Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these dog walkers are bonkers.

161 replies

QuebecBagnet · 30/08/2022 21:02

So at the weekend me and a mate went mountain biking in a local wood. The wood is totally private property and owned by the local cycle shop. No public right of way at all. There is a sign by the entrance saying “bike trail”. You used to have to be a member of the shop’s cycling club to use it but think they’ve stopped that now (I’m a member anyway).

it’s a proper mountain bike track, single track, twisty through the trees, loads of jumps and berms. It’s admittedly not very well used and I’m often the only person there when I go.

we came across two different groups of dog walkers on the path. First one a solo woman with an off lead dog. The second lot a group of 5-6 people with 5-6 off lead dogs. Dogs were running infront of the people (out of their sight) and I nearly flattened them as I came round a bend. First dog was growling and snarling and baring it’s teeth at me. We obviously stopped until the owners came running and put them on leads. They were apologetic about the dogs

I Politely pointed out it’s not a public right of way and they just sort of shrugged and said it’s a nice walk and that maybe we should go slower! They seemed so adamant that it was ok them being there that I came home and checked the OS map and definitely no right of way. No where near a right of way.

Why would they walk on a single track mountain bike trail? It’s dangerous for me as well as them!

OP posts:
SirenSays · 31/08/2022 09:08

If you're often the only person using it on a bike, but there are 7 dog walkers I'd be closing it as a bike path and opening it back up as a dog walking area

megletthesecond · 31/08/2022 09:04

Yanbu. The bikes take priority.
I occasionally walk a dog and am ruthless about not letting it be a dick and keeping it on lead.

Those dog walkers are as bad as parents who let their dc's run around car parks or scoot way ahead of them.

MillyWithaY · 31/08/2022 09:01

Lampyshady · 30/08/2022 21:29

They technically shouldn’t be there but it’s still up to you not to hurt them by riding your bike dangerously fast into them or their dogs-that would probably be a criminal offence whereas trespassing isn’t. So maybe their advice to go slower and watch out for people wasn’t too far off the mark-surely you could have hit another bike anyway if you were going that fast?
also it sounds odd that you’re allowed to go on the land if you’re a member of the public that has a bike but not if you don’t have a bike-surely it’s either private land that no one can use without express permission or it’s not.

It's a bike trail, for bikes, and a one way system to boot! Would you tell skiers they should ski slowly on a ski slopes incase a dog walker decide to take a stroll across the piste?

JustFrustrated · 31/08/2022 09:01

NumptiesIncorporated · 31/08/2022 08:21

They technically shouldn’t be there but it’s still up to you not to hurt them by riding your bike dangerously fast into them or their dogs-that would probably be a criminal offence whereas trespassing isn’t

Yeah.

And people shouldn't trespass on the track at Silverstone when there's a race on, but it's up to the drivers not to hurt them by not driving dangerously fast into them.

That's hilarious. You think they drive around Silverstone cautious of pedestrians? They don't. Not unless they've been told pedestrians are on track.

As a viewer, if say, Verstappen hit a pedestrian on track that wasn't meant to be there, a trespasser my first thoughts would be sympathy for him, then confusion as to where security were.

At no point would I feel remotely sorry for the person on the track. They weren't allowed there, due to you know FAST MOVING VEHICLES.

Obviously, that doesn't stand if it's a Marshall, as they've obviously made the drivers aware, and they're doing something to make the track safe again.

Prescottdanni123 · 31/08/2022 08:55

@NovaDeltas

Hi! I'm on mumsnet and I know perfectly well what a purpose built mountain bike trail is. It is something that I would never walk my dog on.

Prescottdanni123 · 31/08/2022 08:53

As a dog owner, I would never take my dog on a bike trail. Come to think about it, I wouldn't walk along a bike trail without my dog. It is not a footpath.

NumptiesIncorporated · 31/08/2022 08:52

Mothership4two · 31/08/2022 08:42

@NumptiesIncorporated ·

They technically shouldn’t be there but it’s still up to you not to hurt them by riding your bike dangerously fast into them or their dogs-that would probably be a criminal offence whereas trespassing isn’t

I'm no legal expert but I would find that doubtful. If you trespass and put yourself in danger, I would imagine you would be liable. However, I hope the cycle club has sufficient signage that this is private land with no trespassing as they could end up liable if there was an accident.

You are tagging me, making it look like that was my quote. It isn't. My comment was in answer to that. The original quote was by @Lampyshady

Scianel · 31/08/2022 08:49

For people that aren't aware, this is what mountain biking trails look like and how people ride them. As you can see it would be really dangerous to have walkers, children and dogs doddering around on them:

Mothership4two · 31/08/2022 08:42

@NumptiesIncorporated ·

They technically shouldn’t be there but it’s still up to you not to hurt them by riding your bike dangerously fast into them or their dogs-that would probably be a criminal offence whereas trespassing isn’t

I'm no legal expert but I would find that doubtful. If you trespass and put yourself in danger, I would imagine you would be liable. However, I hope the cycle club has sufficient signage that this is private land with no trespassing as they could end up liable if there was an accident.

NovaDeltas · 31/08/2022 08:41

Jets121 · 31/08/2022 06:59

I’m a mountain biker too op and find many dog owners so entitled. I’ve been told off by dog owners on a few occasions when the problem has been their out of control, off-lead, dogs and not my cycling.

I don’t want to hurt a dog, and I could also be injured if I did hit one.

I had to give up riding in a couple of areas near me as even though the trails are wide enough for everyone, the selfish turds let their dogs off the lead and the dogs chase my bike. They cannot control their idiot dogs so I'm at risk of running them over, or getting spooked by their barking and teeth and just kicking it in the face, and then I suppose it will all be my fault.

NovaDeltas · 31/08/2022 08:38

People here aren't going to understand what a purpose built mountain bike trail entails. They're probably the sort to take their dogs there as well.

Imagine watching the biking at the Olympics and seeing some dumbarse with a doodle wander across the track. That's a private, prebuilt trail. It's private. It's for bikes only. It's built for speedy, technical riding.

They might need more clear signs that the trail is incredibly dangerous to trespass on. Give it a clear name and repeat those signs throughout where possible.

I've done some great prebuilt, managed trails and there's usually a lot of signage highlighting that it's off limits to walkers and they're in danger. But oh the joy of not having to swerve around people!

rookiemere · 31/08/2022 08:38

Speak to the shop and ask them to put up more signs to say "Bike Trail only - Private Land - No access for walkers - Likelihood of injury by fast moving cyclists " or something similar.

I agree you should have your cycle trail to yourself in the same way that teens should be able to use scooter parks without indulgent DPs letting their toddlers hog the place. Loads of areas for dog walking these days - they probably wanted to avoid the hassle of bumping into other dogs and having to put them on leads.

hotdiggetydog · 31/08/2022 08:35

SarahSissions · 30/08/2022 21:14

How do you know they haven’t also got permission from the owner to be there?

Love this. Immediate assumption is that it's some oversight by the OP 🙄

BitOutOfPractice · 31/08/2022 08:22

It’s because a large proportion of dog owners believe that their right to own a dog and walk it wherever the hell they like, off lead if they fancy it, absolutely trumps everyone else’s right to enjoy anything. Bike trails, children’s playgrounds, pub gardens, you name it, dogs have a greater right to enjoy them, off lead, than you. That’s just 3 examples I’ve seen in the last 2 weeks.

NumptiesIncorporated · 31/08/2022 08:21

They technically shouldn’t be there but it’s still up to you not to hurt them by riding your bike dangerously fast into them or their dogs-that would probably be a criminal offence whereas trespassing isn’t

Yeah.

And people shouldn't trespass on the track at Silverstone when there's a race on, but it's up to the drivers not to hurt them by not driving dangerously fast into them.

puffylovett · 31/08/2022 08:18

nect Time you see them, ask them if they would also walk down the middle lane of the motorway with dogs off lead and expect not to get hurt 🤦🏼‍♀️

puffylovett · 31/08/2022 08:16

Lampyshady · 31/08/2022 00:04

even if the signs are made clearer, entitled people will still think it's ok to ramble about wherever they choose. As for anyone thinking you should slow down and watch out for pedestrians WHO SHOULDN'T BE THERE, words fail me!**

im not saying that people should walk there dogs there, I wouldn’t do it, but the fact is that people do and cyclists should have been mindful of this-the OP said they had already seen one dog walker so knew crashing into someone was a possibility yet still thought it was ok to go round a blind corner so fast that they ‘nearly flattened” a dog. I don’t know much about mountain biking, but this seems really dangerous-surely you shouldn’t be that out of control on a corner. What is there was another cyclist stopped or going slower on the path ahead.
of course you should watch out for trespassers-it’s not ok to mow them down with a bike and seriously injure them as a punishment for them walking where they shouldn’t! That’s like saying you shouldn’t watch out for pedestrians while driving because they shouldn’t step out on the road.

Clearly you’ve never mountain biked! It’s impossible to take a corner slowly, when you’ve got momentum and there’s jumps and berms you have to keep your speed up just to stay on your bike! Which is why dedicated tracks are safer - because you know what to expect and you know it’s safe at speed and there will be nothing in your way.
The dog walkers shouldn’t have been there, they put themselves, the cyclist and their animals in danger.
I say this as both a dog walker and an ex mountain biker.
OP we have the same issue - the National Trust have given over an area of our local hill to mountain bikers, you have to be a member, it’s all clearly signposted. But, you can’t do anything about stupid people who choose to ignore the signs. Even worse are the ones who think bikers shouldn’t be there and deliberately block the tracks with logs to try and cause an accident.

AnyodyAnywhere · 31/08/2022 08:04

I admit that as a hiker I can be a bit anti cyclist at times but I 100% agree with OP on this one.

I can see no reason that a mountain biker should have to slow down in case they come across dog walkers where they shouldn’t be in the first place. I often hike in an area where some trails are marked as Bike Trials so I don’t use them…makes sense to me.

DougalsBlueJumper · 31/08/2022 07:37

That’s like saying you shouldn’t watch out for pedestrians while driving because they shouldn’t step out on the road.

It's really not like saying that at all though. But if you insist on using that comparison, it's like someone wandering along the middle of a single lane, winding rural road with no footpath and expecting drivers to watch out for them. Maybe drive at 5 or 10mph 'just in case'. The cycle trail is a narrow, multi terrain dedicated path. The signage should definitely be better, but I reckon that it still won't deter some idiots. But they are then trespassers who enter at their own risk.

Random789 · 31/08/2022 07:34

YANBU. They shouldn't be there and if I was the cyle shop owner would be doing something much more decisive about it. They are leaving themselves open to legal peril if they allow this potentiallt dangerous situation to continue.

I'm a dog walker and I am guilty of walking in bits and pieces of woodland that don't have a formal right of way. Generally, I think people will do that if there is no commonsense reason not to. I think that I might stray into those woodsBlushif there wasn't clear enough signage indicating that it would be wrong and hazardous.

missingeu · 31/08/2022 07:33

I would love a bike trail near us, that the bikers could go to. At present our local woods have been taken over by trail bikers - they have cut down trees, built large ramps and ride too fast around the public woodland that they shouldn't in the first place. It would make our woods a safer place to walk without being rundown by trail bikers and having to climb over ramps.

QuebecBagnet · 31/08/2022 07:26

And as you can see from that photo the terrain really restricts visibility. If there’s an off lead dog in the path after the last jump I’m not going see it until I’m in the air over the top of it and I’m not going to be able to avoid it by then.

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 31/08/2022 07:24

Lifeisaminestrone · 31/08/2022 07:14

I had never heard of a bike cycle route so would have thought it was like a bridle way.

I think better signage is needed.

Imagine something like this . So it has a jumps like these scattered throughout, not the whole way round but enough of them to make a dog Walker probably realise this is not a footpath.

To think these dog walkers are bonkers.
OP posts:
ThursdayLastWeek · 31/08/2022 07:15

Imagine if the OP went mountain biking in a private dog field - I reckon the dog walkers would understand the meaning of private land then.

Lifeisaminestrone · 31/08/2022 07:14

I had never heard of a bike cycle route so would have thought it was like a bridle way.

I think better signage is needed.