Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary schools and childcare arent designed for 2 full-time working parents

317 replies

Greywall2 · 30/08/2022 21:22

In 2019, 7 out of 10 households with dependent children had two working parents - ons survey . After covid and with the cost of living crisis, it's likely there has been an increase.

Primary school opening times are between 9am and 3pm (give or take 15 minutes), but a standard working day is 9 till 5. For children with 2 working parents this means that without wrapping around childcare or very flexible working agreements in place, both cannot work full time hours.

Reasonably priced wrap around care is in place for some schools, but in many schools the only option for out of hours care is to employ a childminder or kids club to care for children out of hours. Nurseries tend to be open 8 - 6 and give more flexibility and by secondary school children are able to go to and from school by themselves.

AIBU to think that the government should assist primary schools to allow them to provide wrap around care? I am NOT saying that teachers should be available between 8am and 5 or 6pm, but that there should be a childcare option available.

Children are (rightly of course!) are legally required to have an education, but the timings of the provision mean that parents can't work in certain jobs and financially support their family. The parent/parents who can't afford wrap around care may get fired for not being at work on time and the parent/parents who don't drop off and pickup their children on time are punished as there is no one to look after them (of course as teachers have gone home).

Of course life is unfair and people should budget for childcare costs, but unexpected things happen such as the rise in energy prices or interest rate rises and the childcare options for primary aged children are seem very restrictive.

OP posts:
PuppetEars · 06/09/2022 12:22

Whyaretheynotdoinganything · 01/09/2022 12:45

@rainbowmilk those taxpayers reluctant to pay for nurturing the next generation and supporting parents to work, need to think more long term ie. whose gonna wipe their arse when they no longer can? Or pay into your pension scheme when you are taking out?

We need to support people to have kids as the ageing population is a ticking time bomb. Funding childcare is one way to increase tax take AND build the pipeline of future tax payers and carers of a bulging elderly population.

I hate how short sighted our population has become (not you!). We need to invest in the longer term prosperity of this country!

It's 30 plus years too late.

The baby boomers could not/would not have enough children to replace themselves, for a multitude of reasons.
Now they are moving into retirement, liquidating the capital that they put into our economy.

There are not nearly enough young working age adults NOW to make up for the loss we are going through as the baby boomers cease to work and pay taxes, and become service users.

Our economy is not going to improve. We've had the best of it.

RunningSME · 06/09/2022 12:07

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 05/09/2022 20:58

Typical school day in China is 7.30-5. That’s actual school, not wrap around.

Do you have any stats on Chinese children’s mental health at all ? My daughter was out their doing year three of uni and basically the kids even more fucked up than they are here which is saying something.

RunningSME · 06/09/2022 12:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JackandSam · 06/09/2022 11:54

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 21:39

Many council officer jobs and probably other public sectors too. 10-4 core hours doesn't mean that's the extent of the working day. It might be 8-4 or 10-6 or 10-4 with the missing 2 hours a day made up for some other time like evenings or weekends.

I work across the local authority and NHS and not a single role I work with or know of offers that flexibility. Yes core hours are 10-3, but the reality is that work is 8.30-4.30 or 9-5 and not flexible, even if it is WFH. I'm lucky that my manager gives me a very high degree of flexibility but if other people found out about it, it'd be taken away, my manager and I have to work below the radar with regard to the flexibility we afford my team.

Grasshopper30 · 05/09/2022 23:09

No, you're left with literally thousands and thousands of office-based roles across a multitude of industries including many of the ones you have mentioned which have an army of office workers that mean the customer facing workers can do their jobs!

Notlosinganyweight · 05/09/2022 22:41

Username917778 · 30/08/2022 21:39

I don't believe the answer is children spending more time in childcare/wraparound care but raising wages to a point where both parents don't have to work full time hours and can afford to work flexibly.

Agree with this.

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 22:06

I never wanted wrap around care, I wanted more time with my kids than that and I still think 1 wage should be enough to provide for 4 people. But it isn't. Needs must - I'm about to start sending mine to breakfast club 3 days a week and I know its the thin end of the wedge - they're on the waiting list for the other 2 days and after school club too. So all the people here talking about how their kids are thriving on it are giving me some hope that it will be ok

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 21:39

ChobKnees · 30/08/2022 22:43

Which jobs offer 10-4?

Many council officer jobs and probably other public sectors too. 10-4 core hours doesn't mean that's the extent of the working day. It might be 8-4 or 10-6 or 10-4 with the missing 2 hours a day made up for some other time like evenings or weekends.

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 21:06

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 20:58

So right, so refreshing to see someone else say it

This wasn't meant to be a stand alone statement - I'm new here...

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 21:05

jewishmum · 30/08/2022 21:36

I don't think it's in the child's psychological best interests to be without either parent for so long every day.

I do think that wages should be such that one working parent earns enough to provide for his/her family.

So right and so refreshing to see someone else say it

Pilosella · 05/09/2022 20:58

So right, so refreshing to see someone else say it

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 05/09/2022 20:58

animalprintfree · 30/08/2022 21:32

8 til 6pm! Poor kids.

Typical school day in China is 7.30-5. That’s actual school, not wrap around.

Tallulah28 · 05/09/2022 19:23

Agreed! That’s a really unhealthy proportion of their week spent in a school…

WoodlandMummy · 01/09/2022 15:52

Lanesdown · 30/08/2022 22:30

My kids were in nursery from 7 months + wrap around childcare from 7am until 6pm, in fact we used to leave the house at 6.45am and return at 6.15pm! This was for 3 days a week for years until covid hit. They are now 9 and 11 and well rounded, confident and independent kids. Let's stop with the "poor kids" judgement and assumptions that these set ups are detrimental to a child's wellbeing. My kids are doing amazing and This helped me keep a well paid job and career we are benefitting from now.

All the kids I know that were brought up like yours are confident, happy and outgoing children. It can’t be a coincidence that the kids I know who were at home with a SAHM are all a bit clingy and nowhere near as confident. I was brought up by a SAHM and was so so clingy and used to get homesick and have to come home early from sleepovers. I wish I’d have been exposed to nursery or more social stuff away from my mother!

drspouse · 01/09/2022 15:26

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 14:34

An HCP from another country had no idea what my mum meant when she talked about her athlete's foot.

Ha! And that's even before we get on to elderly women talking about "trouble downstairs", men with their "back passage" and "passing water" or "I can't get it up".

We need home grown HCPs, carers, and school staff and where we can't grow them all, we need not to assume they can parachute in and be ready for action at a day's notice. Overseas HCPs and social care/education staff are brilliant but it's daft to rely on them and assume we don't need any new well-educated adults coming up any time in the next 40 years, and we don't need taxes from their parents.

I've increased my hours at work this year (because I'm lucky enough to have a DH WFH more or less full time and when he has to go into the office I can cover the slack) and my additional income is more than the increase in childcare for DD for whom we can actually get childcare. It's more than the increase would be for DS if we could get it for him as well. But I'd work more efficiently if we could get that, as well.

Zonder · 01/09/2022 15:25

drspouse · 01/09/2022 15:21

You haven't actually read what I wrote, have you?

Just what I was going to write.

drspouse · 01/09/2022 15:21

You haven't actually read what I wrote, have you?

OperaStation · 01/09/2022 15:03

drspouse · 01/09/2022 14:30

@OperaStation - I have a DS who needs a PA/carer/mentor and TAs at his school. I expect him to be able to live independently when he's older but some of his age-mates won't be able to so will continue to need care when they are adults.
He needs TAs and teachers who speak excellent English and are familiar to a fairly good extent with the culture he's living in - he's not great (as in fact most children aren't) at explaining what on earth he's talking about and the TAs that know which particular computer game he's referring to are some of the best.
The same will be true of adults with learning disabilities.
Adults who need care in their home are obviously going to need carers who speak enough English to communicate with them. Clearly once people have lived in the UK for a while they will know enough to e.g. buy the right shopping or know which foods an elderly person likes to eat, but even moving to the UK from another English-speaking country you could make mistakes at first given the dissimilarity of different Englishes.
Many new-to-the-UK doctors are caught out by patients referring enigmatically to the body parts they are having problems with.
I'm not quite sure why this is controversial? "Familiarity with English and with UK culture" does not mean "British born and bred". It does mean you can't just say "let's ship 1000 Filipino/Spanish/Canadian nurses over here for tomorrow".

So a Canadian TA couldn’t look after your son? How ridiculous.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 14:42

It is not always possible I agree.
Because of the lack of carers, many people living in their own homes are got out of bed very early or late and put to bed very early. Early evening is not unusual. So do not assume that your scenario is not a reality just because you have paid carers.
My friend helped her mum move close to her so it was possible. I do know not everyone can move.

RagingWoke · 01/09/2022 14:39

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 13:51

@RagingWoke , Of course, we need younger workers as well.
Most people who need care do not need full-time care. A friend worked full-time and looked after her mum. Seeing to her mum before work, she popped back at lunchtime or had meals in wheels pop in when she could not, then looked after her in the evening. When people need 24-hour care you are usually talking about dementia and that is a whole different kettle of fish.

Oh well your friend did it so it's unanimous then!

It doesn't have to be 24 hour care before help is needed. And just because one person managed to help her mum while working doesn't mean it's an option for everyone. Let's take a fictitious example, parent needs care at home, an hour morning and evening to get up/dressed and then ready for bed. Adult child would like to help, but works full time 37 hours a week, has an hour or more commute each way plus dc (and limited childcare because provision is shit and unaffordable) and that hour morning and evening isn't a small ask and would mean parent needing care is being woken and up at 5/6am and then helped to get ready for bed at 7/8pm. Adult child doing the caring is burnt out before they know it.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 14:34

An HCP from another country had no idea what my mum meant when she talked about her athlete's foot.

drspouse · 01/09/2022 14:30

@OperaStation - I have a DS who needs a PA/carer/mentor and TAs at his school. I expect him to be able to live independently when he's older but some of his age-mates won't be able to so will continue to need care when they are adults.
He needs TAs and teachers who speak excellent English and are familiar to a fairly good extent with the culture he's living in - he's not great (as in fact most children aren't) at explaining what on earth he's talking about and the TAs that know which particular computer game he's referring to are some of the best.
The same will be true of adults with learning disabilities.
Adults who need care in their home are obviously going to need carers who speak enough English to communicate with them. Clearly once people have lived in the UK for a while they will know enough to e.g. buy the right shopping or know which foods an elderly person likes to eat, but even moving to the UK from another English-speaking country you could make mistakes at first given the dissimilarity of different Englishes.
Many new-to-the-UK doctors are caught out by patients referring enigmatically to the body parts they are having problems with.
I'm not quite sure why this is controversial? "Familiarity with English and with UK culture" does not mean "British born and bred". It does mean you can't just say "let's ship 1000 Filipino/Spanish/Canadian nurses over here for tomorrow".

neverbeenskiing · 01/09/2022 13:52

It would actually help more if more families helped look after elderly relatives. It used to be common until recently. No one wants to do it any more.

It's not just that "no one wants to do it". It's been pointed out many times on this thread that most households need two wages coming in to make ends meet. Most people aren't in a position to quit their jobs so they can provide care for an elderly relative.

antelopevalley · 01/09/2022 13:51

@RagingWoke , Of course, we need younger workers as well.
Most people who need care do not need full-time care. A friend worked full-time and looked after her mum. Seeing to her mum before work, she popped back at lunchtime or had meals in wheels pop in when she could not, then looked after her in the evening. When people need 24-hour care you are usually talking about dementia and that is a whole different kettle of fish.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 01/09/2022 13:49

BotterMon · 30/08/2022 21:46

This is common in Europe - 8am to 6pm is the norm or even earlier at the majority of schools. Funny that those kids turn out absolutely fine!

The UK is massively behind a lot of other countries in terms of working parent support whether it be the hours of childcare available and/or the cost.

I lived in France. This is certainly not the case there. The school bus picked children up at 8.30 for a 9am start, it left to bring them them back at 3..30 or 4. Some of the teenagers did longer hours.

the schools closed when the children left in the afternoon. They did not run holiday clubs,,people made their own arrangements. Some of the communes (towns) had holiday activities, mainly families made their own arrangements with relatives.