Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry about transgender ideology being pushed on kids

309 replies

HopefulRose · 31/08/2022 09:31

Noella McHaher is a ten year old model whose parents said she “self identified” as a girl at the age of two. Her parents are also trans.

If my two year old identified as a smoker, I wouldn’t allow them cigarettes. Why is this movement so hellbent on putting children into boxes instead of letting them just grow up without defined labels?

Speaking generally, there is a link between children who “hate” their biological sex and child abuse. Children who have been SA sometimes self harm as a way of trying to prevent further abuse. I’m worried that these signs are being missed.

am I alone on this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Velvian · 03/09/2022 20:33

That is a well articulated letter @Helleofabore . Thank you for sharing.

Helleofabore · 02/09/2022 14:02

This is a good request from a concerned group of clinicians:

www.bmj.com/content/378/bmj.o2016/rr

Tavistock to face possible clinical negligence claims over gender identity service

Published 12 August 2022

The section I found most interesting is this:

The origin of poor governance and lack of data collection needs to be openly addressed as GIDS is not unique. Globally, there are significant difficulties in discussing, let alone challenging, the practice of gender clinics, due to the belief systems of those who adhere to gender identity theory – a non-clinical ideological perspective for which there is little to no empirical support. This position requires clinicians to believe that everyone has an innate, subjective gender identity and that individuals whose bodies do not match this should be provided with ‘gender-affirming’ medical interventions regardless of the harms and lack of evidence of benefit (6,7,8). However, a child or adolescent’s sense of gender is part of a complex inner sense of self that can change during the process of development. Medicalising young people on the basis of unsubstantiated theory is unethical: there are many reasons why they might feel dysphoria, disgust, dissociated or ‘cut off’ from their physical bodies, including internalised homophobia, histories of trauma, cognitive difficulties and mental health problems. Each person suffering from such distress requires space and time to understand their feelings.

Offering puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and radical surgery with the implicit promise of almost magical transformation may cause, and has caused, serious harms. With inadequate follow up by GIDS, no comprehensive long-term observational studies, and no reliable clinical trial data, there is simply no evidence on which to base these interventions (2,6,7,8). It is unsurprising that ‘detransitioners’ (disillusioned people who wish to reverse the effects of ‘treatments’) are coming forward; some may want legal redress and plaintiffs’ firms are seeking them out (9). Without outcome information - let alone understanding how any pre-pubertal child could make a decision to alienate adult functions they cannot understand (like sexual pleasure) - patients and their parents were never in a position to give properly informed consent to uncontrolled experimental interventions (6) clinicians failed to properly describe. These initial cases may herald more as increasing numbers of patients, parents and clinicians question the so-called ‘affirmative model’.

We would advise that the NHS proactively set up clinical services to support detransitioners, and that the NHS Litigation Authority and Medical Defence Organisations prepare. The government should look closely at materials provided by advocacy groups (such as Stonewall, Mermaids, Gendered Intelligence, and others) that teach children and clinicians (e.g. GPs, nurses, medical students and mental health professionals) gender identity theory as if it is fact, without referencing the concerns and uncertainties in the evidence. Until this is addressed young people will be at increased risk of misinterpreting their complex difficulties as proof they are ‘trans’ and believing there are simple and medical solutions to their distress.

Well,... that is most of the letter.

TheKeatingFive · 02/09/2022 12:27

seem to enjoy the "being brave, different and special" plaudits that come their way for being the parent of a trans child.

Quite. It's staggering that people would put the cool points ahead of children's welfare but there you have it.

SidewaysOtter · 02/09/2022 12:20

LuftBalloons · 02/09/2022 09:41

I always think about Munchhausens by Proxy in these sorts of cases. I’ve heard therapists talk (in general terms) about this as well.

Even if it's not MBP, some parents - and I'm thinking of at least one person I know of - seem to enjoy the "being brave, different and special" plaudits that come their way for being the parent of a trans child. Not only that, but being some sort of "representative of trans people" that others can flock round to prove their TQ+ Ally credentials.

Cynical, me? Hmm

BitossiBlues · 02/09/2022 12:13

LuftBalloons · 02/09/2022 09:41

I always think about Munchhausens by Proxy in these sorts of cases. I’ve heard therapists talk (in general terms) about this as well.

I was listening to a podcast the other day, and the person speaking claimed the number of MBP cases have gone down just as the number of parents (particularly mothers) affirming their GNC children's identities (and all the treatments that come with it) has risen. Wish I could remember who it was who said it. I'd be interested to know if this is actually true.

Helleofabore · 02/09/2022 11:51

I was watching this yesterday and I thought it was quite fitting for this thread. From about half way through I guess, it covers children and 'gender'. Both from a transitioned female having the baby and 'not' pushing a 'gender' onto the child as that is for them to work out in the future, to a mother who watched a Netflix show with a NB person and suggested to her 11 year old daughter who did not like 'girly' things that her (at the time suggested the child was still a 'she') twin sister did, that this might be why.

If you do watch this, and watch that 11 year old, notice just how distressed they are. I don't think it is just being on national TV in a programme that will be watched internationally... I suspect there is a lot more to that distress.

By the way, the man in the video thumbnail is not trans at all and discusses it. It is Christian Wilkins and he wears dresses.

LuftBalloons · 02/09/2022 09:41

I always think about Munchhausens by Proxy in these sorts of cases. I’ve heard therapists talk (in general terms) about this as well.

JimTheShit · 02/09/2022 00:18

TheKeatingFive · 31/08/2022 10:25

This is worth a read

pitt.substack.com/p/true-believer

Wow, that’s quite the read. Luckily the mother in this story had the ability to realise the harm she was doing to her sons. I fear that most parents who force this type of ideology on their child would merely double down than actually admit they were wrong.

AmyandPhilipfan · 02/09/2022 00:09

I've only been home educating a year and have come across two children who want to be the opposite sex, which is quite a high proportion of a relatively small group of kids we've come across. I'm not sure if this means it's more rife in the home educating community as a whole though as there are also a lot more children who are allowed to express themselves in a non stereotypical way, while still saying they are the correct sex. For example, about two thirds of the home educated boys I've met have long hair.

apintortwo · 01/09/2022 23:13

I'm very worried about this when my DC start school. DP and I are trying to research schools that haven't been captured. Does anyone know of any? I suppose needs to be private but so many of those have been too

Homeschooling seems to be one of the only safe alternatives nowadays, although obviously not everyone has the funds or time to commit to this

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 23:03

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 17:06

So I expect that has something to do with it. I can't say it's not a worry.

I hope he starts to feel better about it soon. In my experience, discomfort with changing teenage bodies is such a natural thing to go through. It's only now that the idea of being a difference gender is entering people's heads.

As a previous poster said the process of going through puberty itself is thought to make a huge difference to acceptance.

Thank you so much. He is my eldest so my first experience of parenting a teen. I do hope he feels more comfortable with his body in the next few years. It's such a fine line of accepting how they want to identify yet not accepting a lot of the nonsense around it. I fully accept how he may want to dress, how his appearance is, even the name he wants to be called (he has a female name that I think some of his friends use sometimes and he's told me what it is but hasn't asked me to use it.) But transwomen are not women and he can never become a girl/woman.

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 22:54

najene · 01/09/2022 16:21

Thanks for the reply. I do feel for you; it must be a real worry.

Indeed, people wish for all sorts of things that aren't - often could not be - real. One of the difficulties we have to deal with currently is people telling children that some of these things, not only are real, but even are capable of attainment.

It does seem a peculiarly horrible - immoral - thing to do, to tell children that a wish to change sex is not only a sensible and possibly justified desire, but one that is capable of being fulfilled. Because it isn't, it isn't and it isn't.

We can deal with small children and their childish desires to be so-and-so (one of mine wanted to be a bat, for quite a while). It's a hard and terrible thing, though, imo, to encourage a child to take any such impossible desire seriously, particularly given how things may turn out these days, sterilisation, surgery, drugs and so on.

I do hope you and your DS find a safe way through all the contemporary complications and it turns out well for him. You being sensible about it all will surely be a big help for him. Good luck!

Thank you so much.

And I completely agree. I have made it very clear to my DS that no matter how much he wants to be a girl, he can never be one. And he understands that. I have told him he is free to dress the way he wants etc etc.

He hasn't expressed a desire for anything medical. It would be a very firm no from me.

He has definitely read/been told certain things that I find quite dubious. For example he thought there was a 'male brain' and a 'female brain' and wondered if he had a 'female brain'. I sent him lots of things to read about this, which to be fair to him, he is very open to learning more about it even if it contradicts what he has read/been told.

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 22:42

AryaStarkWolf · 01/09/2022 14:47

Isn't the statistic that coming out the other side of puberty resolves this discomfort in like 80%+ of cases? Hopefully that will be the case with your son

I hope so.

apintortwo · 01/09/2022 22:32

This is an interesting analisis of the Denton's report

www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists

The sheer scale of the whole thing, a top international Law firm, a media giant influencing governments globally under the radar and succeeding? Where's the money coming from for such a mammoth initiative? Something doesn't add up

WaveyHair · 01/09/2022 17:31

I have a friend whose (younger) teenager daughter is getting counselling due to the trans pressure. Right now she does not know if, as her parent put it, she is female/male/it.

There is a real push from peers and society that kids must jump on this bandwagon and choose some form of gender identity before they are ready.

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 17:07

It does seem a peculiarly horrible - immoral - thing to do, to tell children that a wish to change sex is not only a sensible and possibly justified desire, but one that is capable of being fulfilled. Because it isn't, it isn't and it isn't.

The lying about it is the rotten core of all this.

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 17:06

So I expect that has something to do with it. I can't say it's not a worry.

I hope he starts to feel better about it soon. In my experience, discomfort with changing teenage bodies is such a natural thing to go through. It's only now that the idea of being a difference gender is entering people's heads.

As a previous poster said the process of going through puberty itself is thought to make a huge difference to acceptance.

HopefulRose · 01/09/2022 16:56

Musti · 01/09/2022 12:04

That’s how I feel. I’m used to being the one defending people. I’m an activist and have always supported any movement that I think discriminates against people.

And of course I’ve supported adults who are trans.

But I really don’t understand how kids are being allowed to make such life changing decisions before they’re adults. I don’t personally understand the pronoun thing and I also don’t understand the attachment of sex/gender to clothes for example. Clothes are just fashion and throughout history people have worn skirts or dresses or make up of both sexes. Long hair and short hair - both sexes. It’s a social thing and whilst before only men wore trousers, women now do and doesn’t mean anything.

Having raised 2 kids of each sex, I can see how little difference there is between the sexes in terms of interests and personality. What they are influenced by is their peers and the world they are raised in.

You’ve summarised exactly how I’m feeling.

Hoping at some point a sensible politician will come along and articulate this into policy to stop children being pressured or funnelled into a making life changing decisions needlessly.

OP posts:
najene · 01/09/2022 16:21

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 14:27

It is just a feeling. It doesn't have any meaning in reality. But my DS wishes that his body was female. People think/feel/wish all sorts of things that aren't real.

Thanks for the reply. I do feel for you; it must be a real worry.

Indeed, people wish for all sorts of things that aren't - often could not be - real. One of the difficulties we have to deal with currently is people telling children that some of these things, not only are real, but even are capable of attainment.

It does seem a peculiarly horrible - immoral - thing to do, to tell children that a wish to change sex is not only a sensible and possibly justified desire, but one that is capable of being fulfilled. Because it isn't, it isn't and it isn't.

We can deal with small children and their childish desires to be so-and-so (one of mine wanted to be a bat, for quite a while). It's a hard and terrible thing, though, imo, to encourage a child to take any such impossible desire seriously, particularly given how things may turn out these days, sterilisation, surgery, drugs and so on.

I do hope you and your DS find a safe way through all the contemporary complications and it turns out well for him. You being sensible about it all will surely be a big help for him. Good luck!

AryaStarkWolf · 01/09/2022 14:47

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 14:39

I'm really not sure. But he said he wants people to think he is a girl. So I think he'd like the physical characteristics of a teen girl.

He doesn't seem to be drawn to female stereotypical behaviour nor does he dress in stereotypical female clothes.

I commented saying it must be hard for him going through puberty when his body is doing things he doesn't it to do and he agreed with that.

I think it is a teen exploring his identity. He has 2 friends who are also trans and they are all autistic. As an autistic boy he never joined in with the rough and tumble of boys (too loud). He has always played a lot with girls (although quieter boys too) and his best friend is a girl. So I expect that has something to do with it. I can't say it's not a worry.

Isn't the statistic that coming out the other side of puberty resolves this discomfort in like 80%+ of cases? Hopefully that will be the case with your son

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 14:39

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 14:30

But my DS wishes that his body was female.

Having never been female, I don't know how he would know that.

Do you think he means that he's drawn towards female stereotypical behaviours?

Or that he's uncomfortable in some way in his body (even though he can hardly compare that to being in a female body because he's never been in one)?

I'm really not sure. But he said he wants people to think he is a girl. So I think he'd like the physical characteristics of a teen girl.

He doesn't seem to be drawn to female stereotypical behaviour nor does he dress in stereotypical female clothes.

I commented saying it must be hard for him going through puberty when his body is doing things he doesn't it to do and he agreed with that.

I think it is a teen exploring his identity. He has 2 friends who are also trans and they are all autistic. As an autistic boy he never joined in with the rough and tumble of boys (too loud). He has always played a lot with girls (although quieter boys too) and his best friend is a girl. So I expect that has something to do with it. I can't say it's not a worry.

TheKeatingFive · 01/09/2022 14:30

But my DS wishes that his body was female.

Having never been female, I don't know how he would know that.

Do you think he means that he's drawn towards female stereotypical behaviours?

Or that he's uncomfortable in some way in his body (even though he can hardly compare that to being in a female body because he's never been in one)?

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 14:27

najene · 31/08/2022 13:17

I'm not really trying to argue with you. But you say "born in a woman's body but should have been born in a man's" as though it means something ("quite simply"), when I can't make head nor tail of it.

If I was born in a woman's body, then anyone born in a man's body is someone else and not me. So what I am I to make of "I should have been born in a man's body"?

... This seems to be the same as saying, "I should not have been me." But, really, if this is so, what am I to make of it? "I am me" is something that cannot be false: "I am not me" looks like a mistake (a grammatical mistake, in all likelihood, given the connection between "I" and "me" in grammar), so likewise "I should not have been me" just makes no sense at all.

Do you see?

It is just a feeling. It doesn't have any meaning in reality. But my DS wishes that his body was female. People think/feel/wish all sorts of things that aren't real.

UndertheCedartree · 01/09/2022 14:19

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/08/2022 12:37

This ideology should stop being pushed until basic questions can be answered.

  1. If kids know as young as too then why do they need puberty blockers for extra time to decide at 10/11.
  1. What can a child do as the opposite gender that they cant do whilst being their birth sex?
  1. What have middle aged males ( the predominant cohort of years ago) got in common with todays cohort of predominnatly teenage girls , that means the treatment should be exactly the same.
  1. Why arent trans children worthy of the same level of safguarding ( ie not being put into dangerous positions such as a female changing with males) by the adults around them, as other children?
  1. Why arent trans children worthy of the same level.of healthv care as other kids. Ie- discussion, report taking, monitoring, constant reviewing, accuracy in recording side effects , proof of effectiveness etc
  1. How does a gender identity differ from personality.
  1. Why is a trans child's health care outsourced to non consenting strangers. Whys it one child's job to affirm something they dont believe in , in another child.
  1. What are these identities and how does anyone know they have one..what are the criteria and how does it differ from child who likes/does/wears the same thing but doesn't have a gender identity.

For my DS the only thing I can get from him is he wants people to think he is a girl.

GroggyLegs · 01/09/2022 13:18

Also going back to the OP...

Making it financially advantageous to transition young children is fraught with problems - something they shouldn't be touching with a barge pole.

I agree wholeheartedly.
We know detransition is a thing, but how can this child voice that? All eyes on them, representing, adulation, money being made.

How can a little child say 'this isn't what I want anymore' when they've got a work contract, publicity & their family are invested in their trans-ness?

I'm NOT saying hide them in a closet before anyone starts, I'm saying this kind of exposure & the associated pressure is not healthy.