Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
RagingWoke · 01/09/2022 13:44

@antelopevalley Responses show just how short sighted and selfish people not living this reality are.

so what happens when those anecdotal drivers retire? Who replaces them? Any chance it's the children of today?

And re caring for elderly relatives, perhaps it would happen more if people could afford to live on once wage so a family unit could have one adult at home able to take on caring for elderly relatives. It's not simple reluctance to do it, often it's simply not possible within time constraints of working, family life and trying to care for another adult if it's more than an hour a few times a week.

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 13:36

drspouse · 01/09/2022 13:23

@Whyaretheynotdoinganything because @rainbowmilk is going for voluntary euthanasia as soon as she needs any care.
We only need replacement levels of births. We can to some extent get the workers we need through immigration but since a) their home countries need them too and b) we need a lot of them to have familiarity with English and with UK culture that's not a complete answer.

I disagree that most jobs need any “familiarity with English and with UK culture”. I live in London and half the people I come across in my work life, social life and in day to day interactions was not born in the UK. They manage just fine.

The real problem with immigration is that the voting population of this country is right leaning and has been brainwashed into thinking that immigration is a bad thing. No political party will ever win and election on a promise to relax immigration rules.

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 13:32

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 13:20

But older people can do the job as well. It does not need young people.

Sure, and what happens when those older people retire or die? Who will back fill those jobs if we stop having children?

drspouse · 01/09/2022 13:23

@Whyaretheynotdoinganything because @rainbowmilk is going for voluntary euthanasia as soon as she needs any care.
We only need replacement levels of births. We can to some extent get the workers we need through immigration but since a) their home countries need them too and b) we need a lot of them to have familiarity with English and with UK culture that's not a complete answer.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 13:20

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 13:04

Thanks for your anecdotal evidence. My Ocado drivers are almost all in their 20s and 30s.

But older people can do the job as well. It does not need young people.

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 13:06

OutsideLookingOut · 01/09/2022 12:51

but how sustainable is this? Each generation must have more and more children like some giant pyramid scheme… unless we vastly change our lifestyles not even the earth will sustain it. Climate change is already causing problems

Not more children than previous generations, but enough to keep the pension pots topped up and vital services staffed.

Why is this so difficult for people to grasp?

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 13:04

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 12:31

Why do you need young people to deliver your shopping? Most of the shopping deliveries I get are delivered by drivers aged 50 to 72 years old. I know the oldest ones age as he told me.

Thanks for your anecdotal evidence. My Ocado drivers are almost all in their 20s and 30s.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 12:55

It would actually help more if more families helped look after elderly relatives. It used to be common until recently. No one wants to do it any more.

OutsideLookingOut · 01/09/2022 12:51

Whyaretheynotdoinganything · 01/09/2022 12:45

@rainbowmilk those taxpayers reluctant to pay for nurturing the next generation and supporting parents to work, need to think more long term ie. whose gonna wipe their arse when they no longer can? Or pay into your pension scheme when you are taking out?

We need to support people to have kids as the ageing population is a ticking time bomb. Funding childcare is one way to increase tax take AND build the pipeline of future tax payers and carers of a bulging elderly population.

I hate how short sighted our population has become (not you!). We need to invest in the longer term prosperity of this country!

but how sustainable is this? Each generation must have more and more children like some giant pyramid scheme… unless we vastly change our lifestyles not even the earth will sustain it. Climate change is already causing problems

rainbowmilk · 01/09/2022 12:48

Whyaretheynotdoinganything · 01/09/2022 12:45

@rainbowmilk those taxpayers reluctant to pay for nurturing the next generation and supporting parents to work, need to think more long term ie. whose gonna wipe their arse when they no longer can? Or pay into your pension scheme when you are taking out?

We need to support people to have kids as the ageing population is a ticking time bomb. Funding childcare is one way to increase tax take AND build the pipeline of future tax payers and carers of a bulging elderly population.

I hate how short sighted our population has become (not you!). We need to invest in the longer term prosperity of this country!

My post on the previous page with the numbered points covered pretty much all of this.

Whyaretheynotdoinganything · 01/09/2022 12:45

@rainbowmilk those taxpayers reluctant to pay for nurturing the next generation and supporting parents to work, need to think more long term ie. whose gonna wipe their arse when they no longer can? Or pay into your pension scheme when you are taking out?

We need to support people to have kids as the ageing population is a ticking time bomb. Funding childcare is one way to increase tax take AND build the pipeline of future tax payers and carers of a bulging elderly population.

I hate how short sighted our population has become (not you!). We need to invest in the longer term prosperity of this country!

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 12:42

I think there are much more urgent issues to address.

rainbowmilk · 01/09/2022 12:40

basilmint · 01/09/2022 12:29

Its not just about carers though. You will need younger people to deliver your shopping, supply your energy, produce your food. Every generation is reliant on the next and for a period of time the next generation ate young and require education and childcare.

Yes, I’m aware of that. Everyone paying for their education is part of the social contract. r paying for their childcare is not, and simply repeating “we need young people” isn’t going to help sell it as a new introduction to the social contract.

And for the final time, I am actually for high tax high provision society. But I think to get others on board you’d need to ensure that service provision across the board for everyone improves, not just stuff parents would like.

rainbowmilk · 01/09/2022 12:36

drspouse · 01/09/2022 12:31

I’m hoping and praying that voluntary euthanasia becomes legal and your child doesn’t have to wipe my bum in my care home.
So you are hoping that as soon as you need any e.g. operation post-retirement age (which could potentially lead to you having another 20 years of happy independent life) you will be bumped off purely to save a few weeks of care??
What if you develop a mental illness in ten years' time and need inpatient care? Will you ask to be euthanised then? Or hope that psychiatric nurses are around, with the jobs being filled by the 11 year olds of today?

I’d like to have options. At the moment, there are no options and I’ve seen the inside of too many care homes to want to end up there.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 12:31

Why do you need young people to deliver your shopping? Most of the shopping deliveries I get are delivered by drivers aged 50 to 72 years old. I know the oldest ones age as he told me.

drspouse · 01/09/2022 12:31

I’m hoping and praying that voluntary euthanasia becomes legal and your child doesn’t have to wipe my bum in my care home.
So you are hoping that as soon as you need any e.g. operation post-retirement age (which could potentially lead to you having another 20 years of happy independent life) you will be bumped off purely to save a few weeks of care??
What if you develop a mental illness in ten years' time and need inpatient care? Will you ask to be euthanised then? Or hope that psychiatric nurses are around, with the jobs being filled by the 11 year olds of today?

basilmint · 01/09/2022 12:29

Its not just about carers though. You will need younger people to deliver your shopping, supply your energy, produce your food. Every generation is reliant on the next and for a period of time the next generation ate young and require education and childcare.

rainbowmilk · 01/09/2022 11:43

I knew I’d get a million comments about how your kids are paying my taxes etc etc etc.

A few points on that.

  1. Childless people are already paying towards services that we get no direct benefit from. We pay tax for maternity provision, schools, child healthcare, etc. That’s why we then expect those kids as adults to pay taxes to support us in our old age. That’s part of the social contract etc., and it’s already happening. This thread is about providing even more of taxpayers money to parents to assist with childcare. Essentially what we’re saying is that childless people should be happy to pay even more tax for anything which bolsters the birth rate, and I’m saying that that’s a hard sell.

  2. Falling birth rates are a thing in many countries now, and it isn’t all about subsidised childcare. In my view people have babies if they want them or they don’t if they don’t. Environmental concerns are putting people off, as are housing prices and general cost of living issues. Are we saying that taxpayers should be paying even more tax to subsidise the housing costs and bills of childbearing age couples? If not, why not? It’d help the birth rate, wouldn’t it?

  3. I’m hoping and praying that voluntary euthanasia becomes legal and your child doesn’t have to wipe my bum in my care home. I’m not reliant on a state pension or NHS as I don’t believe either will exist, and I’d much rather we weren’t locked into a pyramid scheme of endlessly creating more and more babies just to keep people like me alive beyond any enjoyment of life.

  4. Most people do not have children that go on to be carers anyway. I don’t care about this as taxes will be spent to help raise them regardless but acting like we need to be paying everyone’s childcare because all of these kids are going to be future carers and nurses is nonsense.

Anyway as I said I’m not actually against it in principle but I can see why it’s a hard sell. Childless people are already paying disproportionately more than parents and asking more of us is bound to sow discord.

RagingWoke · 01/09/2022 08:22

rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 20:04

I suspect part of the problem selling this is that childless people already pay a great big whack of tax and are rarely entitled to anything in return, whereas parents are usually net takers not contributors, and of course they’re up for it because it means they’ll pay less to a childcare provider. For childless people with little interest in the mechanics of caring for primary school children, the benefits are there but far more abstract and we’re already forking out a lot for other people’s kids. Don’t get me wrong, I’m up for being a high tax, high provision society like Sweden. but I can see why many would be like, no, pay for your own sodding childcare.

Most people are net takers. You have to be a very high tax payer to not be.

Those childless people will no doubt expect care, services, state pensions and everything else these children will provide in years to come? Then public funding to make sure people continue to have children and they can be raised with the right care provisions isn't a big ask.

A falling birth rate is a disaster for everyone.

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 07:30

rainbowmilk · 31/08/2022 20:04

I suspect part of the problem selling this is that childless people already pay a great big whack of tax and are rarely entitled to anything in return, whereas parents are usually net takers not contributors, and of course they’re up for it because it means they’ll pay less to a childcare provider. For childless people with little interest in the mechanics of caring for primary school children, the benefits are there but far more abstract and we’re already forking out a lot for other people’s kids. Don’t get me wrong, I’m up for being a high tax, high provision society like Sweden. but I can see why many would be like, no, pay for your own sodding childcare.

That’s a very simplistic view of the tax system and society as a whole.

Parents are only net takers from the tax system if you think there is no benefit to the UK from people having and raising children. Someone who chooses not to have children still need others to have children. Who do they think will provide their care in old age? Who are the people who will be paying taxes to keep the country afloat in 20 years time? The falling birth rate in the UK presents a very real threat to the future wealth of the country and is bad news for all of us unless we relax our immigration laws.

user1487194234 · 01/09/2022 07:22

There is no way I would have sacrificed my career to the benefit of my husband’s
And to be fair he would never have wanted that either

Thepeopleversuswork · 01/09/2022 07:08

CookieDoughKid · 01/09/2022 02:41

@Thepeopleversuswork Because there is still a lot of men out there who firmly see it as the womans place to stay at home and male chauvinism is still in abundance. There needs to be a lot more successful women in positions of power, influence and money and they need to be in equal or a majority number to make a difference.

Yep. And a lot of women who have internalised the idea that it's their job by default. Hence all the "poor kids" comments about children in daycare. Because that's the mother's job. Obviously.

CookieDoughKid · 01/09/2022 02:41

@Thepeopleversuswork Because there is still a lot of men out there who firmly see it as the womans place to stay at home and male chauvinism is still in abundance. There needs to be a lot more successful women in positions of power, influence and money and they need to be in equal or a majority number to make a difference.

TheSmallAssassin · 01/09/2022 00:11

Hulahoops78 · 31/08/2022 18:45

I totally agree. I was full-time pre having DD, but now part-time. I have had to alter my hours again when she starts school in a couple of weeks time. It feels it is the woman who has to sacrifice career etc.

In addition, a friend of mine with a DD going to another school has said that afterschool wraparound is a bun fight. I am not saying you should discriminate against parents that don't work, but parents who do work should be offered wraparound 1st.

There is no reason why it has to be the woman who sacrifices their career, legally dads have as many rights as mums to request flexible working hours. We just have to make it happen! I did, there was no way we weren't sharing the childcare burden equally. We happened to be earning about the same, but even if we didn't then it's short term thinking to only consider current salary and not earning potential. I earn more than my husband now, having earnt slightly less than him for years.

Fynix · 31/08/2022 22:05

I work full time nights and partner full time days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread