Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be actually really worried about you? NHS related

282 replies

Itsonthestairs · 31/08/2022 00:32

As a highly skilled NHS nurse of 15 years I had to leave my job due to the stress and not being able to provide the care I wanted to, I was burnt out following covid (my mum died), I have definaly save a fair few lifes in my clinical time, I loved my job and I was good at it (emergency department background). Reading the posts on MN has really upset me recently, the disrespect, dislike and darn right hatred for healthcare professionals really worries me. My friends are on their knees and this abuse doesn't help, people are getting crap care because there is no staff and this awful attitude is just adding fuel to the fire. I'm really worried about you, me and our families future healthcare.

OP posts:
XelaM · 04/09/2022 03:49

Sorry I see this case is already being discussed.

XelaM · 04/09/2022 03:48

Maybe you should read Martha Mill's story...

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/sep/03/13-year-old-daughter-dead-in-five-weeks-hospital-mistakes

An absolutely chilling account of the NHS.

ImustLearn2Cook · 04/09/2022 02:43

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/sep/03/13-year-old-daughter-dead-in-five-weeks-hospital-mistakes

We had such trust, we feel such fools’: how shocking hospital mistakes led to our daughter’s death.

…

I am a fierce supporter of the principles of the NHS and realise how many excellent doctors are practising today. There’s no need for the usual political arguments: as the hospital in question has confirmed to me, what happened to Martha had nothing to do with insufficient resources or overstretched doctors and nurses; it had nothing to do with austerity or cuts, or a health service under strain.

…

Severe sepsis is most often dangerous when patients don’t make it to intensive care, where it can be treated with powerful drugs and frequent interventions. Martha could easily have gone to paediatric intensive care (PICU), which was just down the corridor and had beds free. But her consultants preferred not to involve PICU.

…

“I’m worried Martha is going to go into septic shock on a bank holiday weekend and none of you will be here.” The consultant ran her finger down a screen of numbers. “I’m not worried about sepsis,” she said. When I went back to the cubicle, Martha looked at me with narrowed eyes. “I heard you talking about septic shock.” “Don’t worry, my love,” I said. “I just need to make sure they’re thinking of everything.” The consultant’s parting words as she left were: “It’s just a normal infection.”

…

King’s later produced a Serious Incident report into why Martha died and its writer told me that she should, at this time, have been moved to PICU.

…

But Prof Checked Shirt, in charge that day, didn’t once consider such a move. Tellingly, the report revealed high-status consultants on Rays of Sunshine (“level sevens” in the ranking of seniority) had a dismissive attitude to less senior colleagues in PICU (“level fives”). This made them reluctant to do the right thing and involve intensive care: Martha died in part because of inflated egos.

…

When Prof Checked Shirt made his routine call from home that evening to the head of PICU, he painted only a partial picture of Martha’s condition. He did not mention her previous bleeding or the fact that the rash she had was new. He was relaying her details “for information only”; intensive care “categorically” should not pay Martha a bedside visit, he said: “no review was needed” and it would increase my anxiety. The hospital’s policy dictates that parents being worried is a reason to escalate; he decided the opposite.
The head of PICU could reply only that there was a bed available if needed. He was asked at the inquest whether, had he been given the full picture by Prof Checked Shirt, Martha would have been moved to intensive care. He answered: “Without a doubt, 100 per cent.”

…

Other consultants were also at fault: the hospital report concluded that on at least five occasions Martha’s care should have involved PICU. Yet at no stage did any doctor let me know that she was in real trouble. I was kept in the dark and condescended to. The focus on my – justified – anxiety reeks of misogyny.

ImustLearn2Cook · 04/09/2022 02:16

Onceuponatimethen · 03/09/2022 14:44

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/sep/03/13-year-old-daughter-dead-in-five-weeks-hospital-mistakes

This article struck me as very relevant to lots of what is discussed on this thread. I think what the writer says is very wise - let’s support the nhs but let’s not accept poor care is acceptable.

@MissHavershamReturns I was about to come on and post the same link. So, absolutely heartbreaking and so very brave of her mum to go into such detail of every step that led to her daughter’s preventable death.

It really is so very relevant to this thread and the OP.

safarisogoody · 03/09/2022 22:09

that article was so terrible and yet I can say I had a near miss with my daughter that smacks of the same issues.
17 year old put on an adult ward acute appendicitis left fir three days / highly emotive reasons given fir the delay in surgery . Terrible car crashes etc
She deteriorated quite quickly day 3 ( appendix had ruptured) I insisted a doctor was called ) I'm a community nurse and went to my car and took her observations with my own equippment as the ward staff were horrendous.
Big fuss made - a disgruntled doctor came didn't even put her huge mulberry bag down to examine her kept it over her shoulder the whole time. i feel tearful writing this so god only knows how that poor poor family are feeling.
the doctor said it's fine even if it has ruptured she's ( my daughter) is on IV antibiotics. Which was rubbish as a treatment option and also inaccurate as she was on IV paracetamol for pain not on antibiotics.If o hadn't been a nurse I might have thought that's ok then. Such a hideous experience and I must say i felt so alone another patient s relatives accused me of attention seeking .
i often think that the brightest people are encouraged or aspire to do medicine but it's actually completely unsuited to their real skill set and oftentimes what they are dealing with is not that interesting to them.
Not sure what to say about the nursing staff good and bad i suppose i suppose the thing really comes down to poor service in a supermarket for example is highly unlikely to result in death or injury whereas in nursing it can.
is it true to say you get what you pay for?

XingMing · 03/09/2022 20:30

The NHS is good, but could be better, and the tragic story above speaks volumes about complacency. I don't mind so much if the patient is elderly or in chronic poor health (although I know the relatives will be desolate at the loss) but for an injured healthy young person... words simply fail me.

But I do think the NHS needs reform, a bit more money too, but it needs critical friends much more. I think threads like this may be beginning to erode the NHS worship. What was possible in 1947 has been superseded by decades of science. Longevity is +20 years what it was in 1947. Old people no longer die of pneumonia; they die of dementia which is a disease of keeping bodies alive too long. The various versions of dementia are all versions of long and slow and miserable declines (for everyone involved) and very very expensive. My DMIL's care home (very pleasant and well run for the record) is only keeping a life present that has no value to its owner. Which costs £4265 per month (she self funds).

I don't know the answer, but I can state that this is not what DMIL wanted; she asked me to take her to Dignitas if she was diagnosed as seriously ill and I promised I would, but with dementia, she no longer has capacity to frame the request.

GelatoQueen · 03/09/2022 17:31

@MissHavershamReturns that's a shocking article and has brought back lots of memories for me when DS was born and became ill within a few hours of his birth. He was OK in the end but I have never had satisfactory explanation of what the issue nor if it could have been a hospital-acquired infection (GP was the only one who dared mention this). Our care was shambolic - riddled with miscommunication, errors and borderline neglect. The excuse was being short-staffed. So many other women were also not given the care they needed by the time I came out of hospital I thought I'd been on a tour of duty in a war zone.

Onceuponatimethen · 03/09/2022 14:44

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/sep/03/13-year-old-daughter-dead-in-five-weeks-hospital-mistakes

This article struck me as very relevant to lots of what is discussed on this thread. I think what the writer says is very wise - let’s support the nhs but let’s not accept poor care is acceptable.

Biscuitandacuppa · 03/09/2022 14:36

@nellytheelephant1980 i was an occupational therapist, I worked for the NHS for 21 years and was a band 7 community lead. The management structure was totally unsupportive and unrealistic on the service that could be delivered by a steadily reduced workforce. The difference from when I qualified in the quality of care was shocking. Patients were seen as numbers to be processed in a set number of days and discharged come hell or high water. The hours wasted reporting on delays to transfer of care was ludicrous and took away from clinical hours. The post I was in went from one service area to responsibility for an entire county for inpatient and community plus peripatetic management to two services hosted in social services.

By the end I hated it, I was completely burned out and became physically unwell which was totally unsupported by management who took the opportunity to manage me out and make a cost saving. I sometimes wake up in a cold sweat dreaming I still work there. I’m now in education and far far happier.

Hyacinth2 · 03/09/2022 06:52

I wish nurses had gone on strike 20 years ago and got decent salaries and conditions but no they wanted 'to put the patients first' well that totally backfired and made the job more of a calling than a serious career - you reap what you sow.

nellytheelephant1980 · 03/09/2022 06:12

I'm an occupational therapist in the NHS, but I too am HORRIFIED by the 'care' so many of my colleagues (don't) provide and the general NHS systems/management.

The clapping and the fact that NHS workers think that just by stating 'I'm an NHS worker so you must worship me' doesn't help. Believe me when I say it has gone to SO many of my colleague's heads. We should not be immune to reproach.

I totally despair at the system.

forgotoldusername · 03/09/2022 05:48

@TheInkBlackHeart zero thanks to no win no fee. But yes I've tried a couple of times (all for legitimate reasons) and it's not easy.

I got a small payout once (no I'm not a serial suer but they have messed up a few times)

As I said, I go private 90% of the time so my encounters with the NHS are limited. I absolutely think it should be privatised but still accessible to all

TheInkBlackHeart · 03/09/2022 05:37

@forgotoldusername yeah go for it, sue them. I hope it costs you an absolute fortune

forgotoldusername · 03/09/2022 05:29

@TheInkBlackHeart the NHS has f...d up quite a few times with me and my children. Unfortunately suing them is very difficult but I'll try. I work bloody hard and my "customers" get the best service from me without any complaint.

Instead here we need to think of NHS workers as some kind of demigods - who spend their time moaning and not actually doing the job they are paid for. Just get on with your job please rather than come on mumsnet and complain

TheInkBlackHeart · 03/09/2022 05:25

@forgotoldusername the level of vitriol in your post is disgusting.

Drs and nurses already know the meaning of a hard days work ffs.

forgotoldusername · 03/09/2022 05:23

OP, did you want sympathy? Won't get it from me. Crap crap service from the NHS for me and my children and unfortunately you can't really go private for emergencies (I go private 90% of the time, I have good insurance and sometimes I self pay)

Honestly I don't like the Tories but I can't wait for the day the NHS is fully privatised so nurses and doctors (especially GPs, my dream is to see them actually doing some work, I know I must be delusional) actually need to work - you know, many of us have to put money aside for our pensions, we don't get final salary or anything like that

So if you are "burnt out" I hope you don't need a job in the private sector as you will learn the meaning of the word "work". So nope, absolutely no sympathy from me

nowaynotnownotever · 03/09/2022 05:18

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62757787

Paranoidandroidmarvin · 01/09/2022 20:57

@StridTheKiller im sorry to say I’m with u. The maternity department were awful when I was there. As I said further up the thread they are a huge reason why I only had one child.
One if the specialist I spoke to for help after told me to be grateful I don’t have cancer. My doctor was horrified at that as there was something they could. I never went back.

I spent years trying to fix myself and failing as ever person I met was either rude or wouldn’t help me even though I know they could and others have.

I currently has a huge amount of problems with intolerance to foods to the point where I have barely anything left to eat. And I’m told by the doctors to just get on with it and be grateful I have something when asked if I could see a dietitian.

My Nan was left to her own devices while she in there four seven weeks. She is blind but no one helped her. To the point that she said she would rather die than go back in.

Im sure there are good nhs people but I have yet to actually meet one. Or one that has helped me on the slightest. I have got more helps from Facebook groups than anyone at my hospital.

StridTheKiller · 01/09/2022 19:40

But some nurses and medical professionals are neglectful, uncaring and down right nevligent. I've had my health and thus life destroyed by our wonderful NHS. It can go and fuck itself.

Steakandquinoa · 01/09/2022 19:37

Birma - sounds perfect. Also time for managers to ensure training is up to date (not just the basics either), staff are supported, issues are investigated fully, improvements implemented and embedded in ward culture.

BirmaBrite · 31/08/2022 20:56

Basically if you do long shifts, imagine that for 3 hours a day you get double the amount of nursing staff and what that would mean to your work load and level of patient care, that was what the olden days looked like.
Imagine if Trusts could afford to pay additional nurses to do short shifts, so 10-4 or 12-6 and the impact of that on patient care ? So you have a core staff doing long days and then additional staff doing shorter shifts which fit in with normal childcare providers.
Everyone gets their unpaid breaks, everyone gets the care they need and no-one is burnt out.

BirmaBrite · 31/08/2022 20:45

The rota is the rota. I don't know any ward that will allow everyone to do 7.5 hours. You don't get continuity of care with that. Id spend half my time handing over.

That was all that was offered when I started nursing, you did earlys/lates/nights. The day shifts were 7.5 hours and you handed over from the early to the late, as you do now from the day to the night, so you only handed over once. It also meant that for a short while there were a lot more staff on the ward, so the early staff could crack on with IV's whilst the lates went round and did obs, checked everyone etc.
Continuity of care was there, because you were there with the patients 5 days a week.
Now most staff in the hospital work long shifts, which is great from a work life balance perspective and I can completely understand why a lot of people prefer those shifts.

EverythingHeadinSouth · 31/08/2022 17:47

lampygirl · 31/08/2022 12:57

Places that deliver good customer service don't need signs saying please don't abuse staff etc. Usually places that rely on Computer Says No and people who can't be fucked to go even 0.01% off the one size fits none approach in order to make it fit have these signs and they are almost all public services. People are used to a much higher level of service from everything now but with healthcare they are often over a barrel.

Maybe GPs and more specifically the GP nurses need to read my sign saying 'don't give out incorrect advice, don't talk to the patient as if they are their medical condition and don't make throwaway disparaging comments to people raising genuine concerns because they don't affect you the same way'. I have quite severe PTSD and phobias regarding accessing healthcare and it is all because of poor treatment, lies and comments made by healthcare staff.

Or more simply treat people how you'd want your child to be treated.

You can tell a lot about a person and organisation with how they deal with when they've made a mistake, and the NHS is shockingly shite at it.

What utter victim-blaming nonsense. You're basically saying it's all right to be abusive if the CS falls below a certain level, which for some people means not getting what they want, no matter how unreasonable their expectations are. I've received my fair share of substandard and even appalling customer service over the years yet I have never resorted to abusing the staff. It has nothing to do with the CS and everything to do with the abusive customers.

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 31/08/2022 16:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

XingMing · 31/08/2022 16:23

@cptartapp
Most co-pay mutualised insurance models incorporate an element of upfront payment, which is refunded via the social insurer (or state) up to c80%. In France, you pay the initial consultation fee and reclaim it or most of it.

Disabled people, children, and those receiving only basic state pension/benefits are covered by the state. If you have another pension from work, then you'd be expected to enrol with a mutual insurance company who are not permitted to cherry pick customers on the basis of age, or pre-existing conditions; customers can shop around for a package of benefits appropriate for them. So everyone has routine health and emergency care but at 66, I wouldn't pick maternity cover or fertility treatment, preferring the options like eye or hearing care. Some German health packages offer spa/convalescent after illness.

If you work, you and your employer both contribute and as there's no opt out, the costs are kept fairly moderate. And because everyone contributes, there's a bit more understanding of what care really costs. Clinicians and labs deal with customers direct, so you drop your urine sample off wherever is easiest for you, as you decide between the pharmacist near home or close to work.

And well-to-do retirees keep on paying their mutuels.

Swipe left for the next trending thread