Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Musti · 31/08/2022 12:56

It is very worrying. Let kids wear whatever clothes they want and do what they enjoy doing and leave it at that. Don’t start complicating it and putting lots of attention to it.

Eduardo is a Tik Tok star who is now a girl and the parents keep posting Tik Tok after Tik Tok about it. How they have 3 daughters etc.

The boy gets lots of attention and is a celebrity purely because he identifies as a girl.

There is another boy Brody who is super camp acting. He’s so young and getting so much attention just from being camp.

I am a girl but when young was very much a tomboy. I had brothers and played with them. I hated my boobs when they came out and envied my brothers flat chests.

My youngest son wore a lot of girls dressing up costumes and tried breastfeeding his dolls. Why? Because he had 2 sisters and played with whatever they played. He enjoyed cooking and crafts but when he saw his dad doing DIY, he would also pretend to do that.

No one questioned or assigned their gender. And I do absolutely believe that there are people who identify as the opposite sex . Whose brains are female or male but their bodies are the opposite sex.

And can you imagine how confusing it is for these kids? So much attention and pressure! I see a lot on tik tok - glamourising lgbt, almost making Hetero seem boring and uncool. I can imagine how a young kid getting really influenced by it. And then once you’ve started and you have your people, it must be hard to change.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:53

That's not to say that people should be able to present as they choose in terms of gender stereotypes

Shouldnt - sorry

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:51

So, we need a real mix of characteristics to define sex.

Look, this is nonsense. At a chromosomal level we are all one sex or another. There is no 'third' option or fluidity. There are DSDs, but they affect the presentation of sex characteristics, they are not indicative of sex being anything other than binary and immutable.

The kind of scientific illiteracy you are spouting isn't helping this debate. We need clarity in arguments, not obfuscation.

That's not to say that people should be able to present as they choose in terms of gender stereotypes, but quite how that applies to two year olds is anyone's guess.

Fladdermus · 31/08/2022 12:50

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/08/2022 12:22

At school? I thought this was no longer allowed.

No not at school thankfully. Out and about. For example once at soft play he can back to me upset and confused as a woman told him he was a girl. He corrected her and told her he was a boy but she she wouldn't have it and told him that he was a girl, because of his long hair.

Topgub · 31/08/2022 12:49

@Eeksteek

Yeah

That's not why we're going to end up with another tory govt.

Beowulfa · 31/08/2022 12:45

If that 10 year old boy is put on puberty blockers, it may result in a micro-penis and fertility issues. If he realises at 16 that he's just a gay lad his future sex life is damaged. If he decides he wants genital surgery; there may not be enough penis to create a fake vagina (essentially an open wound that needs daily maintenance).

This is the blunt reality away from the pouting and glitter. I suspect things will change once US surgeons and parents start getting sued.

Eeksteek · 31/08/2022 12:45

najene · 31/08/2022 10:05

You write of "cases of people being born in the wrong body", but what might this even mean? It's obviously a metaphor: people aren't "in" their bodies the way their heart, lung, cervix or prostate are; nor are they "in" their bodies the way they might be in their bedroom or their place of work ... but what on earth is it a metaphor for?

So far, I haven't come across any attempts to explain this that actually make any sense. Can anyone help?

For full disclosure, I do think "born in the wrong body" is a peculiar kind of nonsense. But if anyone can make any sense of it, perhaps they might like to share their explanation?

If it is, as I suspect, just a simple load of nonsense, it goes without saying that it shouldn't be told to children as though it does make sense. So, no OP, YANBU.

So, I dont know a lot about trans stuff. But I do know about ‘biological sex’. What defines biological sex? Really think about this as a scientific exercise. What?

Chromosomes? Are we chromosome testing these kids? I don’t think we are, but even if we were there are well documented, decades old cases of chromosomes not correlating with physical presentation of sex. WTAF? Really? Yes really. Because genes are just blueprints. On their own, they don’t do anything. They need to be switched on. And some people’s don’t. We don’t know why.

Man. OK, lets look at internal sex organs. They’re pretty important. Ovaries and whatnot. Except they control sex by producing hormones. And some people don’t produce high enough levels of hormones for their chromosomal sex and their appearance to correlate. Hermaphratidism in people happens. Some people have a mix of sexual organs. Some people are born girls, because they don’t have penis’ and that’s as far as anyone looks and then hormones levels surge at puberty and they display male characteristics.

OK then, hormone levels. But they vary widely between people. They are controlled by things that are not sex-dependent. PCOS is super common (like 10% of women, I think?) I have PCOS and the only hormone that’s out of normal range is my testosterone. It’s high. But I’m definitely still female. It affects things like facial hair and weight and stuff, sure, but I still look female, despite an elevated male hormone and some definitely masculine features. Plenty of other hormones can be affected by all kinds of things. They must be, otherwise we couldn’t alter them with medications. Some times, the levels are normal, but some people are more sensitive than others, so even an objective hormone range isn’t definitive.

Bugger. External sex organs? Y’all know blokes with boobs, right? And anyway, they don’t always correspond with chromosomes, which is the ultimate biological sex, even though it isn’t always accurate. So we’ve come full circle.

So, we need a real mix of characteristics to define sex. It’s much more nebulous scientifically than people seem to think. And while wild discrepancies are well documented in the medical literature, as it’s so complex its hardly surprising there are more mild cases of gender fluidity. Because gender is different from sex anyway. It’s not physical, is a societal construct. It’s how we treat people based on their appearance, which is never a good thing, is it?

I don’t really care how people define themselves. I really don’t care who uses what bog. Just don’t piss on the seat. There are massively bigger issues in society. Should we be ensuring children’s health is protected and teens have good mental health support? Hell yes. Should we be protecting women’s spaces and (especially) sporting events? Yep, for sure. Are there likely to be other issues. Yep. Can we solve is without all this hyperbole and hysteria around ‘knowing what a woman is?’ Of course, if people calm down and stop being so childish about it. Are this issues more important for women than stopping the world being run by and for old, rich white men? Nope. Are they part of it? Yep.

So by all means be sceptical about trans people. But don’t claim it’s a scientifically sound position on gender, because it’s not. And don’t claim that it’s feminist position either. It’s a patriarchal strategy to divide and rule, as always. We are going to end up with a patriarchal Tory government (again) because they have successfully convinced the large majority of women that a tiny sub-set of trans women threaten their rights and identity. When the actual problem is, as it always has been, the patriarchy.

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 12:37

This ideology should stop being pushed until basic questions can be answered.

  1. If kids know as young as too then why do they need puberty blockers for extra time to decide at 10/11.
  1. What can a child do as the opposite gender that they cant do whilst being their birth sex?
  1. What have middle aged males ( the predominant cohort of years ago) got in common with todays cohort of predominnatly teenage girls , that means the treatment should be exactly the same.
  1. Why arent trans children worthy of the same level of safguarding ( ie not being put into dangerous positions such as a female changing with males) by the adults around them, as other children?
  1. Why arent trans children worthy of the same level.of healthv care as other kids. Ie- discussion, report taking, monitoring, constant reviewing, accuracy in recording side effects , proof of effectiveness etc
  1. How does a gender identity differ from personality.
  1. Why is a trans child's health care outsourced to non consenting strangers. Whys it one child's job to affirm something they dont believe in , in another child.
  1. What are these identities and how does anyone know they have one..what are the criteria and how does it differ from child who likes/does/wears the same thing but doesn't have a gender identity.
roarfeckingroarr · 31/08/2022 12:36

I'm very worried about this when my DC start school. DP and I are trying to research schools that haven't been captured. Does anyone know of any? I suppose needs to be private but so many of those have been too.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:27

It specifically said, 'avoid discussing sport, because once people discuss sport, they are not going to be persuaded that people can change sex'. (my paraphrasing)

Wow, that's very interesting

I've thought for a while now that sport is where it's all going to come tumbling down.

euphigee · 31/08/2022 12:27

I'd like to try and answer the question as to why things have come to this in the Uk.
I am bringing up my kids( now teens) in a different country on the continent and am also from a different, mixed race background.
One of the things I love and miss about the UK is in my opinion one of the reasons this agenda has taken hold so well( aside from the obvious Anglo Saxon association with to the USA).
The Uk is a flexible country, it is accepting and will quickly modify its customs within a short space of time. A lot of the country will get behind whatever is of the moment, whether it be a new food or a policy. Dietary needs and preferences are catered for, nationwide, hidden disabilities are known about as well as mental health , people can work part-time, change jobs, start up their own businesses with relative ease. There are so many examples, especially when you live somewhere where these things are not available.
If you live in a place where change takes multiple generations, where tradition and religion is so strong and important that to change and adapt takes forever you appreciate lots of things about the Uk.
However, a country that is inflexible also will not allow a movement such as the trans ideology to take hold with such ease. Where primary school classrooms are straight off the Anne of Green Gable's set, and children have to be silent at school and walk in line, it doesn't leave much room for drag queen story time.
I hope that things in the UK sort themselves out regarding this issue. I do believe though that the people who are pushing this agenda have been taking advantage of the good will of a society that is open minded enough to not immediately squash them.

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/08/2022 12:22

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 31/08/2022 11:11

It worries me very much. My autistic 9 year old is gender no confirming but he's still a boy. He's already had adults confusing him by telling him he's a girl.

At school? I thought this was no longer allowed.

Sunnyqueen · 31/08/2022 12:21

SILdidittoo · 31/08/2022 11:26

@Sunnyqueen

What do you mean "born in the wrong body"? Does this just apply to trans people or does it include physically disabled people as well?

As in people who think that because they were born in a female body but should have been born in a man's quite simply or vice versa.
I used that line because it seems to be the go to line trans people use to say how they feel about their dysphoria. My point was I agree that there will be a tiny minority who genuinely do feel that way from birth but not the masses we have now. The ones who do say it no I don't know how they would answer the disability argument and I don't really care either way if they have an argument or not does not affect me in the slightest.

No point trying to argue with me about it I'm very happy in my body always have been, always will be as a straight female.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 12:20

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:06

For whoever asked "how have we go to this" I think it was Keating?

Yup that was me. Appreciate the reply.

The Denton report is chilling. I still can't quite fathom how the strategy worked so well. People are clearly easily manipulated.

There was that document released by the US Trans Law project last year or before too. It was almost a copy of Dentons. It specifically said, 'avoid discussing sport, because once people discuss sport, they are not going to be persuaded that people can change sex'. (my paraphrasing)

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 12:12

Why can't it be talked about? What's so special about this subject that it needs to be sectioned off into a dark little corner so people don't read about what's happening?

Because that cognitive dissonance can only be quietened so many times.

And because every single time this topic is discussed outside of the 'Special dark little corner' those who support gender identity theory unquestioningly, find they cannot answer the questions, cannot provide evidence to support their statements and resort to emotional manipulation, name calling, denigration, slurs and generally any distractive technique they can apply to hide the fact they cannot answer the questions or provide robust evidence beyond ' because it is a kind thing to do'.

Lima1 · 31/08/2022 12:10

www.childlawproject.ie/publications/interim-care-order-for-transgender-teenager/

A case recently in Ireland. I watch these with interest to see where Ireland is going with this madness. Social services were trying to send the child for assessment with a clinical psychologist to assist with the mental health aspect of gender dysphoria.

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 12:06

For whoever asked "how have we go to this" I think it was Keating?

Yup that was me. Appreciate the reply.

The Denton report is chilling. I still can't quite fathom how the strategy worked so well. People are clearly easily manipulated.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/08/2022 11:56

Why can't it be talked about? What's so special about this subject that it needs to be sectioned off into a dark little corner so people don't read about what's happening?

Why indeed.

If someone tells me I shouldn't think or talk about something, I want to know why

Yep.

Topgub · 31/08/2022 11:52

On other sm anything other than complete acceptance of trans ideology is viewed as transphobic and will be banned.

Its very hard to have a rational discussion.

Parents will say things like the op (my toddler knew they were a boy and said the doctor would make them one) and it absolutely cannot be challenged.

Anything other than twaw is not accepted. Its easy to see how people become indoctrinated into that way of thinking.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 31/08/2022 11:52

And being born in the wrong body? What a load of bollocks.

Unless you believe in a soul, how can this actually happen?

Are disabled people born in the wrong body? Ugly people? People with other mental health issues?

If it's not a mental issue and not a physical issue, what is actually being treated by the NHS?

It's a mental health issue being obfuscated by people with a vested interest in the subject.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 11:51

What do you mean "born in the wrong body"? Does this just apply to trans people or does it include physically disabled people as well?

This is never answered.

It is almost like those saying 'born in the wrong body' realise where it goes if you extend it to other groups. And then you have to ask, why is this group treated so very differently, yet demand to be treated as 'just like the sex they feel'.

The dissonance alarms then clang until either they seek to find more information and 'educate' themselves and make up their own mind (because anyone repeating that trope has heard it from someone else) or someone assures them that there is no dissonance here, it was just a temporary glitch.

CuntAmongstThePigeons · 31/08/2022 11:47

For whoever asked "how have we go to this" I think it was Keating? Apologies I'm useless on this and can never remember how to quote or tag people.

But check out the Denton report, very illuminating

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 31/08/2022 11:46

I've got a 4-year-old boy that sometimes insists he's a girl. If I was one of those parents I could quickly agree and push him towards being trans and he wouldn't know any better.

Do you know why he thinks he's a girl? Because he has an older sister he idolises and likes to try on all her pretty outfits. Who wouldn't want to wear a swirly skirt and paint their face with makeup when they are 4? It's fun to play dress-up.

It's horrifying that there are a lot of people who are going along with this because they think it's harmless and anyone questioning is being mean and transphobic. It's anything but harmless, it's just they haven't had to face the reality of what this ideology does yet.

It needs talking about and all the people that try and shut down conversation should really think about why. Why can there be multiple threads about Meghan Markle, parking, MILs, etc but when trans is mentioned everyone needs to shut up and go away?

Why can't it be talked about? What's so special about this subject that it needs to be sectioned off into a dark little corner so people don't read about what's happening?

If someone tells me I shouldn't think or talk about something, I want to know why.

Helleofabore · 31/08/2022 11:45

SidewaysOtter · 31/08/2022 10:52

I have a theory that my generation (X), the one before me (post-war Baby Boomers) and subsequent generations look back in horror at the fight for race equality, sex equality and gay equality. We can’t fathom why so many stood against it when it made no difference to them in the grand scheme of things.

So when a new oppressed group came along, we fell over ourselves to demonstrate that a) we weren’t like our predecessors because we wanted everyone to live freely and equally, and b) we were willing to extend rights to anyone who wanted them.

Unfortunately we picked the wrong cause to do this for because it DOES have an effect on another marginalised group - women - so then you get into a “my rights are more important than yours” bunfight, plus the intentions of some of the proponents of trans rights are distinctly shady and self-interested. Throw in people who don’t want to accept that they’ve been wrong or sold a lie, plus a cohort of people who have grown up having everything their own way and who see any obstacle in their way or any opinion other than their own as an existential threat to their very existence and we get…this.

There is a great deal of truth in this otter!

ThickCutSteakChips · 31/08/2022 11:43

Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/08/2022 11:40

Children are being used to legitimise and sanitize the life choices of adults.

Why else would children need to be made sexless and sterile and lifelong medical patients, yet adult males can say they are 'women' without changing a thing about themselves and most keep their fully functioning penis and can still reproduce.

Why would any adult think performing a radical double mastectomy on a healthy teens breasts or a hysterectomy which they know will cause long term damage by putting a women though menopause so young. (Bones, brain function, heart health etc etc etc etc), would be a better option than helping the teen come to terms with their sexed body by actually finding, the causes of their dysphoria and mental distress?

They also conveniently ignore that the majority of children who present with dysphoria actually grow out of it. The 'cure' is the very puberty they want to opt out of. You know, the natural, normal process of the body and brain maturing.

Excellent post.