Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much do you expect to be informed..

37 replies

MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 13:26

As to what your little ones are doing with their grandparents?

I have very little contact with my parents, however still try to enable DS (aged 4) to have a relationship with them. I'm not sure if IABU I'm expecting to know where they are when DS is with them so looking for others opinions so I can make clear what my expectations are.

For example, when would you expect to be told if they left the village, city, county? Do grandparents let you know what yoir DC had for tea or what they've been up to?
GPs usually collect from preschool but then I have radio silence unless I ask, to which I usually get the bare minimum to vaguely answer my question. Not sure if I'm the unreasonable one and I'm being controlling or if I need to start expecting more communication from them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Orangey25 · 30/08/2022 21:38

Yeah, no i wouldn't be allowing that. Why do you want your dc to have a relationship with people who cant even be civil to you? Absolutely no chance.
And thats a lot of time they are having him. My mum has never had my son overnight.

Pixiedust1234 · 30/08/2022 20:21

I am so sorry you are being treated this way. Its beyond wrong. To reply to your original post, now knowing they do not speak to you at all - yes, I would expect to know, even if only written on a piece of paper/text.

HOWEVER, I would actually stop all contact. Grandparents have no legal rights, only what the parents allow, and if mine did not talk to me they could whistle for any access. You have no idea of what poison they are drip feeding your son. You have no idea of the damage you/they are causing ds by him watching your (lack of) communication and interactions. Children learn by watching. Walk away Flowers

HMReturnsBag · 30/08/2022 19:43

That sounds awful, op. I’m really sorry. I think in your shoes I’d be tempted to limit their contact with your child as well. They can’t demand access and if they’re not willing to treat you decently, do you really want them in his life?

MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 19:15

Pixiedust1234 · 30/08/2022 18:07

So they say goodbye to ds but don't chat to you. At all? They just shut the door?

Yeah. I wouldn't be facilitating any relationship between them if thats the case.

I know it sounds ridiculous but yes, thats pretty much what happens.

I fully see that the whole thing is dysfunctional, but DS on the whole seems to enjoy going, and any mention of him going less results in texts of how we are alienating him from them and how he's missing out on a relationship with his grandparents (MIL and FIL live abroad so he doesn't have that sort of relationship with them).

To give some back story, my parents have always been quite cold and unemotional, and growing up quite "shouty". I wouldn't say I had an abusive childhood, and was quite privileged in terms of the activities and hobbies i did, and things i was bought, but it was deffinatley not "right". A long time ago my parents split and I was piggy in the middle and didn't handle it great. Unpleasant things were said by all, but now they are back together and have happily forgiven each other yet seem to hold a grudge against me for not dealing with a horrible situation differently. We tried to move forward but everytime I dare disagree with anything g they say they being up anything from the past (including things I said/did as a child).
When I met DH he brought some outside perspective (I have aspergers, in case that's relevant) and slowly I cut contact which pretty much resolved my anxiety and depression. Then when I had DS they saw him sporadically as a baby, then last year decided they wanted regular contact with him.
Obviously that is a very brief overview of how we got into this situation.

OP posts:
TiggeryBear · 30/08/2022 18:39

My 2DC recently had a weeks holiday (holiday park in UK, reasonably near where we live) with PILs. We had an update maybe once or twice a day with things like "been to the beach this morning, going to park later" or "went to the pub for lunch & DC1 tried Nanny's lunch" or perhaps a photo of DC on a sun-lounger 🤷🏼‍♀️
I don't necessarily expect such updates, but it's nice / reassuring that they are having a good time.
When my kids have a sleepover or days out with my parents I get similar updates.
But then, thinking about it, I send similar updates to both sets of grandparents if we're on a day out to a zoo or something. So I guess it's similar expectations all round 🤷🏼‍♀️

GrazingSheep · 30/08/2022 18:33

This sounds completely dysfunctional.

FlissyPaps · 30/08/2022 18:29

This is so sad to read OP. Has something absolutely awful happened in the past or are they just really cold people?

Given you had a “normal” relationship with your DPs I absolutely would expect to be informed if they were taking DS on a trip/travelling somewhere.

Then I’d expect at least some communication with them at pick up/drop off about their day, if they’ve had a nice time, what they had for lunch etc.

But to them this ‘not communicating’ with you sounds normal and reasonable to them. If you don’t like this, make it clear to them.

Fink · 30/08/2022 18:26

It's not normal, but then it's not a normal situation. I wouldn't be facilitating that relationship if there's practically no contact between you and them.

The nearest I come to it is letting dc stay with their other grandparents (ex-h's parents), with whom I would have no contact if it weren't for dc. They live further away so it's a few days in the holidays rather than a day a week. Dc are now old enough to tell me themselves what they've been up to. When they were younger, I would phone daily to talk to dc and grandparents would talk through the children, e.g. 'we've had a lovely day at the farm, haven't we?'. I wouldn't expect, and didn't get, any report of what they ate, how they slept etc. unless they were sick and needed picking up earlier than planned. I think your problem is not the lack of information but the lack of relationship. The amount of information provided is normal, but the lack of engagement with you (do they know you would like to talk? Do you give the impression of wanting to say something, maybe they think you don't want any contact with them?) makes it unworkable. I would stop contact with them entirely until you've worked through whatever made you go LC.

TakeYourFinalPosition · 30/08/2022 18:20

I wouldn't be facilitating this. It sounds toxic, and there are many situations where having contact is more damaging than not.

If you cannot maintain, or don't want, a functional relationship with them which includes you having conversations, your child shouldn't either. What are you teaching them about relationships with parents? Or acceptable ways to be treated?

Pixiedust1234 · 30/08/2022 18:07

So they say goodbye to ds but don't chat to you. At all? They just shut the door?

Yeah. I wouldn't be facilitating any relationship between them if thats the case.

MarinoRoyale · 30/08/2022 18:02

The bigger question is why you’re facilitating a relationship with people who you yourself have no real relationship with.

Pumperthepumper · 30/08/2022 18:01

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable, I’d definitely expect to be told if my parents took my kid out of the country! But I think the reason for your low contact is the actual issue here, why do they have your kid so much?

Ragged · 30/08/2022 17:58

1-2 minute update? If they had a good day then why would I need to try to learn more?

luxxlisbon · 30/08/2022 17:54

Surely this just comes up in conversation?
I can’t tell if you are being unreasonable or now because your two examples are so extreme, it’s not crazy to want to know if DS fell and hurt himself but it is sort of crazy to want a text because he didn’t like his veggies!

StopFeckingFaffing · 30/08/2022 17:51

I struggle to understand how you can be happy for your 4yo DS to stay overnight every fortnight with family members who you have almost no personal contact with. However, assuming you trust them to care for your DS and keep him safe then you can't really expect a detailed report from them about how they spend the time.

Very strange situation but I think YABU one way or another

Kite22 · 30/08/2022 17:43

I wouldn't expect a report.

But then I wouldn't leave my dc with people I couldn't even bring myself to have a 2 minute chat with when I pick them up. That is what is weird here.

As I only ever left my dc with people I liked and people I trusted completely then I didn't need them to check in with me, but as they were normal people that I had a relationship with, then they'd probably say "ooh, he hasn't eaten much today" or "sorry, hope it doesn't disrupt his sleep tonight be he fell asleep in the car to 2 mins on the way home at about 4pm" etc etc.

shazzybazzy34 · 30/08/2022 17:30

MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 17:06

I don't use them for child care, I have no need for them to have DS for me. They want to have a relationship with him, so they collect him from nursery as they prefer to do so just after lunch and I am at work then. They don't have him every day, they have him one day a week from lunch time and he stags over night every other week, at their request. They made it perfectly clear they would not be used as child care and as such, I have my child care needs covered.

Well you said in your opening post that they collect him from nursery every day, you are in work at this time so that sounds like childcare in some form to me.

HMReturnsBag · 30/08/2022 17:12

Is there a reason you have so little contact with them?

MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 17:10

I think the issue is there is no informal chat between me and my parents at all so I get no insight into their relationship with him. They pick DS up from preschool and then they either take him to preschool the next day, or I go to pick him up and they say bye to DS and shut the door. They do not text unless they want to change a premade arrangement, just complete silence.

OP posts:
MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 17:06

shazzybazzy34 · 30/08/2022 13:44

I have very little contact with my parents, however still try to enable DS (aged 4) to have a relationship with them

So I let them do childcare by picking him up every day from preschool. They do not give me a blow by blow account of what he is doing when they have him and if he liked his veggies or not.

Give me a fucking break.

I don't use them for child care, I have no need for them to have DS for me. They want to have a relationship with him, so they collect him from nursery as they prefer to do so just after lunch and I am at work then. They don't have him every day, they have him one day a week from lunch time and he stags over night every other week, at their request. They made it perfectly clear they would not be used as child care and as such, I have my child care needs covered.

OP posts:
CurbsideProphet · 30/08/2022 14:27

The reason why you don't have much contact with your parents is clearly the missing piece of the puzzle here. My parents look after my sibling's children regularly and put photos in the family WhatsApp group so we can all see them happy / playing / on days out. They don't have to, they just think it's a nice thing to do. If you don't get along with your parents it's not surprising that you would want more info about how your DS spends his time with them.

2bazookas · 30/08/2022 14:17

would you expect to be told if they left the village, city, county?

No, if that was within the expected period of care.

Do grandparents let you know what yoir DC had for tea?

Why should they? As a grandparent, it would never occur to me to mention the menu. My sons know we feed the GC's healthily and the GC's love eating our food.

Whodoiwanttobe · 30/08/2022 14:09

MandrakesMum · 30/08/2022 13:26

As to what your little ones are doing with their grandparents?

I have very little contact with my parents, however still try to enable DS (aged 4) to have a relationship with them. I'm not sure if IABU I'm expecting to know where they are when DS is with them so looking for others opinions so I can make clear what my expectations are.

For example, when would you expect to be told if they left the village, city, county? Do grandparents let you know what yoir DC had for tea or what they've been up to?
GPs usually collect from preschool but then I have radio silence unless I ask, to which I usually get the bare minimum to vaguely answer my question. Not sure if I'm the unreasonable one and I'm being controlling or if I need to start expecting more communication from them.

If I didn’t have a relationship with my parents I wouldn’t allow my child to either. I like knowing what my son does with his Aunty (the only person who has him) and she always texts me.

Rosebel · 30/08/2022 14:03

My parents used to have my children for a few days in the holidays when they were younger.
Never got updates or expected them. They would quite often take them on days out and I found out afterwards.
I don't really think you should let your son go if you don't trust them and if you want updates then you obviously don't trust them.

TabithaTittlemouse · 30/08/2022 13:47

We might send a photo of something that we are doing with dgc (for example today we fed the ducks so sent a photo of dgc at the duck pond).

We wouldn’t let them know every time dgc eats and sleeps and although we might mention where we are going we don’t feel the need to ask.

You either trust them or you don’t.

fwiw I don’t have any communication with my mother so my dc didn’t visit until they could communicate about how they were, if they wanted to come home etc.