Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
Maryann1975 · 30/08/2022 23:25

AntlerRose · 30/08/2022 21:53

I agree that high quality, funded/very subsidised childcare should be available 8-6.

If people want to work part time or do opposite shifts they dont have to use it.

One of the issues is its not attractive employment. We really struggle to staff our morning club in particular.

i see this as the problem. The whole early years/child care industry is in crisis. Nurseries and after school clubs can’t get staff. Childminder numbers continue to fall every year. Every nursery in our town has advertised for staff since May half term, some repeatedly- the nurseries also run the after school clubs and the childminder numbers are down by 50% since covid. The job is low paid and is not respected by government. It’s not an attractive job- minimum wage, with high levels of stress and responsibility. You get paid more for working in Aldi and I’m told that is a far easier job.

But the government refuse to fund either education or early years adequately, so i see little hope for them funding after school provision. I know very few people who would choose to work 7-9 and then 3-6 every day for minimum wage, so until the financial side is sorted, good quality care just won’t be available.

Mummybud · 30/08/2022 23:25

Isn’t it sad that the OP started this post re how difficult it is for two working parents to manage school life and the lack of wraparound care available and it quickly descended into some women tearing apart other families for utilising wraparound care and proclaiming that 8am to 6pm is unconscionable and that one parent should go part time?

I was the kid who was at school 8am to 6pm. I’m now that parent. I have a very good career and my kid is absolutely fine. If we’re generalising (and there’s a lot of it on this thread) the majority of kids (particularly girls) I grew up with who were picked up at 3:30/4pm by their SAHM or part time working parents grew up with a distinct lack of ambition. History repeats itself, people recreate their known environment. Something that is unconscionable to some is the norm to others. I agree with the OP - better wraparound options are essential to modern families.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 23:24

LilacPoppy · 30/08/2022 23:07

Children deserve time at home with their parents preferably a full time stay at home parent.
We shouldn't be making it easier for children to be in childcare 11 hours a day.
If the majority of families had a stay at home parent then house prices would fall to reflect the fact that people were mostly buying on one income.

What? That is not how the housing market works.

Toddlerteaplease · 30/08/2022 23:22

Try being. Nurse that's works 12 hour shifts. There are a couple of nurseries round here that open at 6.30am but the all close around 6pm. Not ideal if you don't finish till 7.30om.

WeeM · 30/08/2022 23:22

OiFrogg · 30/08/2022 21:29

  1. Being picky, but I've never worked in a school that didn't finish at 3.30pm. I've honestly never come across a school that finishes at 3pm.
  1. You state at most schools one of the options is to attend a kids' club. So you're saying wrap around care is available? I don't really understand what you are suggesting that is different to this.
  1. In expecting schools to provide an ASC, it will come back on teachers whether it should or not. I not infrequently have to stay til 6pm because staff from our ASC are off sick or we can't get cover or whatever. Working 3.30pm til 6pm are not popular working hours. Schools are struggling to recruit for all roles.
  1. I do agree it's hard as a working parent, and part of the difficulty is cost. Two days at nursery (basically the 30 hours free allowance spread across the year) doesn't even allow me to work two teaching days without taking a significant amount of work home with me (work that'd be more easily done in school).

@OiFrogg my DD’s school finishes at 3 as do all the others in our area.

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 23:22

Wages should be high enough for one parent working full time to earn enough to pay for a home, all the bills, food, clothes & have some money left. What has changed so much from the 1970's to now?

Well, it's because the norm became for both parents to work that a one parent wage is no longer enough. Companies are aware that families have more income and so the cost of things go up to reflect this, leading to better profits for the companies. Both parents deciding to work has created the economy where both parents now have to work.

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 23:17

Wages should be high enough for one parent working full time to earn enough to pay for a home, all the bills, food, clothes & have some money left. What has changed so much from the 1970's to now? One parent is working now for much less than NMW after childcare is paid for. The population in the UK is declining as the birth rate falls, there will be less young people leaving school, starting work, paying tax & NI, the government should be making it more attractive for couples to have children by either increasing free hours childcare or increasing in work benefits to allow one parent to stay at home. Increasing in work benefits would probably work out cheaper than increasing free hours childcare. Incentives could be made to companies over a certain size to provide on site childcare.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 30/08/2022 23:14

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 22:33

But that doesn't work - because you either pick the kids up, go home, and ignore them because you need to log on again OR you do play, dinner, bath, bedtime and THEN log on eating into your only downtime of the day when you're aleady exhausted.

Thats just what teachers do and they need wrap around care too.

Justanotherwinter · 30/08/2022 23:13

It’s sad people are saying ‘poor kids’. Like the parents have any choice right now. I’m sure if they could survive with just one parent working they would. Most people now struggle with 2 incomes in the household, especially with full time childcare upwards of £100 a day

SE13Mummy · 30/08/2022 23:12

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 22:12

Good luck, the fact that teachers don't have the option for a more flexible timetable has always astounded me

DH and I are both teachers too. When our DC were primary aged and younger we each worked four days per week (each having a different day off) and had a term-time only nanny for the other three days each week. The nanny did 7.30am to 6pm for us and it was much more straightforward than when we only had one DC but needed to drop them off ourselves.

oviraptor21 · 30/08/2022 23:11

holidaynightmare · 30/08/2022 23:09

This is an excellent point
The hours are very restrictive and the jobs usually minimum wage too

Recruit for eg. 7-3 and 11-7

gogohmm · 30/08/2022 23:11

@Apl

You mean privileged office workers?

What about the people working in shops, in hospitality, in emergency services, in healthcare, in personal services, in transport, in call centres ... you wouldn't like it if nobody was on the end of the the phone when you want to report something at 5pm, you want take aways, you want to buy food ....

Most people don't work in offices, around half do

holidaynightmare · 30/08/2022 23:09

Hankunamatata · 30/08/2022 22:02

Recruitment is the issue. No one wants to work 7-9am then 3-6pm for essentially peanuts

This is an excellent point
The hours are very restrictive and the jobs usually minimum wage too

oviraptor21 · 30/08/2022 23:08

Agree with some PP - it's not wrap around childcare that needs to be provided but many more flexible working practices.
From the list of @TastesLikeStrawberries above, the majority do not have to be 9 to 5.

JackandSam · 30/08/2022 23:07

But I'm also a person who chooses to work when I don't need to. I couldn't be a SAHP.

LilacPoppy · 30/08/2022 23:07

Children deserve time at home with their parents preferably a full time stay at home parent.
We shouldn't be making it easier for children to be in childcare 11 hours a day.
If the majority of families had a stay at home parent then house prices would fall to reflect the fact that people were mostly buying on one income.

PurpleFlower1983 · 30/08/2022 23:07

I work in a large primary school and we provide this. Breakfast club from 7.45am and an on-site after school provider until 6pm.

JackandSam · 30/08/2022 23:06

Yanbu.

Almost all families I know have both parents working full time.

And jobs where there's significant flexibility (e.g. exDHs) wreak havoc on the workers mental health and work life balance because of the stop/ start nature of the working day. It's not sustainable. A block is much better.

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 23:04

TastesLikeStrawberries · 30/08/2022 22:39

This.

All these comments saying 8-6 is too long for a child is making me feel like a terrible parent for going back to work but I have no choice. I'll be working 8.30 - 5.30 4 days per week, meaning DC will be dropped off around 8 and collected at 5.45. Flexible working hours aren't an option, nor is working from home. In an ideal world I'd love to work 16 hours a week and spend the rest of my life with my DC but that's not realistic for me, or I'm sure for many parents out there.

I agree, at the moment I would imagine there are very few families that can afford to cut hours. The first year my kids were in nursery, I went part time working 4 days a week 10 - 6 so I could do the drop off and spend 3 days at home with them.
My wages + travel covered childcare but I wasnt left with much as the £1200 a month childcare for each cost more than our monthly mortgage at the time. Once the kids were in school I used the extra money to start saving again.

OP posts:
holidaynightmare · 30/08/2022 23:02

I'm very lucky I have a childminder who I have used since I went back to work after maternity leave and she does wraparound

There was a breakfast/ after school club Pre-covid that serviced 3 local schools
One academy primary age 4-11

Then one infant/ nursery - age 2-7

One middle school age 7-11

Now post Covid as a lot of people still work from home and have more flexible work it has closed as people who work from home can often squeeze in a school run so it saves them money.

The club did try to run as a smaller setting and do after school only as opposed to breakfast but it just wasn't financially viable for them with a lot less children and so it's gone all together

The local childminders all have huge waiting lists so I consider myself to be very lucky

TastesLikeStrawberries · 30/08/2022 23:02

HorribleHerstory · 30/08/2022 21:56

I don’t think employment options that require people to work 9-5 are a standard working day. I’m not sure that’s ever been an actual standard in the vast majority of professions - perhaps one or two very desk based industries that’s the traditional way, but that’s a small percentage of the working population. I have never worked 9-5 Monday to Friday and I don’t know anyone who does those hours now. Healthcare isn’t 9-5, retail isn’t 9-5, construction isn’t 9-5, Education isn’t 9-5, Leisure and Hospitality isn’t 9-5, being a student isn’t 9-5, caring isn’t 9-5, transportation isn’t 9-5, manufacturing and factories arent 9-5. Aren’t you left with very few roles that are? Why do the people who happen to work a specific working pattern need to be catered to over and above every other working pattern?

Your opinion on 9-5 jobs appears very biased and I find it hard to believe you only know 2 people with those working hours. A lot of the industries you mention have 9-5 roles, many of which are not admin based as you have suggested, healthcare really stood out to me. The following roles in my experience are generally 'office based' hours.

GP surgeries
Practice/Treatment room based nurses
Non hospital based pharmacists
Community nurses
Health visitors

Dentists
Opticians
Occupational therapists
Speech and language therapists
Most outpatient hospital roles, think of all the staff based at various clinics; antenatal, respiratory, diabetic, neurology, rheumatology, x-ray depts, physiotherapy etc
Plumbers
Electricians
Mechanics
Joiners
IT based roles, software engineers etc
Banking/finance based roles
Solicitors
Many civil servant roles
Architects, building surveyors

I'm sure the list could go on...

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 23:00

We could if children were a government priority but they never are.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 22:56

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 22:50

Not enough is being done yet: it's still far too "optional".

If you look at a country like Sweden, they have a much higher level of equality when it comes to men and women taking care of children. That's, in part, because both men and women get the same "post child leave" following the birth or adoption of a child and they can't transfer it so it makes sense for both to take it.

It's such a aimple change, isn't it? and it would be so effective. But as a country we can't afford it.

Dibbydoos · 30/08/2022 22:54

I dont think tgey need government intervention. Raise it with the PTA or governors. If they can make them work commercially they are super.

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 22:50

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 22:46

Oh, I agree, but someone needs to tell the men because they didn't get the memo.

Not enough is being done yet: it's still far too "optional".

If you look at a country like Sweden, they have a much higher level of equality when it comes to men and women taking care of children. That's, in part, because both men and women get the same "post child leave" following the birth or adoption of a child and they can't transfer it so it makes sense for both to take it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread