Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think video games aren't just for teenage boys?

187 replies

KassandraOfSparta · 30/08/2022 16:48

Why does playing video games have such a poor image/reputation?

Numerous threads on here with posters confidently proclaiming that they wouldn't let their children play games, would never date anyone who plays games, would never dream of gaming themselves.

Why is gaming any less "worthy" than sitting watching sport all evening, or soap operas, or painting watercolours or doing jigsaws? Just another form of entertainment, isn't it?

And before anyone pops up saying it's so addictive, well of course anything taken to excess is a problem, whether you're staying up all night with your crochet, jigsaws or tv boxset.

OP posts:
CruCru · 31/08/2022 18:46

Hello! I am a 44 year old woman and I love gaming. I particularly loved Assassins Creed Valhalla, the Ghost of Tsushima and Red Dead Redemption 2. All really interesting and beautiful.

I was given Elden Ring for my birthday and am struggling with it. What am I missing? Or is it just not very talky and quite difficult?

Fladdermus · 31/08/2022 17:45

Is Skyrim easier to play on a Switch? I bought it through steam and tried it on my desktop but gave up as I just couldn't get to grips with the movement controls.

EmotionalSupportLynel · 31/08/2022 17:43

On the back of this thread I've gone and bought Skyrim Elder Scrolls V for my Nintendo Switch.

So that's me lost to the world for the weekend 🤣

Interesting comments on this thread. I don't know when video gaming became known as a male geeo thing. When I was young I was playing King's Quest, Money Island, Prince of Persia etc on the PC and Mario, Sonic on the Nintendo 64 and Sega GameCube. Me and my brother played together all the time and loved it. Some of it was escapism for sure, but I don't see the harm if it's not taking you away from other stuff. My ds is a gamer but he is very social in his gaming, he has a tight group of friends who game together and they talk about all sorts of stuff so I'd argue it does help with interaction and friendships (they meet IRL too and are great friends.) So I'm not disappointed he's into that and not sport - he's a lovely, well-rounded young lad, polite, kind and compassionate. Doesn't seem his gaming has caused any harm at all. The other plus is that we love gaming together so it's great for spending time with him.

Mumoblue · 31/08/2022 17:18

I’ve always played games, and I don’t really care much what people say about it. Usually when people share negative opinions of gamers, it becomes clear quickly that they have no idea what they’re talking about.

That said, my ex was addicted to games, but not because the games were inherently addictive, just because he was selfish and wanted to spent 100% of his life doing fun things and not being responsible.

I don’t hold games responsible for that, in fact as a single parent- games give me something to do when my kid has gone to bed. Playing an MMO with the same people regularly also gives me a chance to be social without my kid in the evening.

People not liking games/gamers doesn’t bother me. You do you. What does bother me is when people write them off entirely without trying them- and when women on MN (and I’ve seen this multiple times) say they have NO hobbies. That just makes me sad.

Some of my favourite games: FFXIV, Fire Emblem, Bloodborne, Skyrim. But I’ll play a bit of anything, really.

Cosycover · 31/08/2022 17:03

Vates · 31/08/2022 11:48

YANBU. I love playing animal crossing. Currently playing Until Dawn on the ps4. Also watch my favourite gamer on twitch. I count it as a hobby.

Oh I loved Until Dawn. The makers have a new one out The Quarry which looks equally good. It's on my list for when I have the time.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 31/08/2022 16:59

justaladyLOL · 31/08/2022 08:48

It does not help kids to learn how to interact in real life situations
Mine are just into sport and i am delighted

See, I'd be a bit disappointed if mine were into sport. For me, that would be just like being into computer games (equally boring) - though I suppose it has the fitness element in its favour. Other than that - and there are lots of ways you can be fit without participating in sport - I'd not be in the slightest bit delighted about this. The conversations at home must be very, very dreary.

Dreamstate · 31/08/2022 16:44

Well most things can be considered a form of escapism like reading books (in particular fiction books), watching movies and non documentary TV shows, boxsets etc. Going out playing sports or to the gym is a form of escapism (escaping the house Grin which we can all appreciate post lockdown).

Majority of people can and do find time to do all the boring stuff like cleaning, food shop etc alongside their hobbies.

SweepItUnderTheCarpet · 31/08/2022 11:57

I've adult children and playing video games has played a massive role in our family. We've had so much fun over the years with them. My kids still get together to play together and if they don't meet in person they play together online. They were never allowed to play video games excessively, maybe 1 hour a day when they were kids. Always strictly timed. They were also never allowed to play first person shooters or anything unsuitable.

The are all healthy, social and hardworking people and they all do plenty of other things apart from gaming. I don't see any downsides tbh. I genuinely think video games have made our family closer.

Our games systems (N64, GameCubes, wii etc) are an important part of our family 😂😂😂

Vates · 31/08/2022 11:48

YANBU. I love playing animal crossing. Currently playing Until Dawn on the ps4. Also watch my favourite gamer on twitch. I count it as a hobby.

Chikapu · 31/08/2022 11:42

Angelinflipflops · 31/08/2022 10:08

So do people who game have more sex then?

Oh because if you don't game you're obviously shagging like rabbits 🙄Maybe read some posts on here about all the people in sexless relationships, not all of them are gamers.

KassandraOfSparta · 31/08/2022 11:30

No but you don’t have to play it all through at once. Don’t most people play for a couple of hours, save and come back to it?

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 31/08/2022 10:54

I think playing long games while you have young kids is basically impossible (not that it stops some people).

There must be a market ready to explode of 5-10 hour games that cater to new parent gamers who enjoyed gaming themselves as kids. Not everyone has time for the Witcher 3.

Adversity · 31/08/2022 10:49

I am in my fifties and joint leader of a gaming clan where you need minimum stats and skill level to join. I was in a very elite clan a few years ago where you had an actual interview to be allowed to join.

The reason MN is especially negative is because so many women on here seem to end up with no lifers as we call them, they only game. They give gaming a bad name.

We have a couple of people in our clan who were when younger on esports teams and paid to game. That’s what so many young gamers want but it’s really rare. We also have a few people who are programmers, I myself was writing web pages in the dark ages back in the mid 1990’s though I’m not a programmer. DH also games, he is a science Professor and can code in a few languages and does use it for work.

My greatest achievements have been being part of a team who helped a deaf mute gamer through a complicated raid and absolutely chewing the arse off disrespectful men who feel threatened by women gaming. It is a horrifically misogynist area of life as anonymous.

@CeratopsofthePharoahs I have only been playing Minecraft for 2 months but it is a great game, wish I had played before. I just made my best thing so far an underwater rollercoaster that’s rolls through an underwater garden it goes straight in to a glass structure that’s got my enchanting table in and a big aquarium.

LSSG · 31/08/2022 10:46

Felixfriend · 31/08/2022 10:33

Well, YANBU.

You ask why people are snooty about it, I suppose I might fall into this category so I will try to explain.

Now I think about it, I have no strong feelings (feelings at all, in fact) about people who might spend an hour a day on a game, same as they might do a crossword or read a book or watch a soap. Fine, do what you enjoy.

I think with gaming it’s the addictive nature of it - people rarely play for just one hour at a time - and the association with gamERS, ie people who define themselves by this hobby, that put me off.

No doubt I am wrong about this and I am indeed narrow in my preconceptions, but I sort of view gamERs as escapists living an alternative life, instead of living their life in the real world. As with addictive pastimes of all sorts I suppose.
I (no doubt incorrectly) assume that we will not have much in common because as a gamER, I presume their gaming hobby is all-consuming.

I can see the appeal of gaming really, life is stressful and escapism is tempting. I remember playing The Sims for 10 hours when I was a teen avoiding GCSE revision. That early experience has been my warning really. I am fairly sure that if I started I could get very ‘into’ whatever it was I found that suited me and I could find myself becoming a gamer. But playing the game would mean that I spent less time doing other stuff in the real world - walking, cooking, having coffees with people, gardening, shopping, stuff that I can look back on as ‘my life’ when I am old. Being present in the physical space around me and making connections with people who share this space is important for my sense of who I am and for my mental health.
Mental health among gamers is a whole other topic.

Anyway, that’s the way I feel about games, and why, if I had children, I would be cautious about letting them play.

Great post.

TeaMeBasil · 31/08/2022 10:37

@Minfilia

"I just finished my last 3* on TPC!

Stray was cute, but short, and kinda annoying at times (I got lost in those apartment buildings a stupid amount of times but I have zero sense of direction)"

Trying to show your post but not sure I'm doing it right!

Stray was very short and I also have a bad sense of direction so got lost a lot around the alleyways - lost the old robot lady who knits the poncho and then lost the robot I was meant to be giving it to!! But I loved it, the hardest thing is trying to describe it to people and make it sound as fun as it was - they tend to say '....so...you're a cat?'

TPC is so much fun - well done on your 3rd star!!! I'm still working on the 3rd star at Fluffborough! My profits have just nosedived right on time for that to be a goal....it was through the roof for star 2!

Felixfriend · 31/08/2022 10:33

Well, YANBU.

You ask why people are snooty about it, I suppose I might fall into this category so I will try to explain.

Now I think about it, I have no strong feelings (feelings at all, in fact) about people who might spend an hour a day on a game, same as they might do a crossword or read a book or watch a soap. Fine, do what you enjoy.

I think with gaming it’s the addictive nature of it - people rarely play for just one hour at a time - and the association with gamERS, ie people who define themselves by this hobby, that put me off.

No doubt I am wrong about this and I am indeed narrow in my preconceptions, but I sort of view gamERs as escapists living an alternative life, instead of living their life in the real world. As with addictive pastimes of all sorts I suppose.
I (no doubt incorrectly) assume that we will not have much in common because as a gamER, I presume their gaming hobby is all-consuming.

I can see the appeal of gaming really, life is stressful and escapism is tempting. I remember playing The Sims for 10 hours when I was a teen avoiding GCSE revision. That early experience has been my warning really. I am fairly sure that if I started I could get very ‘into’ whatever it was I found that suited me and I could find myself becoming a gamer. But playing the game would mean that I spent less time doing other stuff in the real world - walking, cooking, having coffees with people, gardening, shopping, stuff that I can look back on as ‘my life’ when I am old. Being present in the physical space around me and making connections with people who share this space is important for my sense of who I am and for my mental health.
Mental health among gamers is a whole other topic.

Anyway, that’s the way I feel about games, and why, if I had children, I would be cautious about letting them play.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 31/08/2022 10:28

Angelinflipflops · 31/08/2022 10:08

So do people who game have more sex then?

Eh?

CornishGem1975 · 31/08/2022 10:11

The big problem with it like box set telly and opposed to hobbies like knitting, painting or gardening is that it’s unproductive. I mean it’s really fun and mentally challenging but ultimately it’s pointless.

You are very very wrong. Many people have built successful careers off the back of their gaming 'hobby'. Like the Darling brothers. Still, in the gaming industry today, which is an absolute MASSIVE industry.

Angelinflipflops · 31/08/2022 10:08

So do people who game have more sex then?

TriceratopsRocks · 31/08/2022 10:04

"It does not help kids to learn how to interact in real life situations
Mine are just into sport and i am delighted"

Mine are also into sport, playing 4-5 times a week. And alongside A levels/uni also have part time jobs interacting with customers. Doesn't stop them also being massively into gaming. Everything in moderation, variety is the spice of life and all that.

CornishGem1975 · 31/08/2022 10:04

I am a huge gamer and I love it - it's something that I can share with my teenage DC (which is rare!). I was a teenager in the 90s and had Gameboys and a Megadrive etc but even bore that in the 80s I had a BBC Acorn and a Commodore 64 which I just adored. I don't see the harm and I don't see why it has such negative connotations, it's just another hobby.

Angelinflipflops · 31/08/2022 09:54

I've seen plenty of threads on mumsnet complaining about partners who prioritise gaming over family life, never seen that about books and jigsaws

SleeplessInEngland · 31/08/2022 09:53

*have to be!

SleeplessInEngland · 31/08/2022 09:52

Well they're certainly not just for teenagers as teens who played it in the 90s onwards are now adults and many still play.

So the question is really 'are videogames just for men and boys'. And the answer, of course, is 'no, they don't habe to be'.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 31/08/2022 09:52

My MIL is in her 70's she bought a ps5 the day they came out, way before my teenage boys got theirs Grin