Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
Libertyqueen · 31/08/2022 21:55

Iamnotthe1 · 30/08/2022 21:34

The thing that needs editing here is how we approach working arrangements, not schooling. It's not good for a young child to be in breakfast club, school and then after school club, basically seeing their parents only for getting up and going to bed. However, at the moment, some parents have little choice. We should be making it easier for parents to be more present in their child's life during term time rather than making it the expectation that they'll be away from them.

This. It really doesn’t benefit society to have two full time working parents who can’t afford high quality childcare. I’m very fortunate to be able to work 3 days a week spread over 5 and so do all the drop off and pick ups if needed. But when I’ve had to use ASC it’s been dismal. I really feel for families forced to use it. Staff are paid minimum wage. It’s hardly surprising.
If you are in a high flying career with your very own Mary poppins or have family help then it’s a different matter.
But family help will be few and far between for the next generation - how many millennials will be rich enough to retire in our 60s?

basilmint · 31/08/2022 21:45

rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 20:04

I suspect part of the problem selling this is that childless people already pay a great big whack of tax and are rarely entitled to anything in return, whereas parents are usually net takers not contributors, and of course they’re up for it because it means they’ll pay less to a childcare provider. For childless people with little interest in the mechanics of caring for primary school children, the benefits are there but far more abstract and we’re already forking out a lot for other people’s kids. Don’t get me wrong, I’m up for being a high tax, high provision society like Sweden. but I can see why many would be like, no, pay for your own sodding childcare.

Those childless people will one day rely on the current generation of children who will be creating tax revenue, providing necessary services and generally keeping the country going.

rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 20:04

I suspect part of the problem selling this is that childless people already pay a great big whack of tax and are rarely entitled to anything in return, whereas parents are usually net takers not contributors, and of course they’re up for it because it means they’ll pay less to a childcare provider. For childless people with little interest in the mechanics of caring for primary school children, the benefits are there but far more abstract and we’re already forking out a lot for other people’s kids. Don’t get me wrong, I’m up for being a high tax, high provision society like Sweden. but I can see why many would be like, no, pay for your own sodding childcare.

DobbyHasASock · 31/08/2022 19:20

Because current government subsidies mean nurseries and childminders run at a loss.
And I'd resent paying more taxes to just pip myself and other childcare workers over minimum wage.
But would be happy if either we were paid as professionals or current taxes were used effectively.
Obviously pigs will fly before that happens.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/08/2022 18:45

TheLostNights · 31/08/2022 18:28

Yes, I also think people don't seem to see that childcare workers deserve to be paid well and valued for what they do. They are very looked down upon and I can very much see why there is a recruitment issues in childcare. It's very poorly paid, stressful and not valued as a profession despite it being such an important job role.

Agree with this. And government subsidy is probably the only real solution. I for one would be very happy to pay taxes for this, even if it didn’t benefit me personally.

Its a huge win for society to free women up to work and focus on their careers rather than having to limit everything in order to be the default childcare provider.

If people then make a decision that they would prefer to be at home and have the resources to do so then let them crack on. But why wouldn’t you want a solution which benefits parents overall and supports women in gaining financial independence. I can’t see why anyone would oppose that.

Hulahoops78 · 31/08/2022 18:45

I totally agree. I was full-time pre having DD, but now part-time. I have had to alter my hours again when she starts school in a couple of weeks time. It feels it is the woman who has to sacrifice career etc.

In addition, a friend of mine with a DD going to another school has said that afterschool wraparound is a bun fight. I am not saying you should discriminate against parents that don't work, but parents who do work should be offered wraparound 1st.

TheLostNights · 31/08/2022 18:28

Yes, I also think people don't seem to see that childcare workers deserve to be paid well and valued for what they do. They are very looked down upon and I can very much see why there is a recruitment issues in childcare. It's very poorly paid, stressful and not valued as a profession despite it being such an important job role.

OperaStation · 31/08/2022 18:19

Mummybud · 31/08/2022 18:08

@OperaStation What’s downtime? Sitting in front of Netflix while their mum writes judgemental comments about full time working parents on MumsNet? I’d rather my kids were in after school club to be honest.

Downtime is watching TV, sitting in the sofa with your parents, listening to an audiobook, playing with your toys.

I think you know what downtime in the context of children is so I don’t know why I’m telling you.

Mummybud · 31/08/2022 18:08

@OperaStation What’s downtime? Sitting in front of Netflix while their mum writes judgemental comments about full time working parents on MumsNet? I’d rather my kids were in after school club to be honest.

DobbyHasASock · 31/08/2022 15:01

Just to add that the government funded thirty hours means the childcare professional gets below minimum wage, so I would have absolutely no faith that any scheme extended from early years wouldn't try to pass costs onto childminders and nurseries, like they have with the funded hours.

Sadly, childcare professionals are mostly in it for the right reasons so generally do suck it up but it's absolutely criminal that people pay dogsitters more than adults qualified in childcare.

TheLostNights · 31/08/2022 14:40

Agree with the point made above saying that parents want quality childcare with well qualified staff but complain about the cost.
I know people who don't think twice about paying their cleaner a good hourly rate but will complain about paying the nanny or wraparound care provider. 🤔
There's childcare vouchers as well which help pay for wraparound care and can often make huge savings.
I am personally able to have Fridays off work and DH often a day in the week so we only use wraparound care 3 days a week. The kids love it, much more so than when we had an after school nanny.

OperaStation · 31/08/2022 14:16

luxxlisbon · 31/08/2022 10:09

My toddler deals absolutely fine with nursery 8:30 to 5:30, I’m sure an 8 year old can cope with wrap around care.
Why is it automatically better for kids to be at home after school but not ASC?
Is it okay to go to the park on the way home from school but not ASC?
Or should they go home and just be plonked in front of the tv?
I genuinely don’t understand the people painting wrap around care as this awful thing which is awful for children.

I think the point that people are trying to make is that kids need downtime. They get this when they go home after school. They can relax and be themselves after spending all day concentrating and behaving. School is very tiring for young children. After school club is fun and they’re with their friends but they can’t just switch off and relax. And by the time they get home it’s often dinner time and then bedtime with very little time to just relax and spend some time with parents.

weaselish · 31/08/2022 12:21

I agree with many that better childcare options combined with flexible working where possible is the answer. We both work full time and do a mix of before school club, nanny after school and me on Fridays as I work from home on Fridays and negotiated an early finish (swapping for a longer day which my husband covers the morning). We also occasionally use after school club if my nanny is off. We're lucky the school has lots of places as it's held in the hall, run by the YMCA.
And as for those posters bleating on about "poor kids" and how horrible it must be for them to not have their parents after school etc - give it a rest! Given lots of parents have to both work, you're just making people feel guilty! Well done you for having whatever set up you have - but for parents who chose continue their career, have to work, or don't have the option of any flexibility, they can only do their best with what they have! And their kids will be totally fine.

CookieDoughKid · 31/08/2022 11:39

@sjxoxo Thanks! Fortunately earning the big bucks means I could afford to buy childcare but I appreciate how unaffordable this is for many other professions.

Classicblunder · 31/08/2022 11:31

It's interesting to me how peer pressure affects how you feel about wraparound care. My kids were in 8-6 nursery (we usually pick up by 5 though) and it felt absolutely fine, we socialised mostly with parents of their nursery friends who were doing the same obviously.

We get to reception and even though the school has a great wraparound offer -7:30-6:30 - our son is the only one in his year who goes, he enjoys it but it makes us feel self conscious and different and stressed about whether it's ok.

Now we will just get over it as neither of us is interested in giving up work but it was an eye-opener the impact that peer pressure has on how you feel.

BringOnSummerHolidays · 31/08/2022 11:21

DH and I are both full time and not WFH until Covid. We had a very reliable childminder. She was brilliant and if I was delayed on the commute, she knows without me having to ring her while stuck on the motorway. There are also breakfast and after school club but they aren’t as good with commute delays. So glad we can WFH now.

antelopevalley · 31/08/2022 11:08

I would not be happy with higher taxes for this as the people who would benefit most are middle-class. People on lower wages are much more likely to work outside 9-5 and would largely not benefit from this.

Thatswhyimacat · 31/08/2022 11:06

I think the answer has to lie in better childcare options not in providing wages that means families only need one earner. Simply because that one earner is inevitably going to be the man and it will be regressive for women in the workplace and women's financial independence.

JubileeTrifle · 31/08/2022 11:02

Remember wraparound has to be available so people who work in schools can work also! They can’t do flexible working for pickups.

My primary offered zero wraparound and there was almost nothing locally. One childminder did pick ups and that was it. It’s a massive barrier for lots of people to work.

DobbyHasASock · 31/08/2022 10:48

Again, if you are happy with taxes going up then that's fair enough.
I doubt many people would be though and I would certainly resent paying more Tex so I could pay myself a fair wage(as childcare providers wouldn't be exempt from the tax presumably.)
I am very much in favour of not squandering our tax on pointless shit but that never seems to be a realistic option.

Frezia · 31/08/2022 10:41

"It would be nice if the government would subsidise it but ultimately you would be asking childless people to foot the bill for your choice to have children. I'm not sure that's fair."

Not this nugget again. Investing in services for children is investing in the long-term wellbeing of the whole of society, including childless people. Prosperous Scandinavian societies have recognised it, only here people seem to have an idea that it's not fair Hmm

basilmint · 31/08/2022 10:34

Oops, I think wraparound are works best when it is provided by an outside specialist provider. The school I work at tried to do it in-house and it was a disaster. They understaffed it and were constantly begging people to step in if the regular person was sick. They didn't have enough staff to keep the children safe and didn't spend enough on resources to keep the kids occupied because they were trying to save money. The office staff had to manage the admin on top of their everyday school work.

My DC's school use an outside provider. It is slightly more expensive but they have a proper staffing and booking structure. Bank staff are available if a regular staff member is unwell. Children are sufficiently fed and entertained.

When my DC started school there was no on-site provision and I had to use a mish-mash of private providers that would collect from the school (expensive) and childminders who had a space crop up.

Beezknees · 31/08/2022 10:32

I'm a lone parent and I've managed to work full time for 7 years since DC was 7.

basilmint · 31/08/2022 10:29

I d

DobbyHasASock · 31/08/2022 10:26

Bottom line is childcare is a profession that requires skill, trustworthy people and dedication. If you want decent childcare you need to be willing to value it and therefore play for it. It would be nice if the government would subsidise it but ultimately you would be asking childless people to foot the bill for your choice to have children. I'm not sure that's fair.

It always astounds me that people expect quality childcare for minimum wage then wonder why childminders, teachers and nursery workers willing to do it for life are hard to find.
Ultimately I think no one should be working the hours we are expected to work in this day and age, with the technology we have and understanding of mental health on productivity. Business needs to adapt for modern life, not expecting childcare experts to always pick up the slack.