Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be actually really worried about you? NHS related

282 replies

Itsonthestairs · 31/08/2022 00:32

As a highly skilled NHS nurse of 15 years I had to leave my job due to the stress and not being able to provide the care I wanted to, I was burnt out following covid (my mum died), I have definaly save a fair few lifes in my clinical time, I loved my job and I was good at it (emergency department background). Reading the posts on MN has really upset me recently, the disrespect, dislike and darn right hatred for healthcare professionals really worries me. My friends are on their knees and this abuse doesn't help, people are getting crap care because there is no staff and this awful attitude is just adding fuel to the fire. I'm really worried about you, me and our families future healthcare.

OP posts:
cakewench · 31/08/2022 15:31

I really do mean this kindly as I am a massive fan of the NHS (originally from the USA and have lived in other countries as well so I have experienced a few systems). However:

We see posts here ALL THE TIME from NHS nurses and other staff (but often seems to be nursing?) about how bad the bullying behaviour is and how hard it is to work in some wards because of the behaviour of other staff towards each other.

Well, how do you think those bullies are treating their patients? And why on earth should we not complain about it?

LindsayStauffer · 31/08/2022 15:21

lampygirl · 31/08/2022 14:48

@Topgub Tescos not having the right flavour of breaded chicken is ‘an inconvenience’. Repeatedly being sent between services and thus having a wall put up in front of care you are told you need at the place you’ve been sent to receive it is not ‘an inconvenience’ it’s downright poor treatment and potentially dangerous. You’d think by the second time you’d gone back maybe the two services could ring each other and thrash it out, and direct the patient to an agreed service, not just one say ‘go to this place’ and one say ‘nope, go back to the first place’ ad Infinitum. This has been going on for me for over a fortnight now, and I have managed to not get abusive at all but I am getting to the end of my tether and there does not seem to be a resolution. If I’d come to your service, how would you handle it. Because if you would just shrug your shoulders at me like the staff I’ve dealt with them sorry but that is not good service.

As I have said, I do not condone abuse at all, and I have not been abusive to staff. What I said is I can see how people who are scared, desperate and in pain will not react as per an average human being in those situations. It’s the same way I don’t condone GBH but I’d fully understand why someone might twat a burglar in their bedroom at night round the head with a table lamp when they felt scared, threatened and had had their home violated. That’s an understanding of how others might react to a situation, it’s not encouraging it or thinking it’s OK

Nuance is lost on many.

The NHS definitely needs to invest in conflict resolution training for its nurses. Witnessed so many instances where a confused, upset patient getting a little bit irritated is met with escalation by a nurse. Raised voice, getting louder, increasing the tension, starting to tell the patient (who isn't shouting or being aggressive) not to get aggressive. I've experienced it myself (over the phone, I politely challenged their assessment of something and was told that if I raised my voice they'd end the call... I hadn't, and they did). Some patients go in and act like dicks to innocent nurses but sadly some go in and are perfectly polite and civil, just experiencing normal human emotions, and are then escalated by nurses who completely abuse their power. In healthcare you don't tolerate abuse but you do sometimes expect and understand that someone who's just lost their spouse or whose been given a terminal diagnosis or who has witnessed a traumatic accident might be a bit shirty or prickly and you need to be trained to manage that compassionately instead of just whack them over the head and then shout at them. I understand logically that some cases are compassion fatigue and some are just people who should have never been accepted into a caring profession but it doesn't make it right.

cptartapp · 31/08/2022 15:08

VioletInsolence · 31/08/2022 13:03

I don’t get this. The NHS just needs more funding and it’s failing because it doesn’t have enough funding. The tories have deliberately not given it sufficient finding so that it will fail and people will be desperate for private health care. That was always the plan so why is everyone squabbling amongst themselves about individual issues?

I know there are staffing issues but if there was more funding these would improve. They don’t pay student nurses anymore so there isn’t much incentive to train. The staff shortages due to Brexit will still exist but privatisation won’t affect that.

All that said, I think a small charge to see a GP would maybe be appropriate to prevent time wasters. Why are we all sleepwalking into an American system?

A small charge? For everyone of any age?
Would children, those on benefits, pensioners pay??
Or just the same poor sods in the middle?

Topgub · 31/08/2022 14:56

@lampygirl

I cant comment because I dont know the details.

Abuse, verbal or other wise, is never justified.

Regardless of what abusive people tell themselves.

Staff in the nhs often put up with far more than they should because they minimise and make allowances for the awful circumstances people find themselves in.

That doesn't make it ok.

XingMing · 31/08/2022 14:55

@dockspider the local NHS is over-stretched but absolutely bl**dy marvellous. Cornwall has fewer problems attracting teachers and HCPs than lots of places. It's a double-edged sword though: public sector employees are relatively well-paid in comparison to most local jobs, because it's a national payscale -- even though it's an expensive property market.

However, we're not staying here forever as we have itchy feet and if I never see the summer M5 again, I'd whoop. I'd just like to take my house and hospital with me.

lampygirl · 31/08/2022 14:48

@Topgub Tescos not having the right flavour of breaded chicken is ‘an inconvenience’. Repeatedly being sent between services and thus having a wall put up in front of care you are told you need at the place you’ve been sent to receive it is not ‘an inconvenience’ it’s downright poor treatment and potentially dangerous. You’d think by the second time you’d gone back maybe the two services could ring each other and thrash it out, and direct the patient to an agreed service, not just one say ‘go to this place’ and one say ‘nope, go back to the first place’ ad Infinitum. This has been going on for me for over a fortnight now, and I have managed to not get abusive at all but I am getting to the end of my tether and there does not seem to be a resolution. If I’d come to your service, how would you handle it. Because if you would just shrug your shoulders at me like the staff I’ve dealt with them sorry but that is not good service.

As I have said, I do not condone abuse at all, and I have not been abusive to staff. What I said is I can see how people who are scared, desperate and in pain will not react as per an average human being in those situations. It’s the same way I don’t condone GBH but I’d fully understand why someone might twat a burglar in their bedroom at night round the head with a table lamp when they felt scared, threatened and had had their home violated. That’s an understanding of how others might react to a situation, it’s not encouraging it or thinking it’s OK

LakieLady · 31/08/2022 14:27

When there are grave shortages of both doctors and nurses, care is always going to suffer.

NHS staff shortages

The pressure on the staff is immense and it's no wonder that sometimes they're not as polite or tolerant as they might be. They're struggling to do a decent job with insufficient staff, often knackered equipment, increasingly dilapidated buildings and members of the public who can be incredibly rude and, sometimes, ludicrously demanding.

VivX · 31/08/2022 14:19

Almost all the nurses and midwives and NHS staff I've come into contact with are fabulous - doing a demanding job on rubbish pay in an under-resourced department.

There have been one or two over the years that have been less than wonderful, but everyone has less than wonderful days.

The NHS won't be improved by privatisation, far from it. Hasn't anyone learned from the privatisation of energy, water, rail...
All that will happen is that the private company will take a profit margin and cut the expenditure even further in order to increase profit margins for its shareholders.

fannyfan · 31/08/2022 14:09

@Badgirlriri on the 17th august she posted this

  • just spent 13h in A&E in incredible pain (abscess on my privates ). I was made to sit on a hard plastic chair for the duration (sitting on my infection! ), no pain-relief offered, no triage (I could have been in the throes of sepsis for all they know). I finally collapsed from the shock of pain (I attempted a walk to the loo). At that point I dialled 999 for an ambulance (from the waiting room of ASE!!) I was preparing to call the police too, as the rules in custody compel the officers to provide a doctor within an hour to sick inmates. Anyway, after me getting on the phone the most immediate needs got catered for straight away : the morphine appeared (I asked for Ibuprofen before but didn't even get any) , offers of a hot drink and even a side-room with a mini sofa for me to able NOT to sit on my injury. All the things the department had the ability to provide but chose not to for 13 hours!! The people at the nurse's station barely deserve to be called people. They're some humanoid-creatures devoid of empathy and care. It's not funding that denied me a reading of oxygen/blood pressure/ temperature and a few pills of Ibuprofen. It's the human factor in the NHS. In the time it took them to stand there cracking jokes, doing Corona-tests on all and sundry, clicking their necks and knuckles, they could have given me some pain-relief as I asked for (already in tears)*

It's on the just privatise the nhs thread I'm not a stalker

Badgirlriri · 31/08/2022 14:06

QueenCamilla · 31/08/2022 01:47

I will be complaining. I was outright tortured in the A&E for 13 hours. I just want it on the record, who knows how it might help one fine day.
However, at the moment, it will go nowhere. Because NO ONE gives a damn. The managers won't get paid less even if I die on one of those little, hard plastic chairs.

I relate to the helplessness and actually hate the NHS bestowed upon me like a sack of rotten spuds.
Can't go anywhere else, can't complain...

How were you “tortured” ?

fannyfan · 31/08/2022 14:02

@ItsJustLittleOlMe I agree with you. On the 'just privatise the nhs' thread that poster says the reason she was in a&e was because she had an abscess on her genitals

dockspider · 31/08/2022 13:51

@XingMing We may not agree on Cornwall but couldn’t agree more on healthcare.

Topgub · 31/08/2022 13:50

@lampygirl

You think reasonable humans react with abuse if they're angry at an inconvenience?

Or that staff doing their jobs should prevent every possible upset and inconvenience or otherwise face abuse?

lampygirl · 31/08/2022 13:43

@Topgub I don’t think they deserve abuse in that nobody should be abusing anyone because it’s ultimately a human being, but believe me I can see why some people with less restraint can become ‘abusive’, shouty, obstructive etc. Treating people better would do more to solve abusive patients than putting a sign up and hiding behind a Perspex shield. I’ve had to leave GP’s surgeries without care before getting angry because I’ve had specific instructions and letters to see specific members of staff there and them just saying that they don’t do that go back to the other service, then this in reverse at the other end, like a ping pong ball but at the cost to my time, parking charges, fuel and annual leave. The difference is as a reasonable human I could recognise this was going to make me angry and leave, but if I was scared and in pain, and desperate for someone to see me would I deal outwardly so reasonably despite being inwardly fuming? I don’t know. Also with most things in the NHS the squeaky wheel gets seen first so you have to make a bit of a nuisance of yourself. Then you are on a very fine tightrope!

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 31/08/2022 13:39

QueenCamilla · 31/08/2022 01:33

How do you figure it out? Like private businesses do: customers complain and the horrible employees (particularly those who are rude and break their own company policies) get sacked.

We don't need more nurses. Loads of them were there in the A&E twiddling their thumbs, laughing, feeding cops sandwiches whilst I was dying in their "care". We need quality, not quantity!

I also recognise good when I see it - can't fault ward nurses and I shed a tear when we eventually parted.

I have two simple terms to describe pure hell within the NHS :
Maternity Care
Emergency Care

Both seem to attract the unfeeling. I suppose they're impossibly harsh environments for anyone with even a shred of empathy for human suffering...

While you were "dying in their care"? Well good job the staff did their jobs properly then and you didn't die. Or did they just leave you there to die while "feeding cops sandwiches" and "twidling their thumbs" and you are actually communicating from beyond the grave?

And maternity care - personally I received wonderful, person centred care from my midwives. Emergency care - I've only had to use it once in my life with my mother, fairly recently and again, exceptional care.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 31/08/2022 13:36

It’s such a mixed bag.., fantastic at times and honestly murderous in its negligence at other times. I think medicine attracts really caring people and also psychopaths who enjoy the power. I’ve seen both on wards. Thankfully you get more caring ones.

fannyfan · 31/08/2022 13:32

@lampygirl nice to see that you think nhs staff are deserving of abuse.

Topgub · 31/08/2022 13:28

However, all the negative posts here suggest that my experience is too rare.

I'm not sure that follows.

People are far more likely to remember and discuss negative experiences than positive or even neutral ones.

That doesn't mean negative ones are more common

XingMing · 31/08/2022 13:25

Personally, I have had excellent care over the last 12 months during breast cancer diagnosis and treatment: so surgery, radiotherapy, oncology and an immune reaction that had me in dermatology twice a week. And every nurse and doctor was kind, patient and efficient. The NHS at it's best can do this. It was as good as French healthcare. However, all the negative posts here suggest that my experience is too rare.

For that reason, I am in favour of adopting something similar to the social-mutual employer-employee insurance model used in France, Germany, Australia, the Netherlands and Israel. The state funds the very poor and children are covered via the state or their parents' entitlement. Age and pre-existing conditions are not considered grounds for an insurer to decline any patient. So there is more money to pay for what's needed, but also a wider range of patient choices -- including the freedom to self-refer to a private physio or dermatologist or for an MRI scan without needing a GP to be involved.

As I can afford it, I also think I should pay an element of the cost of my treatment to kickstart the process.

DumpedByText · 31/08/2022 13:10

@itsonthestairs I'm sorry you feel this way, my mum passed away last week, she was in A&E for two days as no beds for her. The A&E staff were amazing, she was extremely poorly and they did their very best for her. Same on the acute medical ward, the staff were so so lovely despite being run ragged. I was with her on my own when she passed, I was a hysterical mess, those nurses comforted me, made me tea and they spent what little time they had with me. The NHS is in crisis but anyone who thinks it's your or the staffs fault are so so wrong. Here's some Flowers for you x

dockspider · 31/08/2022 13:10

VioletInsolence · 31/08/2022 13:03

That last paragraph contradicts itself I know.

I don’t think it does. There’s a massive gap between ‘free at the point of delivery’ and ‘fully private healthcare’ with lots of sensible stops along the way.

VioletInsolence · 31/08/2022 13:03

That last paragraph contradicts itself I know.

VioletInsolence · 31/08/2022 13:03

I don’t get this. The NHS just needs more funding and it’s failing because it doesn’t have enough funding. The tories have deliberately not given it sufficient finding so that it will fail and people will be desperate for private health care. That was always the plan so why is everyone squabbling amongst themselves about individual issues?

I know there are staffing issues but if there was more funding these would improve. They don’t pay student nurses anymore so there isn’t much incentive to train. The staff shortages due to Brexit will still exist but privatisation won’t affect that.

All that said, I think a small charge to see a GP would maybe be appropriate to prevent time wasters. Why are we all sleepwalking into an American system?

Topgub · 31/08/2022 13:00

@lampygirl

That kind of reads like you think nhs staff deserve abuse?

I'm great at my job. I routinely go above and beyond.

That has not stopped me routinely being physically and verbally abused by relatives and pts.

lampygirl · 31/08/2022 12:57

Places that deliver good customer service don't need signs saying please don't abuse staff etc. Usually places that rely on Computer Says No and people who can't be fucked to go even 0.01% off the one size fits none approach in order to make it fit have these signs and they are almost all public services. People are used to a much higher level of service from everything now but with healthcare they are often over a barrel.

Maybe GPs and more specifically the GP nurses need to read my sign saying 'don't give out incorrect advice, don't talk to the patient as if they are their medical condition and don't make throwaway disparaging comments to people raising genuine concerns because they don't affect you the same way'. I have quite severe PTSD and phobias regarding accessing healthcare and it is all because of poor treatment, lies and comments made by healthcare staff.

Or more simply treat people how you'd want your child to be treated.

You can tell a lot about a person and organisation with how they deal with when they've made a mistake, and the NHS is shockingly shite at it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread