Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a huge fan of dogs..

211 replies

miseryguts1988 · 30/08/2022 19:27

I mean don't get me wrong I like dogs.. I'm not phobic of them and I think they are a wonderful and intelligent species. But I think to own one they are hard work, expensive and just too tying and too much effort to basically have an animal living with you. People put too much trust in them which is why children end up being bitten.. and people see them the same as their children when they're not.. they are an animal.
I dunno I probably ABU but I just don't see why we are such a nation of dog lovers and every dog lover is shocked if you say you're not.
People wouldn't be the same if you said you didn't like cats.. I prefer cats! They are much less demanding.
I think I'll get shot for this post..

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 31/08/2022 09:43

@CatsandFish are you being serious?

Terriers are bred to chase rats and other small furry things 🤣

RootinandTootin · 31/08/2022 09:36

I do, they’re arseholes.

knackeredcat · 31/08/2022 08:41

I really don't understand why all dogs are allowed everywhere now - why it is no longer "guide dogs only". I've always been wary of dogs due to negative experiences when younger, and yes, I have worked hard on my fear via costly hypnotherapy. But being ND the hypervigilance is always going to be there if thankfully no longer as prominent. I still know I can't use the vast majority of parks, etc. round my way but TBH it's more gangs of teenage boys that are the problem there, some of which have bull breed dogs (which I will always be scared of).

bozzabollix · 31/08/2022 08:34

I’ve got three but think it’s fine for someone not to like them, but secretly put them in the ‘might be a bit of a precious little dick’ category.

As for the person who thinks dogs are perpetual toddlers, they really aren’t. An old dog is a wise being indeed, they see it all before. And the speed that my 22 week old puppy has got her head around things is amazing.

I think your life is richer for having a dog, so long as you look at them as part of your family and are happy to give them lots of love. I think love is a really key thing for a dog, without it they are miserable. With it they are well balanced and able to give so much back.

Lockheart · 31/08/2022 08:24

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 08:21

Of course you have cats in barns clearing out rats! You don't have dogs doing that. I've never heard of that. That's why there are Barn Cats/Farm Cats. Never heard of anyone using any dogs or terriers for rats, don't see how that would work.

You can't be serious. You've never heard of ratters?

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratter_(dog)

They're incredible to watch at work. The Jack Russell we had on the farm growing up once got 26 rats in one hour when we had a nest (which the farm cats had let go unchecked, I might add!).

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 08:21

Lockheart · 31/08/2022 08:13

Well if you're clearing out a nest or a barn you don't bring in the cat men, you bring in the terrier men. Some dog breeds are incredible ratters! Not sure cats would be as efficient if you tried to use them in the same way.

Of course you have cats in barns clearing out rats! You don't have dogs doing that. I've never heard of that. That's why there are Barn Cats/Farm Cats. Never heard of anyone using any dogs or terriers for rats, don't see how that would work.

Lockheart · 31/08/2022 08:13

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 07:15

@MissyB1 Cats perform a hygiene service by keeping rats and mice at bay. Dogs are far more pointless than cats.

Well if you're clearing out a nest or a barn you don't bring in the cat men, you bring in the terrier men. Some dog breeds are incredible ratters! Not sure cats would be as efficient if you tried to use them in the same way.

Kashmirsilver · 31/08/2022 08:06

Another poster mentioned dogs need a role and a job. They do, added to the fact, that dogs didn't always live inside the home, they had a home of their own in a dog house. A friend has her dog outside, it does come in but retreats to her own home often. We have an older dog, my goodness she's messy and curmudgeonly. Some customers have 3 or 4 labs in their personal space, barging around, I don't understand how they manage to function or keep the place clean.

gatehouseoffleet · 31/08/2022 08:02

YANBU OP and I think there are a lot of irresponsible owners out there who cause trouble for others. I would really like to see some sort of dog licence system to pay for dog wardens (as they seem to be disappearing at a time when dog ownership has increased) but I can't see that it would be enforceable.

It would help if they weren't see as some sort of status symbol (after all, they are expensive to keep).

I personally don't see the attractiveness of a creature who will always be a toddler in terms of emotional, psychological, and physical needs indeed this. I am lazy anyway so pet ownership is far too much effort for me! Cats aren't too bad but you still have to worry about them if you go away more than overnight.

Lockheart · 31/08/2022 08:00

This is not an AIBU. You're allowed to not be a fan of anything you want.

Redqueenheart · 31/08/2022 07:53

''@WifeMotherWorker I’m not a huge fan of cats! They are pointless pets but good for people who can’t be bothered. Cats are not remotely loyal and will go to anyone that feeds them, they shit everywhere where owners take no responsibility (my garden is testament to that, it’s vile and fucking infuriating), they kill so much native wildlife and get run over because they are free roaming and feral!''

What a judgemental and rather ignorant post.

Cats make great pets especially for people who don't have a lot of outdoor space, might not be able to walk an animal regularly or who have the type of personality that match an independent and quiet animal.

I always found having cats incredibly comforting and rewarding.

Redqueenheart · 31/08/2022 07:49

I am not quite sure what point you are trying to make.

It is true that dog ownership comes with responsibilities and can be expensive but there is no law forcing you to have a dog!

You are perfectly entitled to prefer cats and not to like dogs.

Many people are scared of dogs and find them too boisterous. I also think badly behaved dogs very often have rubbish owners who don't train them correctly.

I love animals in general including dogs. I have had mostly cats because I don't have a big garden suitable for a dog and cats can also be a handful and much trickier to handle when you need to get them to the vet...

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 07:38

RootinandTootin · 30/08/2022 20:35

YANBU…you like what you like. I can’t stand cats, they shit everywhere and literally couldn’t care less about their owners. I love my dog though. I don’t understand why people who are scared of dogs make such a big deal out of it, dogs are a part of life and I feel like they should make more of an effort to get over their fear. I’m obviously not talking about dogs that jump up and bite etc that’s bad dog ownership.

literally couldn’t care less about their owners

You have no idea how truly ignorant you are @RootinandTootin . Maybe you should 'make more of an effort' to understand cats.

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 07:30

WifeMotherWorker · 30/08/2022 19:47

If an owner puts in the effort with training and discipline most breeds of dogs are amazing, loyal and rewarding pets!

I’m not a huge fan of cats! They are pointless pets but good for people who can’t be bothered. Cats are not remotely loyal and will go to anyone that feeds them, they shit everywhere where owners take no responsibility (my garden is testament to that, it’s vile and fucking infuriating), they kill so much native wildlife and get run over because they are free roaming and feral!

@WifeMotherWorker Your post is so full of ignorance, that I feel sorry for you. Cats are far more loyal than dogs, and are good with babies, I can post many YT videos and stories of cats saving their owners and saving babies (inc saving a near-SIDS baby through the baby monitor). They are far more loyal than dogs and don't attack toddlers like dogs do. They perform a hygiene service by keeping rats and mice at bay, they helped end the bubonic plague. Dogs will go to anyone who pats them, are dirty animals, don't wash themselves, cause most neighbourhood disputes with their barking, are unpredictable and will jump up at and attack humans, and are far more pointless than cats.

Okbye · 31/08/2022 07:29

YANBY, I hate them.

They seem to be EVERYWHERE now and I hate that more and more places are becoming 'dog friendly'. I'll never understand how people can enjoy their food with a stinking panting dog near them 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

Also, shitty owners who let their mutts off lead when they have zero recall pisses me off! If your dog doesn't know when to stop/come back to you in a busy public area then DONT HAVE IT OFF THE FUCKING LEAD!

AuntieMarys · 31/08/2022 07:25

Not a fan at all. Most of my friends have them and I roll my eyes at their furbaby adoration.

ChagSameachDoreen · 31/08/2022 07:19

I despise them.

Smelly, desperate, sniffing, wagging, dribbling nightmares.

Shitting everywhere, too much energy - like a toddler that never grows up.

CatsandFish · 31/08/2022 07:15

MissyB1 · 30/08/2022 19:38

Well you are free to prefer cats (totally pointless pets to me), and I’m free to vastly prefer dogs to people.

And I’ve never been bitten by a dog, but I have had a few bites from other people’s kids - I work in Early Years!

@MissyB1 Cats perform a hygiene service by keeping rats and mice at bay. Dogs are far more pointless than cats.

RampantIvy · 31/08/2022 07:05

mathanxiety · 30/08/2022 19:56

I have a 100% indoor cat whose litter box is cleaned 3x per week. She's a good mouser and if someone is ill she graces them with her presence in their bed.

How come the litter tray is only used three times a week if the cat never goes outside @mathanxiety? I used to have two cats, and the litter tray used to get cleaned out at least every day. More often if required.

YANBU. I like dogs but I don't love them. I'm not liking the trend now to never leave them alone and to have to take them everywhere

I agree with you @Twizbe. I know dogs shouldn't be left all day, but not being able to go anywhere at all without your dog must limit your choices considerably.

Most dog owners I know are pretty sensible, but it is the inconsiderate "love me love my dog" owners who give all dog owners a bad name.

I don't understand the "cats are pointless" comments. I adore cats. They are affectionate but need less attention than dogs and are far less of a tie. I love their independence and their haughtiness. I love that you can sit watching TV with a purring cat on your knee. I appreciate that not everyone loves cats and would never foist a cat on someone who dislikes them or is scared of them.

Womencanlift · 31/08/2022 07:05

Can’t stand the things and the owners (including several on this thread) who start every sentence with “ah but….” Eg “ah but my dog doesn’t smell/jump/lick/bark/…..” - delete as appropriate

My response is usually “but I do so get your animal away from me”

And those that think they are more important than humans… well that’s a whole different level of nonsense

Sistanotcista · 31/08/2022 06:55

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 30/08/2022 19:45

My ddogs gave me a jolt into reality some time ago.
Ds has a very well off friend... I was invited in on collection from a play date. Sat having a Posh Coffee round a table bigger than my kitchen was quite awesome!
Seeing the 'stuff' the dc had was astounding tbh...
Drove home feeling quite a pauper and felt a bit sorry for ds.
Behind our quite shabby (not chic) front door I could hear much fuss...
As 16 paws eagerly awaited it opening!
Once home I felt very rich.
And much loved! As I know they make ds feel! Ddogs have a way of making us feel worthy. And loved.
Imo

This is so lovely 🤗

InChocolateWeTrust · 31/08/2022 06:51

Yanbu. It is difficult and demanding to properly train most breeds of dog, and provide it with a suitably stimulating existence, and only a minority do an adequate job. Dog ownership should require training and a license and should be available to far fewer people, ideally those who can provide something approaching the sort of working life dogs were bred for.

In recent years I've found many people are getting "difficult" dogs from rescues meaning there are a lot of reactive/aggressive dogs with owners who expect my 3 year old to tiptoe past their snarling, snapping hound on local footpaths. The neighbours have a dachshund that the barks furiously any time any one breathes within 5m of their garden fence. In a pub just yesterday a dog was snapping and barking at every person who passed the table. These aren't suitable pets to have in the community.

HikingBoots · 31/08/2022 06:43

I've never understood the rhetoric that dogs are 'expensive'. Ours (a terrier) costs £20 a month in insurance and £5-7 a month in food.
She is 'tying' I guess, but we're 12 years in and don't know any other life! What can I say? She's SO worth it, I can't even put it into words.

sparkles0405 · 31/08/2022 06:18

YANBU, people are free to like/dislike whatever they want, I see cats as alot of effort and don't really like them, but love my dog and wouldn't be without him. When our cat goes, i'm 100% I will not have another.

When we moved in my partner brought his cat, I didn't know what hard work they actually are. Yes, we can leave him without a sitter. The caveats are, a pissy/shitty stinking litter box in the house that needs changed regularly, furniture destroyed (even with toys and a scratch post) and carpets scratched up when you shut the door (can't sleep with him in the room as the licking drives me insane oh and dive bombs onto you from the top of the wardrobe at 3am which disturbs sleep), he is very vocal (vet checked and there's nothing wrong with him, he does it for attention) and leaves hairs everywhere so I have to vacuum x2 a day. He moves and hairs fall off him, even when brushed! It's too much effort, we don't let him out as he's older now. My partner loves the cat but doesn't see the stinking litter and hairs all over as an issue, to me it's very unhygienic hence I am always cleaning. It will be much easier for me to relax more once I'm not having to constantly clear up hairs that get intertwined in any bit of soft fabric and a litter box (jobs I could do without) and I can have nice plush carpets and furniture again without throwing money away as it gets destroyed by the cat

On the other hand we have a small dog who is well trained, is happy with short walks daily, on a lead, has made us smile & laugh everyday since we got him, and is no bother at all (oh and has never destroyed anything since he's well trained! Or bitten for that matter) All he chews is his toys and he's happy to take them in his bed, minimal mess. He gets bathed 1x a week so doesn't smell. With dogs it comes down to terrible owners not putting in the hard work at the start when they're puppies. They're like kids in the sense they need taught boundaries early on, otherwise you get bad behaviours 

Climbingthelaundrymountain · 31/08/2022 05:12

I am not a big fan of dogs...and I have one. Luckily he isn't hard work or expensive but he is a tie. We can't go away without him really which limits where we go.