Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
orbitalcrisis · 31/08/2022 01:15

This was a Labour policy, all school we going to be required to provide wrap around care. The Tories dropped it along with the promise to fix and/or upgrade all the school that needed it. I assume they thought the trophy wife or nanny could do school runs and buckets under roof leaks were good enough in the 1970s and 1980s so why not now!

Singlemum90 · 31/08/2022 00:53

audweb · 30/08/2022 22:05

My kid is fine thanks. As a lone parent, I have no choice and I refuse to let people like you make comments like that as if my child is suffering. She loves her wrap around care, she has so much fun and is well cared for, and it means I provide a quality of life for us working full time that on benefits I wouldn’t manage.

If you don’t want to do it for your kid, don’t do it. My kid isn’t having a crap time of it though.

You're smashing it! Well done for being a fab mum doing your very best for your child. God knows as parents we feel guilty about bloody everything as it is without the internet feeling sorry for our kids. You're teaching work ethic and strength and resilience while making a good life for your child. Youre doing great! :D

Booklover3 · 31/08/2022 00:53

I think it’s more that we need more flexible working and higher wages.

Littlebluedinosaur · 31/08/2022 00:52

Recruitment for childcare jobs is in crisis. There is hardly anyone wanting to work 3-6!

AprilRae91 · 31/08/2022 00:44

@arethereanyleftatall all parents I know both work full time. I don’t know how many could afford not to with bills and mortgage costs as they are…. we couldn’t

Apple42 · 31/08/2022 00:41

Our infant school finishes at 3 pm and Junior at 3.15pm there is a breakfast club and after school club covering both schools but with a massive waiting list so anyone starting the schools don't get in. We did have a lady who ran an external before and after school club who was a lot cheaper and opened longer the the school one .sadly her business folded during the pandemic as no parent was prepared to support her or pay her a small retainer to hold there spaces they were then all surprised she was no longer their for them when they need the care again and were very rude to her and badmouthed her over Facebook .

Bunnycat101 · 31/08/2022 00:17

I struggle with the quality of our wrap-around care compared to nursery tbh. I have no issue with my 3yo doing 9-6 in nursery. She is well cared for, has down time and is fed properly. Her sister in after school care doesn’t get anything like the same level of care, food is more snacky so she still needs dinner when she gets home and the care is generally run by students so can be a bit variable.

On the days I pick her up at 6 we need need to cram in a lot to evenings when she gets back. I don’t really have many other options for the days she needs it though. Tried looking for an after school nanny and no-one wants the hours, there are no childminders near me who do my school for pick-ups.

Tigofigo · 31/08/2022 00:15

HorribleHerstory · 30/08/2022 21:56

I don’t think employment options that require people to work 9-5 are a standard working day. I’m not sure that’s ever been an actual standard in the vast majority of professions - perhaps one or two very desk based industries that’s the traditional way, but that’s a small percentage of the working population. I have never worked 9-5 Monday to Friday and I don’t know anyone who does those hours now. Healthcare isn’t 9-5, retail isn’t 9-5, construction isn’t 9-5, Education isn’t 9-5, Leisure and Hospitality isn’t 9-5, being a student isn’t 9-5, caring isn’t 9-5, transportation isn’t 9-5, manufacturing and factories arent 9-5. Aren’t you left with very few roles that are? Why do the people who happen to work a specific working pattern need to be catered to over and above every other working pattern?

I think something like 50% of workers are in office jobs. It's by far the most common type of profession

Mollymalone123 · 30/08/2022 23:57

I work in breakfast and after school club-so open from 8am and take children to school for 8.50 start.Then open again at 3pm til 6pm.We are open all through holidays 8-6pm .I have looked after children from 3 years of age right the way through til 11years.A few were with us longer than their parents- it’s so sad to see a 3 year old dropped off at 8 and picked up at 6pm, ( days a week.They are so tired - they get home in time for a snack then it’s bed-and the next day is just a repeat of all the others

it just doesn’t seem right that children don’t get to see their parent/parents properly in the week, I wish there was a better way.
It is also hard to recruit staff as well as the hours will only suit a few people and we mostly need staff who are qualified already.

Livinginanotherworld · 30/08/2022 23:56

Toddlerteaplease · 30/08/2022 23:22

Try being. Nurse that's works 12 hour shifts. There are a couple of nurseries round here that open at 6.30am but the all close around 6pm. Not ideal if you don't finish till 7.30om.

Just imagine if the government were forward thinking enough to provide onsite crèches on all hospital sites. It would be so much easier to recruit and retain staff. Or am I being too simplistic ?

Sparkalinda · 30/08/2022 23:56

Most definitely agree with this. Work routines can be flexible, as proved during lockdowns/pandemic in general and work places need to get with the times in order to keep our economy flowing....

musicviking1 · 30/08/2022 23:52

And more and more jobs are requiring start and finishing times of 8am-6pm

ChocolatemilkBertie · 30/08/2022 23:51

So my schools wrap around care is run by a combination of TAs and kitchen staff. Kitchen staff cover breakfast club, two or three of them come in earlier than normal start time to run it. Think it’s £5 or £6? Starts at 7:45 and runs for an hour. Cereal and toast and childcare, easy activities just drawing, some games and Lego I think to keep them occupied.

Our after school is currently run by TAs but us under review. When I was a TA I did it. The TAs who do it are either childless or have grown up children and appreciate the extra money, I think one does every day a week and others do a couple each. It’s under review because there’s currently no other TAs who want to do it / can do it and one of the TAs is retiring at Christmas which is going to cause a shortage. I stepped back once I became a teacher and do end up covering sometimes but it makes life so much harder because it leaves me working late into the night. Hiring is currently a struggle. No one wants a job where the hours are 3:15 -6. Plus a bit more when children are late to be collected and set up/pack up - unpaid.

There is no funding for it, it all comes from parents fees. And if you want decent qualified and first aid trained staff, good resources, good food and quality care and activity, it’s going to come at a cost.

The debate at our school is to give it over to an outside company. It will send the price up. But we can’t staff it. Last advertisement for a breakfast club and / or after school care assistant produced one applicant. A college student, who then realised they wouldn’t make it to college on time. Can’t be surprised people don’t want those hours.

My old nursery used to provide wrap around after school care. In line with when funded children left for the day, we had a walking bus to the village school up the road and picked up WAC children and they came to our nursery, we had a WAC room which doubled as a holiday club room for the infant age range in the holidays.

Livinginanotherworld · 30/08/2022 23:45

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 22:41

That sounds like it would make life so much easier for a lot of families, I think the UK could learn a lot from that childcare model.

This works because Sweden is a high tax model. Brits would never vote for a party who suggest raising taxes. I think their highest rate is around 60% but schools are all high standard, everyone gets free school meals. Their social services are well funded.

Feetache · 30/08/2022 23:42

Hankunamatata · 30/08/2022 22:02

Recruitment is the issue. No one wants to work 7-9am then 3-6pm for essentially peanuts

This

DuggeeHugPlease · 30/08/2022 23:38

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 23:26

When I was a child my mum stayed at home when my dad worked & then when we got older my mum worked in the evening, first cleaning at a company 2 minutes walk from where we lived & then later on the twilight shift at a local factory with a lot of the local mums, my dad would walk in from work, my mum would put his tea on the table & go to work 5.30-9.30pm. All the local mums either worked at the factory or packing sweets at Thorntons. She didn't work during the day until my brother was 6 & she saw him through the school gates & went to work 9.00-1.00 in an office. She was always in when we got home from school.

My mum did something very similar and while I understand why she had to I absolutely did not aspire to that for myself.

I would very much like expectations to change and for childcare to be split more evenly between men and women but we are still a way off.

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 23:37

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 23:24

What? That is not how the housing market works.

I mean it's not as simple as that and there's a lower limit but, in general, it kind of does.

Houses are only worth what they are worth because someone is willing and able to pay that amount for that house. If the overall income of the vast majority of the population fell (by making one income families the norm) then, after a short time, house prices would crash too. As would the prices of other expensive, high profit, items. Though that level of crash really wouldn't be desireable as it would throw loads of people into sub-prime mortgages and potential cause significant economic problems at the same time.

TheSmallAssassin · 30/08/2022 23:37

oviraptor21 · 30/08/2022 23:11

Recruit for eg. 7-3 and 11-7

Or 7-3 and 10-6. If you had one parent on an early start they could do the pick up and do after school routine and make the tea, if they have the late start, they would do the morning routine and the drop off. My ideal solution would be both parents sharing the load like that, and more employers enabling that.

It's essentially what we did, except we both went a bit part time (81%) so neither of us had super early starts.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 23:35

And my mum worked full time during the 70s and 80s. The difference then was that she could pay a neighbour to look after us. She paid a low amount as it was keeping an eye on us while we played with our friends, including the neighbours kids. Not the current demands of Ofsted.

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 23:33

Although I agree with you in theory, in practice getting staff for those hours is hard. Who wants to work 8-9 am and 3-6 pm for not much more than minimum wage? It does not appeal to anyone with children and those without will want better hours. So it is not as simple as it sounds.

Mummybud · 30/08/2022 23:29

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 23:17

Wages should be high enough for one parent working full time to earn enough to pay for a home, all the bills, food, clothes & have some money left. What has changed so much from the 1970's to now? One parent is working now for much less than NMW after childcare is paid for. The population in the UK is declining as the birth rate falls, there will be less young people leaving school, starting work, paying tax & NI, the government should be making it more attractive for couples to have children by either increasing free hours childcare or increasing in work benefits to allow one parent to stay at home. Increasing in work benefits would probably work out cheaper than increasing free hours childcare. Incentives could be made to companies over a certain size to provide on site childcare.

How are you planning to pay for that if half the workforce is sat at home not paying tax?

Girlmama · 30/08/2022 23:28

I am an assistant head in a primary school and my fiance also works full time, we have a 3 and 9 yr old. We have always had a childminder as we have seen the horrendous task of covering working hours in terms of childcare. Wrap around care at school is available in many schools and is absolutely fine, however, I feel better knowing my children are away from school and having 'down time' at their lovely childminder's home until we are able to pick up. It's always felt like a more organic choice for us than the school building for 10 hours although I totally understand that excellent childminders are not freely available in all areas.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 30/08/2022 23:28

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 23:26

When I was a child my mum stayed at home when my dad worked & then when we got older my mum worked in the evening, first cleaning at a company 2 minutes walk from where we lived & then later on the twilight shift at a local factory with a lot of the local mums, my dad would walk in from work, my mum would put his tea on the table & go to work 5.30-9.30pm. All the local mums either worked at the factory or packing sweets at Thorntons. She didn't work during the day until my brother was 6 & she saw him through the school gates & went to work 9.00-1.00 in an office. She was always in when we got home from school.

What's your point? We should all be allowing our menz to go to work, put their dinner on the table and then work inba factory for the evening? That's your answer?

Lolliepoppie · 30/08/2022 23:27

Schools are there to educate children.

DP need to arrange childcare for their own DC, it is not the responsibility of the state.

Nat6999 · 30/08/2022 23:26

When I was a child my mum stayed at home when my dad worked & then when we got older my mum worked in the evening, first cleaning at a company 2 minutes walk from where we lived & then later on the twilight shift at a local factory with a lot of the local mums, my dad would walk in from work, my mum would put his tea on the table & go to work 5.30-9.30pm. All the local mums either worked at the factory or packing sweets at Thorntons. She didn't work during the day until my brother was 6 & she saw him through the school gates & went to work 9.00-1.00 in an office. She was always in when we got home from school.