Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think video games aren't just for teenage boys?

187 replies

KassandraOfSparta · 30/08/2022 16:48

Why does playing video games have such a poor image/reputation?

Numerous threads on here with posters confidently proclaiming that they wouldn't let their children play games, would never date anyone who plays games, would never dream of gaming themselves.

Why is gaming any less "worthy" than sitting watching sport all evening, or soap operas, or painting watercolours or doing jigsaws? Just another form of entertainment, isn't it?

And before anyone pops up saying it's so addictive, well of course anything taken to excess is a problem, whether you're staying up all night with your crochet, jigsaws or tv boxset.

OP posts:
PeasOff · 30/08/2022 17:38

@KassandraOfSparta I used to love Assassins Creed.

I enjoy the strategic side of COD... and I'm really competitive so that's another lure!

MrsMcisaCt · 30/08/2022 17:36

I'm 50 and play video games. They take my mind off things for a while, so in that way I think they are a positive thing. I also read for the same reason- it stops me dwelling on difficult things going on in my life.

KassandraOfSparta · 30/08/2022 17:35

I'm not a fan of the modern day ones - Grand Theft Auto, Call of Duty, that sort of thing. I really prefer the ones set in a totally different period like the Assassin's Creed ones - who wouldn't enjoy sailing a boat around the Caribbean being a pirate?? Or Skyrim, Tomb Raider.

Agree that the modern production is almost cinematic. Red Dead 2 is the most beautiful game. Just stunning graphics and you can wander around admiring it for hours.

OP posts:
PeasOff · 30/08/2022 17:35

YANBU.

Me and my OH enjoy gaming (I'm partial to COD).

If gaming was so pathetic and took zero talent people wouldn't be able to make a small fortune off of being a gamer or a fortune out of producing them.

MoistBandana · 30/08/2022 17:34

True story.

A woman I know, let's call her Catherine... Cause that's her name.. she is forever having a go at her other half for playing video games.
"He's always on that Xbox, every spare minute he gets, he comes in from work and it's Xbox Xbox Xbox all night till he goes to bed."

Thing is, Catherine doesn't work, she's a SAHM to a 4 year old. Drop in on her now and then for a cup of tea and... She's in level 3000+ on Candy Crush and will happily sit there with you and play it whilst you talk.
But she reckons that a game in her phone is t the same as a game on the telly so her playing Candy Crush for hours every day is fine.

🤪

totallyaddictedtocheese · 30/08/2022 17:31

I'm a 34 year old female and I enjoy computer games. I see it as a form of entertainment in the same way that loads of people find soaps or sport entertaining. I don't watch soaps or sport but would never judge those that do. It's mad how so many people have such low opinions of people that play computer games.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/08/2022 17:30

People claim they don't but they love to attach a virtue to an leisure activity.

So reading = virtuous. Gaming = damaging.

I think a lot of the people that claim (for example) GTA will never come in my house, or that it's so dangerous are completely ignorant. Microsoft and Sony tech support must be sick to the back teeth of parents who will allow a console but then can't even be arsed to find out how to set up parental controls or how to keep their money safe.

KassandraOfSparta · 30/08/2022 17:28

There are already posters saying that games aren't "worthy". Well no they aren't. But neither are a whole host of other hobbies but people who spend their evenings writing fan fiction about gerbils or making life size models of Harry Styles don't get any of the criticism.

OP posts:
lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 17:19

Video games are appealing because they have bright colours and sounds, you get a dopamine hit when you complete a challenge/ level etc. - you do get that dopamine hit when you complete a painting or finish a book, too - but in video games, they come faster. That's why it is hard for children (and some adults) because there is a lot of pleasure involved.

ok well I take back my last comment. Yours kinda nails why they are a worry.

As for being a non gamer I played all the Tomb Raider series when they came out and that was a proper every day hobby.. I loved them and loved watching other people play them. But realistically it’s not that healthy sat in front of screen. And it’s too easy to just play rather than do stuff ( similar to MN)

Mangogogogo · 30/08/2022 17:15

JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 30/08/2022 16:58

Also a gamer. Husband is a gamer and when he mentions it people look at me with sympathy - I probably play more than he does these days.

I've finished work and I'm having half hour of fall guys to chill before the kids get home.

Same. My mum will go ’oh is he on his Xbox again’ and I’m like no… I am.

30not13 · 30/08/2022 17:14

Playing fortnite and fall guys is my relaxation. I can't see that it's any less worthy than sitting mindlessly watching TV all night?
fortnite especially keeps my brain working. I'm in my late 40s. My OH doesn't game So I do it when he is out

fyn · 30/08/2022 17:12

I have always played computer games, starting on PC with Star Wars Phantom of the Menace game when I was little. I am 30 but grew up playing computer games with my friends, whether something like the Sims or Crazy Taxi. I don’t know anyone that didn’t play Pokémon on our gameboys. We use to play COD or Assasins Creed when we were a bit older.

I don’t really have time now I have babies/toddlers but I don’t think there is such a stigma amongst my peers!

locke360 · 30/08/2022 17:12

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 17:04

Yuck. What’s sex got to do with it.

The big problem with it like box set telly and opposed to hobbies like knitting, painting or gardening is that it’s unproductive. I mean it’s really fun and mentally challenging but ultimately it’s pointless.
I guess reading is similar but the difference is the books people write are different in style and content and they are of fixed length. Playing a game is like reading the same book for months and months and months. And then re reading it over again for months.

^ Spoken by an obvious non-gamer.

You can't compare these hobbies. I mean, what's the point of a painting? What's the point of knitting? OK you get something you can wear/ hang on your wall, but the end product is not usually the reason people do those things.

They do them for the enjoyment of it, which is the exact same reason people play video games.

Video games are cognitively challenging, require logical and strategic thinking, fast reflexes - depending on the game you're playing they can require a plethora of different skills and abilities and they can be educational, too. It's not "like reading the same book for months".

There is nothing qualitatively better or worse about playing video games than any other hobby you listed.

The problems come when people (usually kids) are unable to regulate themselves, usually because their parents don't fully understand what they are doing.

Video games are appealing because they have bright colours and sounds, you get a dopamine hit when you complete a challenge/ level etc. - you do get that dopamine hit when you complete a painting or finish a book, too - but in video games, they come faster. That's why it is hard for children (and some adults) because there is a lot of pleasure involved.

That doesn't mean it's worse/ better than any other way to pass time - it just means you need a bit of awareness if you are prone to getting addicted to things.

ThisIsWhyWeCantHaveNiceThings · 30/08/2022 17:11

I think it's a weird mentality to have. Ok, so you might not like gaming. Fair enough. But to label it as something terrible is bizarre. It's just a hobby, like anything else is.

I love a video game. Nintendo games are my favourite. Have enjoyed many a day playing Mario games. Also love a Star Wars game. And bloody love playing the Sims. Before we had kids, me and my husband (not at the time) would whole away our evenings and weekends playing Star Wars battlefront on the PS2, and it was such fun.

I also think some games are really good for your brain. Straight up shooter games, probably not so much, but for a lot of them, you need quick reflexes and the ability to problem solve. Things like Zelda are essentially puzzles.

Hugasauras · 30/08/2022 17:09

Playing a game is like reading the same book for months and months and months. And then re reading it over again for months.

This really isn't a good analogy. If people are playing the same game for months it's because it has a shedload of content for them to do. But it's the kind of thing I would expect someone who doesn't understand or know modern gaming to say. It's not all shoot-em-ups (and even those games are a lot deeper now).

Also some games are creative outlets, most modern games are cinematic in their production with storylines, character development, world-building. They are hugely social too - my husband is off next month to the wedding of a friend he met through gaming; there is a whole set of gaming friends going to it.

PurpleMarie · 30/08/2022 17:09

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 17:04

Yuck. What’s sex got to do with it.

The big problem with it like box set telly and opposed to hobbies like knitting, painting or gardening is that it’s unproductive. I mean it’s really fun and mentally challenging but ultimately it’s pointless.
I guess reading is similar but the difference is the books people write are different in style and content and they are of fixed length. Playing a game is like reading the same book for months and months and months. And then re reading it over again for months.

You clearly don’t know what you’re fucking talking about.

JurrasicCazza · 30/08/2022 17:09

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 17:04

Yuck. What’s sex got to do with it.

The big problem with it like box set telly and opposed to hobbies like knitting, painting or gardening is that it’s unproductive. I mean it’s really fun and mentally challenging but ultimately it’s pointless.
I guess reading is similar but the difference is the books people write are different in style and content and they are of fixed length. Playing a game is like reading the same book for months and months and months. And then re reading it over again for months.

It's not pointless though. There are plenty of games like Minecraft where the whole point of the game is to create something. Would you argue that physical model building or painting and drawing is equally pointless?

I enjoy gaming, specifically the type of games that involve crating and designing. It's definitely more productive and rewarding then scrolling on social media and watching love Island IMO.

Anniegetyourgun · 30/08/2022 17:07

They're also for semi-retired grandmothers. And why not?

GoneWithTheWine1 · 30/08/2022 17:06

Completely agree.

I game I play games like the sims, Stardew valley, animal crossing, final fantasy.
I'm in my 30s and really don't get this stupid narrow minded stereotyping.
I'd rather game than go out to the pub.

locke360 · 30/08/2022 17:05

I agree and I love video games. I regularly indulge and have all my life, unapologetically!

It's easy to see where the stigma comes from, though. There are a lot of young people completely addicted to them, and having a very negative impact on their lives and those they love.

It can be difficult for parents to manage because they can't relate to it.

The answer is that everyone should play more games! Then they would understand and be able to better help their children regulate.

Hugasauras · 30/08/2022 17:04

Elden Ring took us bloody ages. Definitely got our money's worth there!

lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2022 17:04

gamerchick · 30/08/2022 16:55

We're all gamers. I had a chunk of hours today before work. I gamed on my own and gamed with my teen who didn't want to go out. It's been fun.

Mumsnet is full of lemon lips who need to get laid imo.

Yuck. What’s sex got to do with it.

The big problem with it like box set telly and opposed to hobbies like knitting, painting or gardening is that it’s unproductive. I mean it’s really fun and mentally challenging but ultimately it’s pointless.
I guess reading is similar but the difference is the books people write are different in style and content and they are of fixed length. Playing a game is like reading the same book for months and months and months. And then re reading it over again for months.

Hugasauras · 30/08/2022 17:04

My husband and I met on WoW more than 10 years ago now! We both still play now although kids have put paid to formal raiding alas. Maybe in a few years again!

KassandraOfSparta · 30/08/2022 17:04

I'd also argue that gaming is a good value hobby. Obviously you have the initial outlay of the console. But the actual games - £50 to £60 for 150ish hours to play through one of the big games?

OP posts:
JustTheOneSwan · 30/08/2022 17:03

PonyTime · 30/08/2022 17:00

I misread that as WW1 verateran

And was thinking damn

Not quite as harrowing but about the same time frame 😁iI was in the trenches of Burning Crusade though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread