Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
factfile · 31/08/2022 07:50

Whitewolf2 · 31/08/2022 07:44

i think part of the problem is that when young I was sold that I could have it all. I’d work hard, go to university, get a good degree, get a private sector job (9-5) that paid well and I enjoyed and also have a family. But the reality is that although my kids could have done 8-6 in nursery 5 days a week and then wrap round care at primary school 5 days a week 8-6 I didn’t feel comfortable with it for lots of reasons, I’m sure they could have coped but for me and them I was lucky to be able to go part time. My wage was lower than my husbands.
But of course my career has stalled, I just got a promotion which took me 8 years whereas my young male colleague got it in 3 (appreciate there are other factors but my 2 years out for Mat leave and 3 days a week must have contributed). So you can’t have it all, some compromises have to happen. I am very grateful for the wrap around care which for the 3 days they are there my Dd really enjoys. I don’t know how we’d cope without it.

It's this 100%

I have a daughter and it makes me angry thinking about how we'll plough just as much energy into her education and access to life experiences as her brother but essentially she'll be expected to be fine with either giving that (mostly) up once (if) she has kids or be fine with farming her kids out to childcare round the clock. I exaggerate to make my point and of course her partner could be the breadwinner etc but you get my point.

Superstar22 · 31/08/2022 07:49

our school finishes at 3pm and after school club is £17 a day which is until 5.30pm. Totally unaffordable to most families with more than one child/ needing a few days.

however I agree that it’s the working hours of parents that should be more flexible, not the expectation that kids should do 10 hour days. I don’t want to/ wouldn’t cope well with 10 hour days 5 days a week, so wouldn’t expect young children too.

we’ve always worked full time ish. Husband more than 40 hours, me around 4 days a week on average usually doing 5 days but slightly shorter days to pick them up most of the week.

Greywall2 · 31/08/2022 07:47

User65412 · 31/08/2022 07:19

Pregnant then screwed on Instagram is trying to change the childcare situation in this country. They've already made great progress with this government. Please go and support them if you want to see change!

Nice, a great site and hopefully something that will help change things for the better. Here's the link for easy access: pregnantthenscrewed.com/

OP posts:
Whitewolf2 · 31/08/2022 07:44

i think part of the problem is that when young I was sold that I could have it all. I’d work hard, go to university, get a good degree, get a private sector job (9-5) that paid well and I enjoyed and also have a family. But the reality is that although my kids could have done 8-6 in nursery 5 days a week and then wrap round care at primary school 5 days a week 8-6 I didn’t feel comfortable with it for lots of reasons, I’m sure they could have coped but for me and them I was lucky to be able to go part time. My wage was lower than my husbands.
But of course my career has stalled, I just got a promotion which took me 8 years whereas my young male colleague got it in 3 (appreciate there are other factors but my 2 years out for Mat leave and 3 days a week must have contributed). So you can’t have it all, some compromises have to happen. I am very grateful for the wrap around care which for the 3 days they are there my Dd really enjoys. I don’t know how we’d cope without it.

AppleKatie · 31/08/2022 07:41

@sjxoxo you’re half right. Change the rhetoric, fund childcare appropriately and you will find there is less of an issue with birth rate.

TooHotToTangoToo · 31/08/2022 07:36

I think the cost of childcare is outrageous. When my 2 needed childcare it was costing me £800 a month. This was way more than my mortgage (and a fair few years ago). But when you look at it sensibly, they are your most precious things, so you wouldn't want to be paying minimum wage for someone to look after your dc. I think it needs to be subsidised somehow. I used to be able to claim 70% of all childcare costs back, which I think should be available to everyone.

sjxoxo · 31/08/2022 07:28

@AppleKatie its not about the rhetoric being good or bad - it’s the wider picture that’s important rather than individual families’ choices. It’s the fact that two working parents and children in childcare 40+ hours a week doesn’t inspire people to have kids and the declining birth rate is a real problem for all of us x

OperaStation · 31/08/2022 07:25

Flatfish123 · 30/08/2022 21:27

It’s the way they ask you - repeatedly - if you can be a parent helper on school trips etc. no. I have a job. Like last time you asked.

Presumably they’re asking all parents, not just you? Just because people work full time it doesn’t mean they can’t occasionally rearrange their schedule to fit in the odd school trip. I don’t understand why you feel so offended by being asked.

User65412 · 31/08/2022 07:19

Pregnant then screwed on Instagram is trying to change the childcare situation in this country. They've already made great progress with this government. Please go and support them if you want to see change!

AppleKatie · 31/08/2022 07:19

The rhetoric that suggests after school club or other childcare is somehow bad for the poor tired children just boils down to patriarchal misogyny. My DC beg to be allowed to stay longer at afterschool club, and it’s not just my little weirdos I know other kids at the school do the same.

if the provision is good- and I do agree the provision isn’t always good- there is no guilt or shame attached.

OiFrogg · 31/08/2022 07:17

My DD primary school finishes at 3pm as does every single primary school in this area and tbh my sister s area.

Well the good (?) news is the govt has published a paper saying schools need to be open for 32.5 hours, ie 9-3.30, by 2023. It also states most schools are already open for this number of hours.

Q2C4 · 31/08/2022 07:02

MissAmbrosia · 30/08/2022 21:52

In Belgium this is available - 7.30 to 18.00 or 18.30 is standard in most state schools. It is never hosted by teachers - separate staff cover breakfast, lunchtime, evening. Kids cope perfectly well with this in my experience. Mine always played outside with her friends or did some activity or other til i picked her up - normally 5/5.30. Without trying to sound goady or anything, I am always slightly surprised that on MN all UK 5 year olds are seemingly exhausted by 3pm and need a snack (but not a lie down as the parents them take them on endless activities)

I agree - and it's only from 5yrs old.... kids younger than this may go to nursery from 8am-6pm without an issue!

londonrach · 31/08/2022 06:52

OiFrogg · 30/08/2022 21:29

  1. Being picky, but I've never worked in a school that didn't finish at 3.30pm. I've honestly never come across a school that finishes at 3pm.
  1. You state at most schools one of the options is to attend a kids' club. So you're saying wrap around care is available? I don't really understand what you are suggesting that is different to this.
  1. In expecting schools to provide an ASC, it will come back on teachers whether it should or not. I not infrequently have to stay til 6pm because staff from our ASC are off sick or we can't get cover or whatever. Working 3.30pm til 6pm are not popular working hours. Schools are struggling to recruit for all roles.
  1. I do agree it's hard as a working parent, and part of the difficulty is cost. Two days at nursery (basically the 30 hours free allowance spread across the year) doesn't even allow me to work two teaching days without taking a significant amount of work home with me (work that'd be more easily done in school).

My DD primary school finishes at 3pm as does every single primary school in this area and tbh my sister s area.

HikingBoots · 31/08/2022 06:32

This is the main reason that my husband (40) and I (38) aren't having kids.
We've always been on the fence and never had any overwhelming desire, but could certainly be swayed with the right circumstances.
But we've observed so many others do it - raise one or two kids, whilst working full time, without the luxury of family help, and it just looks too hard.
School hours of 9-3, and all of those school holidays to cover?! It's not that it's IMPOSSIBLE, but it creates a life that is expensive, busy, stressful and full of compromise and guilt.

MissTrip82 · 31/08/2022 04:42

There’s a huge number of jobs that can’t be done between 10 and 4 or ‘on the Internet’. Virtually every job that’s of significant value to society can’t be done that way.

My husband and I resuscitate people, including children, for a living. Funnily enough nobody seems to think our kid is doing ‘too long a day’ when we’re there saving your kid’s life. People are on board with us not dialing it in from home.

I can’t think of an emergency dept or ICU I’ve worked in that could even be half-staffed without parents working the kind of hours that make paid childcare essential.

sjxoxo · 31/08/2022 04:36

I think often the problem with debating this subject on MN is that we all give our 50p’s worth on our own situations & experiences - which of course is the point of mumsnet & a great thing - but this particular issue of working/mums/childcare is a big one because it will have long term outcomes on society. It’s not really about what we are each doing today in this context and whether it’s better or worse for us/our kids, it’s about what it all means in the bigger picture. And the truth is that two working parents in todays times means a lower birth rate. That’s bad news long term for the whole of society. x

MintJulia · 31/08/2022 04:22

TheNefariousOrange · 31/08/2022 03:15

What do you think the kids of teachers do? 🤨
What about single parents who don't have two incomes and don't want a life on benefits?

My dc love wrap around care. They get to see friends, have fun, do interesting activities or just chill out. It's not as if those extra hours are sat at a desk doing times tables. Your comment is incredibly self-righteous and you come across as a bit of a prick 🙂.

👏

InstaHun88 · 31/08/2022 03:47

The problem, I think, is so many of us have been forced to move away from wider family. When I was growing up most kids had grandparents and aunties and uncles around the corner to help. But most people my age have no family nearby so rely on organized childcare which is 1) expensive and 2)exhausting for the child. Not sure what the solution is.

MintJulia · 31/08/2022 03:37

Schools aren't there for the parents' benefit. They are there to educate children.

If there are two working parents in a household, they should be able to negotiate hours that allows one of you to do morning drop-off and one to do afternoon pickup. And having two salaries coming in, means you should be able to afford wraparound care.

As a single mum with no family support at all, and a completely absent ex, I still manage to work full time, and adjust/negotiate my employment to fit in with school and after school club, pay the mortgage etc. Now ds is teenage, I'm still doing it, because school is 20 miles away and there's no direct bus. It takes some flexing and a bit of planning but it can be done.

My ds always loved afterschool club. As an only child, they were his 'little tribe', they raced round together letting off steam for a couple of hours until I collected him. It worked well for everyone.

sjxoxo · 31/08/2022 03:25

CookieDoughKid · 31/08/2022 02:53

I had two babies and raised them through primary school years whilst myself and husband held down full on corporate roles. The sort of roles where folks regularly worked till 7pm, then went out for drinks on a Thursday and Friday and always got into work at 8am.... big city roles with big pay and a demanding boss who answered to THE Board. Guess what? I was the only working mother over the age of 35 in a twenty strong male sales team . I only stuck it out for the money and had to hire a live in nanny and then aupair to help me raise my children. Post pandemic, I now work from home more but i still work hours outside school hours. Much that I want to think we are being progressive in the work place the reality is that many FTSE100 companies demand long hours, at least in the early career stages and I just don't think companies WANT to be very flexible as they are driven by profit.

Wow I take my hat off to you. That sounds tough! Of course companies don’t want to be flexible because family life doesn’t make them money. In the UK we care only about money so the attitude of employers is pretty dire where families are concerned x

TheNefariousOrange · 31/08/2022 03:15

animalprintfree · 30/08/2022 21:32

8 til 6pm! Poor kids.

What do you think the kids of teachers do? 🤨
What about single parents who don't have two incomes and don't want a life on benefits?

My dc love wrap around care. They get to see friends, have fun, do interesting activities or just chill out. It's not as if those extra hours are sat at a desk doing times tables. Your comment is incredibly self-righteous and you come across as a bit of a prick 🙂.

CookieDoughKid · 31/08/2022 02:53

I had two babies and raised them through primary school years whilst myself and husband held down full on corporate roles. The sort of roles where folks regularly worked till 7pm, then went out for drinks on a Thursday and Friday and always got into work at 8am.... big city roles with big pay and a demanding boss who answered to THE Board. Guess what? I was the only working mother over the age of 35 in a twenty strong male sales team . I only stuck it out for the money and had to hire a live in nanny and then aupair to help me raise my children. Post pandemic, I now work from home more but i still work hours outside school hours. Much that I want to think we are being progressive in the work place the reality is that many FTSE100 companies demand long hours, at least in the early career stages and I just don't think companies WANT to be very flexible as they are driven by profit.

BritInAus · 31/08/2022 01:56

I'm in Australia. I don't know of any primary schools that don't have OSHC (Out of school hours care), generally from 7:30am - 6pm, so you can opt in any morning and/or afternoon sessions you need. They're very reasonable - I'm a slightly abov e average earner, and pay about the equivalent of 15 pounds per week for 4 sessions a week (3 morning, 1 after school). They're run by separate staff from school, and the cost includes a simple breakfast if there before 8:15 (toast and hot chocolate) and decent snacks after schools (fruit, veg, dip, crackers etc plus one extra treat item - eg sausage rolls, mini pizzas, cake, etc).

However, agree that flexibility for work is key - not just constant wraparound care. I'm lucky to be able to work from home a day and leave early one day.

Appleblum · 31/08/2022 01:46

I agree that it's a problem but I don't think wrap around childcare is the solution. I don't think it's in the best interests of young children to be out of the home for such long hours, it'll be even longer than the standard 9-5 work day!

There needs to be higher wages and more flexible working hours.

LilacPoppy · 31/08/2022 01:33

@StepAwayFromGoogling What? That is not how the housing market works. of course it is. Houses are only worth what people can afford to pay for them. If the average family had half the income they currently earn then house prices would drop.