Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be actually really worried about you? NHS related

282 replies

Itsonthestairs · 31/08/2022 00:32

As a highly skilled NHS nurse of 15 years I had to leave my job due to the stress and not being able to provide the care I wanted to, I was burnt out following covid (my mum died), I have definaly save a fair few lifes in my clinical time, I loved my job and I was good at it (emergency department background). Reading the posts on MN has really upset me recently, the disrespect, dislike and darn right hatred for healthcare professionals really worries me. My friends are on their knees and this abuse doesn't help, people are getting crap care because there is no staff and this awful attitude is just adding fuel to the fire. I'm really worried about you, me and our families future healthcare.

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 31/08/2022 07:27

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

The Dutch system is very good. It is a compulsory insurance based system where existing conditions and age are not taken into account.

Premiums are around €1400/year with a cap on individual costs of around €400/year per adult. There are various income related allowances etc for low income households. Children are covered by their parents' policy.

This has to be seen in the context of other taxation and welfare policies.

The Dutch system also has to be seen in the context of Dutch attitudes to personal responsibilty for health. My experience of the Netherlands was that people were generally healthy and health conscious.

In the UK A&E and the Police are the services of last resort. People turn to these services because they cant get help elsewhere.

IMO the problem is not the funding of these front line resources but the lack of support for mental health, addiction and chronic physical health problems. If these problems were supported properly and effectively then we would see far fewer people turning to accute services in a crisis.

Providing proper support mental health, addiction and chronic physical health problems is unglamorous. Tends not to have quick fix results. Doesnt provide politicians of any hue with good photo opportunities.

kateandme · 31/08/2022 07:26

And i know there might bevthe best of excuses for staff behaving shorter or seeemingly less caring.but this also isn't the ill person's fault. And in there most desperate bearing the brunt of this mood isn't nice no matter the valid excuses.

BirmaBrite · 31/08/2022 07:25

Also the UK doesn't appear to have a fabulous track record when it comes to the privatisation of anything, when you consider value for money and customer experience.
Social care is for the most part privatised, it is in crisis, not enough staff, not enough beds and especially very few true rehab or step down beds, this has had a massive impact on the functioning of the NHS and especially emergency care and the Ambulance services.
If there are no social care beds or care packages available outside the NHS, remember that the NHS and social care are two completely seperate entities, then people can not be moved home or to another setting. If they can't be moved, then the bed remains taken and someone in a cubicle ( once they are lucky enough to get to that point ) or the back of an ambulance, cannot then go into that bed.
The NHS runs its bed capacity very high all the time, and during periods like Winter, dangerously high, so there is literally no slack in the system ever and unlike private hospitals, has to take everyone.
Reenablement teams ( social services) and home from hospital teams ( NHS) are tiny in comparison to the demographic they are expected to support in most geographical areas. They work really well for those medically fit but who just need a bit of short term support to get back to living independently.
We also used to have teams who worked trying to prevent unneccessary admissions to hospital, these seem to have fallen out of favour, but if you work in the NHS you see things come back around, so who know's, some bright spark might decide its worth funding that again ?

kateandme · 31/08/2022 07:23

Itsonthestairs · 31/08/2022 01:29

I'm really sorry you had such a terrible time today. It not acceptable, care and comparison is at the heart of nursing. I can only apologise and I hope you are feeling better soon

There are crap people in life though.spme really nasty people.some unfortunately make it the the nhs. It does and will happen moreso now.therd is less means testing,less funding and bother to eek the horrible out.
This sadly has been going on for years in mental health and social care amd vulnerable sectors.because it's an underfunded under cared for sector(comparatively) and the ones who are evil,seek power and are horrid have known they can get away with it in mental health units and care. That's why there has been so much abuse. I know of and have witnessed the most horrid of staff in those places.it would make people shiver if they saw them in ordinary wards.
But there are still nasty people.they do exist in nhs.
And as tho vs get worse this will become more common.

The ones that get it right are magnificiant.but ignoring the too often evil isn't and hasn't helped.especially to our most vulnerable.and people won't believe it enough until they seen or experienced it.

BluOcty · 31/08/2022 07:21

Some of the recent threads have been very ott. I mean there are ways to say you had a very poor experience without calling staff awful names.

The NHS is on its knees due to lack of funding but other factors like poor staff planning. But I honestly think people are super stressed out and anxious about the energy and food costs crisis and that is also coming out in mn posts. I know mn can be harsh but there seems to have been a change of tone.

Cloudonthemountains · 31/08/2022 07:19

Bexblue · 31/08/2022 02:51

Mrs Haversham. You should always be grateful .stuff happens that's life .ull miss it when it's gone and you have to pay to breathe

This attitude doesn't help improve the NHS. I've worked in it for over 30 years. Polarising it as either an untouchable monument or completely awful will not bring about desperately needed change (particularly the former view).

The NHS isn't working in its current form. I've seen so many reorganisations over time, it's endless, and it's an industry in itself, costing the taxpayer billions over the years. I truly think the time has come to look at other European models of care.

One tiny example. I'm having an investigation today (MRI). I'll be seen on time and will have my results in my hand before going home. A process which takes 3 - 4 weeks in the UK (routine scan to receiving results). I could give so many more examples, but the reality is we do need fundamental change in how services are delivered. I don't think any political party will dare to do it though, it'll just be an endless cycle of throwing money at it with no accountability for improved standards and outcomes, or austerity.

ChagSameachDoreen · 31/08/2022 07:17

LikeAStar1994 · 31/08/2022 01:46

I'm not one of them, OP.

Those who are hurling abuse are pond scum which is why I often refer to this place as Scumsnet

Flowers

And yet here you are.

WhoAre · 31/08/2022 07:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

HarlanPepper · 31/08/2022 07:11

I've seen both sides. My dad died a week after a cardiac arrest last year and most of the nursing care he received, and the support we as his family received, was compassionate and sensitive. On the other hand, my mum has recently was an inpatient for a few days following an operation to remove half her colon. She's a retired nurse herself, and commented how different nursing care is now. No-one touched her the entire time she was there, for example (except to do a nasal swab for Covid), or really spoke to her at all. Without exception, everyone I spoke to on the phone on the first couple of days was rude and abrupt - it was made very clear to me that I was wasting their time.

fishonabicycle · 31/08/2022 07:10

Privatisation has worked so well for the railways and utilities, hasn't it? 🙄

rnsaslkih · 31/08/2022 07:10

Oxborn · 31/08/2022 06:55

We don’t all behave like that, i for one only have positive and praise for our amazing health care people

Whilst this sounds very kind, I wonder if people who think like this accept that the NHS is actually broken and something major needs to be done to overhaul it. Both for patients and HCPs. The op was extremely stressed and not able to provide the care she wanted to. We need to accept the problem or it cannot start to be fixed.

i would also say that thinking about the widespread abuse, disrespect etc - that is not because people are bastards. Only a minority of people are bastards. The rest of us are just ordinary and mainly decent and have become frustrated at the extreme difficulty to get care. Minor and major examples.

iloveeverykindofcat · 31/08/2022 07:10

My father died due to medical negligence combined with institutional racism. Really - my mother sued and won - a substantial sum. That's incredibly difficult and shows that his cause of death was unambiguous. That was nearly 30 years ago. I've never been overly impressed with the NHS. It did save my life after a freak accident. But I mean...shouldn't it? Isn't that what its supposed to do?

Phos · 31/08/2022 07:07

Unfortunately apart from a couple of very nice GPs (back in the days when you could see one) I’ve experienced nothing but poor care from the NHS. My community midwife and the experience I had in hospital giving birth were dreadful enough that had we had a second I would have temporarily relocated to go to a private maternity facility. That’s just one example. I now avoid the NHS wherever possible.

There are massive issues with layers of unnecessary management and “woke” roles. There is dire need for reform but the NHS was turned into this golden cow that can’t be criticised, and the clapping didn’t help with that. Maybe the tide is turning.

There are probably good people who go into the profession to help but in my school, the ones who studied medicine (or med related degrees like radiology) either did it for prestige or because their parents told them to and the lasses who did nursing werent academic enough to do something else so just fell into it.

EtnaVesuvius · 31/08/2022 07:07

Damnyouconscience · 31/08/2022 07:00

Sorry, what?! Pond scum? For having a bad experience and daring to speak up about it?

Just because you’ve been lucky enough to not be in that position, doesn’t give you the right to call people who have ‘pond scum’. That’s absolutely disgusting. If you’d been in a position like some people of being in pain for 10+ hours and not being given pain relief, or something similar, I’ve no doubt you’d be feeling the same as a lot of people too. Have some bloody compassion.

@Damnyouconscience I agree.

@LikeAStar1994 - you’d do well to read the post above where someone’s mother died after days of neglect.

Is she ‘pond scum’ for complaining? Or should she just suck it up?

One of the most horrible posts I’ve seen on MN.

Onceuponatimethen · 31/08/2022 07:05

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle Sad

Onceuponatimethen · 31/08/2022 07:05

@Damnyouconscience well said

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 31/08/2022 07:04

QueenCamilla · 31/08/2022 01:02

I was getting "crap care" in A&E BECAUSE of the crap nurses. Humanoid uncaring creatures. There were plenty of them around and not one with a chance to give me some pain relief (apparently ain't a moment for that in the 13h I was there) or triage despite me being in acute visible distress.

Only strange how it all appeared (plus a cup of sweet tea, somewhere to lie down on, my first triage and even a Doctor ) when I called for an ambulance from the waiting room...

It's not finance that's the issue with the NHS - it's the fact that no one cares! Lessons will be learnt and all that....

Privatise. The crap nurses would lose their jobs and everyone would benefit (including the remaining employees).

I would have virulently disagreed with your post until I too had to call 999 from a hospital ward for my mother. I did not expect my mother to be close to death from dehydration and casual neglect

Damnyouconscience · 31/08/2022 07:00

LikeAStar1994 · 31/08/2022 01:46

I'm not one of them, OP.

Those who are hurling abuse are pond scum which is why I often refer to this place as Scumsnet

Flowers

Sorry, what?! Pond scum? For having a bad experience and daring to speak up about it?

Just because you’ve been lucky enough to not be in that position, doesn’t give you the right to call people who have ‘pond scum’. That’s absolutely disgusting. If you’d been in a position like some people of being in pain for 10+ hours and not being given pain relief, or something similar, I’ve no doubt you’d be feeling the same as a lot of people too. Have some bloody compassion.

Sistanotcista · 31/08/2022 07:00

CheapBeersFilledwithCrocodileTears · 31/08/2022 01:33

Well… you’ve got seven comments so far, and two are from people with legitimate reasons to feel like they got short shrift from NHS staff. Of course they’re smart enough to know it’s not all NHS staff, but if your only NHS experience in the last, say, 12 months, was a bad one, or if all your experiences in the last 12 months have been bad ones, you can only speak to what makes up a majority of your experiences and hypothesize about the rest. These commenters can only say: “100% of my recent NHS experiences have been terrible; it is possible that a majority of NHS nurses are good, but I am unable to tell that based on my experience.” I think calling that an awful attitude is way more than a bit unfair. BUT you’re stressed and burned out and you see it from your point of view. Not from the point of view of a patient who was mistreated in A&E by a nurse who didn’t seem to care and is in tears, but hasn’t put in a complaint. I’m sorry your job is taking such a toll on you, OP, truly. But I’m also very sorry for @crabcakesalad and @QueenCamilla

The NHS needs better management and a complete revamp. But we need a private-public hybrid model. Privatization just can not the answer. Because if people think they can’t afford fuel this winter, wait until they have to pay for health insurance to the tune of a few extra hundred pounds up to a thousand pounds every month, it doesn’t cover everything AND you have to pay for prescriptions separately and extra for surgeries and extra as a deductible at the beginning of the year and…

This is brilliantly put.

pinkstripeycat · 31/08/2022 07:00

QueenCamilla · Today 01:02

100% agree

A&E. I was told to take DS3 home without treatment, during an asthma attack as the diagnosis was that he was tired! He was “yawning” (common symptom when breathless) to get air in not because he was tired.
All the time the staff were in groups laughing and chatting and eating cake

BirmaBrite · 31/08/2022 06:59

I don't know how the UK would be able to introduce a European model. To have a similar model to Germany, the UK would need 400,000 more doctors, and Germany has consistently invested in better and more resources like hospitals/imaging/scanners etc.
The UK subsidises peoples wages with UC, so they barely have just enough to live on, any talk of increasing wages is met with howls of protest from businesses as unaffordable, so how are they going to be able to afford to pay for private medical insurance for all their employees ?

Oxborn · 31/08/2022 06:55

We don’t all behave like that, i for one only have positive and praise for our amazing health care people

70billionthnamechange · 31/08/2022 06:54

Some medical professionals are shit , some are amazing. I don't think many people say they're all shit, but just relay incidents where they've felt as such. Try not to take it personally. And thanks for all you do (did)

ImustLearn2Cook · 31/08/2022 06:48

I remember when someone I was with who was taken to hospital in an ambulance at their 20 week scan where she found out the sex of her baby and there was something wrong with the heart rate of the baby.

Nurses at the hospital told her she was probably going to lose the baby but wasn’t pregnant enough to go to the maternity unit. And she started crying at the thought of losing her baby and they laughed at her. Even worse was when one of those nurses walked passed her with a different nurse, whispered in her ear then pointed at pregnant friend and both laughed and sniggered while staring right at her as they passed her.

It was outright bullying and nasty. And no matter how hard you work, or important your job is does not put you above reproach or exempt from deserved criticism.

Oh, and there are other jobs just as important and hard working and are caring roles. Workplace bullying shouldn’t be tolerated in any job and patients or clients who are vulnerable should be protected, along with the employees who are doing the right thing.

Sunshineday2 · 31/08/2022 06:41

I don't really get our country's obsession with 'being grateful'. I have had some good care from the NHS and some not so good.
My mum died last year alone after some horrific 'care' from everyone she came across. Starting with the paramedics who said she was wasting time and there was nothing wrong with her, to the night she spent on a trolley in a&e in her own urine because no one came when she called, to the week she spent shivering because her body was shutting down and no one would bring her another blanket....the day she was transferred to another hospital and given no food or liquid throughout the day because everyone thought someone else had done it...despite her pleas. Died the next day. No, I don't feel grateful anymore. I think a European private style would probably work better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread