear of being branded a ‘terf’ or ‘anti trans’ which I’m not. But I’m afraid that lots of us women are feeling this way and are being silenced and there is no one openly in politics handling this issue logically

I agree a lot of people feel this way.

But we need to be brave and speak the truth anyway. We know that it's is not right to do this to children. We need to advocate for their safety. The bullying and silencing from those who don't want this talked about is abhorrent. Let's keep standing up to it.

Musti · 01/09/2022 12:04

HopefulRose · 01/09/2022 09:37

Wow this thread really took off.

I think the reason it’s bothering me is because I don’t feel I can safely discuss this in public due to fear of being branded a ‘terf’ or ‘anti trans’ which I’m not. But I’m afraid that lots of us women are feeling this way and are being silenced and there is no one openly in politics handling this issue logically.

That’s how I feel. I’m used to being the one defending people. I’m an activist and have always supported any movement that I think discriminates against people.

And of course I’ve supported adults who are trans.

But I really don’t understand how kids are being allowed to make such life changing decisions before they’re adults. I don’t personally understand the pronoun thing and I also don’t understand the attachment of sex/gender to clothes for example. Clothes are just fashion and throughout history people have worn skirts or dresses or make up of both sexes. Long hair and short hair - both sexes. It’s a social thing and whilst before only men wore trousers, women now do and doesn’t mean anything.

Having raised 2 kids of each sex, I can see how little difference there is between the sexes in terms of interests and personality. What they are influenced by is their peers and the world they are raised in.

AryaStarkWolf · 01/09/2022 11:11

ideasmirrour · 01/09/2022 00:09

You’ve got literally zero self-consciousness or shame about putting down women’s concerns as “hysteria” whilst talking about the “patriarchy”?

That’s quite literally “the patriarchy” at work. Dismissing women as “hysterical” is a centuries old technique of patriarchal argument. Do you think we don’t see through the sheer cheek of it all?

I know, I couldn't get passed the use of the word Hysterical in that post either fucks sake, also using the tactic of taking GC arguments and making them their own describing GC are cult like ffs

najene · 01/09/2022 10:45

Eeksteek: "Some people feel very masculine despite having a feminine body. Or vice versa. No biggie. (Which is how I interpret ‘being born in the wrong body’ @najene. You can’t really define someone who is the other sex in their own mind if you can’t define sex as a category anyway. I think I may have been responding to someone who quoted your post. Apologies for any confusion)"

Apology accepted. But this is not really any help. What is it to "feel very masculine despite having a feminine body," I wonder? Is it something like "to wrongly think one is a man when one is actually a woman"? Or perhaps, "to enjoy dressing and behaving in a way stereotypically associated with a man in a certain culture when one is a woman"? Or what?

The thing is, which I think you miss despite your claims to be focussed on scientific aspects, that the "born in the wrong body" notion is usually intended to play a causal role: this (senseless, I have argued in an earlier post) idea is offered in (causal) explanation of the supposed (and again senseless, I have suggested) state of being transgender (sc. being the opposite sex to that which one actually is). That your (Humpty-Dumptyesque) interpretation of the notion makes it unlikely to be able to fill such a role keeps it as empty of sense as it ever was.

Do you see?

As for "someone who is the other sex in their own mind". Do you really think this makes sense? Seriously? To be a certain sex in my own mind could at best be metaphorical for thinking I am a certain sex. But, well, everyone older than (roughly) two or three surely knows what sex they are? ... Oh, and so on: I leave this as an exercise for you to unpick for yourself.

... Do notice, though, how much definition is a red herring here. It's clear "someone who is the other sex in their own mind" has no (literal) sense. We can see this without calling up any scientific endeavour, or by looking in any dictionary ... all we need to be able to do is understand English at a fairly elementary level. (Notice that knowledge of definitions of words comes (a long way) after such understanding, both temporally/deveopmentally and (logico-)semantically.)

Of course you can define things however you like. But recall, perhaps, as well as Humpty Dumpty, Bertrand Russell's apophthegm about "the advantages of theft over honest toil." (To save you googling: “Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy, P. 71”.)

You'd do well to read a little around your own sparse knowledge of biological science, Eeksteek, if you really wish to understand where you are going so (badly) wrong on all this. I used to recommend Hull & Ruse's collection The Philosophy of Biology, but also I suspect you need something a tad simpler ... oh, go do some research for yourself.

(A little modesty might not go amiss, also, when posting here on MN: your de haut en bas schtick doesn't sit too well with what your posts tell us of your level of understanding.)

AlisonDonut · 01/09/2022 09:55

itsgettingweird · 01/09/2022 06:43

You don't seem to be able to understand my words 🤦‍♀️

Let me spell it out for you.

I agree with what she said.

I simply added another opinion of her in general.

I'm able to separate the 2 things and have 2 narratives at once.

I'm sorry that you can only have 1 conversation about 1 topic at once. It was very wrong of me to make the assumption everyone had good fluid conversation skills.

But just for clarity and to reiterate - I agree with what she said. But she literally quoted the law. That's exactly what her job is!

You added a completely irrelevant opinion in the guise of 'Look, a squirrel'.

Perhaps stick to the topic on the thread, and start a new one if you want to talk about sewage?

HopefulRose · 01/09/2022 09:41

Ship · 31/08/2022 18:08

My niece did not like wearing ‘girly’ clothes at 2. Refused all things pink and frilly and has never worn a skirt since. She has her hair cut into a Bob and has never grown it. She liked to wear stereotypically boy clothes and shoes. Not wanting to wear pink at age 2 didn’t make my sister decide she wasn’t a girl; she just let her wear the clothes she wanted as opposed from shouting from the rooftops that her child is infact a boy. We’ve always said we wouldn’t be surprised if she ever said she felt like a boy as she has said said she wished she was one before now. My sister has reassured her she can do anything she likes- she does boxing, football and other stereotypically male sports. Interestingly at the age of 10, she is exploring make up and a new interest in clothes and seems keen to wear more typically girly clothes. It would have really messed up her up I think if we all had declared her a boy at age 2. Instead we just let her be interested in her interests and comfortable in her choice of clothing

this sounds like healthy parenting

OP posts:
HopefulRose · 01/09/2022 09:37

Wow this thread really took off.

I think the reason it’s bothering me is because I don’t feel I can safely discuss this in public due to fear of being branded a ‘terf’ or ‘anti trans’ which I’m not. But I’m afraid that lots of us women are feeling this way and are being silenced and there is no one openly in politics handling this issue logically.

OP posts:
JacketPocket · 01/09/2022 09:23

The key point here are that sex is not as biologically black and white as people think.

As other posters have said, it is. Just because there are very, very rare cases which don't fit the precise norms, the very fact of their being identified as variance indicates there is a binary norm of two sexes.

the hysterical back lash against trans women... It seems such a hysterical response... And the hysteria really doesn’t seem to match the practical scale of the issues

Hysteria is a gendered abuse against women ever speaking up for themselves. Using that term to describe women talking out against the abuse of women and children is really not ok.

people talking about being ‘terrified’ that their children will be exposed to this ideology by ‘captured’ schools and ‘chilling’ tales of people living trans lives. The language is a bit cult-like, and I can’t understand the strength of feeling behind it.

Modern trans ideology is the thing that's cult-like. TRAs talk about "feelings" and "knowing" and "personal truths", all of which are much more cult-like than "can we slow down and get actual medical research before pumping stuff into teens, and maybe look at why this ideology is being pushed and who actually benefits before we roll this out in every school across the country as a matter of course". One is cult-like. The other is rational.

Women here are worried about vulnerable, developing children being repeatedly and constantly exposed to questions about their gender identity. Loads of women on here have talked about how differently their lives and health would have gone if they were growing up now and had those questions and comments pushed at them, and none of them were positive about it. The earlier analogy about parents who constantly talk about food, portions, healthy eating and the relationship their children will have with eating is a good one. Children and teenagers shouldn't be thinking constantly about anything, and certainly not about something as fluid, developing, and vulnerable to outside social pressures as "gender identity". On top of that, the pathway of experimental medication and surgery of course is something any parent would be worried about. None of this is hysterical. All of this is chilling.

Maybe in 50 years we’ll be horrified at how trans people were treated because it’s a measurable thing. Or maybe we’ll be horrified because society changes and we’ll look in the outrage people feel now the way we look at racism in the seventies. I don’t know. I’m not saying either is right or wrong I’m just saying we don’t know everything, and it’s possible, and the scale of the reaction feels very disproportionate to me.

That's fine that you think it's disproportionate. To the mothers and fathers who are dealing with children who are facing social pressures they might not even be aware of, and insisting on medications that will damage and shorten their lives because of social trends and contagion, it's pretty horrifying and doesn't actually look like a civil rights movement at all.

I’m certain more women would benefit overall if the energy against transwomen was redirected toward the patriarchy.

Again: TRAs are the patriarchy.

Explain to me again how the laws being changed to prevent trans men benefiting from male-based positions (aristocratic inheritances, Irish priesthoods) is part of this great positive blurring of sexes/genders/human body mishmash of human rights celebration? Please explain how modern trans ideology benefits women, rather than punishes, even one tiny bit?

x2boys · 01/09/2022 08:53

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 00:57

My DS feels he is a girl - he is autistic. There are 2 others in his friendship group that also identify as trans but they are girls that want to identify as boys - they are also both autistic. It does worry me that there is such a link with autism. On the other hand, I feel it is just part of trying to work out your identity that all teens go through.

Hopefully ,but in the case of one person identifying as male ,they have statred hormone treatment, which is concerning if they later decide they are not trans ,this patcicular person isn't in the UK

Winederlust · 01/09/2022 08:08

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Please, you are being ridiculous. And I suspect you know you are.
The question isn't can every female give birth, but can any male?

itsgettingweird · 01/09/2022 06:45

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 31/08/2022 23:35

My feeling on this is if everyone shaved their hair and walked around naked they would either be visibly male or female (bar any genetic anomalies) everything else is just a social construct

Yep.

And yet you'd still have a load of people who would recognise which ones were men and then want to define why the others are woman!

itsgettingweird · 01/09/2022 06:43

AlisonDonut · 31/08/2022 22:56

She is the Attourney General. The topic is gender ideology. Why would anything else matter?

You don't have to know her personally before you quote her words.

You don't seem to be able to understand my words 🤦‍♀️

Let me spell it out for you.

I agree with what she said.

I simply added another opinion of her in general.

I'm able to separate the 2 things and have 2 narratives at once.

I'm sorry that you can only have 1 conversation about 1 topic at once. It was very wrong of me to make the assumption everyone had good fluid conversation skills.

But just for clarity and to reiterate - I agree with what she said. But she literally quoted the law. That's exactly what her job is!

NicolaSixSix · 01/09/2022 01:06

SleeplessInEngland · 31/08/2022 10:18

Relieved to see another trans thread on MN. It'd had been a whole 20 minutes.

😂

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 00:57

x2boys · 31/08/2022 09:56

I dont think anyone can decide they are transgender at two ,a two year old barely knows the difference between a girl and a boy ,I do find the trend worrying I now know of three families in my circle of friends and extended family, where a teen has identified as a member if the opposite sex ,in all three families there is a history of autism and I understand there is a link between autistic girls believing they are the wring sex .

My DS feels he is a girl - he is autistic. There are 2 others in his friendship group that also identify as trans but they are girls that want to identify as boys - they are also both autistic. It does worry me that there is such a link with autism. On the other hand, I feel it is just part of trying to work out your identity that all teens go through.

DoubleShotEspresso · 01/09/2022 00:25

VestaTilley · 31/08/2022 10:23

YANBU, I agree completely. Massive red flags in all these dysfunctional families.

The whole ideology is built on a tissue of lies, and is wreaking devastation for children and adults alike, especially women.

Transing children should be illegal. We’re heading for the mother of all public scandals with this agenda - God knows how much will be paid out in compensation by the NHS in future years when all these poor kids realise they made huge mistakes.

Stonewall and Mermaids should be shut down.

I agree 100%

ideasmirrour · 01/09/2022 00:09

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 23:00

It’s not possible to change sex. I certainly never implied it was. I said was possible to fit definitely in neither catergory. The key point here are that sex is not as biologically black and white as people think. But that really doesn’t matter, because we are discussing gender. Which is far, far more about social issues than biological ones. I often wonder if we had no sexism - if sexes were truly treated equally - whether there would be any issues at all. I think misogyny is a far, far bigger issue, affecting far more women that trans issues, and that the hysterical back lash against trans women is just an attempt by the patriarchy to divide all women, and continue the misogyny that has worked well for them for so long. So I can’t get all that excited about it as a problem. It seems such a hysterical response with people talking about being ‘terrified’ that their children will be exposed to this ideology by ‘captured’ schools and ‘chilling’ tales of people living trans lives. The language is a bit cult-like, and I can’t understand the strength of feeling behind it. Some people feel very masculine despite having a feminine body. Or vice versa. No biggie. (Which is how I interpret ‘being born in the wrong body’ @najene. You can’t really define someone who is the other sex in their own mind if you can’t define sex as a category anyway. I think I may have been responding to someone who quoted your post. Apologies for any confusion)

@Whatwouldscullydo it’s also relevant to consider that science of any sort is not ‘finished’ there can’t just be a blood test or a brain scan for lots of problems. Even physical ones. Let alone complex psycho-social ones. We can’t just do a brain scan and diagnose someone with depression, or anorexia, but they are definite problems with real effects. There might even be some completely undiscovered physical discrepancy. Maybe there’s a genetic disorder in some people’s brains which renders them hyper-sensitive to sex hormones and makes them ‘feel’ very much of one sex or another. But it’s a sensitivity, not an actual hormone imbalance, present in the brain, but not the body, the way that type 2 diabetes is a problem with insulin sensitivity not production. Maybe in 50 years we’ll be horrified at how trans people were treated because it’s a measurable thing. Or maybe we’ll be horrified because society changes and we’ll look in the outrage people feel now the way we look at racism in the seventies. I don’t know. I’m not saying either is right or wrong I’m just saying we don’t know everything, and it’s possible, and the scale of the reaction feels very disproportionate to me.

I’m fairly neutral about trans people. I know a couple. They’re harmless enough. I can see that for a (relatively) few women there are real issues with trans-women who would previously have been excluded from women’s spaces (but that these were largely caused by plain vanilla men in the first place and working on crimes against women by men would be addressing this problem more fundamentally) I’m uncomfortable with self ID, because of the potential for abuse (which is also a misogyny issue) and there are obvious issues with fairness in sport. But I can’t really see policing or licensing of gender change going well, either. I still think it’s a smoke-screen for bigger issues. And the hysteria really doesn’t seem to match the practical scale of the issues. I’m certain more women would benefit overall if the energy against transwomen was redirected toward the patriarchy.

You’ve got literally zero self-consciousness or shame about putting down women’s concerns as “hysteria” whilst talking about the “patriarchy”?

That’s quite literally “the patriarchy” at work. Dismissing women as “hysterical” is a centuries old technique of patriarchal argument. Do you think we don’t see through the sheer cheek of it all?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 01/09/2022 00:07

And that most people of both sexes neither support legal self ID or males in women's sports?

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/09/2022 00:06

I’m certain more women would benefit overall if the energy against transwomen was redirected toward the patriarchy

They are the patriarchy. Their ideology is detrimental to females as a sex class.

Redefining 'women' to include a subset of men is also massively misogynistic.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 01/09/2022 00:05

Shall we get out that YouGov poll again that said most people weren't paying that much attention? Or shall we just take your word as the only truth?

How about we get out the multiple YouGov and other polls which say that women don't want penis in their spaces?

daisytilly1 · 01/09/2022 00:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But autistic people are normal dear. 🙄

Trying20 · 01/09/2022 00:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Trying20 · 31/08/2022 23:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP