Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect just ONE tradesperson to do a good job?

64 replies

EtnaVesuvius · 30/08/2022 13:45

We’re having work done on our house at the moment so have employed various tradespeople - everything from carpenters to plumbers to garden services.

I’m not super fussy/difficult and haven’t always gone for the cheapest quote but almost without fail they have done a crap job - either spectacularly so or just with lack of attention to detail. I honestly wouldn’t recommend a single on of them.

What is happening?

OP posts:
barkymcbarkface · 30/08/2022 16:10

I had to have some roofing work done (dry verge). I got 3 quotes and went for the middle one as friends had used him previously. I wasn't at home when it was finished. I came home to find mess everywhere, bits of old mortar, nails, metal - some of it on the lawn. He basically bodged it around the gutters, the rest of it appeared to by fine. I phoned him and told him in no uncertain terms that he'd be coming back to clear up and finish the gutters properly. I hate doing this especially as I'm a lone woman, and I knew I was going to have to be there to check he did it properly. It was awful.

I've also had new fencing, new guttering, and a wall repointed. None of them are great, and all have had to come back to finish or put right things they have or haven't done. The mess that is left frustrates me more than anything.

I have however never had a bad plumber or electrician.

Hobele · 30/08/2022 15:50

Penguinfeather781 · 30/08/2022 13:47

My slightly flippant answer is that around here the Eastern European guys went home.

Such rubbish... We had a big extension, started off with British workers, all decent work. (apart from the fact the boss screwed everyone over 😄) , then came the Romanians, who did completely shit work, then I found a fellow Hungarian team, some've done a good job, some were utter crap. My friend's Bulgarian husband did a really good job.
So which Eastern Europeans?

2bazookas · 30/08/2022 15:47

I AM super fussy /vigilant and a very good planner. Like the kind of tradesmen I employ.

IME excellent trademen don't need to advertise for work; their reputation passes by word of mouth. (As do the reputations of good clients). I hire small one-man trades and their charges are not expensive.

If I need a plumber I'll phone my trusted joiner or plasterer for a recommendation. When contacting the plumber I tell him who recommended him to me. Knowing full well that plumber will then ask joiner " Have you worked for bazooka? " I have built a reputation as an excellent person to work for, very clear, particular, attentive and straightforward. The site will be clear and ready when they arrive; hot drinks offered at regular intervals otherwise I keep out of their way. The day they finish the job, I pay.

Surplus2requirements · 30/08/2022 15:45

EtnaVesuvius · 30/08/2022 15:30

I’m seeing more than just lack of training though. It’s sloppy workmanship, dishonesty and lack of care. An ‘it’ll do’ attitude rather than taking pride in their work.

It constantly astounds me that tradespeople are happy to cut corners and think the customer won’t notice. I feel like I’ve become a serial complainer, but all I want is for them to do a decent job for fair money.

If I was that slapdash I’d get fired, but they have no repercussions because they just move on to the next job.

Yes, I guess that's what happens when there a lack, the space gets filled by chancers.

My only suggestion is to get recommendations from people you trust and know have had work done and you can see (not your local FB page and definitely not those awful trustatrade types sites, I know people making more than I do through them that I wouldn't trust to sweep up!).

JustTheOneSwan · 30/08/2022 15:39

I blame the internet too.
people went by word of mouth and had a reputation to protect.
now they can stick up a new fb page and be going again in minutes.
we need some disability adaptation done and it's torture just getting quotes.

PeloAddict · 30/08/2022 15:34

I've found a plumber. He came out the next day, arrived on time, did the work perfectly and wasn't expensive
As he left he said "oh and I am gas certified too"
Never letting him go Grin

Pumpkinbite · 30/08/2022 15:33

Yes YABU
every single one causes hundreds if not thousands of pounds worth of damage
and leaves having done a job that I need to employ someone else to fix or learn how to fix myself. Or just accept that the thing in my house I paid a ton of money for - bathroom kitchen carpet windows whatever - has a shite finish and I may as well have got the cheapest item and installed it myself

EtnaVesuvius · 30/08/2022 15:30

Surplus2requirements · 30/08/2022 15:25

I think part of the problem is the historic specialisation. People that learnt a trade working for a large company and then going it alone where multiple skills are needed.

Likewise where multiple trades done by different people on the same job with little or no understanding of the trades they are working alongside.

There are lots of good tradespeople, both Brits and European but not enough to fill the requirement. They tend to keep to their established and trusted customers (yes customers can be very untrustworthy).

This country hasn't invested in good training in ANYTHING for decades and vocational training is increasingly devalued in education

I’m seeing more than just lack of training though. It’s sloppy workmanship, dishonesty and lack of care. An ‘it’ll do’ attitude rather than taking pride in their work.

It constantly astounds me that tradespeople are happy to cut corners and think the customer won’t notice. I feel like I’ve become a serial complainer, but all I want is for them to do a decent job for fair money.

If I was that slapdash I’d get fired, but they have no repercussions because they just move on to the next job.

OP posts:
Surplus2requirements · 30/08/2022 15:25

I think part of the problem is the historic specialisation. People that learnt a trade working for a large company and then going it alone where multiple skills are needed.

Likewise where multiple trades done by different people on the same job with little or no understanding of the trades they are working alongside.

There are lots of good tradespeople, both Brits and European but not enough to fill the requirement. They tend to keep to their established and trusted customers (yes customers can be very untrustworthy).

This country hasn't invested in good training in ANYTHING for decades and vocational training is increasingly devalued in education

PeasOff · 30/08/2022 15:11

@EtnaVesuvius Well you must have if they're all doing rubbish jobs!

Always best to find tradespeople via word of mouth and check previous work completed - if you've done this I'd be questioning the recommendations you received.

Heartbreaktuna · 30/08/2022 15:00

Yup. Paid for ceilings to be plastered. They left grooves and marks all over it.
Gutting resealed. Leaked even worse.
New wooden floors laid. All out of alignment and uneven.
New car tyres. They destroyed the powder coating on the wheels.
Bicycle in for repair. They ruined the shocks.
Car in for oil change. They forgot to put the oil cap back on.
Luckily DH is very handy so could rectify all these. But he already works very long hours.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/08/2022 14:54

bellamountain · 30/08/2022 13:50

If you want a decent job, then you'll have to pay more. I know you've not gone for the cheapest quotes but still, you'll have to except to pay at the top end for proper skilled trades and not chancers.

Sometimes even the expensive ones do a shit job. Paying more is no guarantee of anything.

nonevernotever · 30/08/2022 14:53

I should also add that while I didn't go out looking for a cheap job, in both cases I think the work was competitively priced. The kitchen came in at just under £15k including £2k for a range cooker, all units, solid wood worktops, lighting, rewiring the house to accommodate moving the kitchen into our bedroom, redoing the plumbing to accommodate the move, stripping out fitted wardrobes, stripping out the old kitchen, replastering that room completely, laying new flooring in both rooms and commissioning a local company to make a quad wardrobe for the new bedroom. The bathroom was £13k including gutting the room completely installing a false ceiling, new lighting, panelling all walls, solid wood worktops, custom making shelves and even putting up a new curtain rail for us in a bedroom just while they were there. For Edinburgh that's extremely good value. ( Oh and I don't do cash in hand so those prices also include the VAT.)

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 30/08/2022 14:51

I've hired many nationalities, varying price points- all shit. all lazy all slapdash- you basically need to marry a tradesman to get a half decent job.

catwomando · 30/08/2022 14:50

Agreed. We've had bad experiences with
floor fitters - used wrong screed and had to take it all up and do it again at huge inconvenience and additional expense
carpenters - poor finish, things not fitting together
painters - emulsion peeling off after a few weeks showing that no proper prep. Painting the bannisters with emulsion not eggshell so it all rubbed off.

general builders - building our extension the wrong size and then blaming us , having to re do the roof covering 3 times and it still leaked. Chimney breast taken out but not supported, rear wall not propped correctly during extension so back wall sagged. Brickwork so bad that it ended up having to be rendered to cover it,
plumber - plumbed in new hot cold sink pipes but both ran cold on,u. By then the floor had been screeded so they had tore lay pipes above ground.
Garden people - did patio and all the cement came straight out

The only people any good were the sparkies.

And they always blame each other and criticise the previous trades' work.

If I had my time all over again I'd train as a builder and have an all female crew, delivering quality jobs on time. With decent tea. 😬

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/08/2022 14:47

It’s a total gamble. I admit we’ve got to the point where we know, we cannot do any worse - so diy as much as possible. 🤷‍♀️
Tbh, the very few trades we’ve had to rely on have been excellent, the exception being the electric board, who are needed to put in a new earth, but apparently they aren’t qualified to connect it to our fuse and mains box - that has to be a separate electrician, all the local electricians say it has to the electric board who connect this earth. We’ve gone round in circles for 3 months, we may just give up and live with the electrics as they are.

nonevernotever · 30/08/2022 14:45

We've obviously just been really lucky then. Just before lockdown we replaced our kitchen which also involved moving the kitchen into a different room with a knock on impact on two other rooms, and we've just had the bathroom done. The kitchen was arranged through IKEA originally but we really liked the guy who came out to measure, and he was one of IKEA recommended fitters. He project managed the whole thing for us including arranging the electrician, plumber and plasterer and they were all uniformly excellent, as well as a pleasure to do business with. For the bathroom we went through a company linked to a local housing association because they were the only company even available to quote. Again the plumber, joiner and electrician were excellent and finished the job on time and under budget. I had to ask for one piece of work to be redone and there was an issue with the plans both of which were the fault of the man who did the original quote. Both were rectified immediately by the tradesmen and the finished result is wonderful. (And I do all the conversations with tradesmen rather than DH. They were always entirely respectful, understanding of the problems and just keen for us to be happy with the end result.)

BrianWankum · 30/08/2022 14:42

It just feels like a gamble every time, doesn't it? Had so much hassle trying to get a tree cut down this year - took ages to get quotes, arranged a date with one company, they cancelled on the day and have ghosted me ever since.

If anyone's in Berkshire/Hampshire area, I do know a good bricklayer, passionate about his work, listens to women and isn't intimidating! (Not related to me either 😁 )

EtnaVesuvius · 30/08/2022 14:37

Just to clarify - I haven’t paid low! I made that clear in my OP.

OP posts:
HannahSternDefoe · 30/08/2022 14:30

You're expecting a lot...

We've had all kinds of trades (door fitters, plumbers, joiner, plasterer, spark) and all, bar one fantabulous plumber, were complete jokes or a liability.

Damage to the house (water leak needing a new ceiling - joiner) fused the electrics, couldn't hang a door properly - and when they did manage it, ballsed up the lock and had to break in to/ruin a brand new 2k door (it took them quite a whileGrin) not to mention having to listen to the fucking moaning about other trades.

I don't care any more.

I pay you money - you fix my problem (preferably in silence) then bugger off...got it???

I'll hire anyone non-british from now on.

mommybear1 · 30/08/2022 14:30

I disagree with the pp who say you have paid low so not got good trades in. Or that is your fault you have hired poor trades. We did a house renovation and paid a good price to our trades - without exception they were all shit. We have had to have a lot of work redone, in some cases more than twice (tiling/plastering/roofing), all the trades were recommended - in some cases they were friends of DH (note the were). The key thing I can say is if you can do it yourself do - trades don't care about your home as you do. By trial and error we have now found some decent trades but it is not easy at all.

entropynow · 30/08/2022 14:25

EtnaVesuvius · 30/08/2022 14:06

Do you know, I actually think you’re right.

The only one who did a decent job was the plasterer, who was Polish.

They're not.

Isitsixoclockalready · 30/08/2022 14:24

PeasOff · 30/08/2022 13:54

You've picked shit tradespeople.

I think that was the point of the thread.

entropynow · 30/08/2022 14:22

IceCreamTime19 · 30/08/2022 13:57

If you want a decent job do not hire british tradesman. Easy as that. Best to stick to Europeans.

Oh don't be stupid. We've had really good work done by Brits and a mix of good and poor by Europeans.

billyt · 30/08/2022 14:21

As a fully qualified Electrician I disagree about British Trades, to a point. Maybe it's because I'm an old git but I always did my utmost to do the best job I could.

I'm not in that business anymore but I do see a lot of shit installations. When I ask why it was accepted I was often told the 'Trades' weren't bothered if he customer was happy or not. My bigger concern is if the bits you can see are shit what about the bits you can't see??

A lot of Eastern European workers are keen to work and work hard. Unfortunately, we as country have shot ourselves in the foot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread