Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/08/2022 11:40

Children are being used to legitimise and sanitize the life choices of adults.

Why else would children need to be made sexless and sterile and lifelong medical patients, yet adult males can say they are 'women' without changing a thing about themselves and most keep their fully functioning penis and can still reproduce.

Why would any adult think performing a radical double mastectomy on a healthy teens breasts or a hysterectomy which they know will cause long term damage by putting a women though menopause so young. (Bones, brain function, heart health etc etc etc etc), would be a better option than helping the teen come to terms with their sexed body by actually finding, the causes of their dysphoria and mental distress?

They also conveniently ignore that the majority of children who present with dysphoria actually grow out of it. The 'cure' is the very puberty they want to opt out of. You know, the natural, normal process of the body and brain maturing.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids
to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids
to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids
megosaurusrex · 31/08/2022 11:38

When I was a toddler I frequently said I wanted to be a boy. I told everyone I wanted to be a farmer or a builder when I grew up. I also wanted to be a princess and only wear pink dresses and be a nurse when I grew up. No idea what I'd be transitioning into now if I'd have been born recently.
I agree with others that it's along the lines of gender/body dysmorphia. If I said that at work I'd be pulled up to HR. I hate that as a society, we can't have an honest discussion about it, being respectful and tolerant of all views, without having "TRANSPHOBIC" screamed at you. You should never bully anyone with your ideology, regardless of what that is.

SILdidittoo · 31/08/2022 11:26

Sunnyqueen · 31/08/2022 09:39

I don't think for the majority it's to do with them being sexually abused at this point.
It's just a massive social media trend that's going waaayy too far at this point that it's damaging kids. I do believe there are genuine cases of people being born in the wrong body but no where near in the droves this is happening. I think maybe these people just wish to belong to something, a cause and end up sucked in and a bit brainwashed. Same way people get in to a gang or a religious group.

@Sunnyqueen

What do you mean "born in the wrong body"? Does this just apply to trans people or does it include physically disabled people as well?

MotherofPearl · 31/08/2022 11:20

*AFAIK I meant

MotherofPearl · 31/08/2022 11:19

I don't get it either @SidewaysOtter (about the different approach to treating types of body dysphoria). ASAIK anorexia is a type of body dysphoria, but if an emaciated anorexic presented at the GP saying "I think I am very fat and hate my body", the GP would of course not affirm this and say "well go ahead and fix that by not eating." Instead they would be referred for treatment and care which would hopefully try to tackle the underlying causes of the dysphoria.

AryaStarkWolf · 31/08/2022 11:12

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 11:08

I guess people mean there are people born with an over whelming case of body dis-morphia where they are really uncomfortable in their sexed body and want to be the opposite? That's the only thing that makes sense really

What I don’t understand is why gender dysmorphia is treated differently to any other dysmorphia. If you went to your GP and said you wanted your legs amputated, you’d be sent for psychiatric treatment. But those saying that gender dysmorphia should have psychiatric treatment before any further steps are howled down in a hail of “It’s conversion therapy!” I don’t see why one is blindly affirmed and the other is treated as a problem to be addressed.

Oh yeah I totally agree with you there. I don't know when the message of accepting who you are and learning to love your body ever changed so much, especially when you're talking about children, pre teens and teenagers who are notoriously uncomfortable in their own skin especially when puberty starts

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 31/08/2022 11:11

It worries me very much. My autistic 9 year old is gender no confirming but he's still a boy. He's already had adults confusing him by telling him he's a girl.

euphigee · 31/08/2022 11:09

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 10:10

Because if they even start to think that trans isn't real, they have to then face up to the fact that they have taken their barely legal teenager abroad to be castrated and that's all on them.

And, in the case of her from Mermaids, potentially made a career out of pushing an ideology that’s harming children. So you can see why they’re screaming until they’re blue in the face that the emperor very much IS fully clothed, because they have so much to lose.

Yes, this.

MaryraspBerry · 31/08/2022 11:08

'Even when she was two, she said she’s not a little boy.

I went to school with a girl who spent her days pretending she was a horse until she was around 10. Another boy ran up and down the corridors pretending to be a car for a long time too. They didn't let him drink fucking petrol 🙄

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 11:08

I guess people mean there are people born with an over whelming case of body dis-morphia where they are really uncomfortable in their sexed body and want to be the opposite? That's the only thing that makes sense really

What I don’t understand is why gender dysmorphia is treated differently to any other dysmorphia. If you went to your GP and said you wanted your legs amputated, you’d be sent for psychiatric treatment. But those saying that gender dysmorphia should have psychiatric treatment before any further steps are howled down in a hail of “It’s conversion therapy!” I don’t see why one is blindly affirmed and the other is treated as a problem to be addressed.

Seehe · 31/08/2022 11:07

Abigail Shrier who wrote the book Irreversible Damage, said in interviews about children with sexual abuse and autism as being indoctrinated online.

Velvian · 31/08/2022 11:06

YANBU, as a parent of a DD that likes traditionally 'boys' stuff, it is terrifying that someone might be get hold of her and convince her there is something 'wrong' with her.

DD is also awaiting an ASD diagnosis, so a classic case.

When she was born, I was of the opinion that gender stereotypes were on the path towards being quashed. I dressed her in trousers and trainers so she was free to play. Bought books about dinosaurs and space. Had I known that stereotypes were soon to be seen as somehow essential, I think I would have steered down a different path TBH.

AryaStarkWolf · 31/08/2022 11:01

najene · 31/08/2022 10:05

You write of "cases of people being born in the wrong body", but what might this even mean? It's obviously a metaphor: people aren't "in" their bodies the way their heart, lung, cervix or prostate are; nor are they "in" their bodies the way they might be in their bedroom or their place of work ... but what on earth is it a metaphor for?

So far, I haven't come across any attempts to explain this that actually make any sense. Can anyone help?

For full disclosure, I do think "born in the wrong body" is a peculiar kind of nonsense. But if anyone can make any sense of it, perhaps they might like to share their explanation?

If it is, as I suspect, just a simple load of nonsense, it goes without saying that it shouldn't be told to children as though it does make sense. So, no OP, YANBU.

Yeah was going to pick up on that point too, you can't be born in the wrong body, you are your body, it's a ridiculous notion. I guess people mean there are people born with an over whelming case of body dis-morphia where they are really uncomfortable in their sexed body and want to be the opposite? That's the only thing that makes sense really

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:59

So when a new oppressed group came along, we fell over ourselves to demonstrate that a) we weren’t like our predecessors because we wanted everyone to live freely and equally, and b) we were willing to extend rights to anyone who wanted them.

Yes I do think that's playing a part in it and agree with your other points.

I also think the women who the march of trans rights affects most, via the erosion of sex designated spaces (prisoners, abuse victims, orthodox religious) are very low in the pecking order in society, so few actually care that they're being compromised for the new woke cause.

You could say the same for the non neurotypical girls that hugely over represented in those transitioning.

Depressing as hell

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 10:55

YADNBU

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 10:52

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:45

*Seriously this whole trend has gone too far but as the movement is so powerful no one will, or can, argue against them

I honestly cannot fathom how we got to this stage. Can anyone shed any light?

I have a theory that my generation (X), the one before me (post-war Baby Boomers) and subsequent generations look back in horror at the fight for race equality, sex equality and gay equality. We can’t fathom why so many stood against it when it made no difference to them in the grand scheme of things.

So when a new oppressed group came along, we fell over ourselves to demonstrate that a) we weren’t like our predecessors because we wanted everyone to live freely and equally, and b) we were willing to extend rights to anyone who wanted them.

Unfortunately we picked the wrong cause to do this for because it DOES have an effect on another marginalised group - women - so then you get into a “my rights are more important than yours” bunfight, plus the intentions of some of the proponents of trans rights are distinctly shady and self-interested. Throw in people who don’t want to accept that they’ve been wrong or sold a lie, plus a cohort of people who have grown up having everything their own way and who see any obstacle in their way or any opinion other than their own as an existential threat to their very existence and we get…this.

OfficiallyBroken · 31/08/2022 10:52

Trans ideology goes hand in hand with reinforcement of negative and regressive stereotypes. Anyone championing trans ideology is deep down saying that girls/women should be soft, feminine and only like pretty things and boys/men must be strong, masculine and be into sports.

It's fucking nuts and I can't believe that people of reasonable intelligence buy into it.

I was a "masculine" girl. Short hair, BMX, climbing trees, exclusively wore boys clothes, joined the army, hated having periods. At no point in my life did I ever think that made me a boy/man because the message I grew up with was that being my version of me was perfectly fine. Kids now are being bombarded with the message that if they don't confirm with stereotypes they can't possibly be a boy/girl and must be the opposite. How the hell people think this is right I have no idea.

WaveyHair · 31/08/2022 10:49

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:45

*Seriously this whole trend has gone too far but as the movement is so powerful no one will, or can, argue against them

I honestly cannot fathom how we got to this stage. Can anyone shed any light?

I am at a loss. If I made death threat's against someone I would be arrested but somehow they manage to getaway with it by threatening JK Rowling.

It has become a cult..maybe if it stops getting the media attention it will die down a bit but the child grooming going on is just ridiculous.

CatSpeakForDummies · 31/08/2022 10:47

The trouble is that for even well meaning people, who try and stay neutral, it's creating a thing to worry about.

Children who grow up with disordered eating and issues with their bodies around weight can come from families who tried extremely hard to push the healthy eating narrative or from people who allowed their kids to eat badly. The best attitudes are found in people whose parents make good choices without much fuss. The idea you would ask your child regularly if they were happy with their weight would be a sure fire way to make sure that they gave their diet more headspace than was healthy.

Now we have kids being asked ALL THE TIME how they feel inside and how that corresponds to gendered stereotypes. You used to be able to have days where you felt you didn't fit in or noticed you were the only girl in the computing club, without so much weight being put on it.

It's all so unnecessary, it has taken the worries of a tiny group of people, who tended to have grown up in sexist households, and spread it to the whole population.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:45

*Seriously this whole trend has gone too far but as the movement is so powerful no one will, or can, argue against them

I honestly cannot fathom how we got to this stage. Can anyone shed any light?

WaveyHair · 31/08/2022 10:44

They should be getting social services in for child abuse.

Seriously this whole trend has gone too far but as the movement is so powerful no one will, or can, argue against them. Same situation which allowed Jimmy Saville to abuse kids. As he did so much charity work & shook hands with the royals a blind eye was turned by many.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:44

Practically everyone I know was uncomfortable with their changing body, especially from a female perspective having to deal with periods, bras and shaving body hair

Exactly. I was a 32D aged 12 and sure as hell I was uncomfortable with that. That didn't mean I was actually male.

Having said that, this is about two year olds, which is a whole other level of crazy.

Namedifferentorquestion · 31/08/2022 10:41

Exactly
"think we need to normalise feeling uncomfortable with your body as a pre teen/teenager. Practically everyone I know was uncomfortable with their changing body, especially from a female perspective having to deal with periods, bras and shaving body hair etc. If someone had suggested to me I was uncomfortable with it because I was in the wrong body and that there was a way out of the discomfort by transitioning there's a very good chance I'd have taken it."

Namedifferentorquestion · 31/08/2022 10:41

"The problem is that adults that have transitioned then encourage younger children to transition. It's a very wobbly house of cards and it will collapse, we are already seeing 1000 families suing Tavistock/GIDS."

They should also prosecute the parents for allowing the nonsense in the first place.

MustBeThursday · 31/08/2022 10:41

I think we need to normalise feeling uncomfortable with your body as a pre teen/teenager. Practically everyone I know was uncomfortable with their changing body, especially from a female perspective having to deal with periods, bras and shaving body hair etc. If someone had suggested to me I was uncomfortable with it because I was in the wrong body and that there was a way out of the discomfort by transitioning there's a very good chance I'd have taken it.

Yes for a small number of people the discomfort is due to dysphoria but plenty of others it's not.