Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People in Council houses should be reassessed…

352 replies

AlwaysAnnoyed · 30/08/2022 20:44

I want to tread carefully. But then again I’m pissed off.

I live in a 3 bed house with a mortgage. On our estate there is a selection of Council houses. I have no issue with people having Council homes, people fall on hard times and DESERVE support.

however what really grinds my gears, is on our estate we have one Council house which have 2 brand new Audi’s. Top of the range. Just got back off holiday to Florida. Weekends away. they pay £350 a month to the council for this 4 bed property. (They are very loud about telling everyone this)

it really really winds me up. We have a COST of living crisis, people are going to be struggling to pay bills but yet there are people who are in these Council houses on holidays and brand new cars.

it doesn’t seem fair. Surely Council houses need to be regularly means tested… How can this happen? Able to afford 2 brand new cars but cannot afford to pay their own rent/mortgage!

or am I just being a moany witch!

OP posts:
unbreakbroken · 31/08/2022 10:17

It all comes down to emotions.

Logically, it makes sense for people to only rent council housing as long as they cannot afford the private sector. But what does that mean?

Well, it means you don't have those spare bedrooms for just in case your kids come back. You don't have room to host relatives at Christmas. You leave behind the kitchen where you and your granny once made a cake together.

People get ridiculously attached to bricks and mortar. We lock away memories in property, we fill them with junk, we nest.

People also like stability. Potentially moving every six months is a lot of disruption - even if you're cool with that, think of the hassle of packing and unpacking. And fighting spurious deposit claims. Now, think of children. If you have kids living in the property, moving every six months is going to unsettle them, and they're going to act up, and that's going to be a major headache to deal with.

What if you can afford private sector property... and then you suddenly can't? And then you can again? Do you keep moving back and forth between council stock and private stock?

I think there are a lot of reasons why booting people out of council properties once their circumstances change just isn't feasible.

How can we equalise this? Maybe if you could afford private sector rent, after all, we put up the price of your council property to match those changed circumstances. But what's reasonable? The going rate for a private property? Well, quite often, that rate is ridiculously overpriced/unreasonable. OK, a bit less? Well, that is still going to make people in private housing pissed off.

The only way it actually works is if the cost of housing is broadly comparable for everyone, and that level of cost is affordable for everyone. But that's an impossible ask - you'd have to bring the cost of private rent down, rather than the cost of council rent up.

You could only do it if you forced property rentals to become a not-for-profit endeavour. Given how many people 'invest' in property to fund their retirement, if you applied restrictions on rental income receivable, you'd push a bunch of older people into poverty, creating a different problem. What if we had exemptions for individuals owning a max of two properties (one to live in, one to invest)? Well, we'd still alienate all of those foreign investors. Can we afford to effectively boot them out of the UK?

It's just all broken. I don't see a solution.

Shaaameless · 31/08/2022 10:13

For whatever reason not everyone wants a mortgage. Did you buy a council House? You can always sell your home & move back to council, many people do this especially the elderly. Or some have council homes & don’t live in them. Did you forget about those people? No one cares about it. Your neighbours probably don’t pay rent anyway, hence them shouting so loudly about it to you.

Dodie66 · 31/08/2022 10:11

I agree with the OP to some extent. I thought council houses were for people who couldn’t afford to rent privately.
i live on an estate where there are council properties. One single mum with 2 children moved in, a couple of weeks after afterwards moved in a partner and got married. Now have 2 cars which they change regularly and go on holidays etc. another single mum with 2 children has just paid to have new kitchen and bathroom installed with permission from the council and has her garden redesigned. Seems like they have plenty of money

tttigress · 31/08/2022 10:00

PaperMonster · 31/08/2022 08:35

Bloomin eck. I live in a HA house and have been to Florida a couple of times. Can’t afford to buy a house here, but I have been able to afford a Florida holiday after a lot of saving up. You sound like a right judgy pants.

That's actually an interesting point. Consumer items/services have gone up a lot less than houses/rents.

So you do get somewhat of a disconnect.

hatgirl · 31/08/2022 09:59

I think you are confusing council housing with housing benefit.

the two do not necessarily go hand in hand.

People in private rentals can also get housing benefit to reduce their housing costs if they are eligible. People in council houses may pay full rent out of their income much as they would in private rentals.

people on council housing lists are supported to access all types of housing including private social landlords and private rentals.

it's generally considered to be a good societal benefit to have a mix of different types of people in council housing to prevent them becoming sinks for people with social problems.

KettrickenSmiled · 31/08/2022 09:53

with the way the mortgage rates are going we won’t be able to afford our property. So will end up having to sell it or have it repossessed and will move into rented accommodation.
Don't worry, you can move into a 4 bed council gaff for £350 a month once you're repo'd OP.

there is a massive LACK of Council properties with many families living in b&b’s waiting for properties. Surely if someone is able to afford 2 brand new cars and multiple holidays they can be worked with to spend that money on private rent… then their lovely Council house can be given to another family who is stuck in some Air BnB waiting for something to come up.
Imagine the amount of holidays & flash cars you can splurge on when you have got rid of your appreciating asset, & your potential to eventually have owned it outright, with no mortgage or rent to worry about ever again ...

Will you be pissed off then when PP resent & envy you so much they post on MN just to slag you off, & call for draconian measures to stop Your Sort from having any pleasure in life?

Newrumpus · 31/08/2022 09:47

@Oblomov22 - you need to read the thread more carefully. You have misunderstood how council housing works.

If private landlords had to give reasonable notice for no fault evictions (3-5 years). It would make private landlords think again if they are only interested in turning a quick profit rather than providing an essential service. Larger landlords that work in corporations or associations are more concerned about providing a service and making long term profits. Housing is an essential service. It needs proper regulation.

Jengnr · 31/08/2022 09:46

Perhaps those with low mortgages should be forced to buy bigger houses so that those that get kicked out of social housing for having ‘too much’ can buy their properties.

This thread is as awful as it is misinformed. And fwiw, a nice car, a holiday and a telly isn’t a lavish lifestyle.

tttigress · 31/08/2022 09:44

RocketPanda · 30/08/2022 20:49

Maybe they won the lotto.

Yeah, but obviously if you won the lottery you need to be reassessed.

miserablecat · 31/08/2022 09:40

I think part of the issue is that a lot of council houses that were sold have not been replaced, and There are fewer smaller eg 1 bed council properties. So some (not all) areas have large waiting lists of people (potentially in unsuitable temporary accomodation) who need a council house, and some older people in houses that are bigger than they need but with no suitable housing to downsize to.

BTW there was a poster recently who said they paid £97/wk for a 5 bed council house so the OP could be right about their rent.

BordoisAgain · 31/08/2022 09:37

Been given a council house is someone been given a helping hand which is what they need at that time.

No. It's someone meeting the eligibility criteria and then being allocated a property to rent. What the tenant then chooses to do with their own income is their business.

x2boys · 31/08/2022 09:32

Oblomov22 · 31/08/2022 09:22

I disagree with @BordoisAgain.
Been given a council house is someone been given a helping hand which is what they need at that time. It is funded by all the other taxpayers. this is fine when someone needs help. And some might need that help long term, but not all. They can't be given it for life and then not take any responsibility or change. There may be extenuating circumstances Such as disability, health, MH or they may have disabled children in which case that would be noted and therefore would only be sporadically reviewed. but for many other people they can do better, they can go on a training course, they can get a better job and then they should be able to move out of the house onto a rental. and leave the next person who really needs it to be able to move in.

there should be a sporadic review every say 5 or 10 years to review the situation. no one minds helping someone but not paying for it for their whole lives.

How is it funded by tax payers?

SerenaB12 · 31/08/2022 09:24

£350 for a 4 bed??? Nonsense, social housing tenant here. That's absolutely crap

Oblomov22 · 31/08/2022 09:22

I disagree with @BordoisAgain.
Been given a council house is someone been given a helping hand which is what they need at that time. It is funded by all the other taxpayers. this is fine when someone needs help. And some might need that help long term, but not all. They can't be given it for life and then not take any responsibility or change. There may be extenuating circumstances Such as disability, health, MH or they may have disabled children in which case that would be noted and therefore would only be sporadically reviewed. but for many other people they can do better, they can go on a training course, they can get a better job and then they should be able to move out of the house onto a rental. and leave the next person who really needs it to be able to move in.

there should be a sporadic review every say 5 or 10 years to review the situation. no one minds helping someone but not paying for it for their whole lives.

JaceLancs · 31/08/2022 09:02

I don’t believe the rent you have quoted and yes I’m in the north
I am also fully aware of local housing rates

richcouncilhousetenantfreehouse · 31/08/2022 08:59

And ultimately. Insecure housing tenure damages the future of the next generation.

What have the kids done to deserve that?

richcouncilhousetenantfreehouse · 31/08/2022 08:58

So I pay £400 a month for a council house.

I'm reassessed and have to pay £875 a month for the same house (based on private rents in the estate where I used to live).

I have to pay moving costs etc.

I move. I pay £875 a month. Which means I have £475 a month less to support my family so either the benefits system kicks in and I get assistance or I can't pay my rent and I get kicked out of my private rental and present as homeless to the council. And rinse and repeat.

Even if I scrimp and save to make up the difference, that means I couldn't have afforded to pay for the courses I took (or the fuel to get to college) that qualified me to go to university and ultimately move out of council housing to a bought house.

BordoisAgain · 31/08/2022 08:57

Why do people think council/housing association houses are for poor people who need to be continuallyproving how poor and deserving they are?

If you meet the criteria and are allocated a house then as long as you pay your rent its no one else's fucking business what you spend your money on. Just the same as if you were renting privately or paying a mortgage

Fed up with sour face fuckwits like the OP bitching about other people's lives.

Lifelessordinary1 · 31/08/2022 08:54

You could use your energy to campaign for more council houses to be built - not on trying to penalise a single family.

Then you could be in the same position of you wanted to.

Getoff · 31/08/2022 08:53

The only way social housing should be distinguishable from other housing is that instead of distributing profits on the market rents they charge, they reinvest them to expand (or possibly upgrade) the housing they provide.

From a tenants point of view, it should make no difference to them if their landlord is a housing association or a commercial company. (I exclude councils because I don't believe local government should be in the housing business, and I exclude individual landlords because they can't offer long-term security of tenure in the way a corporation can.)

RocketPanda · 31/08/2022 08:52

And there we have it. You want to line the pockets of landlords because someone paying £350 a month on SH isn't going to magic up £1200 a month for a private landlord so they will need HB. Their cars and holidays are probably through loans or PCP so they're not assets. Or they could give up their cars, not be able to get to work and need even more benefits.

Or you know shit about fuck and just want someone to feel superior to. Nasty undertone whichever way.

Sandinmyknickers · 31/08/2022 08:51

I can kind of see your point. However, I grew up in council housing and I remember this coming up in conversation once and my mum made the point that if that were the case, she would have to throw me out once I became an adult and had a job. I would probably then in turn have to qpply for council housing potentially. As it qas, I was able to live at home for a year after getting my first job and save up to be more self sufficient and get a good flat. 10 years on, I am now a homeowner. I think if council houses were regularly means tested, you would also be trapping people in a cycle

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 31/08/2022 08:46

Council housing was built for EVERYONE.
Not just for those who were poor/ struggling.

The rent they pay isn't 'subsidised' - it's just closer to the actual cost of providing housing than the private rental market provides.

If you want to be angry at someone, be angry at the private landlords, who are taking the piss by charging super-high rents. Be angry at the Governments who have allowed council housing stock to be privatised, pretty much ended the council house building programme, and continually seek to erode the rights and security of tenants. (It's no coincidence that many MPs are also landlords).

Instead of being annoyed by your neighbours enjoying a decent life, fight for everyone to have a decent life.

Fairyliz · 31/08/2022 08:46

x2boys · 30/08/2022 20:55

Only on mumsnet do people discuss the ins and outs of their finances .

@x2boys
Thats not true in my experience. I am often really surprised at the amount of people who openly talk about their finances in a sort of look how much money I have got way.
The funny thing is it’s often the people fiddling the system, so for example a tradesman accepting cash in hand for jobs to avoid tax. Just the sort of people who you would think would keep very quiet about money.

richcouncilhousetenantfreehouse · 31/08/2022 08:43

Also. Before I bought a house and moved out - I wasn't claiming any benefits. I paid the full rent by myself.

And a lot of the decorative improvements I had done to the house were ripped out and put in a skip. I had to pay the council to restore the council issue fake electric fire rather than the wall mounted one I had (which had been installed by an electrician and I had the certificate), rip out the double oven and hob I had added and leave a space for a slot in cooker, take up my wooden flooring and leave the floors bare.

(I gave the oven and hob and flooring to my next door neighbour. The council put my electric fire in the back of a van and drove off with it. No one knows where it went but I'm pretty sure it didn't go to the tip.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread