Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be a huge fan of dogs..

211 replies

miseryguts1988 · 30/08/2022 19:27

I mean don't get me wrong I like dogs.. I'm not phobic of them and I think they are a wonderful and intelligent species. But I think to own one they are hard work, expensive and just too tying and too much effort to basically have an animal living with you. People put too much trust in them which is why children end up being bitten.. and people see them the same as their children when they're not.. they are an animal.
I dunno I probably ABU but I just don't see why we are such a nation of dog lovers and every dog lover is shocked if you say you're not.
People wouldn't be the same if you said you didn't like cats.. I prefer cats! They are much less demanding.
I think I'll get shot for this post..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WalkingOnTheCracks · 04/09/2022 11:34

Suzi888 · 03/09/2022 18:49

“Taking in a rescue, should really be considered to be deciding if you would accept someone being released from a youth offending institute or a prison into your home, someone unpredictable, with a complex past, who you need to reintegrate into society”.

I disagree. A dog isn’t a human. They live in the now.
You’ve anthromorphosised dogs, to think they can exhibit some kind of premeditated actions. Any dog can form those behaviours (resource guarding etc) rescues or otherwise. Likening a rescue dog to a maximum security prisoner is a little far fetched.

They may not premeditate, but they learn behaviours. Hence Pavlov.

The problem with rescues is that you can’t know what events trigger what behaviours until they happen.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 04/09/2022 08:52

Not for me, I don’t mind other people’s dogs but I wouldn’t have one for the reasons people have stated here. I work and have young DC, I already have to get up early to get them to school or childcare for me to go to work in community nursing without having to get up any earlier to walk a dog. They are tying and I like my house without the smell of dog or having to clean up accidents.

on the note of my job in community nursing the amount of homes that refuse to put their pets away is astounding whether that be cat or dog, I’ve had cats walk all
over my sterile field and a dogs jumping up my back when kneeling down to work with people and those who refused to let me do what I had come to do until I fussed over their dog

Suzi888 · 03/09/2022 18:49

“Taking in a rescue, should really be considered to be deciding if you would accept someone being released from a youth offending institute or a prison into your home, someone unpredictable, with a complex past, who you need to reintegrate into society”.

I disagree. A dog isn’t a human. They live in the now.
You’ve anthromorphosised dogs, to think they can exhibit some kind of premeditated actions. Any dog can form those behaviours (resource guarding etc) rescues or otherwise. Likening a rescue dog to a maximum security prisoner is a little far fetched.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 03/09/2022 18:36

JurrasicCazza · 30/08/2022 19:56

As with everything to do with dogs, it's not really the dogs that are the problem, it's the owners.

It's the owners who don't clean the shit up in the park.
The owners who don't train their dogs.
The owners who let their dogs run off in the park to jump up at small children while insisting they are friendly.
The owners who let their dogs 'play out' on a busy main road.
The owners who don't clean their homes properly. The owners who come into the office covered in dog hair and complain when their allergic colleague is sneezing.

Nah, seriously, for me, it’s the dogs.

Culldesack · 03/09/2022 18:28

And neither am I changing my ideas. Glad that's sorted.

Kanaloa · 03/09/2022 17:50

Culldesack · 03/09/2022 16:37

You didn't explain your reasons for saying more ppl shouldn't have dogs only than it ties people. That's not your decision to make. Unlike you. Dog lovers aren't fickle. You really do have the bit between your teeth with my earlier post. How sensitive you are.

I’m not sensitive at all - I just think you’re aggressive and to be honest a bit hard of thinking. I did explain in my very first post why I think more people have dogs than should - because I think people who own dogs should be those who are well educated about animal care, have very very few ties outside the home so can be available to the dog most of the time, and have extensive funds in case of needing training classes, vet care, etc etc. The majority of dog owners simply aren’t very good at it/don’t really have the time and resources for a dog. And how silly you don’t generalising that ‘dog owners aren’t fickle.’ Why are rescues full to the brim? Why are there reams of ‘no longer wanted’ posts about 1/2 year old dogs on social media? Why is there a post about rehoming a ‘problem’ dog on here every couple of months? Some dog owners are plenty fickle. Me? I know I wouldn’t have another dog, because right now I’m not in a place to offer a dog the proper care. Not fickle, as I’m not changing my ideas on it.

Culldesack · 03/09/2022 16:37

Kanaloa · 02/09/2022 17:20

Who are you to say who is questionable or has zero personality? If you don’t agree that many more people have dogs than should have dogs, you’re no dog lover.

You didn't explain your reasons for saying more ppl shouldn't have dogs only than it ties people. That's not your decision to make. Unlike you. Dog lovers aren't fickle. You really do have the bit between your teeth with my earlier post. How sensitive you are.

LostInSpaceRaiders · 03/09/2022 13:04

You’re not being unreasonable one bit; and I say that as a lifelong dog owner. My dog is my life, she comes everywhere with me within reason, we centre our life around her - we’re in a remote cottage on holiday right now chosen for good dog walks and dog friendly pubs! But could I do any of that if I wasn’t a dog person? Would I do that for another animal or even person who I didn’t want to dedicate my life to? Not a fucking chance!

Having a dog, and that that comes with it is bloody hard work. People buy dogs often for all the wrong reasons, because they want an Andrex Puppy, because they think they’re cute, because they want a best friend, because they think they’re easier than having a baby and they’ll receive unconditional love of a being that won’t then develop their own mind and life away from them…. this has actually been said to me and it drives me mad!

The truth is, that if you do not want to essentially dedicate your life to their well-being (much as you would do with a child), then a dog is really not for you. My dog has a job, she is a working breed with retrieving and flushing instincts, and we use those instincts to give her purpose and focus. If we didn’t do that, we know she would become bored, destructive, exhibit poor behaviour due to not having an active brain and body. That would not be her fault; it’s is entire the fault of a shitty and unrealistic owner when any of those behaviours set in with a dog that has come to them from pup without pre-existing issues. Rescues are then an entirely different matter and increased level of dedication; people have idealistic views that they’re always going to be getting a well trained former companion of an older person who has passed away. 9 times out of 10 you’re not, you’re rehabilitating either an animal that has been abused, and will have trust issues, resource guarding issues, struggle to understand intentions, aggressive behaviour due to fear etc, OR, it’s a dog that has developed issues due to simply poor handling, or a huge change of circumstance for former owners, abandonment etc that will need huge amounts of training and behavioural therapy. Taking in a rescue, should really be considered to be deciding if you would accept someone being released from a youth offending institute or a prison into your home, someone unpredictable, with a complex past, who you need to reintegrate into society and support mentally and physically along the way. It would distinctly sharpen the sense of those going into it for the wrong reasons, and above all would protect the welfare of the dogs involved who end up on a roundabout of rescue > new home > rescue > repeat,

TLDR - Animals of any kind aren’t for everyone, I wish more people would admit they aren’t a dog/cat/rabbit/horse person and just not have one, rather than following trends or buying a designer dog to keep up with the Jones’s. They aren’t play things, they are a commitment for the rest of that animals life. Buy a bloody tamagotchi if you want to be occupied by something needy occasional, or get a house plant!

Kanaloa · 02/09/2022 17:20

Culldesack · 02/09/2022 12:57

Who are you to say who has a dog?!

Who are you to say who is questionable or has zero personality? If you don’t agree that many more people have dogs than should have dogs, you’re no dog lover.

123ROLO · 02/09/2022 16:44

I love dogs, I think the sun shines out of my dogs arse, he brings so much joy to me and my partner and our friends and family love him. He is very intelligent and has such human levels of empathy, if he sees someone sad he will whimper and place his chin on their legs or arm, if people get angry at each other he'll try to stand in the middle of them to separate them, he checks on people and other dogs if he thinks they are hurt. He's amazing. But, that's how i feel about him. I don't expect everyone to love him like me and my partner do. It's perfectly reasonable to not be a 'dog lover'. However to actively hate dogs is odd. (I know you haven't said that but a few dog threads on mumsnet have called for dogs to be banned and even culled).

Mumspair1 · 02/09/2022 16:22

zingally · 02/09/2022 11:58

I'm the same. I tolerate dogs, I'm quite fond of my friends elderly whippet, but I can't really see a world where I'd want one of my own. Huge tie, huge expense!

Same. We had a very much loved almost child like dog for most of my childhood until I left home. As much as I loved her, I remember all the work and it puts me right off. Now I look at people walking dogs in bad weather, or stopping to pick up shit and carry it for a while, the pain of taking it for a daily walk, the pain of always making arrangements if you are away - I just don't see the benefit of having one again.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 02/09/2022 16:04

soggydigestives · 02/09/2022 12:08

I don't like them and will avoid at all costs. They're animals and I can't understand people who treat them like children. SIL and BIL just got a great big slobbery thing and MIL started calling it her 'granddog'! 😬 FFS!🥴🙄

And why does what your MIL calls her child's dog impact your life at all?

FruitPastilleNut · 02/09/2022 13:25

I said more people have dogs than really should

Agree with this.

I see (in rl and online) frequent examples of people getting dogs completely inappropriate for their house/lifestyle. Huge penis extension 'protection' dogs in a 2 bed flat with 2 dc under 5. Large, high energy breeds that are not exercised nearly enough but got because they're cute.

However, by far the worst example that I see of inappropriate dog ownership is Cocker Spaniels and it's matched by nothing else I've seen. So many people have them and think of them as a cute fluffy small lap dog and do no breed research. Then they discover they're an extremely intelligent, high energy working breed that starts chewing their house up and wreaking havoc because they cannot cope with the daily 20 minute walk around the block that the family can offer.

I volunteer in a very large rescue centre and the amount of Cockers they have in is heartbreaking...i was totally shocked at just how many are given up before 3 years old. At one point, about 40% of all the dogs they had were Cockers.

basilmint · 02/09/2022 13:05

1994girl · 02/09/2022 09:40

Me and my partner have an 8 week old son. For the past 4 years my partner has always been talking about getting his dream dog, a staffie. Now our baby is here he is mentioning it more and more to protect our little one. And I know that dogs are great with children providing they are taught correctly etc etc but I'm just not a massive dog lover. I've always been a cat lady. Plus you hear so many stories of dog attacks on children and I think regardless of how well the dog was with him I'd still be a nervous wreck. Not to mention how much staffie puppies go for these days! He says we can get a cat in the future but he wants a dog first. Sigh...Confused

Your son is more likely to be injured by a staffing in the home than protected by it. What sort of protection is the dog supposed to be offering a baby?

Culldesack · 02/09/2022 12:57

Kanaloa · 02/09/2022 11:29

I don’t pass comments. I said more people have dogs than really should, and that I wouldn’t have another dog because of the ties you have ie holidays, days out. I didn’t say those who like dogs have no personalities and are questionable people. You said that.

Who are you to say who has a dog?!

soggydigestives · 02/09/2022 12:08

I don't like them and will avoid at all costs. They're animals and I can't understand people who treat them like children. SIL and BIL just got a great big slobbery thing and MIL started calling it her 'granddog'! 😬 FFS!🥴🙄

zingally · 02/09/2022 11:58

I'm the same. I tolerate dogs, I'm quite fond of my friends elderly whippet, but I can't really see a world where I'd want one of my own. Huge tie, huge expense!

FruitPastilleNut · 02/09/2022 11:43

I feel similarly about dogs and children tbh.

I love my own and I make sure they're thoroughly trained and well behaved around others.

I'm often not keen on other people's though when they're messy/loud/poorly behaved.

Kanaloa · 02/09/2022 11:29

Culldesack · 02/09/2022 09:19

Yet it's OK for those, who don't like dogs, to pass comment on those that do. Funny that.

I don’t pass comments. I said more people have dogs than really should, and that I wouldn’t have another dog because of the ties you have ie holidays, days out. I didn’t say those who like dogs have no personalities and are questionable people. You said that.

DougalsBlueJumper · 02/09/2022 10:53

I always thought I liked dogs, but I have been put off them I think by my SIL acquiring a puppy. She had never owned a dog or had any previous meaningful contact with dogs. Not much happened in the way of training, other than toileting. SIL still lives with her parents and their lives started to revolve around the dog. Then SIL decided she needed another puppy because she was depressed and one overindulged dog wasn't enough. So then there were two untrained, endlessly barking dogs which clawed at our clothes until we paid them attention. And I know full well that this is not the dogs' fault, but I hate visiting PILs now because the entire visit is about the dogs. Being ordered to pet them to get them to shut up. Sitting on the floor or bringing in extra chairs because they are on the sofa. Talking about them. Watching their 'antics'. And allowing them into our home for fear of offending very sensitive SIL, where they scratch the sofa and occasionally piss on the rug. And the delightful time one of them was 'so excited to see us' that she shat all over the floor boards in a big runny river of diarrhoea. Knife and cloth job to get it out from between the boards🤢

So I don't know. Maybe I like some dogs. Maybe some just have very, very annoying or irresponsible or incompetent owners.

1994girl · 02/09/2022 09:40

Me and my partner have an 8 week old son. For the past 4 years my partner has always been talking about getting his dream dog, a staffie. Now our baby is here he is mentioning it more and more to protect our little one. And I know that dogs are great with children providing they are taught correctly etc etc but I'm just not a massive dog lover. I've always been a cat lady. Plus you hear so many stories of dog attacks on children and I think regardless of how well the dog was with him I'd still be a nervous wreck. Not to mention how much staffie puppies go for these days! He says we can get a cat in the future but he wants a dog first. Sigh...Confused

Culldesack · 02/09/2022 09:22

BobbysGirly · 01/09/2022 22:53

Don't get me started on those ridiculous dog prams I've seen everywhere

Those ridiculous prams that help elderly/ dogs who’ve had an
operation get to a place where they can wee you mean? Or allow an elderly dog to spend a pleasant day out with its family…

Hmmm, I agree. There's plenty of ignorance, snobbery and arrogance in this thread. All over an animal.

The more people I meet, the more I like my dog. Never was there a truer quote. When you read these comments, you can see why.

Culldesack · 02/09/2022 09:19

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 22:57

Saying people have a no personality and are ‘questionable’ because they aren’t a fan of dogs is a bizarrely aggro response. It’s normal for others to dislike things you like - to immediately assume that means they have no personality is odd behaviour.

Yet it's OK for those, who don't like dogs, to pass comment on those that do. Funny that.

CatsandFish · 02/09/2022 08:05

Just came across this on one of my Facebook groups just now, I just had to share it!

To not be a huge fan of dogs..
Dunnoburt · 01/09/2022 23:04

YANBU .....Not a dog fan......Dreading how my 12 year old maine coon size Heinz 57 puss is going to react to the rat dog..sorry....chihuahua....we are taking in next week.....MIL has dementia and is going into a home......who knows....I may be converted

Jury will be out